Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: League Cup Round 1: Charlton 2-1 Reading

Well that was exciting for those few at the Valley, please give your marks up to 10, halves allowed. So copy and paste the list:

Hamer
Francis
Doherty
Mambo
Evina
Green
Hughes
Pritchard
Bover
Benson
Euell
Wagstaff

Morrison n/a
Solly n/a



«13

Comments

  • Mrs AFKA's

    Hamer - 8
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 7
    Mambo - 8
    Evina - 8
    Green - 8.5
    Hughes - 7
    Pritchard - 8
    Bover - 8
    Benson - 7.5
    Euell - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 8
  • Hamer 8 
    Francis 7 
    Doherty 7
    Mambo 8
    Evina 8
    Green 8.5
    Hughes 7
    Pritchard 8.5
    Bover 8
    Benson 8
    Euell 8
    Wagstaff 8
  • Hamer - 8 - decent debut, did well when called upon
    Francis - 6.5 - a decent enough game from him, the odd comedy moment as usual
    Doherty - 7 - solid
    Mambo - 7 - even more solid
    Evina - 7.5 - quick, skilful and will be pushing Wiggins soon enough
    Green - 8 - dangerous throughout, although he's not going to give the right back much protection
    Hughes - 7 - honest and hardworking
    Pritchard - 8.5 - MOTM, pace, skill, relentless work - was he really signed from the non-league?
    Bover - 7.5 - very good debut, bit lightweight at times but caused them problems when on the ball
    Benson - 8 - looked sharp, ahead of Euell in my view
    Euell -7.5 - good to have him back, nicely taken goal
    Wagstaff - 8 - this boy is lightning, relentlessly hardworking, skillful and Reading couldn't handle him 
  • edited August 2011
    Hamer 7 - Made a few good saves. No mistakes made. Good debut against his former club.
    Francis 8 - Him and Green worked well together. Definitely wants to prove a point! 
    Doherty 7 - Comfortable before going off. Worked well with Mambo.
    Mambo 8 - Also wants to prove a point. Dealt with Manset well and he controlled the defence.
    Evina 7.5 - He will give Wiggins a run for his money. Great vision and picked out some love passes.
    Green 8.5 - Almost scored from 2 corners.. and he takes them! Great delivery and a good full debut.
    Hughes 6.5 - Shakey. Wayward passes and headers. Good leader though but bench please.
    Pritchard 8.5 - Showed that he can hack the football league. Deserves a place on the bench. MOM
    Bover 7 - Not a lot to do but he caused problems when he had the ball. Not ready for the league yet though.
    Benson 7.5 - Definitely out to prove a point. If he stayed on I reckon he could of got another. He's a poacher.
    Euell 7.5 - should have scored first half. Took his time getting into the game but in the second half he was alive! Nice head.
    Wagstaff 7.5 - Caused all sorts of problems when coming on. His best position is behind the striker!

    Morrison n/a
    Solly n/a
  • edited August 2011
    Hamer   7.5
    Francis   7
    Doherty 7.5
    Mambo  7
    Evina    7
    Green   8,5
    Hughes  7
    Pritchard  8
    Bover  6.5
    Benson  7.5
    Euell  7.5
    Wagstaff  8

    Morrison n/a
    Solly n/a
  • edited August 2011
    Hamer 8
    Francis 7
    Doherty 7
    Mambo 8
    Evina 7
    Green 8
    Hughes 7
    Pritchard 8
    Bover 7
    Benson 7
    Euell 8
    Wagstaff 8
  • Hamer 7.5 very good debut.
    Francis 7 variable.
    Doherty 7.5 Got better as game went on, injured.
    Mambo 7.5 very good home debut
    Evina 7.5 very good debut, improved as game went on.
    Green 8 Will be 83% great, and 17% exasperating.

    Hughes 7 Well he was at least a presence.
    Pritchard 8 and shades my MOM. Very very good debut
    Bover 7.5 Ruby don't take your love to town.
    Benson 8 Much better than usual
    Euell 8 A really good 90 min shift
    Wagstaff 8 Excellent half, nigh on faultless.

