FA Cup 2nd Round: Charlton 2-2 Luton - Player Marks

lancashire lad

For those of you that braved the cold of the Valley your marks out of 10, half marks allowed, please cut and paste the player list below.

Elliot
Francis
Llera
Fortune
Jackson
Wagstaff
Racon
Reid
McCormack
Anyinsah
Benson

N/A Sodje

The stats for this match will be published on Tuesday morning.

Clem_Snide

Elliot - 6.5
Francis - 5
Llera - 7.5
Fortune - 4
Jackson - 6.5
Wagstaff - 5
Racon - 6.5
McCormack - 6
Anyinsah - 6.5
Benson - 6

N/A Sodje - 6

Macronate

Elliot - 6.5 (didn't do anything wrong)
Francis - (minus)-6 (nuff said)
Llera - 7 (important blocks/interceptions)
Fortune -5.5 (still not convincing)
Jackson - 6 (took goal well)
Wagstaff - 6 (doesn't look 100% although covered Francis' mistakes well more than once)
Racon - 7 (played well)
Reid-6.5 (needs to play the easier ball sometimes especially when in own half)
McCormack - 5.5 (not a great game)
Anyinsah - 6 (goal but didn't do a lot otherwise)
Benson - 5.5 (not his day)

Sodje-5 (no effect)

Kap10

Elliot 6.5
Francis 4
Llera 7.5
Fortune 6.5
Jackson 6.5
Wagstaff 6
Racon 6
Reid 6
McCormack 7.5
Anyinsah 6
Benson 5

N/A Sodje

nth_london_addick

Elliot 5
Francis 3
Llera 6
Fortune 4
Jackson 4.5
Wagstaff 4
Racon 5.5
Reid 4
McCormack 4
Anyinsah 5
Benson 4

N/A Sodje 4

incorruptible addick

Elliot 5
Francis 3
Llera 7.5 MoM, by a long way
Fortune 3
Jackson 6
Wagstaff 4
Racon 6
Reid 6.5
McCormack 5
Anyinsah 5.5
Benson 5.5

The Red Robin

Elliot 5
Francis 4
Llera 7.5 - MOM
Fortune - 6
Jackson 6.5
Wagstaff 5
Racon 7
Reid 6.5
McCormack 5.5
Anyinsah 5.5
Benson 5.5

N/A Sodje 6

masicat

Elliot 6
Francis 4
Llera 4
Fortune 3
Jackson 5
Wagstaff 1
Racon 5
Reid 5
McCormack 5
Anyinsah 4
Benson 3

CAFCsayer

Elliot 5
Francis 4
Llera 2
Fortune 4
Jackson 6
Wagstaff 3
Racon 5
Reid 4
McCormack 4
Anyinsah 4
Benson 3

Sodje 5

Bedsaddick

Elliot - 7 - Saved the pen had no chance with their 2nd goal
Francis - 6.5 - Did ok - distribution still not great
Llera - 7.5 - Got better as the game went on.
Fortune - 7 - Steady
Jackson - 6.5 - Prefer him in Midfield
Wagstaff - 5 - anonymous
Racon - 7 - Had a good game in midfield
Reid - 8 - Sublime at times MAN OF THE MATCH
McCormack - 6 - Look ok defensively but too negative at times
Anyinsah - 6.5 - Not his best game.
Benson - 4 - Poor poor Poor

Nicholas

Elliot -6
Francis -5
Llera -6
Fortune -5
Jackson -6
Wagstaff -3
Racon -6
Reid -5
McCormack -6
Anyinsah -6
Benson -5

N/A Sodje -5

lordromford

[cite]Posted By: UP...THE...ADDICKS[/cite]Elliot 5
Francis 4
Llera 2
Fortune 4
Jackson 6
Wagstaff 3
Racon 5
Reid 4
McCormack 4
Anyinsah 4
Benson 3

Sodje 5

Not judging, as I wasn't there, but what did you see Llera do wrong that no one else saw?

Salad

I wasn't there, and appreciate that it was as disappointing as 95% of Charlton cup performances since Wembley, but ratings of 2 & 3 I would expect if I was playing - not a professional footballer. Interesting that most people's motm (thus far) gets a mind-blowing 2 from one person.

Bedsaddick

He wasn't anywhere near a 2 neither was any of the players . Llera had one of his best games in a Charlton shirt ( not that there have been many).

Valley_floyd_red

Elliot 5
Francis 6
Llera 7
Fortune 3
Jackson 8
Wagstaff 4
Racon 7
Reid 7.5
McCormack 7
Anyinsah 7
Benson 3

N/A Sodje 5


(EDIT AS I GAVE WAGGY THE SAME SCORE AS RACON UNINTENTIONALLY)

Pavo

Elliot - 6
Francis - 4 (needs to find a bit of form)
Llera - 7.5 (very pleased for him - MOTM- a solid effort, from a man that I usually view a pure liability)
Fortune - 6 (OK)
Jackson - 7 (Is a very good player at the minute)
Wagstaff - 5 (Very quiet going forward today)
Racon - 7 (worked very hard and showed some lovely skill at times)
Reid - 6.5 (bags of tricks and a couple of lovely crosses, especially for JA's goal)
McCormack - 6 (put lots in)
Anyinsah - 6.5 (simple goal and a whole lot of running)
Benson - 5 (not his day, but many days to come will be)

BigRedEvil

Elliot-7
Francis-5
Llera-6
Fortune-5
Jackson-7
Wagstaff-5
Racon-6.5
Reid6
McCormack-5
Anyinsah-5
Benson-5

N/A Sodje

Valley_floyd_red

He wasn't anywhere near a 2 neither was any of the players . Llera had one of his best games in a Charlton shirt ( not that there have been many).

