Elliott - 1 Totally at fault for the decisive goals
Jenkinson - 7 Early mistake, but recovered and grew in confidence. Needs a wide player in front of him.
Doherty - 1 Dreadful
Dailly - 5 Too much is being asked of him.
Fry - 5 Bewildered. Time to move across to CB.
McCormack - 6 He's not Parker, Kinsella, Murphy or Jensen, but he gets from box to box, competes and gives everything he has.
Semedo - 5 Has had better games.
Jackson - 3 Way off the pace. 4-3-3 does not suit him.
Eccleston - 6 Profligate.
Bradley Wright Philips - 6 Took his goal well. Did little else right.
Abbott - 6 A very poor player, who gives everything he's got. Just about our level.
Elliott 5 Jenkinson 6.5 Done OK Doherty 3 Shocker. Far too slow to play alongside Daily Dailly 6 Fry 5 McCormack 5 Lost in space Semedo 5 Three forward passes in 90 minutes (I counted them) Jackson 5 Needs to impose himself more Eccleston 7 Lively., our biggest threat. Bradley Wright Philips 6.5 including 1 for the goal. Abbott 5
Racon 6 tried to liven things up. Reid 5 Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Elliott - 4 - Poor for all 3 of their goals, although those around him didn't help.
Jenkinson - 6 - looked to play, made a few mistakes but didn't hide and did try and get at them.
Doherty - 4 - Not good enough given his experience.
Dailly - 7 - Looked in control of things until those around him went AWOL.
Fry - 4 - defended ok but offers little support going forward.
McCormack - 3 - more interested in creating trouble than opportunities for the front line.
Semedo - 4 - breaks up their play but we will never play enough offensive football with him as the pivot.
Jackson - 4 - looked lost in the 4-3-3
Ecclestone - 6 - tried his best but lacked support going forward.
Bradley Wright Philips - 6 - lost and a waste drifting wide right, he needs to play in front of goal.
Abbott - 5.5 - agian 4-3-3 didn't suit him although he won enough that came to little as no one playing close enough to benefit.
Racon - 7 - Did get things happening from central midfield.
Reid - 6.5 - Caused a few problems for them when he came on, but his final delivery could have been better.
Wagstaff - 6 - Little time to have a real impact.
Elliott - 4: Made big errors that cost us, throwing wasn't bad. Jenkinson - 7.5: Very good home debut, well done Carl. Doherty - 4: Poor, need I say more? - Kept the ball alive for our goal. Dailly - 5: Not his usual self. Fry - 4.5: Not a left back and is showing it lately. McCormack - 1: Useless, when he plays we basically have 10 men. Semedo - 6: Not like last week where he was amazing but did okay today. Jackson - 5: What does he do other than score when/if he gets the chance? Ecclestone - 7: Thought he was bright and one of our better players, up there with Jenkinson. Bradley Wright Philips - 5.5: Scored but done nothing more, I honestly though Doherty had scored as it was so packed in there. He needs to play central. Abbott - 6.5: Running constantly and you can see he is trying so hard for the team. Unlucky when he hit the bar, great piece of skill.
Racon - 6: Done 10 times more than what McCormack done, I think he changed the game as an attacking sense. He MUST start. Reid - 6: Showed signs of getting some form, didn't have too long but was bright. Wagstaff - N/A: Was on for about 5 mins? Hardly got a touch.
