Sky news - Charlton appeal against sending off

Stone

Waste of time or got a genuine chance? I'd like to think the later.

Medders

We'd all like to think, just a shame the FA don't

Stone

Even if you take El Kak out the frame, he still didn't deny Van Persie a goalscoring chance because he would (or should) have been flagged offside when he played the ball.

Ketman

Not a chance this will be overturned. If it was John Terry or Rio Ferdinand on the other hand...........

Ledge

has to be overturned

Stone

if it was either of them two he wouldn't have had the balls to even award a pen!

Salad

But does appealing allow him to play on Saturday, after which LY may be back?
If so then all the more reason to appeal.

Salad

[cite]Posted By: football365[/cite] The true offside scandal is the one that was highlighted at the Emirates Stadium with the penalty decision that sank Charlton's hopes.