    Morrison n/a
    Solly n/a

  • edited August 2011
    Hamer-7.5
    Francis-7.5
    Doherty-7
    Mambo-8.5
    Evina-8.5
    Green-7.5
    Hughes-6.5
    Pritchard-8.5 MOM
    Bover-7.5
    Benson-7.5
    Euell-7.5
    Wagstaff-7
  • Hamer - 8
    Francis - 7
    Doherty -7
    Mambo - 8
    Evina - 7.5
    Green - 8.5
    Hughes - 7
    Pritchard - 8
    Bover - 7.5
    Benson - 7.5
    Euell - 8
    Wagstaff - 8 this should be his new position


  • Hamer 7 needs to be more commanding of his area few decent saves though
    Francis 6 frightens the life out of me.great crosses though
    Doherty 6.5 helped mambo bit slow for me though
    Mambo 7.5 great in the air improved drastically in a year
    Evina 7.5 great debut worked hard very quick
    Green 7.5 very clever player
    Hughes 7 looked edgey to start works hard though
    Pritchard 8 MOM excellent in both attack and defence
    Bover 7.5 great debut,needs to hit the weights but could be great
    Benson 7 good backup striker
    Euell 7.5 worked hard,glad he scored
    Wagstaff 7 good cameo looked very sharp
  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer - 7.5; a couple of class saves that boosts him up from a 7. Good shift.
    Francis - 7; still looks tangibly a member from last season's team, but played quite well. Needs more passion!
    Doherty - 7; got rid safely. Quiet but did enough.
    Mambo - 8.5 and my MOM. Absolute beast. Headed everything that moved and had Manset in his pocket. Really good performance.
    Evina - 7.5; enterprising runs and decent enough defending. Excitingly quick.
    Green - 8; certainly will be a good player. A lot of ability and he showed it at times.
    Hughes - 7; captain 110% but let's face it, he's awful technically!
    Pritchard - 8; he's energetic and intelligent. Promising, and he's a more than useful option.
    Bover - 7.5; not ready physically but he's a good player. Intelligence and flair abundant.
    Benson - 7.5 on the basis he scored. Good link-up play, too.
    Euell - 7.5; same as Benno, really.
    Wagstaff - 7.5; industrious as always. He's an excellent athlete and that came out today.

    Morrison n/a
    Solly n/a
  • Hamer 7.5
    Francis 8
    Doherty 7.5
    Mambo 8
    Evina 8.5
    Green 8.5
    Hughes 7
    Pritchard 8
    Bover 7.5
    Benson 8
    Euell 8
    Wagstaff 7.5
  • Hamer 7
    Francis 7
    Doherty 7
    Mambo 7
    Evina 8
    Green 7
    Hughes 7
    Pritchard 9
    Bover 7
    Benson 7
    Euell 7
    Wagstaff 7
  • Hamer - 7 - a couple of good blocks and a decent tip over. solid debut!
    Francis - 7 - a decent game, looked reasonably solid at the back and got forward on occassions , althought final back wasn't brilliant

    Doherty - 7 - Ginger pele had a solid game, looked solid throughout
    Mambo - 7 - done well. no sign of nerves that have crept in in previous appearances. he's a big lad and could be a beast of a CB. work needed on his passing at times though

    Evina - 7.5 - looked very good going forward and rreasonably solid in defence. be interesting to see how he performs against better opposition.

    Green - 8.5 - looked lively throught, he's delivery will be a real asset this season. may be pushing waggy for that starting birth on sat.

    Hughes - 6 - worked hard enough but his passing at time was poor and put team mates under pressure.

    Pritchard - 8.5 - didn't look out of place at all. his passing was always spot on and he worked hard all game. if he keeps this up he could be a gem of signing.

    Bover - 7 - looked very good on the ball. got caught in possession a couple of times, but when he had the ball you thought he could create something.

    Benson - 8 - i really like benno. he works so hard, and if he's given service he will score!! i hope he doesn't leave

    Euell -7 - took his goal well and later on in the game he showed some good touches. however he looked slightly off the pace in the first half

    Wagstaff - 7 - worked hard and caused problem, as ever. maybe we don't need to sign a young quick striker, we could have one already.

