Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Best XI Since Premiership

peteshep1905peteshep1905
edited September 2011 in General Charlton

I know people will have a huge range of opinions on this but i'm interested to know who people would say are the best players we've has since we dropped out the premiership. This is mine...

Elliot

Richardson - Morrison - Sodje - Youga

Sam - Hollands - Zheng - Thomas

Wright-Phillips - Varney

 

Subs: Solly, Wagstaff, Holland, Shelvey, Semedo, Jackson, Burton

 

just opinion

«1

Comments

  • Friend Or DefoeFriend Or Defoe
    edited September 2011
    Good idea

                                  Weaver
    Richardson - Bougherra - Fortune (pre injury) - Basey
    Green - Stephens - Reid - Bailey - Ecclestone
                   Wright-Philips - Iwelumo (Imagine him playing with Green!)
  • paulsturgesspaulsturgess
    Andy Reid is by some considerable distance the best player who has played for us since we were relegated
  • RizzoRizzo
    Andy Reid is by some considerable distance the best player who has played for us since we were relegated
    I would argue that Zheng Zhi would take that accolade.
  • BR7_addickBR7_addick
    Elliott
    Richardson, Bougherra, Hudson, Youga
    Thomas, Zheng, Bailey, Reid
    Wright-Phillips, Varney
  • RizzoRizzo
    HUDSON?!
  • MikeMike
    Good idea

                                  Weaver
    Richardson - Bougherra - Fortune (pre injury) - Basey
    Green - Stephens - Bailey - Ecclestone
                   Wright-Philips - Iwelumo (Imagine him playing with Green!)
    You honestly think Green the player who has played 2 cup games and one league game and who can't get into our current team is the best right winger we've had since the prem days? I won't get started on Eccleston.
  • peteshep1905peteshep1905
    Andy Reid is by some considerable distance the best player who has played for us since we were relegated
    I would argue that Zheng Zhi would take that accolade.

    agree... zheng or bwp
  • Friend Or DefoeFriend Or Defoe
    Andy Reid is by some considerable distance the best player who has played for us since we were relegated
    Good point, I'll amend my team.

    Mike, I'll see you under the wheels of my taxi.
  • MikeMike
    you mean you actually go and watch the team and that's still your best team??? even worse than I thought.

    Thomas is miles better than Green and Reid is miles better than Eccleston.
  • Oggy RedOggy Red
    It's only an opinion Mike ...... not life or death, mate!

    ;o)
  • Sponsored links:


  • MikeMike
    edited September 2011
    im aware thanks. Just thought I would question a few of his picks get some debate going rather than everyone just posting their teams. :)
  • peteshep1905peteshep1905
    wot did others think of varney?? i really liked him, worked really hard, never gave up on lost causes and was a good finisher... i assumer he left for for free just to reduce the wage bill...?
  • Oggy RedOggy Red
    edited September 2011
    Fair enough, Mike.
  • Friend Or DefoeFriend Or Defoe
    edited September 2011
    Mike, please post your team! Reid nearly made it but Ecclestone piped him to it due to his performances last season, which is probably why he hasn't got a club at present. Didn't think much of Thomas when we were in the championship, although clearly he's decent as he's at West Brom, he's certainly no Danny Green!
  • MikeMike
    wot did others think of varney?? i really liked him, worked really hard, never gave up on lost causes and was a good finisher... i assumer he left for for free just to reduce the wage bill...?
    worked hard, plenty of effort but some of the sitters he missed in that relegation season from the championship were unforgivable. Remember one at Cardiff away before things went tits up and QPR away to name a few.
  • paulsturgesspaulsturgess
    Andy Reid is by some considerable distance the best player who has played for us since we were relegated
    I would argue that Zheng Zhi would take that accolade.

    agree... zheng or bwp
    eh? BWP has only played for us in the third tier so impossible to even compare him. zheng was good but reid was pure class for the first half of that season and completely dominated games, it is no coincidence that we were basically in the top two when he got injured (and subsequently sold), and then collapsed (in spite of Zheng) to midtable mediocrity.
  • peteshep1905peteshep1905

    considering taking thomas out of my team because he only played two games in the time-range this is based on, jackson may get a call up to the mighty peteshep1905 2007-present dream team!!

  • Friend Or DefoeFriend Or Defoe

    considering taking thomas out of my team because he only played two games in the time-range this is based on, jackson may get a call up to the mighty peteshep1905 2007-present dream team!!

    He played a lot more than two games!
  • Oggy RedOggy Red
    Thing with Varney was that he tried too hard, always running at full tilt - it can be hard to retain composure when you bust a gut to get in scoring position.

    A more relaxed player might have put some of those chances away ......but would he have got into the positions that Varney got into?

    One thing about non-League players coming into the game late - they may often lack a little finesse, but their attitude is generally spot on.
  • peteshep1905peteshep1905

    considering taking thomas out of my team because he only played two games in the time-range this is based on, jackson may get a call up to the mighty peteshep1905 2007-present dream team!!

    He played a lot more than two games!

    quite right! i got me years mixed up, it was the following season he only played twice me thinks
  • Sponsored links:


  • J BLOCKJ BLOCK
    Scott Sinclair anyone?
  • Friend Or DefoeFriend Or Defoe
    Scott Sinclair anyone?
    Based on how he's done at Swansea - Yes
    Based on how he did for us - No.
  • mid_life_crisismid_life_crisis
    you mean you actually go and watch the team and that's still your best team??? even worse than I thought.

    Thomas is miles better than Green and Reid is miles better than Eccleston.
    You mean you actually go and watch the team and believe Grant Basey was a better left back that Kelly Youga.
    Shurely shome mishtake. 
  • cafcdan18cafcdan18
    edited September 2011

                      Elliot

    Richardson Dailly Bougherra Youga

    Waggy Stephens Reid Jackson

                Burton BWP

    Subs- Weaver, Morrison, Zheng, Hollands, Iwelumo

  • gilbertfilbertgilbertfilbert
    edited September 2011
    What about doing it without players who had played in the Prem with us?

    Randolph

    Solly
    Morrison
    Dailly
    Youga

    Varney
    Stephens
    Hollands
    Jackson

    Wright-Phillips
    Iwelumo

    subs:  Weaver, Richardson, Taylor, Wagstaff, Burton
  • SheffieldRedSheffieldRed
    What about doing it without players who had played in the Prem with us?

    Randolph

    Solly
    Morrison
    Dailly
    Youga

    Varney
    Stephens
    Hollands
    Jackson

    Wright-Phillips
    Iwelumo

    subs:  Weaver, Richardson, Taylor, Wagstaff, Burton
    Randolph played in the prem
  • gilbertfilbertgilbertfilbert
    Oh yes.  I'd forgotten that.  Weaver in goal and Elliot on the bench then.
  • Dazzler21Dazzler21
    Weaver

    Richardson
    McCarthy
    Dailly
    Youga

    Varney
    Shelvey
    Holland
    Reid

    Wright-Phillips
    Iwelumo

    subs:  Elliott, Solly, Zhi, Wagstaff, Burton


  • superjonniejacksonsuperjonniejackson
    elliot

    richardson
    dailly
    bourgerra
    youga

    varney
    holland
    zheng
    a.reid

    bwp
    burton

    subs: weaver, solly, hudson, shelvey, semedo, lita
  • smudge7946smudge7946
    Shelvey hasnt made many peoples best xi
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!