Elliott 6 kicks long too often when options available Jenkinson 6 looks like a centreback out of position Doherty 4 woeful. A liability Dailly 6.5 Fry 6 not a full back McCormack 5 didn't hide but lacked impact Semedo 6 trying too bail out a sinking ship Jackson 6 not his best game Ecclestone 7 can't be expected to score every time Bradley Wright Philips 7 always a threat Abbott nothing stuck.poor. even at this level
Racon 6.5 need him back Reid 6.5 looked his old self Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Elliott - 5 Getting a lot of stick but the two massively experienced centre backs take more of the blame imo Jenkinson - 7 not a bad start for a young lad Doherty - 1 - And he doesnt deserve that. Absolutely shocking!!! Dailly - 5.5 Not great but needs a proper partner Fry - 5 - I'd try jacko at LB and give Reid a chance McCormack - 4 - Tries hard but not great. Racon is better but perhaps still not good enough. Semedo - 6 - needs more support Jackson - 5 - Lost his way recently Ecclestone - 7 - Played well but I think he was better on the RW against Posh Bradley Wright Philips - 6 - a goalscorer who doesn't do much else - so play him in the centre. Abbott - 6.5 - Tried very hard and did better than most
most of these marks above are ridiculous and out of total frustration. We were the better side for most of the game, had numerous corners, had the better of possession and anyone who marked lowe than wallsall or swindon really has lost it. Luckily SCP comments are more balanced
Elliott - 6.5 - probably panicked on the pen but otherwise was OK Jenkinson 6.5 - very promising but caught out a couple of times Doherty 5.5 - - did well mostly, helped jenkinson but then made a couple of serious errors Dailly -6.5 Fry -6.5 McCormack - 7 thought battles well in our outnumbered midefield Semedo -7 Jackson - 7 Ecclestone - 5 - missed 2 good chnaces , rarely tracked back - seemed to be playing for himself not charlton Bradley Wright Philips - 4.5 - obviously doesnt like RW, improved when he came more in middle Abbott - 7.5 MOM - had that one gone in that hit the crossbar! Best game for us - however we cant play all 3 of him BWP and NE - selection problems for SCP
Racon - 7 - did fairly well when he came on Reid - 6 - ineffective Wagstaff N/A (edited) - was it a penalty near the end?
Elliott - 4 - At fault for at least one goal.
Jenkinson 5.5 - Didn't look great going forward
Doherty 5 - I actually thought he had a good first half but ruined everything with the mistake
Dailly 5 - Treading water
Fry 5.5 - Not as good as he was earlier in the season
McCormack - 4 Not Good
Semedo 6 - Had to do the work of two men
Jackson 5 - Is he really our best option out wide?
Ecclestone 4.5 - worst game since he came to Charlton
Bradley Wright Philips 5 - Gave up too easily at times
Abbott - 7 . Best player in a red shirt by far. MOM
Racon -5 made no difference ( see below)
Reid - 6 Brought on far too late
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
[cite]Posted By: redman[/cite]Elliott - 6.5 - probably panicked on the pen but otherwise was OK
Jenkinson 6.5 - very promising but caught out a couple of times
Doherty 5.5 - - did well mostly, helped jenkinson but then made a couple of serious errors
Dailly -6.5
Fry -6.5
McCormack - 7 thought battles well in our outnumbered midefield
Semedo -7
Jackson - 7
Ecclestone - 5 - missed 2 good chnaces , rarely tracked back - seemed to be playing for himself not charlton
Bradley Wright Philips - 4.5 - obviously doesnt like RW, improved when he came more in middle
Abbott - 7.5 MOM - had that one gone in that hit the crossbar! Best game for us - however we cant play all 3 of him BWP and NE - selection problems for SCP
Racon - 7 - did fairly well when he came on
Reid - 6 - ineffective
Wagstaff N/A (edited) - was it a penalty near the end?
Obviously watched a different game from the one I did - we were mostly overrun or clueless in possession in midfield and yet you gave the 3 MF 7 points apiece. McCormack battles well - you're having a giraffe!
Elliott 6 Average Jenkinson 7 Grew into the game and did well MOM Doherty 6 Would have been 7 but the second goal was down to him and cost us the game Dailly 6.5 Ok has been better. Talked to Jenks early on Fry 6 Average McCormack 5 They dominated midfield much of the time and that is in large part down to him Semedo 6 One good tacle one good shot not much else. Not helped by McCormack's lack of impact though Jackson 6 Offered a bit going forward tried to help Fry out not at his best Ecclestone 6 Offered more in general play than BWP but too often Pawel headed to nowhere which is partly down to him Bradley Wright Philips 6 Anonymous will be credited with Doc's goal Abbott 7 worked hard with little service unlucky with his shot which hit the bar
Racon 6 A bit of fancy footwork here and there but no real impact better than McCormack but may not be over 90 minutes Reid 6 won a corner or two Wagstaff N/A (edited) 6 little impact but hardly any time
Elliott 4 could have done better with the first and doc didn't help with the third Jenkinson 6.5 done well got up and down well seeing as there was no winger infromt of him Doherty 1 so slow! Whenever he gets in Pressured Its a long punt or a back pass Dailly 6 what can 1 man do? Fry 4.5 done alright but had his moments McCormack 0.5 whyyyy is he still starting we have semedo on to break up attacks then why do we need him to try to it aswell? He doesn't win balls and although he tries racon he leagues better Semedo 5.5 he did try .. Jackson 4 wasn't really involved seemed a little lost at times... Ecclestone 6 should of scored, seemed are biggest threat Bradley Wright Philips 6 good goal want to effect wide right Abbott 5.5 he's got a good touch 4-3-3 didn't really work to his favour though..
