Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Ratings v Warsaw

edited December 2010 in General Charlton
Same rules half points accepted

Elliot
Francis
Fry
Doherty
Fortune
Semedo
Racon
Benson
Anyinsah
Jackson
Wagstaff

Reid
Akpo
Martin
«1

Comments

  • Elliot 7 - kicking was atrocious but I think he did well to keep the score down
    Francis - 4
    Fry - 5
    Doherty - 5
    Fortune - 3
    Semedo - 4
    Racon - 4
    Benson - 4
    Anyinsah - 5
    Jackson - 5
    Wagstaff - 4

    Reid - 5
    Akpo - 5
    Martin - 5
  • [cite]Posted By: Kap10[/cite]Same rules half points accepted

    Elliot 7
    Francis 5
    Fry 5
    Doherty 4
    Fortune 5
    Semedo 4
    Racon 4
    Benson 3.5
    Anyinsah 4.5
    Jackson 5
    Wagstaff 4.5

    Reid 4.5
    Akpo 5.5
    Martin 5
  • edited December 2010
    Elliot - 5
    Francis - 4.5
    Fry - 5
    Doherty 5.5 - gets an extra .5 as he was effectively playing CB on his own
    Fortune - 3
    Semedo - 4
    Racon - 5.5
    Benson - 4
    Anyinsah - 5
    Jackson - 4.5
    Wagstaff - 4.5

    Reid - 4
    Akpo - 4.5
    Martin - 4
  •  

    Elliot 4
    Francis. 5
    Fry. 5
    Doherty. 7
    Fortune. 6
    Semedo. 5
    Racon. 5
    Benson. 5
    Anyinsah. 5
    Jackson. 5
    Wagstaff. 5

    Reid. 5
    Akpo 5
    Martin5
  • Elliot 4.5
    Francis 4.5
    Fry 4.5
    Doherty 4.5
    Fortune 4.5
    Semedo 4 - centre midfield was where the battle was lost today and the rest did nothing to help. Nothing creative or forward thinking for the whole 90 mins.
    Racon 4 - ditto
    Benson 4.5
    Anyinsah 4.5
    Jackson 4.5
    Wagstaff 4.5

    Reid 4.5
    Akpo 4.5
    Martin 4.5
  • Elliot 4
    Francis 4
    Fry 4
    Doherty 4
    Fortune 4
    Semedo 4
    Racon 4
    Benson 4
    Anyinsah 4
    Jackson 4
    Wagstaff 4

    Reid 4
    Akpo 4
    Martin 4

    They all get 4 from me, they all managed to get a red shirt on the correct way round
  • edited December 2010
    Elliot 6
    Francis 3
    Fry 5
    Doherty 5
    Fortune 4
    Semedo 4.5
    Racon 4.5
    Benson 3
    Anyinsah 5
    Jackson 5
    Wagstaff 4

    Reid 4
    Akpo 4
    Martin 4
  • TELTEL
    edited December 2010
    Elliot 4
    Francis 3 if he doesnt get dropped after that then he must be Parky's secret lover....truly abysmal
    Fry 4 worst game for him so far
    Doherty 4 another woeful performance
    Fortune 3 Bye Jon, nice knowing you when you were a decent player
    Semedo 4 worst Ive seen him play
    Racon 5 Dragged down by the rest of them....our shape was non existent
    Benson 4 no service, but also no class
    Anyinsah 4 Battering ram tactics come undone sooner or later
    Jackson 4 looked better at LB.....he didnt do anything as LM
    Wagstaff 3 Time for a rest, I rate him, but today he didnt really want to know and he spends too much time covering Francis

    Reid 4
    Akpo 5 he did try, I'll give him that
    Martin 3 is this the real Martin and the reason he has been farmed out? if so, au revoir. Not a game for flicks that dont work and his petulant moaning just gets up my nose.

