I remember Jim Stannard playing for us on loan at The Valley around 1983/4 against bottom of the table Cadiff City. We lost 4-1 and I think he was to blame for at least three of the goals. Never played for us again after that.
There is only one goalkeeper surely, Jim "celery" Stannard. A decent career elsewhere sandwiched around 90 catastrophic minutes for us v Cardiff (lost 1-4 BTW)
Jim Stannard Greg Halford Djimi Traore Lindsay Smith Alan Dugdale Viggo Jacobsen Gary Churchouse Scott Sinclair Paul Bacon Mike Small Luke Varney - there were worse players sure, but when he rounded the keeper against Burnley and spent two hours dithering before missing the chance, it was one of the most pathetic things I've ever seen on a football pitch. Holloway must be a genius.....
[cite]Posted By: oohaahmortimer[/cite]Akpo sodje for not being able to kick a ball properly and making me cringe if he was going to have more than one touch with his feet
[cite]Posted By: E-cafc[/cite]Nicky Weaver
Paul Curtis
Peter Shaw
Steve Dowman
Jamie Stuart
Amdy Faye
Neil Redfern
Kevin Smith
Paul Bacon
Mike Small
Mark McCammon
Dunn Bruik Shaw Goldthorpe Tunbridge Goldsmith brisley Mehmet Lansdown Endean Plumb
Les Surman was our hapless kid who I saw let in 6 at Portsmouth. Bit unfair to pick on him so Dunn will do. Rommedarl nearly made this team on sheer frustration values but I have mainly gone for clueless at Charlton. Oddly Brisley played well for Orient and Mehmet did the biz for the spanners.
This is as difficult as the best team I too do not like picking young players for example one of our youth team Goalies Lee Harmsworth was probably the worst Keeper but I suspect he would not have even got there if it had not been for the worst injury crisis in that position i have ever known.
The reverse of Dave Rudd because we have had so many bad CB's I've picked five at the back.
GK Stannard RB Duffield One game too many on loan from QPR LB Hovi CB Gray Loan player from the O's cost us about three goals in 82/83 CB El Khalej CB Lindsay Smith RM Churchouse CM Mountford CM Pouso LM Cook ST Small
Yes, Nigel Gray was pretty disastrous, can't believe I forgot about El-Khalej, maybe my pain receptors overloaded and blanked him out. Peter Mountford was another one that slipped my mind, Duffield was something of a cult figure to a few of us but probably no worse than some of the duds Pardew parted with money for.
Can only judge on what ive seen... Randolph is the worst keeper I've seen in the Charlton goal, doesnt say alot cos we've been lucky with keepers.
Deano
Illic
Mhyre
Anderson
Weaver
Carson
Robbie
Are/were all better than him, always sticks in my mind the time he caught the ball, turned round and smacked it in Paddy Mccarthy's head for an own goal
I would never brand someone who donned the Charlton shirt as the worst but from my goalkeeping recollections Randolph would be better than Wood,Patterson and Salmon.
On a par with quite a few other Charlton keepers including Elliot.Best keepers IMO Nicky Johns,Bob Bolder and the best Deano.
The transformation of our team when by sheer luck randy fell into it at the end of last season was amazing, the team that was sliding out of the play offs nearly nicked an automatic spot once he came in between the sticks
i find it amazing that last years squad managed to attain the clubs 4th lowest finish in 75 years, yet some people find room in their worst XI for internationals, champions league winners and players that have spent most of their careers in the top flight.
[cite]Posted By: UP...THE...ADDICKS[/cite]Can only judge on what ive seen... Randolph is the worst keeper I've seen in the Charlton goal, doesnt say alot cos we've been lucky with keepers.
Deano
Illic
Mhyre
Anderson
Weaver
Carson
Robbie
Are/were all better than him, always sticks in my mind the time he caught the ball, turned round and smacked it in Paddy Mccarthy's head for an own goal
Randolph was a better shot stopper than Elliott and a better kicker.
Comments
Jim Stannard
Greg Halford
Djimi Traore
Lindsay Smith
Alan Dugdale
Viggo Jacobsen
Gary Churchouse
Scott Sinclair
Paul Bacon
Mike Small
Luke Varney - there were worse players sure, but when he rounded the keeper against Burnley and spent two hours dithering before missing the chance, it was one of the most pathetic things I've ever seen on a football pitch. Holloway must be a genius.....
What are you talking about? Complete tosh
He's just signing a contract for his 46th league club as we speak!
Nicky Weaver? what axactly did he do wrong?
Bruik Shaw Goldthorpe Tunbridge
Goldsmith brisley Mehmet Lansdown
Endean Plumb
Les Surman was our hapless kid who I saw let in 6 at Portsmouth. Bit unfair to pick on him so Dunn will do.
Rommedarl nearly made this team on sheer frustration values but I have mainly gone for clueless at Charlton. Oddly Brisley played well for Orient and Mehmet did the biz for the spanners.
when he let in a floated free kick from about 35 yards plus!
He had so much time he could have walked across the goal and caught the ball!
The reverse of Dave Rudd because we have had so many bad CB's I've picked five at the back.
GK Stannard
RB Duffield One game too many on loan from QPR
LB Hovi
CB Gray Loan player from the O's cost us about three goals in 82/83
CB El Khalej
CB Lindsay Smith
RM Churchouse
CM Mountford
CM Pouso
LM Cook
ST Small
Deano
Illic
Mhyre
Anderson
Weaver
Carson
Robbie
Are/were all better than him, always sticks in my mind the time he caught the ball, turned round and smacked it in Paddy Mccarthy's head for an own goal
Francis
Hudson
Sorondo
Traore
Blomquist
Pouso
Faye
Cook
Gray
Hasselbaink
On a par with quite a few other Charlton keepers including Elliot.Best keepers IMO Nicky Johns,Bob Bolder and the best Deano.
or is it just me that's read it like that?
Thom Hovi
Phil Chapple
Alan McCleary
Grant Basey
Ricky Otto
Omar Pouso
Peter Garland
Alex Dyer
Chris Dickson
Kenny Achampong