    Morrision - 6 - not really enough time to make a big impression

    Solly - 6 - as above
  • Hamer - 8
    Francis - 7.5
    Docherty - 7
    Mambo -7
    Evina -8
    Green - 7.5
    Hughes - 7
    Pritchard -8
    Bover -7
    Benson -7
    Euell - 7
    Waggy 7.5

  • Hamer - 7 Few flaps but few quality stops
    Francis - 6.5 Does something good then something woeful
    Doherty - 7 Solid but slow
    Mambo - 8 Very impressive, he needs more game time and if he carries on, could be an option.
    Evina - 7.5 Really think he'll be pushing Wiggins for a place
    Green - 8.5 So exciting to watch. Won't always go right but some of his passing had me dribbling!
    Hughes - 7 Solid enough but nearly dropped a clanger that could have cost us.
    Pritchard - 8.5 Little man, big heart and a decent footballer. Impressive game.
    Bover - 6.5 Did ok but didn't have time he wanted on the ball. Loan move would be ideal.
    Benson - 7.5 Thought he did well and was a handful when on.
    Euell - 7 Worked hard but thought tonight showed how at best he'll be a sub. Love the guy but we need better.
    Wagstaff - 8 Was excellent off the bench and the cross for second goal was sublime.

  • edited August 2011
    Green - 8.5 So exciting to watch. Won't always go right but some of his passing had me dribbling! 
    Just as well his dribbling didn't have you passing.
  • Some people are giving Hughes a higher rating than Francis. I don't see how Francis was worse than Hughes. I thought Hughes was shocking.
  • edited August 2011
    Hamer 7 - Made a couple of decent saves - good debut - need to see more as slight doubt of his command of box.
    Francis 8 - Very good game and won a few headers too!!! Not Solley's fault he is short but Francis does add something to the defence IMO. Did himself no harm at all.
    Doherty 8 -Will head balls clear all day long -composed and comfortable
    Mambo 8.5 - Thought he was bloody excellent -keep this up and he will be knocking on the door.
    Evina 7 - Not sure defensively but good going forwards -very good.
    Green 8.5 - Great delivery, abilty and competes. A key player for us this season.
    Hughes 6.5 - Thought he improved as the game went on.
    Pritchard 9 -MOTM This player is a real find - Despite our midfield being do strong he is knocking on the door big time. 
    Bover 6.5 -Could tell it was his first competetive match - possibly tried a bit too hard.
    Benson 7.5 - Looked sharp and up for it
    Euell 8-  How can anybody say he was slightly off the pace? - missed good one on one chance but oozed class and touch was top drawer.
    Wagstaff 7 - Looked lively -caused problems - ball in on occasions could have been better but a good game.
  • Hamer-7.5 Great save at the end of the 1st half, was good
    Francis-8 Good headers/tackles
    Doherty-7.5
    Mambo-7.5
    Evina-7.5 Better than what I've seen of Wiggins so far
    Green-7.5
    Hughes-6.5 Same as Mutley he got better as the game went on
    Pritchard-8.5 Looks very good
    Bover-7 Alot of potential there
    Benson-8 Shame he got injured as he was doing brilliantly
    Euell-8 He's not past it by a long way
    Wagstaff-7 Good game, this boy keeps getting better and better imo

    Morrison n/a
    Solly n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer 8
    Francis 7.5
    Doherty 7
    Mambo 8
    Evina 8
    Green 8.5
    Hughes 7
    Pritchard 8.5
    Bover 8
    Benson 8
    Euell 7.5
    Wagstaff 8

     

  • Imagine the team we would have put out if we made eleven changes last season!!! This 'reserve' team would be play off standard in League one. Pritchard a massive find- massive - Mambo showing that he might just be ready -terrific game - Francis was excellent, Euell looked a class apart, Green was quality and Hamewr looks a decent keeper. Deserved to win by a bigger margin.
  • Hamer 7.5. A fantastic save in the 1st half 
    Francis 7.5 A couple of dodgy moments but coped well
    Doherty 7. Was carrying an injury for quite a while before he went off 
    Mambo 8 Won just about everything thrown at him
    Evina 8 some great attacking runs
    Green 7.5. Some fantastic crosses but missed a sitter early on 
    Hughes 6 The only player who made a umber of poor errors
    Pritchard 8.5 A superb all round performance and was unlucky not to score 
    Bover 7.5 good performance and hit the woodwork just before cramp set in
    Benson 7 good performance but went off with a hand injury
    Euell 7.5 good hold up play
    Wagstaff 7.5 looked good up front
  • Hamer 8 I like him hope his number 1 on Saturday
    Francis 8
    Doherty 7
    Mambo 7
    Evina 7
    Green 8
    Hughes 7
    Pritchard 8
    Bover 7
    Benson 7
    Euell 7
    Wagstaff 8 I know he wouldnt agree but he would be a great sub to bring on every game
  • Hamer - 7.5 - Good Debut
    Francis - 7.5 Quality Assist for Euelly goal
    Doherty - 7.5 Pretty Solid , shame he came off with a knock
    Mambo - 7,5 - Phew did well tonight
    Evina - 7.5 - One or two shaky moments , some moments of real promise & quality
    Green - 8 - I love watching this guy cross a ball , pure poetry in motion
    Pritchard - 9 - Outstanding MOM ran the show , well done son
    Bover - 7 - Bit lightweight , will improve , lot to learn glad to see him on the pitch , looked like cramp caught up with him
    Benson - 8 Shame he got injured , good goal and performance
    Euell - Looked rusty , scored a goal and made another , long may he look rusty!
    Wagstaff - 7.5 A real live wire effervescent performance as usual , roll on Bury!



