Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Best player you've seen at the Valley

24

Comments

  • Was that for Graeme Tutt`s testimonial by any chance? Remember Malcolm McDonald played that night as well, and Bill Oddie! lol
  • George Best
    Yes...and in a Charlton shirt
    indeed
  • That night brings back memories! Massive shame about Tutt as he was tipped to go right to the very top of the game. Think the crowd was around the 9,000 mark.
  • Overall Parker our best player by a mile but best individual performances Kevin Lisbie v Liverpool and against us, Berbatov for Spurs the night we got relegated with Ronaldo and Henry not far behind




  • for us Scott Parker

    for the opposition Glen Hoddle or Ryan Giggs


  • Us: Parker by a mile. Bent, di canio, Jensen, kinsella, Rufus,Mendonca all deserve praise for diff reasons.

    Others (based on performances against us): hated him but Henry, ginola, bergkamp, kanoute (always impressed me for west ham against us), Zola, van nistleroy, Owen, dugarry for the brummies. Probably loads more.
  • I think Best played in Les Berry's testimonial . I wouldn't count him

    For Charlton it has to be Simonsen although Di Canio comes second.

    Against as well as Giggs ,I would also make a case for John Barnes .

  • Oliver Bierhoff for Ascoli ... absolute imense
  • Scholes always seemed to have a solid game against us

  • If i had to pick one; Thierry Henry (there was no need to kick our corner flag and give it so much though, the postulating ponce)
  • Sponsored links:


  • Without a shadow of doubt for me , this fella

     

  • Thierry Henry.
  • The best for Charlton at The Valley I've seen were Allan Simonsen, Andy Hunt or Scott Parker. Di Canio was very good but he only scored one open play goal for us (in the League Cup).

    Not necessarily the best opposing player but he murdered us in a cameo after coming on as sub....Ali Bernarbia of Manchester City.

    The best I've seen against us were in our Selhurst Park days....Des Walker, Tony Adams, Mark Wright and Paul Gascoigne.

     

     

  • I cannot recall Bergkamp or Zola ever producing their best performances against us. Both wonderful players of course, but don't remember them turning it on at The Valley.

    Mark Viduka destroyed us a couple of times. 


  • In a Red shirt i would say Parker, Mendonca , Kiely , Jensen and i liked Andy Reid

    Visiting players - Giggs in the 3-3, Henry everytime and Viduka for Leeds - Jon Fortune always had Shearer in his pocket at the Valley !

  • Without a shadow of doubt for me , this fella

     

    Jan Molby??
  • I'm trying to think of a keeper for the opposition who has played a blinder but can't think of one off hand apart from Nigel Martyn maybe
  • edited November 2011
    Thierry Henry, definitely
  • Thierry Henry, definitely
  • Sponsored links:


  • I'm trying to think of a keeper for the opposition who has played a blinder but can't think of one off hand apart from Nigel Martyn maybe
    Mark Crossley always had a blinder at the Valley! Topped off with his penalty save from Neil Redfearn against Forest in 1999
  • I'm trying to think of a keeper for the opposition who has played a blinder but can't think of one off hand apart from Nigel Martyn maybe
    Mark Crossley always had a blinder at the Valley! Topped off with his penalty save from Neil Redfearn against Forest in 1999




    Mark Swarzcher for Bradford played a blinder in around 96/97 - think it was one of his first games and was sold to Boro a few days later for £1m.

    Oakes for Villa in 98/99 and the Norwich keeper in 09/10 were both unbeatable in those games.  

  • Thierry Henry always scared me

  • I'm trying to think of a keeper for the opposition who has played a blinder but can't think of one off hand apart from Nigel Martyn maybe
    Mark Crossley always had a blinder at the Valley! Topped off with his penalty save from Neil Redfearn against Forest in 1999




    Mark Swarzcher for Bradford played a blinder in around 96/97 - think it was one of his first games and was sold to Boro a few days later for £1m.


    Yep I remember the Swarzcher game

    Does anyone remember the first game of the season back in the late 1980s against Liverpool when they spanked us 5 nil when Aldridge got a hatrick 
    ... that was possibly the best team performance I've seen against us

    Was men versus boys that day


  • david ginola had a 3 year period when he was the bane of our PL lives.

    wanted to hate him for scoring against us, but it was impossible as he was such a class player

  • Eddie Firmani first time around : too good for everyone else - a different class so went to Italy for a world record fee.
  • Ginola was good when he came on in that night game for spurs
  • edited November 2011
    Paul Mortimer, sentimental too. When he scored THAT goal against Bradford I nearly headbutted the roof of the west stand. Had great games and absolute mares. And my dad thought he was crap and lazy!
    Do you remember similar goals from Morts in the mid 90's - namely Bristol City in a 3-2 win. Scored at the south stand end. And another great strike v Wolves at the north stand end.
  • ya think we were winning through a kinsella strike then ginola terrorised us, 4.1 and we went down that game
  • Eddie Firmani first time around : too good for everyone else - a different class so went to Italy for a world record fee.
    Always was, and still is the best player I've seen at the Valley by a country mile.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!