Racon 6.5 ran past players ran foward passed forward why is he not starting?! Reid 5.5 didn't really notice him.. Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Elliott - 5 - Below par, blame him for letting the 1st one through his legs and the lame effort on the penalty. Jenkinson - 7 - Solid full debut, couldn't fault him. Doherty - 3 - Simply no pace; Directly at fault for the last two goals. Dailly - 5 Fry - 5 McCormack - 5 - Below par; Don't see anything in him. Semedo - 6 Jackson - 6 Ecclestone - 7 Bradley Wright Philips - 6 Abbott - 5
Comments
Jenkinson - 6
Doherty - 3
Dailly - 5
Fry - 5
McCormack - 4
Semedo - 5
Jackson - 5
Ecclestone - 6.5
Bradley Wright Philips - 5.5
Abbott - 6
Racon - 5.5
Reid - 5.5
Wagstaff - genuinelly didn't realise he came on so no mark!
Jenkinson - 6
Doherty - 4.5
Dailly - 5.5
Fry - 5.5
McCormack - 4
Semedo - 6
Jackson - 5
Ecclestone - 6
Bradley Wright Philips - 5.5
Abbott - 6
Racon - 6
Reid - 5.5
Jenkinson - 7
Doherty - 4
Dailly - 5
Fry - 5.5
McCormack - 4
Semedo - 6
Jackson - 5
Ecclestone - 7
Bradley Wright Philips - 6
Abbott - 6
Racon - 6
Reid - 6
Wagstaff - genuinelly didn't realise he came on so no mark![/quote]
Sorry Waggy only came on 87th minute
Shows how much interest I had in the game.....I stayed till the final whistle as well!.
Jenkinso 6.5
Doherty 4.5
Dailly 5.5
Fry 5
McCormack 4
Semedo 6
Jackson 5
Ecclestone 6.5
Bradley Wright Philips 6
Abbott 6
Racon 6.5
Reid 6
Wagstaff
Jenkinson - 7 Early mistake, but recovered and grew in confidence. Needs a wide player in front of him.
Doherty - 1 Dreadful
Dailly - 5 Too much is being asked of him.
Fry - 5 Bewildered. Time to move across to CB.
McCormack - 6 He's not Parker, Kinsella, Murphy or Jensen, but he gets from box to box, competes and gives everything he has.
Semedo - 5 Has had better games.
Jackson - 3 Way off the pace. 4-3-3 does not suit him.
Eccleston - 6 Profligate.
Bradley Wright Philips - 6 Took his goal well. Did little else right.
Abbott - 6 A very poor player, who gives everything he's got. Just about our level.
Racon - 5
Reid - 4
Wagstaff - 4
Jenkinson 6
Doherty 3
Dailly 5
Fry 5
McCormack 4
Semedo 6
Jackson 4
Ecclestone 6
Bradley Wright Philips 5.5
Abbott 5
Racon
Reid
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Jenkinson 6.5 Done OK
Doherty 3 Shocker. Far too slow to play alongside Daily
Dailly 6
Fry 5
McCormack 5 Lost in space
Semedo 5 Three forward passes in 90 minutes (I counted them)
Jackson 5 Needs to impose himself more
Eccleston 7 Lively., our biggest threat.
Bradley Wright Philips 6.5 including 1 for the goal.
Abbott 5
Racon 6 tried to liven things up.
Reid 5
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Jenkinson - 6 - looked to play, made a few mistakes but didn't hide and did try and get at them.
Doherty - 4 - Not good enough given his experience.
Dailly - 7 - Looked in control of things until those around him went AWOL.
Fry - 4 - defended ok but offers little support going forward.
McCormack - 3 - more interested in creating trouble than opportunities for the front line.
Semedo - 4 - breaks up their play but we will never play enough offensive football with him as the pivot.
Jackson - 4 - looked lost in the 4-3-3
Ecclestone - 6 - tried his best but lacked support going forward.
Bradley Wright Philips - 6 - lost and a waste drifting wide right, he needs to play in front of goal.
