Elliot may divide opinons and has certainly had some shaky moments this season. However he has also been very good on occassions and could turn into a very good goalkeeper. He is a very good League 1 keeper and has the ability to play at a higher level one day. Keepers do not reach their peak till late 20's and Robbie is still relatively inexperienced.
Nevertheless do people think a rest may do him good, just for a couple of games?, Randolph although maybe a bit error prone has shone he has ability aswell, Lets not forget, he was probably rated higher than Elliot a few years ago. Also Randolph would be keen to do well so to prove a point to Parky and put himself in the shop window as I cannot see him signing a new contract.
0
Comments
All 'keepers make the odd mistake but overall he has done well.
I don't rate Randolph too highly I'm afraid as a first choice.
So my answer to your question is NO
''eight goals went past Robbie, went past Robbie Elliot...''
If it goes to a shoot-out, it just doesn't bear thinking about.
But I've seen very few better in div three and Randolph definitely is not one of them...
Made far too many mistakes and looked abit dodgy in recent weeks butv i agree with Len, I don't rate Randolph highly enough for him to be our number one at this stage of the season.
And your learned opinion is based on what exactly? Before he was anywhere near the first team I used to see him in The Portrait in Sidcup on the odd Tuesday, never pissed I might add. He looks the fittest I have ever seen him at the moment so that doesnt add much weight to your claim either...... if you are going to post things that are at best offensive to a player that has come through the ranks and had a good season and at worst bordering on lible, you really need to be able to back it up.
Weaver, not so sure, I saw him in Blackheath and he was a little worse for wear but again not sure if it was a one off. Weaver was a big unit though, Robbie has got himself in shape in the last year.
but oh no he's alright cos he is charlton and he stopped a couple that were at him.....
as far as his goalkeeping ability goes atm he really is 'the emperors new clothes' for us .....
the worse regular keeper in my 34 years of watching charlton by some distance
if weaver had put in the displays he had this season he would have been lynched ....
i'd be farking comitted for charlton but i'm pony (although i'm good at catching!!)
i feel sorry for randolph his ex bird has upgraded him for a jls fella and he sits on the bench watching goal after goal fly past the much excused robbie , give randy a chance!
He was out there last Tuesday week. My brother had a chat with him.
If he needs a break from anything it would be from clubbing and going out on the lash. I don't begrudge any player having a bit of R and R during the season but with our run in the last thing I want to hear is stories of him going out round Canterbury on a Tuesday night.
I nearly asked whether they had their pj's on under their top clothes !