nickaspanner did you go to the game? Waggy a 4. He wasn't that bad. Marking him down because you don't like him. I was there and I would give him a 6. Not his best game, but didn't do too much wrong. Had a shot that went wide.
Marks out of 10 from those at the game, half marks allowed.
Randolph - 8 won us the game, despite a couple of iffy punches Richardson - 7 not helped by Waggy's ineffective display Borrowdale - 8 covered well for Reid's lapses, great delivery from corners again S Sodje - 7 better with head than feet, wanted more time than available Dailly - 7 steady Wagstaff - 5.5 2 or 3 good touches, but not enough. Poor attempt on goal Semedo - 8 stopped them from creating much Racon - 8 ditto Reid - 6 so much potential but little impact Mooney - 6.5 good work to create the penalty situation, but not much else Forster - 7.5 industrious display, converted penalty well under pressure Sam - 7 more impact than Waggy in far less time
Shelvey - 7 bit impetuous, but created problems for them A Sodje - 7 put himself about more than previously, decent cameo
We need to learn that long punts out of defence to no-one in particular - there was 15 minutes of hell to endure after we scored, giving them a copious supply of 'free' balls. All started with Mooney (again) losing possession on half-way shortly after the pen was scored.
Randolph - 8 -MOM -glad he's been given his chance and taking it well Richardson -7 - seems to have got over his dodgy spell Borrowdale -6 - seemed he did ok but their most of their danger stuff was fom his side S Sodje -7 - prob his best game for ages Dailly - 7.5 - seemd back to his best and responding to the captaincy Wagstaff -6 - ok but still seems more effective as an impact sub Semedo -7 - defensively ver good but still should look for the ball more Racon -7 - better game - harried a lot - but still didn't do much creatively Reid -6.5 - not as good as recent but did seem to be targeted to be closed down quick Mooney -6.5 - worked hard - be better if we passed the ball to his feet - good ball for the pen Forster -7 - i;m sure getting his first goal for us will do him good Sam - 7.5- made a difference when he came on - somebody who held the ball to take some pressure off
Shelvey -7.5 - also looked good when he came on and took the pressure off when he had the ball A Sodje -5 - erm no comment
must say good on Parky - the subs made a diference and were made at good times also top marks to fans who generated some decent noise in a souless stadium - and backed the team even when it was looking difficult.
Solaraddick - Richardson needs to pass to feet and stop 'long punts out of defense to no-one in particular' (using your words) and then maybe Sam/Waggy can get on the ball more. I would expect someone who is 6 years older should have more of an impact in a game, though this is not always the case. Agree Waggy should have done better with the shot, though I am sure you would agree most of our older players should do better.
[quote][cite]Posted By: RedRobin-son[/cite]nickaspanner did you go to the game? Waggy a 4. He wasn't that bad. Marking him down because you don't like him. I was there and I would give him a 6. Not his best game, but didn't do too much wrong. Had a shot that went wide.[/quote].
He produces nothing every time he starts, he is better coming off the bench for the last 10-15 minutes. And yes I was at the game. I think the amount of 5/10 marks he got proved he wasnt very good. I also base my marks on how I saw the game, not how you saw it, Maybe we should all just copy your marks after every game.
i am quite amazed at the high marks that racon ans semedo have been getting - did we dominate midfield? I'm not even sure we got the better of the midfield dual
Randolph - 8 Good shot stopper Richardson - 6 Borrowdale - 7 Has slotted in well S Sodje - 7.5 Kept composed, in his warrior like way. Dailly - 7.5 Wagstaff - 6 Worked hard but ineffective Semedo - 8 Racon - 7 Reid - 6 Skillful but ineffective, one fantasitc cross. Mooney - 6 Forster - 7 Sam - 6 Shelvey - 7 Kept control of the ball and helped to play out time. A Sodje - 6
Randolph - 8 Excellent once again - 3 games and no errors of any consequence.