  • Extremely impressive display from our second eleven. We have a talented squad on this display.
    Hamer - 7.5 Made great saves either side of half time
    Francis 8.5 A different player from last season. Man of the match
    Doherty 7.5 Played well - Injured
    Mambo 8 Very solid display
    Evina 7.5 I would say he's better option than Wiggins
    Green 8 - nearly scored directly from two corners
    Hughes 7.5 Ran his socks off. Impressive 
    Pritchard 7 Looked a little lost at times but was composed when on the ball.
    Bover 7.5 Hit the bar. he's going to be a big star in the future .  
    Benson 7.5 Out to prove a point until he got injured
    Euell 6.5 Not convinced he's a better option than Benson.
    Wagstaff 8 Very dangerous when he came on.

  • edited August 2011
    Some people are giving Hughes a higher rating than Francis. I don't see how Francis was worse than Hughes. I thought Hughes was shocking.
    Francis was better than Hughes but how can you say Hughes was shocking? There wasn't a player in a red shirt who came close to being shocking.
  • Some people are giving Hughes a higher rating than Francis. I don't see how Francis was worse than Hughes. I thought Hughes was shocking.
    Francis was better than Hughes but how can you say Hughes was shocking? There wasn't a player in a red shirt who came close to be shocking.
    I hold my hand up to that comment I made about him being shocking. A bit harsh to be fair. I wouldn't bench him over Francis though but I see why he is on the bench... same reason as why Euell is on the bench.
  • Hamer - 7
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 7
    Mambo - 8
    Evina - 8.5
    Green - 7.5
    Hughes - 7
    Pritchard - 9 MOM
    Bover - 7.5
    Benson - 7
    Euell - 7
    Wagstaff - 7
  • Hamer 8 - Some good saves, played well.
    Francis 8 - Very good. Got forward well and cleared the ball from under pressure.
    Doherty 7 - Did quite well. Looked shaky at the beginning but became better throughout.
    Mambo 8 - Was fantastic in the air and commanding too.
    Evina 7.5 - Fast and showed he can run with the ball well. He has a lot of power and some of his cross-field delivery was excellent.
    Green 8 - Was a constant threat and showed good delivery, but some of his play was quite wayward and he wanders around the pitch, completely exposing the RB.
    Hughes 4 - Absolutely awful. Tried a headed back-pass from nearly the half-way line that nearly cost us a goal, and constantly messed up. Works hard, but that's not good enough IMO.
    Pritchard 9 - Fantastic. That lob was superb and was very unlucky not to score from it. Commands well and looks very composed.
    Bover 7 - Showed flair and loads of skill, but faded quite a lot and didn't contribute too much. Wins loads of fouls and was unlucky not to score though.
    Benson 9 - I thought he was excellent before he went off. Scored, chased, tackled, showed a good first touch and his link-up play was impressive. Showed be on the bench ahead of Euell every day of the week.
    Euell 7 - Was quite off the pace and made errors. Glad to see him score, but he should've buried the one-on-one and wasn't very impressive.
    Wagstaff 7.5 - Made an instant impact with his pace and work-rate. His back-heels were brilliant (although completely accidental), but became a bit of a spectator in parts.

    Morrison n/a
    Solly n/a
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!