Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Jonjo Shelvey you are quality

edited August 2009 in General Charlton
The boy is an extremely good footballer. He is 17.
He played some lovely stuff yesterday.
I just wanted to make it clear to the lad if he comes on this site that most folk on here appreciate that he goes out there gives his all and we recognise and fully support his considerable abilities.
I know we sing his name but when you see stuff in print that is derogatory about you it can stay with you especially when you are at the start of your career.
So jonjo if you read this and I hope you do, you always have to look at who is criticising you and ask - who exactly are you?
Anyway you look pretty effing good to me!

Comments

  • Jonjo...

    Youve got a massive fan here in Australia mate..... your goal against Orient was top drawer mate.....
  • edited August 2009
    I just want to add a couple of points so it is clear where I'm coming from on this

    I have spent time coaching 7 and 11 year olds. Some of them are great little players and look like exciting prospects but the truth is in 16 years I have maybe seen one lad who might possibly have some chance. It seems to me that the critical time for these kids to make it professionally is between 16 and 19 that is normally when they cut it or they don't.
    So the likes of all our players will have had to undergo a ton of hard work and they are ALL extremely good players to get to this level bar none. 99% of the people on this board could not touch their talent.
    Jonjo and his like come this way rarely.
    I just think that if you are going to write and say some of the derogatory stuff then you had better be at least as good as the person you are knocking. There's that old adage that if you've got nothing good to say how bout you keep your mouth shut.
    It may well be different at professional level but absolutely no kid I have ever coached has ever responded to negative destructive comment. You can tell them where to improve and what you are looking for and you can build their confidence and they will run their hearts out and play to their best.
    I am not suggesting that people should not voice their views at all but calling a player at this level the varied equivalents of useless is utter nonsense and pointless.
    And whilst we are all entitled to an opinion it does not follow that it automatically has any merit.
    For instance if NASA rang me up to ask me for my opinion on their new Saturn rocket I could say some old bollocks about it but my views would hardly be much use to anyone would they?
  • [cite]Posted By: 3blokes[/cite]For instance if NASA rang me up to ask me for my opinion on their new Saturn rocket I could say some old bollocks about it but my views would hardly be much use to anyone would they?

    do you think they would be a bit sensitive to your criticism?
  • edited August 2009
    As far as 'I'm concerned' it's best to say nothing at all folks, at least for the time being, until this matter is resolved somehow.
    It seems to me that friendly advice or saying someone looked out of sorts or didn't play very well has become an horrendous crime and that it's in some way connected with twats that shout really insulting stuff from the terraces rather than folk making a genuine heartfelt opinion or observation....there's a big big difference....don't merge the two.
    I'll just say this....haven't we all come across some kid or another misbehaving or doing something wrong and we've pulled them up for it....and got the reply back "I bet you used to do things like that when you were my age". My reply to that normaly is .........."Yes I did...and I just like you are now, I used to get some advice or a bollocking for it." It's called learning I believe.
  • My point is that if you are young and you read negative stuff about yourself then you will most likely take it to heart. You may well learn to deal with it. But I wonder how most of us would feel at any age we were getting those comments on a site that purported to support us.
    Just think it is completely unnecessary. We all might complain when a player misses something we feel is easy. That is fair enough in the moment.
    And I'm sure we have all written stuff that may have been unfair I have done it myself.
    I just think in this instance there are comments that are not fair and we could do better than that in my opinion especially to one of our own players
  • edited August 2009
    [cite]Posted By: 3blokes[/cite]My point is that if you are young and you read negative stuff about yourself then you will most likely take it to heart. You may well learn to deal with it. But I wonder how most of us would feel at any age we were getting those comments on a site that purported to support us.
    Just think it is completely unnecessary. We all might complain when a player misses something we feel is easy. That is fair enough in the moment.
    And I'm sure we have all written stuff that may have been unfair I have done it myself.
    I just think in this instance there are comments that are not fair and we could do better than that in my opinion especially to one of our own players