Richardson - 7 Another good game
Borrowdale - 7 Played well, presumably recovered from last week's virus
S Sodje - 7.5 V Good
Dailly - 7.5 V Good looking back to his best in last couple of games
Wagstaff - 5 Not in it again - needs replacing - it's almost like playing with 10 men
Semedo - 8 V good game
Racon - 7.5 Best game for ages
Reid - 6 Quiet game, but did nothing wrong
Mooney - 6 Tried hard as usual, unfortunately not quite as good as most would like
Forster - 6.5 Good game - won and took penalty well
Sam - 7.5 The game changed for the better when he replaced Waggy IMO
Shelvey -7.5 Looked good when he came on
A Sodje - 6 - Solid - chased hard
Randolph - 7.5 Three or four great saves and some useful punched clearances did the job Richardson - 6.5 solid defensively, distribution very poor Borrowdale - 7 Solid enough S Sodje - 7.5 Solid Dailly - 7.5 Solid Wagstaff - 6 Didnt assert himself on the game Semedo - 8 Kept the ball moving Racon - 8.5 Solid and creative, a far better performance Reid - 7 Not as bright as I expected but always an uphill task for him Mooney - 6.5 Movement good, didnt have much chance with balls played up to him Forster - 7 Movement good, could do with ball to feet more Sam - 7 A brighter performance when he came on
Shelvey - 7.5 His movement when he came on showed much of what we had been missing A Sodje - 7 Good substitute performance
Comments
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 7
S Sodje - 8
Dailly - 8
Wagstaff - 4
Semedo - 7
Racon - 7
Reid - 7
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 7
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 8
Wagstaff - 5
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8
Reid - 7
Mooney - 5
Forster - 8
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 5
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 7
S Sodje - 8
Dailly - 8
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8
Reid - 6
Mooney - 7 (purely for setting the penalty up, brilliant little pass)
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 7
Richardson -7
Borrowdale -6
S Sodje -7
Dailly -7
Wagstaff -5
Semedo -7
Racon -7
Reid -7
Mooney -6.5
Forster -7
Sam -6
Shelvey -7
A Sodje -6.5
Randolph - 8 won us the game, despite a couple of iffy punches
Richardson - 7 not helped by Waggy's ineffective display
Borrowdale - 8 covered well for Reid's lapses, great delivery from corners again
S Sodje - 7 better with head than feet, wanted more time than available
Dailly - 7 steady
Wagstaff - 5.5 2 or 3 good touches, but not enough. Poor attempt on goal
Semedo - 8 stopped them from creating much
Racon - 8 ditto
Reid - 6 so much potential but little impact
Mooney - 6.5 good work to create the penalty situation, but not much else
Forster - 7.5 industrious display, converted penalty well under pressure
Sam - 7 more impact than Waggy in far less time
Shelvey - 7 bit impetuous, but created problems for them
A Sodje - 7 put himself about more than previously, decent cameo
We need to learn that long punts out of defence to no-one in particular - there was 15 minutes of hell to endure after we scored, giving them a copious supply of 'free' balls. All started with Mooney (again) losing possession on half-way shortly after the pen was scored.
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 7
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 8
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon -7
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 6
Richardson -7 - seems to have got over his dodgy spell
Borrowdale -6 - seemed he did ok but their most of their danger stuff was fom his side
S Sodje -7 - prob his best game for ages
Dailly - 7.5 - seemd back to his best and responding to the captaincy
Wagstaff -6 - ok but still seems more effective as an impact sub
Semedo -7 - defensively ver good but still should look for the ball more
Racon -7 - better game - harried a lot - but still didn't do much creatively
Reid -6.5 - not as good as recent but did seem to be targeted to be closed down quick
Mooney -6.5 - worked hard - be better if we passed the ball to his feet - good ball for the pen
Forster -7 - i;m sure getting his first goal for us will do him good
Sam - 7.5- made a difference when he came on - somebody who held the ball to take some pressure off
Shelvey -7.5 - also looked good when he came on and took the pressure off when he had the ball
A Sodje -5 - erm no comment
must say good on Parky - the subs made a diference and were made at good times
also top marks to fans who generated some decent noise in a souless stadium - and backed the team even when it was looking difficult.
