Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Best Ever Charlton Loan Team

Henry IrvingHenry Irving
edited June 2012 in General Charlton
With the sad news of Alan McDonald's death it was suggested that he might be one of our all time best loan players.

That started me thinking; what would be our best loan XI.

GK: Carson

Defence: McDonald, Kernaghan, Costa

Midfield: Jackson, Smertin, Bart-Williams

Forwards: Jeppson

Who have I forgotton?

PS. Keep the worst loan team for another thread please : - )

«1

Comments

  • Options
    ScohamScoham
    Bartlett started on loan
  • Options
    superclivesuperclive
    John hendrie from spurs. scored a great winner against millwall. that alone gets him in!
  • Options
    lordromfordlordromford
    Alex Song?
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    Hendrie and Song are great calls.

    Don't think we should count Bartlett (good though he was) as it was just a very short loan until he signed perm terms) *if we don't find anyone better might change that : - )
  • Options
    Danny AddickDanny Addick
    Hmm, do they have to play well whilst on loan? If so, Jackson was ok but he became a brilliant signing for us after becoming permanent.
  • Options
    Ormiston_AddickOrmiston_Addick
    John hendrie from spurs. scored a great winner against millwall. that alone gets him in!
    Great minds think alike, we should probably have a stand named after him!
  • Options
    shine166shine166
    Ricky otto would have to be in it for me
  • Options
    bolloxbolderbolloxbolder
    Based on above qualification - Paul Kitson
  • Options
    Ormiston_AddickOrmiston_Addick
    Ricky otto would have to be in it for me
    Did he do very much in that loan spell? I remember his hair and the fact that he had done time but not much else!
  • Options
    shine166shine166
    Ricky otto would have to be in it for me
    Did he do very much in that loan spell? I remember his hair and the fact that he had done time but not much else!

    I was only a pup, but if jacko makes the cut from his first visit...
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    se9addickse9addick
    edited June 2012
    Martin Pringle was so exciting on loan. Not so great after he became perm.

    Neil Heany for his role in our'98 promotion ?
  • Options
    ScohamScoham
    Hendrie and Song are great calls.

    Don't think we should count Bartlett (good though he was) as it was just a very short loan until he signed perm terms) *if we don't find anyone better might change that : - )
    Over half a season, while Jackson was here about a month as said.
  • Options
    shine166shine166
    Martin Pringles was so exciting on loan. Not so great after he became perm.

    Neil Heany for his role in our'98 promotion ?

    good call on heany

  • Options
    BubbleBubble
    Wasn't Mark Bowen on loan?
  • Options
    ColinTatColinTat
    Jason Lee scored against Palace.
  • Options
    bolloxbolderbolloxbolder
    Did he?
  • Options
    Kap10Kap10
    Martin Pringle was so exciting on loan. Not so great after he became perm.

    Neil Heany for his role in our'98 promotion ?
    This on both counts

  • Options
    queensland_addickqueensland_addick
    Yes to Alex Song. Perhaps Zheng Zhi also (first spell)
  • Options
    Valley11Valley11
    Think it shows that loan players rarely prove a success.
    Heaney has to be in that team
  • Options
    Zinedine BagheriZinedine Bagheri
    Lee Power and Matt Jackson were handy at the time. Not sure they'd get in the side though.

    Jorge Costa is deffo my top loanee.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    Hendrie and Song are great calls.

    Don't think we should count Bartlett (good though he was) as it was just a very short loan until he signed perm terms) *if we don't find anyone better might change that : - )
    Over half a season, while Jackson was here about a month as said.
    You're right. Barlett was on loan a lot longer and Jackson a lot less than I remembered.

  • Options
    Ormiston_AddickOrmiston_Addick
    John MacDonald from Rangers in 1986, he played in three games and I think we won them all?
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    So far:

    GK: Carson

    Defence: McDonald, Kernaghan, Costa, Jackson

    Midfield: Song, Smertin, Zheng Zhi, Hendrie

    Forwards: Jeppson, Barlett

    Subs: Heaney, Kitson, Bart-Williams, Pringle, Ikeme
  • Options
    thai malaysia addickthai malaysia addick
    edited June 2012
    Wasn't Danny Mills on loan? Spector wasn't too bad either. I think we had David Whyte on loan as well.
  • Options
    DaveMehmetDaveMehmet
    edited June 2012
    .
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    Wasn't Danny Mills on loan? Spector wasn't too bad either. I think we had David Whyte on loan as well.
    Three good late signings for the Loan Rangers XI
  • Options
    Valley11Valley11
    Carlton Cole??
  • Options
    WoodsywoodWoodsywood
    Carlton Cole??
    21 games, 4 goals
  • Options
    Gazcafc81Gazcafc81
    Carlton Cole??
    21 games, 4 goals
    Loved seeing him rip up Sol Campbell at Highbury and Scoring at White Hart Lane.

    I would definitely have Song and Smertin in midfield.

  • Options
    WoodsywoodWoodsywood
    He was a great prospect
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!