Abbott - 5.5 - agian 4-3-3 didn't suit him although he won enough that came to little as no one playing close enough to benefit.
Racon - 7 - Did get things happening from central midfield.
Reid - 6.5 - Caused a few problems for them when he came on, but his final delivery could have been better.
Wagstaff - 6 - Little time to have a real impact.
Jenkinson 6.5
Doherty 3.5
Dailly 6
Fry 5
McCormack 4
Semedo 5
Jackson 5
Eccleston 7
Bradley Wright Philips 6.5
Abbott 5.5
Racon 6
Reid 5
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Jenkinson - 7.5: Very good home debut, well done Carl.
Doherty - 4: Poor, need I say more? - Kept the ball alive for our goal.
Dailly - 5: Not his usual self.
Fry - 4.5: Not a left back and is showing it lately.
McCormack - 1: Useless, when he plays we basically have 10 men.
Semedo - 6: Not like last week where he was amazing but did okay today.
Jackson - 5: What does he do other than score when/if he gets the chance?
Ecclestone - 7: Thought he was bright and one of our better players, up there with Jenkinson.
Bradley Wright Philips - 5.5: Scored but done nothing more, I honestly though Doherty had scored as it was so packed in there. He needs to play central.
Abbott - 6.5: Running constantly and you can see he is trying so hard for the team. Unlucky when he hit the bar, great piece of skill.
Racon - 6: Done 10 times more than what McCormack done, I think he changed the game as an attacking sense. He MUST start.
Reid - 6: Showed signs of getting some form, didn't have too long but was bright.
Wagstaff - N/A: Was on for about 5 mins? Hardly got a touch.
Jenkinson - 7
Doherty - 4
Dailly - 5.5
Fry - 5.5
McCormack - 4
Semedo - 7.5
Jackson - 5.5
Ecclestone - 7
Bradley Wright Philips - 6
Abbott - 6.5
Racon - 7
Reid - 6.5
Jenkinson - 6.5
Doherty - 3
Dailly - 5.5
Fry -5
McCormack - 3
Semedo - 7
Jackson -5
Ecclestone - 5.5
Bradley Wright Philips - 6.5
Abbott- 6
Racon - 7.5
Reid - 7
Jenkinson 6 looks like a centreback out of position
Doherty 4 woeful. A liability
Dailly 6.5
Fry 6 not a full back
McCormack 5 didn't hide but lacked impact
Semedo 6 trying too bail out a sinking ship
Jackson 6 not his best game
Ecclestone 7 can't be expected to score every time
Bradley Wright Philips 7 always a threat
Abbott nothing stuck.poor. even at this level
Racon 6.5 need him back
Reid 6.5 looked his old self
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Jenkinson - 7 not a bad start for a young lad
Doherty - 1 - And he doesnt deserve that. Absolutely shocking!!!
Dailly - 5.5 Not great but needs a proper partner
Fry - 5 - I'd try jacko at LB and give Reid a chance
McCormack - 4 - Tries hard but not great. Racon is better but perhaps still not good enough.
Semedo - 6 - needs more support
Jackson - 5 - Lost his way recently
Ecclestone - 7 - Played well but I think he was better on the RW against Posh
Bradley Wright Philips - 6 - a goalscorer who doesn't do much else - so play him in the centre.
Abbott - 6.5 - Tried very hard and did better than most
Racon - 7 - As above
Reid - 6.5 - As above
Jenkinson - 6
Doherty - 3
Dailly - 6
Fry - 5.5
McCormack - 4
Semedo - 6
Jackson - 3
Ecclestone - 7
Bradley Wright Philips - 6
Abbott - 6
Racon - 7.5
Reid - 6.5
Jenkinson - 6.5
Doherty - 4
Dailly - 6
Fry - 5.5
McCormack - 5
Semedo - 5.5
Jackson - 6
Ecclestone - 7
Bradley Wright Philips - 6
Abbott - 6
Racon - 6.5
Reid - 6
Jenkinson 6.5 - very promising but caught out a couple of times
Doherty 5.5 - - did well mostly, helped jenkinson but then made a couple of serious errors
Dailly -6.5
Fry -6.5
McCormack - 7 thought battles well in our outnumbered midefield
Semedo -7
Jackson - 7
Ecclestone - 5 - missed 2 good chnaces , rarely tracked back - seemed to be playing for himself not charlton
Bradley Wright Philips - 4.5 - obviously doesnt like RW, improved when he came more in middle
Abbott - 7.5 MOM - had that one gone in that hit the crossbar! Best game for us - however we cant play all 3 of him BWP and NE - selection problems for SCP
Racon - 7 - did fairly well when he came on
Reid - 6 - ineffective
Wagstaff N/A (edited) - was it a penalty near the end?
