Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

FIFA 13 - What would you rate our players for it?

SheedyCAFCSheedyCAFC
edited June 2012 in General Charlton
Our team is always under-rated from what we think it should be, so baring that in mind, this is what I'm guessing:

Ben Hamer 68
John Sullivan 60
Nick Pope 50
-
Chris Solly 70
Michael Morrison 70
Leon Cort 67
Rhoys Wiggins 67
Matt Taylor 64
Cedric Evina 60
Yado Mambo 55
-
Scott Wagstaff 68
Danny Hollands 69
Dale Stephens 66
Johnnie Jackson 70
Andy Hughes 62
Bradley Pritchard 64
Ruben Bover 60
Danny Green 67
-
Bradley Wright-Phillips 70
Yann Kermorgant 72
Danny Haynes 68
Michael Smith 54
Paul Hayes (if he's still with us) 63
Leon Clake (if he's still with us) 1
«1

Comments

  • sam3110sam3110
    Think we'll be mostly 'silver' players. Doubt many players will be lower than they were in FIFA 12 considering we won the league.

    Ben Hamer 70
    John Sullivan 64
    Nick Pope 53
    -
    Chris Solly 71
    Michael Morrison 72
    Leon Cort 69
    Rhoys Wiggins 70
    Matt Taylor 67
    Cedric Evina 63
    Yado Mambo 57
    Jordan Cousins 60
    -
    Scott Wagstaff 69
    Danny Hollands 71
    Dale Stephens 68
    Johnnie Jackson 73
    Andy Hughes 64
    Bradley Pritchard 66
    Ruben Bover 62
    Danny Green 70
    -
    Bradley Wright-Phillips 71
    Yann Kermorgant 71
    Danny Haynes 70
    Michael Smith 59
    Paul Hayes 66
    Leon Clake 67
  • ChiAddickChiAddick
    When is it out?
  • cafcrocky87cafcrocky87
    Not til the end of September.
  • JiMMy 85JiMMy 85
    I'd like to be able to keep the Hollands/ Stephens axis for longer, so would love for them to start out at 70. Found it odd this year that BWP stuck at 68 for 5 years, yet bossed it in every division (and Europe!!).
  • kentaddickkentaddick
    more interested in our ratings for football manager to be honest!
  • superjonniejacksonsuperjonniejackson
    more interested in our ratings for football manager to be honest!
    This
  • BensonFCBensonFC
    Bover will be about 58/59
  • JiMMy 85JiMMy 85
    If it's THIS (incidentally, the most irritating forum posts known to man), then start your own thread!!
  • laujameslaujames
    Yann's heading better be around 99, or else....
  • SuperYannSuperYann
    edited June 2012
    more interested in our ratings for football manager to be honest!
    Now this guy knows football games!

  • Sponsored links:


  • AddickRamAddickRam
    Much Wider Scale I think is needed.


    Premiership 95-85-75
    Championship 75-70-65
    League One 65-60-55
    League Two 55-50-45

    Ben Hamer 71 (Mid Championship)
    John Sullivan 58 (Mid League One)
    Nick Pope 45 (Lower League Two)
    -
    Chris Solly 75 (Top Championship)
    Michael Morrison 73 (Top Championship)
    Leon Cort 69 (Mid Championship)
    Rhoys Wiggins 74 (Top Championship)
    Matt Taylor 69 (Mid Championship)
    Cedric Evina 61 (Mid League One)
    Yado Mambo 48 (Mid League Two)
    Jordan Cousins 49 (Mid League Two)
    -
    Scott Wagstaff 63 (Top League One)
    Danny Hollands 70 (Mid Championship)
    Dale Stephens 67 (Lower Championship)
    Johnnie Jackson 72 (Mid Championship)
    Andy Hughes 62 (Mid League One)
    Bradley Pritchard 64 (Top League One)
    Ruben Bover 50 (Mid League Two)
    Danny Green 62 (Mid League One)
    -
    Bradley Wright-Phillips 70 (Mid Championship)
    Yann Kermorgant 77 (Lower Premiership)
    Danny Haynes 70 (Mid Championship)
    Michael Smith 50 (Mid League Two)
    Paul Hayes 63 (Top League One)
    Leon Clake 60 (Mid League One)
  • sam3110sam3110
    edited June 2012
    There is no way in hell any of our players will be 75 or above, as that would make them a gold player in ultimate team, and usually theres about 5-6 players in the whole championship who are gold! We will be mid championship rated, about 10th-14th in overall stats
  • Dazzler21Dazzler21
    Who is Leon Clake?
  • Addickted4lifeAddickted4life
    Also I can't see how Fifa could down grade any of our players when we won the league with 101 points. They would all rise or stay about the same if they didn't play.
  • JiMMy 85JiMMy 85
    Who is Leon Clake?
    It's a piece of Clake.
  • dizzeedizzee
    Ben Hamer 66
    John Sullivan 58
    Nick Pope 48
    -
    Chris Solly 72
    Michael Morrison 70
    Leon Cort 65
    Rhoys Wiggins 69
    Matt Taylor 64
    Cedric Evina 58
    Yado Mambo 48
    -
    Scott Wagstaff 64
    Danny Hollands 69
    Dale Stephens 66
    Johnnie Jackson 70
    Andy Hughes 63
    Bradley Pritchard 66
    Ruben Bover 58
    Danny Green 67
    -
    Bradley Wright-Phillips 69
    Yann Kermorgant 73
    Danny Haynes 67
    Michael Smith 52
    Paul Hayes 66
    Leon Clake 48
  • thai malaysia addickthai malaysia addick
    Who is Leon Clake?
    It's a piece of Clake.
    You just want to have your Clake and eat it
  • Addickted4lifeAddickted4life
    Ben Hamer 68
    John Sullivan 61
    Nick Pope 50
    -
    Chris Solly 72
    Michael Morrison 71
    Leon Cort 68
    Rhoys Wiggins 69
    Matt Taylor 65
    Cedric Evina 63
    Yado Mambo 55
    -
    Scott Wagstaff 65
    Danny Hollands 68
    Dale Stephens 66
    Johnnie Jackson 70
    Andy Hughes 62
    Bradley Pritchard 65
    Ruben Bover 61
    Danny Green 66
    Callum Harriott 62 (You missed him)
    -
    Bradley Wright-Phillips 69
    Yann Kermorgant 70
    Danny Haynes 68
    Michael Smith 54
    Paul Hayes 63
    Leon Clarke 63
  • Dan C 4Dan C 4
    Ben Hamer 66
    John Sullivan 58
    Nick Pope 48
    -
    Chris Solly 72
    Michael Morrison 70
    Leon Cort 65
    Rhoys Wiggins 70
    Matt Taylor 64
    Cedric Evina 58
    Yado Mambo 48
    -
    Scott Wagstaff 64
    Danny Hollands 69
    Dale Stephens 66
    Johnnie Jackson 70
    Andy Hughes 63
    Bradley Pritchard 99
    Ruben Bover 58
    Danny Green 67
    -
    Bradley Wright-Phillips 73
    Yann Kermorgant 99
    Danny Haynes 67
    Michael Smith 52
    Paul Hayes 66
    Leon Clake 48
  • Powell Is PleasantPowell Is Pleasant
    Who is Leon Clake?
    It's a piece of Clake.
    You just want to have your Clake and eat it
    I think he meant Leon Cack.
  • Sponsored links:


  • samcooke91samcooke91
    Literally always underrated on Football Manager as well , I reckon worse than Fifa , anyone else find it incredibly hard to do well with us or is that my lack of FM talent
  • Covered_End_LadCovered_End_Lad
    Literally always underrated on Football Manager as well , I reckon worse than Fifa , anyone else find it incredibly hard to do well with us or is that my lack of FM talent
    have managed to get charlton into the prem eventually, but yes our players especially hollands and jacko are very underated
  • cafctomcafctom
    No matter what we all know, there is little chance they will have Yann Kermorgant's stats ahead of Bradley Wright-Phillips.

    For a start, I've never found it to be the sort of game where ariel attacking seems to come into play too much.
  • ScohamScoham
    edited June 2012
    Seeing as Yann is our best player he will be our best player in the next FM (assuming he stays and excluding any new signings of course)...

    How well he and BWP do in the match engine is an issue with the game itself. Hopefully there will be some improvements in the next version in that area.

    On us being underrated, the ratings probably look harsh compared to games like FIFA, but it's about how they perform in the game. It was definitely possible for BWP to score 20+ a season for example.

    Other thing to remember with FM 12 we signed nearly 20 players last summer. They were all rated by the researcher of their previous club, so they won't all 'fit' perfectly with each other.

    They are aware that Norwich and Southampton in particular have shown there isn't a huge gap between the divisions. I don't think many will be disappointed with our new ratings.
  • BroadstairsAddickBroadstairsAddick
    I dont think BWP wont be much more higher, maybe 69/70 overall, But Kermorgants heading Accuracy should be between 82/87 and jumping 84/89.
  • BroadstairsAddickBroadstairsAddick
    Ben Hamer 67
    John Sullivan 61
    Nick Pope (Dont Know)
    -
    Chris Solly 73
    Michael Morrison 72
    Leon Cort 66
    Rhoys Wiggins 70
    Matt Taylor 66
    Cedric Evina 62
    Yado Mambo 55
    -
    Scott Wagstaff 68
    Danny Hollands 70
    Dale Stephens 68
    Johnnie Jackson 70
    Andy Hughes 60
    Bradley Pritchard 65
    Ruben Bover 60
    Danny Green 66
    -
    Bradley Wright-Phillips 70
    Yann Kermorgant 73
    Danny Haynes 68
    Michael Smith 54
    Paul Hayes 63
    Leon Clarke 61
  • SheedyCAFCSheedyCAFC
    -Potential signings ratings-
    Keith Andrews 73
    Anthony Wordsworth 65
    François Zoko 63
  • kentaddickkentaddick
    Seeing as Yann is our best player he will be our best player in the next FM (assuming he stays and excluding any new signings of course)...

    How well he and BWP do in the match engine is an issue with the game itself. Hopefully there will be some improvements in the next version in that area.

    On us being underrated, the ratings probably look harsh compared to games like FIFA, but it's about how they perform in the game. It was definitely possible for BWP to score 20+ a season for example.

    Other thing to remember with FM 12 we signed nearly 20 players last summer. They were all rated by the researcher of their previous club, so they won't all 'fit' perfectly with each other.

    They are aware that Norwich and Southampton in particular have shown there isn't a huge gap between the divisions. I don't think many will be disappointed with our new ratings.
    I'm expecting Yann to have 20 jumping stat Scoham :) I'm sure you'll get the ratings spot on, you almost always do.
  • SE18AddickSE18Addick
    I'd like to be able to keep the Hollands/ Stephens axis for longer, so would love for them to start out at 70. Found it odd this year that BWP stuck at 68 for 5 years, yet bossed it in every division (and Europe!!).
    my BWP is sittin at 71?
  • CoxeyCoxey
    sam3110 said:

    There is no way in hell any of our players will be 75 or above, as that would make them a gold player in ultimate team, and usually theres about 5-6 players in the whole championship who are gold! We will be mid championship rated, about 10th-14th in overall stats

    Yeh but what about Ricardo Fuller ?
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!