Kirlkland out for 6 weeks - will Carson get the call

Ledge

for England in Israel by McLaren.

He doesn't like Charlton players that is plainly obvious.

Will be interesting.

I bet he brings back James - who deserves it to be fair - but will be interesting

AFKABartram

can't see it, and not sure i'd really want him to at the moment. Seems to me there's little to gain from a match like this, but a lot to lose.

If i was McClaren, i'd probably go for experience for this one, but Scotty should be in the frame next season.

BlackForestReds

What would the point be in recalling James again?

AFKABartram

a solid short-term stop gap measure.

James has arguably been the best English goalkeeper this season anyway

BlackForestReds

James has been the best English goal keeper for the last few seasons - at club level. In internationals he has never looked comfortable or convincing. As a one-off measure maybe, but at his age he's not part of the future. Carson is, so I'd take Carson and use it as experience for him, Israel are a tough nut to crack but they aren't one of the better international sides, no disrespect to them but if Carson can be considered a Premiership keeper then he should be more than capable of performing against Israel.

oohaahmortimer

[cite]Posted By: BlackForestReds[/cite]James has been the best English goal keeper for the last few seasons - at club level. In internationals he has never looked comfortable or convincing.

even our dennis scored past him!

WSS

and Amady Faye...

Medders

McClaren has recently been quoted as saying the door isn't shut for James, Campbell and Beckham.... so my money would be on a recall for James....