    What EXACTLY do you mean 3blokes?
    Are you talking about the twats who shout out insulting stuff or those who make genuine observations and opinions put in a positive fashion..there's a huge difference..so where is that line crossed?
    I for one am now confused as to what I can and cannot comment on re Jonjo, therefore I'm going to say nothing at all until I know I'm safe to do so.
  • Well let's hope the rest of the squad's relatives don't sign up to this site because then all comment and opinion will be banned and the place will shut down.
  • Soundas I'm not suggesting you should not voice opinions about players that is what the site is for, it is more that some of the comments on this board in addition to the stuff that the family has had to endure in the stands is completely unreasonable and quite baffling. How does that stuff help anyone.
    I just wanted to put up a post that was unequivocally in support of the player so the family know that he and them have our support. And I know Soundas you and loads of others are right behind the boy.
    That's all I'm going to say on it now.
  • [cite]Posted By: LeaburnForEngland[/cite]Well let's hope the rest of the squad's relatives don't sign up to this site because then all comment and opinion will be banned and the place will shut down.

    Exactly LfE..........exactly.
  • And thank god Kelly Youga is 24 as by that age you're immune to criticism and people saying you are useless as you lose all emotional insecurities by that age otherwise we'd need another thread telling him how great he is!
  • Sponsored links:


  • As I have said elsewhere, THE LAD IS CLASS, and I am delighted to have him at our club and hope he will stay as long as possible! a moment for me that epitimised his class was last season, cant remember who against but he tried to lob the keeper from almost halfway, it just went over. the vision to do that is ver rare.
  • [cite]Posted By: 3blokes[/cite]Soundas I'm not suggesting you should not voice opinions about players that is what the site is for, it is more that some of the comments on this board in addition to the stuff that the family has had to endure in the stands is completely unreasonable and quite baffling. How does that stuff help anyone.
    I just wanted to put up a post that was unequivocally in support of the player so the family know that he and them have our support. And I know Soundas you and loads of others are right behind the boy.
    That's all I'm going to say on it now.

    Thanks mate............you know I am totally behind the lad.........One thing though....where are all these really nasty comments on this board re Jonjo........I've not seen them?
  • edited August 2009
    I haven't seen any nasty comments about Shelvey, either.

    What I have seen is a lot of people who, because he has premiership potential, seem to expect him to play two levels above the other 21 players every single week.

    That isn't going to happen. And when it doesn't happen, two basic reactions seem to occur.

    The starstruck pretend that he was two levels above, even when he patently wasn't. Another group moans that 'Shelvey was below par today'.

    IMO, neither view is very helpful in what are still the very early days of what we all hope will be a great career for the lad!
  • Nigel W will probably class me as 'starstruck' but all I know is that whether he is on form or slighly below par, it does my old heart good to see Jonjo on the pitch. Even when he isn't on fire or is youthfully trying too hard he always does a couple of things per game that are unexpected and exciting. He's got a real footballing brain and vision - a rare thing. I wake up on match days feeling privileged that I'm going to see a player like him in Charlton colours. I haven't felt like that about a Charlton player since Parker was, briefly, in his pomp for us.
  • Been said before I know but we should enjoy him while we can. Breath of fresh air for sure.
  • edited August 2009
    Nadou said ''Nigel W will probably class me as 'starstruck' ''

    Only where Bob Dylan is concerned, Nadou... although I have to say you did pretty well to keep your sang-froid when you got to shake the great man's hand at the Roundhouse earlier this year !
  • Bit of a storm in a teacup in my opinion. When it comes down to it, it's about respect. People should always have the right to voice their opinions, here or anywhere, but there has to be respect... respect for those involved and respect, in this case, for the community here. Unfortunately, some people need to abuse and antagonise to get their kicks in life. These people are the problem, whether liquored up during a match or playing the keyboard warrior in the forums. It seems this is the only way these people know how to get attention.

    I only get to see the highlights every week, but one thing that is relevant is that Jonjo seems to love playing football and playing for this team and this club. Looking at yesterday's highlights, he seemed genuinely excited when Wagstaff scored. Great kid.

    Long may it continue.
  • [cite]Posted By: LoOkOuT[/cite]Bit of a storm in a teacup in my opinion. When it comes down to it, it's about respect. People should always have the right to voice their opinions, here or anywhere, but there has to be respect... respect for those involved and respect, in this case, for the community here. Unfortunately, some people need to abuse and antagonise to get their kicks in life. These people are the problem, whether liquored up during a match or playing the keyboard warrior in the forums. It seems this is the only way these people know how to get attention.