    Parky 4 Mate you need to up your game big time
    Crowd 4 its like a frigging Morgue
  • Elliot 5
    Francis 5
    Fry 5
    Doherty 7
    Fortune 5
    Semedo 5
    Racon 5.5
    Benson 5
    Anyinsah 5
    Jackson 5
    Wagstaff 5

    Reid 5
    Akpo 5
    Martin 5
  • Elliot-5
    Francis-3
    Fry-4
    Doherty-2
    Fortune-2
    Semedo-4
    Racon-4
    Benson-3
    Anyinsah-4
    Jackson-4
    Wagstaff-2

    Reid-2
    Akpo-3
    Martin-4
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliot 6- could have been worse if not for robbie, but needs to sort out his kicking
    Francis 3- do not rate him at all
    Fry 5- At least he tries
    Doherty 5- looking jaded
    Fortune 4- not the same player, looks slow at times
    Semedo 4.5- too many side passes at times
    Racon 4.5- did not get going
    Benson 3- looks a poor man's Dave mooney,too lightweight
    Anyinsah 5- surprised he went off was he injured ?
    Jackson 5- looked subdued today
    Wagstaff 4- just not in it at all,better coming on as an impact sub

    Reid 4-
    Akpo 4
    Martin 4
  • Elliot 7
    Francis 3
    Fry 5
    Doherty 6.5
    Fortune 6
    Semedo 5.5
    Racon 4.5
    Benson 3.5
    Anyinsah 4
    Jackson 4
    Wagstaff 4.5

    Reid 5.5
    Akpo 3
    Martin 5
  • Elliot 7 Is he injured ?
    Francis 5 Frustrating player , didn't get forward enough
    Fry 5 Another frustrating player one minute I'm worried Wham may recall him to play LB , then I'm not sure he is good enough for us.
    Doherty 7 Best outfield player today held us together.
    Fortune 5 Not the player he used to be.
    Semedo 5 Not his best game
    Racon 5 Didn't get going
    Benson 5 Too lightweight today.
    Anyinsah 5 I'm not sure he is match fit
    Jackson 6 Adaptable and dependable
    Wagstaff 5 Didn't get going

    Reid 5 Disappointing
    Akpo 6 Looked threatening
    Martin 5 Lacks an end product
  • edited December 2010
    Not looked at the other rating - here are mine.

    My men of the match were the North stand who started singing Parky's name when a bunch of mindless idiots started singing anti Parky songs. Well done.

    Bad day at the office today. Apart from three players the rest were pretty awful and We were lucky just to lose by one.

    Elliot - 6 . made a couple of crucial saves
    Francis - 4 . Can defend but has no idea how to pass the ball. How much longer do we give him?
    Fry - 5 . Did ok
    Doherty - 7 Solid , especially in the air.
    Fortune - 7.5 Best match since his return 7.5
    Semedo - 5 Looked knackered
    Racon - 5 poor
    Benson - 3 Sodje and Abbott must wonder what they have to do to get in the side when Benson is this bad.
    Anyinsah - 5 Should have stayed on ahead of Benson
    Jackson - 4 was awful in the first half just bad in the second.
    Wagstaff - 2 - Lazy sod

    Reid - 5 his moves didn't come off today
    Akpo - 5 Didn't get much of a look in
    Martin - 6 looked lively when he came on.

    We must sacrifice the JPT on Tuesday and rest the ones who looked tired today.
  • Elliot- 5 poor kicking, could he have done better with goal aswell.
    Francis- 3 nothing to add to what has already been said.
    Fry- 6 least he tried, was far from the worst.
    Doherty- 6 ok
    Fortune- 5 at fault for the goal.
    Semedo- 5 poor for the first time in a while.
    Racon- 5 also poor for the first time in a while
    Benson- 4 no excuse for not hitting target when clean through, his touch was poor and generally not good enough.
    Anyinsah- 4 not at his best but better than anyone else up top.
    Jackson- 5 ok, been better of course.
    Wagstaff- 4 did nothing positive.

    Reid- 4 apparantly his spell out of the side has affected his confidence, was poor again today
    Akpo- 5 tried
    Martin- 3 when Keane gets sacked, he will go back to Ipswich and will not be missed.
  • Elliot 6 woeful kicking again
    Francis 5 worst game for ages
    Fry 5 worst game for us
    Doherty 6.5 some excellent blocks
    Fortune 5.5 at fault for the goal. Shadow of his former self.
    Semedo 5.5 no time on the ball and constantly in the wrong place
    Racon 5 same as semedo really disappointing
    Benson 4.5 must have incriminating photos of parky. Should have been subbed
    Anyinsah 5.5 looked alright but appears to be made of glass! If he ever gets 100% he could be good
    Jackson 5 not as influential as usual. Looks leggy
    Wagstaff 5 bit of a nothing show

    Reid 5.5 couplem of nice runs but makes bad decisions.
    Akpo 4.5 won a header but not much else
    Martin 5 didn't do much


    Was very impressed with several of their players. Westlake rb, the 11 nicholls and the blond right winger.