He made some decent blocks and headers. He defended really well.

nth_london_addick

Not one player deserved more than a 6 very abject and effortless performance

Jpb Junior

Elliot 7. Unlucky with the penalty
Francis 4. Not good at all
Llera 8 Played well
Fortune 6
Jackson 6.5
Wagstaff 5 Big fan of Waggy but did he turn up
Racon 7
Reid 6. He loses the ball trying to be flash and NEVER covers back
McCormack 6
Anyinsah 7
Benson 5

N/A Sodje 6

LenGlover

Elliot 6 Although he had no chance with the goals for the first time I could sort of understand why ooh ahh bangs on like he does.
Francis 6 shaky but doesn't hide
Llera 6.5 I like Big Mig and he was good in the air but shaky on the ground as best exemplified by his air shot!
Fortune 6 Gets effort marks because he tried but slow and shaky. Nowhere near the Fortune I used to like and defend on here.
Jackson 7.5 Took his goal well and worked hard. My MOM by a short head.
Wagstaff 6 Not much to offer going forward but worked hard helping Francis out defensively
Racon 6.5 Featured more than McCormack and did some good things but still disappeared too much.
Reid 7 Good run and cross for Joe's goal. More like his old self.
McCormack 5 Anonymous much of the time and allowed Luton to boss the game for long periods.. Semedo needs to come back in pronto
Anyinsah 7 Took his goal well and worked the opposition defence. Not fully fit
Benson 6 Poor by recent standards but little service

N/A Sodje 6 No real impact good or bad today.

eddieaddick

Elliot 5.5
Francis6
Llera7.5 MOM
Fortune 5
Jackson 6
Wagstaff 5
Racon 5.5
Reid 6
McCormack 5
Anyinsah 6.5
Benson 5.5

N/A Sodje 5.5

Stig

Elliot - 6
Francis - 5
Llera - 7
Fortune - 5
Jackson - 7
Wagstaff - 5
Racon - 8
Reid - 7
McCormack - 6
Anyinsah -7
Benson - 5

N/A Sodje - 6

CAFCsayer

[cite]Posted By: lordromford[/cite]

Not judging, as I wasn't there, but what did you see Llera do wrong that no one else saw?

Constntly out of possition... if Francis wasnt playing as a 3rd centre back we wouldve been majorly exposed. 90% of the time committed himsrlf when going in to tackle

Bedsaddick

Llera's positioning was spot on . How you can say he was constantly out of position is beyond me.
He cut everything out in the air and apart from a nervy first 20 minutes he also put in some good tackles in the second half.

Oggy Red

[cite]Posted By: Salad[/cite]I wasn't there, and appreciate that it was as disappointing as 95% of Charlton cup performances since Wembley, but ratings of 2 & 3 I would expect if I was playing - not a professional footballer. Interesting that most people's motm (thus far) gets a mind-blowing 2 from one person.

It's apparent that some people understand how to mark players. And some people don't.

shirty5

Elliot 6
Francis 6
Llera 6
Fortune 5
Jackson 6
Wagstaff 5
Racon 7
Reid 6
McCormack 6
Anyinsah 6
Benson 5

Buglehorn

Elliot 6.5
Francis 5.5
Llera 7.5
Fortune 5
Jackson 6
Wagstaff 5
Racon 6
Reid 7
McCormack 6
Anyinsah 6.5
Benson 5.5

Sodje 6

boogica

Elliott-6.5
Francis- 4.5 played ok in the week today awful couldnt find a red shirt and his positioning was woeful
Llera- 7.5 p[layed ok considering he aint played much
Fortune-5 still well off the pace
Jackson -6
Wagstaff-5
Racon -7
Reid-6.5
Mccormack-6
Ayinsah-6
Benson-6 works hard no end product needs to start scoring at home.

Clem_Snide

[cite]Posted By: CafcAndy[/cite]The time the ball went through all Llera had to do was kick it, swung his foot and missed kicked it..Another time, got beaten in the air numerous times by that 5ft nothing fella. That number 9 was fast, but beat him everytime he had the ball, never got in front of his man, He didn't play well, and against better oppenents would have got majorly embarrased.

Congratulations you've just described Fortune's performance in a nutshell.

Llera was solid throughout. Lost next to nothing in the air and made a number of key interceptions\tackles on the deck.

He had one air kick and that is all people choose to remember.

The bloke deserves credit for yesterday.

Stig

[cite]Posted By: CafcAndy[/cite]The time the ball went through all Llera had to do was kick it, swung his foot and missed kicked it..Another time, got beaten in the air numerous times by that 5ft nothing fella. That number 9 was fast, but beat him everytime he had the ball, never got in front of his man, He didn't play well, and against better oppenents would have got majorly embarrased.

Yes I remember 1 very worrying miss-kick, thought he was superb in the air though. I'm sure some people had made up their minds before kick off.