Jenkinson 5.5 - Didn't look great going forward
Doherty 5 - I actually thought he had a good first half but ruined everything with the mistake
Dailly 5 - Treading water
Fry 5.5 - Not as good as he was earlier in the season
McCormack - 4 Not Good
Semedo 6 - Had to do the work of two men
Jackson 5 - Is he really our best option out wide?
Ecclestone 4.5 - worst game since he came to Charlton
Bradley Wright Philips 5 - Gave up too easily at times
Abbott - 7 . Best player in a red shirt by far. MOM
Racon -5 made no difference ( see below)
Reid - 6 Brought on far too late
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Obviously watched a different game from the one I did - we were mostly overrun or clueless in possession in midfield and yet you gave the 3 MF 7 points apiece. McCormack battles well - you're having a giraffe!
Jenkinson 7 Grew into the game and did well MOM
Doherty 6 Would have been 7 but the second goal was down to him and cost us the game
Dailly 6.5 Ok has been better. Talked to Jenks early on
Fry 6 Average
McCormack 5 They dominated midfield much of the time and that is in large part down to him
Semedo 6 One good tacle one good shot not much else. Not helped by McCormack's lack of impact though
Jackson 6 Offered a bit going forward tried to help Fry out not at his best
Ecclestone 6 Offered more in general play than BWP but too often Pawel headed to nowhere which is partly down to him
Bradley Wright Philips 6 Anonymous will be credited with Doc's goal
Abbott 7 worked hard with little service unlucky with his shot which hit the bar
Racon 6 A bit of fancy footwork here and there but no real impact better than McCormack but may not be over 90 minutes
Reid 6 won a corner or two
Wagstaff N/A (edited) 6 little impact but hardly any time
Jenkinson -5
Doherty -5
Dailly -5
Fry -4
McCormack -2
Semedo -5
Jackson -4
Ecclestone -5
Bradley Wright Philips -5
Abbott -5
Racon -6
Reid -5
Wagstaff N/A (edited) 5
Jenkinson 6
Doherty 5
Dailly 6
Fry 6
McCormack 4
Semedo 6
Jackson 5
Ecclestone 7
Bradley Wright Philips 6
Abbott 6
Racon 7
Reid 7
Jenkinson 7
Doherty 6
Dailly 6
Fry 6
McCormack 5
Semedo 6
Jackson 7
Ecclestone 7
Bradley Wright Philips 7
Abbott 8
Racon 7
Reid 6
Wagstaff N/A (edited) 6
Jenkinson 6.5 done well got up and down well seeing as there was no winger infromt of him
Doherty 1 so slow! Whenever he gets in Pressured Its a long punt or a back pass
Dailly 6 what can 1 man do?
Fry 4.5 done alright but had his moments
McCormack 0.5 whyyyy is he still starting we have semedo on to break up attacks then why do we need him to try to it aswell? He doesn't win balls and although he tries racon he leagues better
Semedo 5.5 he did try ..
Jackson 4 wasn't really involved seemed a little lost at times...
Ecclestone 6 should of scored, seemed are biggest threat
Bradley Wright Philips 6 good goal want to effect wide right
Abbott 5.5 he's got a good touch 4-3-3 didn't really work to his favour though..
Racon 6.5 ran past players ran foward passed forward why is he not starting?!
Reid 5.5 didn't really notice him..
Wagstaff N/A (edited)
Jenkinson -6
Doherty -3
Dailly -5
Fry -4
McCormack -4
Semedo -5
Jackson -4
Ecclestone -5.5
Bradley Wright Philips -5
Abbott -6
Racon -6.5
Reid -6
Jenkinson - 7 - Solid full debut, couldn't fault him.
Doherty - 3 - Simply no pace; Directly at fault for the last two goals.
Dailly - 5
Fry - 5
McCormack - 5 - Below par; Don't see anything in him.
Semedo - 6
Jackson - 6
Ecclestone - 7
Bradley Wright Philips - 6
Abbott - 5
Racon - 6
Reid - 6
Wagstaff - N/A