Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

If you could only improve one player....

2»

Comments

  • Clinical striker BWP should have been closer to Rhodes
  • shelvey in on loan ( i doubt it as i see him doping very well under rodgers)
  • edited July 2012
    People wanting to replace Hamer, will have serious egg on their faces sooner rather than later. He is one of the best talented young keepers coming through. Very lucky to have him IMO.
    I second that. Still very young for a GK and will only get better.

    And I must add that I've never seen a keeper pick on his team-mates from 50 yards so consistantly as he does. Great asset to have.

    Think if we had Joe Hart some people on here would still moan that he's not good enough..............
  • Central midfield to play alongside Hollands, in the Parker role. When Hughes played a defensive role last season Hollands managed to get forward and even scored a couple.
    This is so true and seems to have been forgotten by many, including SCP when we persisted with making Stephens/Hollands work when the Hollands/Hughes partnership seemed our strongest.

    But if I could improve one player/position it would be BWP. His number of goals was good, but considering he played pretty much every game a return of 22 goals isn't amazing in that pub league and his goals to shots ratio will need to improve big time considering he'll have far fewer chances in the Chsmpionship.
  • I personally don't think there would be too much of a problem if Hollands was urged to sit more and Stephens was to push forward more. I think its more down to Powell the way they play so not sure how much difference a new midfielder would be.

    I'd go for a new CB
  • I don't really understand BWP being particularly highlighted.


    His return of 22 goals in 41 matches last season, is very respectable.
    Most strikers don't get a better return than averaging 1 goal in 3 games.


    Sure, he had that mid-season patch where nothing would go right for him - but he finished the season strongly.

    And if he had nicked a few goals during that lean patch, then his tally would have been nearer to 30 goals.

    Apart from a weakness 1-on-1 with the keeper, BWP is a natural finisher (look at the goal he scored against Carlisle to win promotion, for example). I feel BWP will always score goals - and that he's as good as the service he receives.


    I guess people compare him with Jordan Rhodes, who had an absolutely exceptional season - and who'd be hard pressed to get anywhere near the same return this coming season.
  • edited July 2012
    Still think Stephen Quinn is the midfielder we need. Can play wide left if Jackson is injured / out of form or can also offer creativity in the middle by playing CM / just behind the front man were he played quite a bit for sheff utd at the end of last season.

    He needs to move if he wants to get in the Ireland squad and even though Sheff Utd have now got some money in from the sale of Lowton I still think Quinn will move on this summer as well.
  • Rather have Wordsworth than Quinn
  • Centre midfield / Striker back up / option alongside BWP / Another decent centre back / right back cover / Pacy Left winger

    If we go in as the team we have, will be lower mid table, a decent centre midfield will bring us to mid table, add in a striker we are getting close to top 6 and with pacy left winger - centre back cover and right back cover we are top 6. Add in a decent right wing and we are promotion material.

    Remains to be seen, if any of the above is fulfilled.
  • It may be a step too far in the championship having just been promoted but a brave manager would play stephens just behind a sole central striker with hughes holding and wagstaff and Hollands holding and breaking on the counter .thing is that I don't think that despite his energy wagstaff would be good enough to rely upon to put his foot in although Hollands ought to be .also BWP would be the striker to play that role and he doesn't work hard enough and hasn't got a good enough strike rate to make that work.the biggest problem is that our best player kermogant wouldn't get in on this basis which would be a travesty.also we don't presently have an out and out winger who is good enough in such a formation although I would definitely start a fully fit Green .so forget everything I said !
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited July 2012
    Agree with your last 5 words ashley :-)

    I'd like a centre half with a bit more pace and mobility any budding rufus's out there !

    And if hughes starts games we're gonna be in a relegation battle , he is not good enough for a regular championship berth imo
  • Agree we should sign a player in Hughes' mould, but good enough for the Championship, which in turn would free up his partner (be that Hollands or Stephens)
  • Central midfield.
  • edited July 2012
    It has to be central midfield. Last season even with a superb back four and more than adequate front two we were often out played and out battled in the centre. The front and back quality in division one papered over this considerable crack. Without at least one very good centre midfielder coming in I really think we will struggle against most of the Championship sides. For a team that quite honestly pissed the league it's one of the reasons that we rarely had very much more possession than the opposition but still won. Central midfield is a must.
  • It has to be central midfield. Last season even with a superb back four and more than adequate front two we were often out played and out battled in the centre. The front and back quality in division one papered over this considerable crack. Without at least one very good centre midfielder coming in I really think we will struggle against most of the Championship sides. For a team that quite honestly pissed the league it's one of the reasons that we rarely had very much more possession than the opposition but still won. Central midfield is a must.
    Spot on. And that's not to say that individually Hollands, Stephens and Pritchard aren't up to Championship level, I'm sure they will be. But they will be further helped if we can add a strong central midfielder to play alongside one of them. Also some games may warrant a 4-5-1 or 4-1-4-1 formation, and that could mean Stephens and Hollands both starting alongside a new man, if we got one.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!