    I only get to see the highlights every week, but one thing that is relevant is that Jonjo seems to love playing football and playing for this team and this club. Looking at yesterday's highlights, he seemed genuinely excited when Wagstaff scored. Great kid.

    Long may it continue.

    Quality post Looky
  • You explained that much better than me LookOut.
  • Spot on Lookie.
  • Sponsored links:


  • [cite]Posted By: Nadou[/cite]Nigel W will probably class me as 'starstruck' but all I know is that whether he is on form or slighly below par, it does my old heart good to see Jonjo on the pitch. Even when he isn't on fire or is youthfully trying too hard he always does a couple of things per game that are unexpected and exciting. He's got a real footballing brain and vision - a rare thing. I wake up on match days feeling privileged that I'm going to see a player like him in Charlton colours. I haven't felt like that about a Charlton player since Parker was, briefly, in his pomp for us.

    That's the problem i find. you get so attached to your new star player and you just assume because he plays for us that hes happy. And then bang some money bags swipes him from under your nose and hes stuck on one of the prems finest subs benches. Hope he stays tho. i really do see him becoming a proper charlton legend.
  • Massive fan here JJ
  • That's the problem i find. you get so attached to your new star player and you just assume because he plays for us that hes happy. And then bang some money bags swipes him from under your nose and hes stuck on one of the prems finest subs benches. Hope he stays tho. i really do see him becoming a proper charlton legend.[/quote]

    A bit like life, really - you just have to enjoy it while you've got it.
  • Nadou philosophically observed :

    ''A bit like life, really - you just have to enjoy it while you've got it.''

    Or Together Through Life, Nadou ? Still Bob's worst album in more than 20 years for me, I'm afraid!

    But seriously, our mutual Dylan obssession apart, I do agree with you about Shelvey. He's the best I've seen since Parker, too. I just hope he doesn't end up playing alongside Scotty at WHU any time soon, although that would no doubt make disgruntled uncle v happy...
  • edited August 2009
    [cite]Posted By: LoOkOuT[/cite]Bit of a storm in a teacup in my opinion. When it comes down to it, it's about respect. People should always have the right to voice their opinions, here or anywhere, but there has to be respect... respect for those involved and respect, in this case, for the community here. Unfortunately, some people need to abuse and antagonise to get their kicks in life. These people are the problem, whether liquored up during a match or playing the keyboard warrior in the forums. It seems this is the only way these people know how to get attention.

    I only get to see the highlights every week, but one thing that is relevant is that Jonjo seems to love playing football and playing for this team and this club. Looking at yesterday's highlights, he seemed genuinely excited when Wagstaff scored. Great kid.

    Long may it continue.

    Agree Looky.....but wil you kindly concur..........(for uncles sake at least and my sanity because I started the thread re him being lucky not to be sent off)
    that no one and I mean no one, has ever been abusive or indeed non supportive of Jonjo on this message board..if they have, I've yet to see it.
  • [quote][cite]Posted By: nigel w[/cite]Nadou philosophically observed :

    But seriously, our mutual Dylan obssession apart, I do agree with you about Shelvey. He's the best I've seen since Parker, too. I just hope he doesn't end up playing alongside Scotty at WHU any time soon, although that would no doubt make disgruntled uncle v happy...[/quote]

    Yes, a lot of people on this list seem to forget that he could still be off before the window closes. I just hope he'll still be with us by the middle of next week.
  • edited August 2009
    I really hope Jonjo dosent read this board. If he reads threads like this they could be disillusioning, if he comes across any constructive criticism it perhaps could be taken negatively as we've seen before. It's a no win situation and I would have thought that all young players and players in general would be strongly discouraged from browsing any forums linked with their clubs. So IMO(and it is just my opinion) addressing any player directly in a thread is just wrong and no good can come from it.
  • That's fair enough comment Charlton.
    It would be good to think that charlton staff from all areas of the club could come on a site like this and I'm sure they do. It provides feedback and if it is done with reasonable respect then great, it gets people's views across.
    I would imagine that for players it may be a bit like getting reviews of your performance. And as someone posted earlier this is not just about jonjo, youga has had a lot of stick on here, as have plenty of others. They also get plenty of praise too on here.
    I just wanted to make sure that this site is seen as generally fair and supportive. There are some cracking debates and thoughtful comment about all sorts of things on this forum and it is a great place to visit.
    That was how this thread was intended to come across.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!