    Parky - this will be forgiven and forgotten if we can win Tuesday
  • Elliot 6
    Francis 3
    Fry 5
    Doherty 6
    Fortune 3.5
    Semedo 3.5
    Racon 3.5
    Benson 3.5
    Anyinsah 5.5
    Jackson 5.5
    Wagstaff 5.5

    Reid 5.5
    Akpo 5
    Martin 6

    Parkinson 2 - wrong team selection and completely failed to change the course of the game by making any meaningful tactical or strategical change. As normal, he took no responsibility for the result or the team he put out.
  • Elliott - 7 Apart from his kicking (which doesn't bother me too much) he was ok.
    Francis - 4 Bad on the ball but Wagstaff didn't show for him at all. Looked indecisive and should have been more direct late on instead of fannying about with it.
    Fry - 5.5 He was ok (ish) but not especially good on the ball apart from one wriggle out of trouble.
    Doherty - 6.5 Won all of his headers but got done once. Made superb clearance from near his own goal line.
    Fortune - 7 Thought he looked better in the air today than any other game this season and did ok for most of the game.
    Semedo - 4.5 Terrible today and every touch seemed to take us backwards.
    Racon - 5 A bit better than Semedo.
    Benson - 4.5 Lucky not to be subbed. Fluffed his (and our) one chance which was critical.
    Anyinsah - 5.5 Ran the channels a bit but didn't threaten.
    Jackson - 6 Was ok but that's all.
    Wagstaff - 3 And I might be being generous. A non-performance.

    Reid - 5 Didn't do a lot. Tried but it was headless chicken stuff.
    Akpo - 5.5 Shame we didn't resort to whacking it up to him in the air because it's a waste of time trying to play football off him. Tried hard.
    Martin 5.5 Mainly for effort. One lovely ball for Benson and that was his lot.
  • Elliott - 5.5 Awful kicking, not too bad apart form that
    Francis - 4 Poor but was basically playing on his own down the right
    Fry - 5 Nowhere near what he is capable of
    Doherty - 7 Probably our best player
    Fortune - 5 Hasn't been great since his return
    Semedo - 4 I can't remember a forward pass
    Racon - 5 Not great, but not that bad
    Benson - 4 Should have been taken off, wasn't up for it and missed a great chance
    Anyinsah - 6 Puts himself about, needs better service
    Jackson - 5 Not up to his usual standard
    Wagstaff - 3 Didn't look interested

    Reid - 4 No end product today
    Akpo - 6 Made an effort, lacks skill and pace
    Martin - 5 Little impact
  • I am worried i will be too negative so have decided to add a point to each of the players scores today above where I actually think they should have been marked, so as not to be too mean, therefore:

    Elliot 7 didnt do anything wrong except kicking
    Francis 1 didn't do anything right
    Fry 1 passing...maybe someone should show him how
    Doherty 2 how old is he - could we check his passport - Seip must be awful if he can't dislodge this guy
    Fortune 3 not what he once was
    Semedo 2 worst game in a CAFC shirt - will forgive him one bad day though
    Racon 2 ran about a bit
    Benson 1 forgot he was playing - should have been replaced at HT - failed to make the keeper save when through on goal
    Anyinsah 2 ran about and should have stayed on with Benson off
    Jackson 3 not as good as usual
    Wagstaff 2 anonymous

    Reid 1 waste of a sub
    Akpo 2 tried a (v) little
    Martin 4 great ball to Benson which should have been converted, otherwise nothing

    Worst game I have seen in a long time - how are we 4th!
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliot 4
    Francis - 1.5
    Fry - 2.5
    Doherty - 4.5
    Fortune - 1.5
    Semedo - 3.5
    Racon - 3.5
    Benson - 3
    Anyinsah - 3.5
    Jackson - 4
    Wagstaff - 2.5

    Reid - 2
    Akpo -2
    Martin - 2.5

    and that's being generous, five hours later after calming down a bit.