Richardson - 6.5
Borrowdale - 6.5
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 5
Semedo - 7
Racon - 8
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 6.5
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 7
S Sodje - 7.5
Dailly - 7.5
Wagstaff - 5.5
Semedo - 7.5
Racon - 8
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6.5
Forster - 7
Sam - 6.5
Shelvey - 6.5
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 4.5
Semedo - 7.5
Racon - 8
Reid - 5.5
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey -6
A Sodje 5.5
Richardson - 5
Borrowdale - 5
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon - 7
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 6
A Sodje - 5.5
He produces nothing every time he starts, he is better coming off the bench for the last 10-15 minutes. And yes I was at the game. I think the amount of 5/10 marks he got proved he wasnt very good. I also base my marks on how I saw the game, not how you saw it, Maybe we should all just copy your marks after every game.
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 5
Semedo - 7
Racon - 7.5
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam -6
Shelvey - 6
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 5.5
S Sodje - 7.5
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 5.5
Semedo - 7
Racon - 7
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 6.5
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 6.5
A Sodje - 5.5
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 7
Dailly - 8
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon - 9 Probably the best individual performance I have seen this season
Reid - 6
Mooney - 8
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 7
Richardson - 6.5
Borrowdale - 6.5
S Sodje - 7.5
Dailly - 8
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8
Reid - 6.5
Mooney - 7
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 6.5
A Sodje - 6.5
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 7 Has slotted in well
S Sodje - 7.5 Kept composed, in his warrior like way.
Dailly - 7.5
Wagstaff - 6 Worked hard but ineffective
Semedo - 8
Racon - 7
Reid - 6 Skillful but ineffective, one fantasitc cross.
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 7 Kept control of the ball and helped to play out time.
A Sodje - 6
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 6
Dailly - 6
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 6
Racon - 6
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 6
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 6
A Sodje - 6
Job done, nothing more nothing less. Well done Parky and the team.
Richardson - 5.5
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 6
Dailly - 6
Wagstaff - 5.5
Semedo - 6.5
Racon - 8
Reid - 6
Mooney - 5
Forster - 6
Sam - 5.5
Shelvey - 6
A Sodje - 5.5
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 6.7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8
Reid -7
Mooney - 6.5
Forster - 6.5
Sam - 6,5
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 6
nickaspa
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 6
S Sodje - 6.7
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8
Reid -7
Mooney - 6.5
Forster - 6.5
Sam - 6,5
Shelvey - 7
A Sodje - 6
nickaspa[/quote]
you forgot the 10 by my name kimbo :)
Richardson - 6
Borrowdale - 6.5
S Sodje - 6.5
Dailly - 6.5
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 7
Racon - 8
Reid - 6
Mooney - 6
Forster - 7
Sam - 6
Shelvey - 5.5
A Sodje - 5.5
Richardson - 7 Another good game
Borrowdale - 7 Played well, presumably recovered from last week's virus
S Sodje - 7.5 V Good
Dailly - 7.5 V Good looking back to his best in last couple of games
Wagstaff - 5 Not in it again - needs replacing - it's almost like playing with 10 men
Semedo - 8 V good game
Racon - 7.5 Best game for ages
Reid - 6 Quiet game, but did nothing wrong
Mooney - 6 Tried hard as usual, unfortunately not quite as good as most would like
Forster - 6.5 Good game - won and took penalty well
Sam - 7.5 The game changed for the better when he replaced Waggy IMO
Shelvey -7.5 Looked good when he came on
A Sodje - 6 - Solid - chased hard
Richardson - 7
Borrowdale - 7
S Sodje - 7.5
Dailly - 7
Wagstaff - 6.5
Semedo - 8
Racon - 8.5
Reid - 7
Mooney - 6.5
Forster - 7
Sam - 7
Shelvey - 7.5
A Sodje - 7
Richardson - 6.5 solid defensively, distribution very poor
Borrowdale - 7 Solid enough
S Sodje - 7.5 Solid
Dailly - 7.5 Solid
Wagstaff - 6 Didnt assert himself on the game
Semedo - 8 Kept the ball moving
Racon - 8.5 Solid and creative, a far better performance
Reid - 7 Not as bright as I expected but always an uphill task for him
Mooney - 6.5 Movement good, didnt have much chance with balls played up to him
Forster - 7 Movement good, could do with ball to feet more
Sam - 7 A brighter performance when he came on
Shelvey - 7.5 His movement when he came on showed much of what we had been missing
A Sodje - 7 Good substitute performance