    It was the worst performance I can remember in a very long time and so deserves the worst marks in that time, too.

    To give anyone 5 would be hypocritical, because 5 suggests something vaguely OK-ish, if not quite at their best. And that is too kind to anyone, even Doc , who will probably get MoM but doeesn't desrve it.

    Can we just withold MoM on this occasion, because it would be quite inappropriate for anyone to 'win' it. . As Parky admitted, nobody played well and so there wasn't a single player out there who deserves the accolade.
  • Elliot 4
    Francis 4
    Fry 5
    Doherty 5
    Fortune 3
    Semedo 4
    Racon 4
    Benson 4
    Anyinsah 4
    Jackson 4
    Wagstaff 4

    Reid 5
    Akpo 3
    Martin 2
  • Elliot 5.5
    Francis 4.5
    Fry 4.5
    Doherty 4.5
    Fortune 4.5
    Semedo 5
    Racon 5
    Benson 5
    Anyinsah 5
    Jackson 4.5
    Wagstaff 4.5

    Reid 5
    Akpo 4.5
    Martin 4.5
  • Elliot 3
    Francis 3
    Fry 3
    Doherty 4
    Fortune 3
    Semedo 5
    Racon 6
    Benson 4
    Anyinsah 7 - Can't believe he was taken off - seemed to be the only one making an effort - guess it shows that Parky just wont take Benson off no matter what
    Jackson - 4
    Wagstaff - 5 - Still injured I think

    Reid - 6
    Akpo - 4 - Too late, could have used his power from the start of the second
    Martin - 3 - Whish he'd stop all the silly tricks but I still really rate him
  • Elliot 4.5
    Francis 3
    Fry 4
    Doherty 4.5
    Fortune 3.5
    Semedo 3.5
    Racon 3.5
    Benson 3
    Anyinsah 4.5
    Jackson 4.5
    Wagstaff 4.5

    Reid 4.5
    Akpo 4
    Martin 4
  • edited December 2010
    [cite]Posted By: vff
    Parkinson 2 - wrong team selection and completely failed to change the course of the game by making any meaningful tactical or strategical change. As normal, he took no responsibility for the result or the team he put out.

    Really?
  • Elliot 6 A couple of good saves but didn't look himself. Scuffed kick and could have released Wagstaff had he thrown early on a few occasions. He wasn't fuly fit so gets the benefit of the doubt.
    Francis 4.5 Poor but didn't hide
    Fry 6.5 as good as anybody while he was on
    Doherty 7 the one player to perform anything like half decently
    Fortune 5 looked to be struggling for pace at times
    Semedo 5.5 disappeared for much of the match
    Racon 5.5 see Semedo
    Benson 5.5 poor by his recent standards but no service to speak of. Possibly affected by his injury
    Anyinsah 5.5 didn't look the threat he does normally
    Jackson 6 6.5 midfield 5.5 left back
    Wagstaff 5 anonymous. Worked off the ball but little or no contribution on it

    Reid 6 started brightly but disappeared
    Akpo 5.5 as Benson
    Martin 5.5 huff and puff to little or no effect
  • Elliot 4.5
    Francis 4
    Fry 4.5
    Doherty 5
    Fortune 4
    Semedo 4
    Racon 4
    Benson 4
    Anyinsah 4
    Jackson 4
    Wagstaff 4

    Reid 4
    Akpo 4
    Martin 4
  • Elliot 6
    Francis 4
    Fry 5
    Doherty 6
    Fortune 4
    Semedo 5
    Racon 5
    Benson 4
    Anyinsah 5
    Jackson 6
    Wagstaff 5

    Reid 6
    Akpo 5
    Martin 5
  • Elliot 6
    Francis 4
    Fry 4
    Doherty5
    Fortune 5
    Semedo 5
    Racon 5
    Benson 3
    Anyinsah 6
    Jackson 6
    Wagstaff 4

    Reid 5
    Akpo 5
    Martin 5
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!