Butters Transfer ListedNot sure if this has been posted, but Butterfield has been transfer listed with 12 months left on his contract.
Thoughts? Personally, I can't see Murty (if he joins us) lasting 46 games for the season, he's been so injury prone. If we want to reduce player turnover as much as possible and keep the majority of the squad together, no doubt he could do a job for us in League 1. Shouldn't be much either.
Comments
Oh, and dont want Butterbean
If we got Murty then him and Solly would be fine for us.
Still got the hat!!
What he said
Poor opening game but did little else wrong IMO.
Apart from the fact he was at Palace.
Poor opening game but did little else wrong IMO.
Apart from the fact he was at Palace.[/quote]And tells three year olds he hasnt got time for charlton fan
Thought Butterfield did OK but nothing special.
Murty is better but then he's more injury prone.
Wow Large I actually agree with you on those points above!
But AFKA's point still stands Butterfield had a poor first game and did nothing wrong from there - Only problem was he didn't do anything special either. He would do very well in league 1 but he'll go Ipswich.
When you look at someone like Graham Alexander and the money he earnt week in week out struggling to get the contracts he won, whilst Semedo probably got given that wage after proveing nothing in his career and deserving little past the national average wage. I want a right full back who is hungry for his wage, at whatever level that is.
I've always thought he works hard, seems to have a decent enough attitude, he just doesn't have that 'character' that someone like Nicky Bailey has (which often leads to him giving away silly free kicks).
He was good enough to come through the youth system at Sporting (fair enough he didn't play for their first team), played for Portugal u21s, gone out on loan a few times. Not really proven himself any less than a lot of other players.
Poor opening game but did little else wrong IMO.
Apart from the fact he was at Palace.[/quote]
Agreed.[/quote]
which people need to get over
well they pick and choose as they feel it seems didn't see to many moaning at Powell, whyte, mortimer Humphrey and pardew as a player. when they came back back or orignially joined.
He played in side that knew they were down but only lost 1 in the last 8
I am staggered at this comment - absolutely astounded in fact
Semedo is a much much better player than he gets credit for and will be a key part of our midfield if he stays.
I truly wonder what game I am watching sometimes
Poor opening game but did little else wrong IMO.
Apart from the fact he was at Palace.[/quote]
Agreed.[/quote]
which people need to get over[/quote]
well they pick and choose as they feel it seems didn't see to many moaning at Powell, whyte, mortimer Humphrey and pardew as a player. when they came back back or orignially joined.
He played in side that knew they were down but only lost 1 in the last 8[/quote]
Exactly
He offers nothing going forward and is an average defender at best. Ok if you want to play for 0-0's, but no use otherwise.
BUT he is 30 or thereabouts and therefore likely to be at the higher end of the wage scale. Whilst he has been competent he has not been outstanding and thus does not justify pushing out the wages boat.
Semedo, Moutouakill or Solly are at least as capable as Butterfield in my view.
The one advantage Butterfield had was previous experience in a back 4 with Hudson and Ward. Given that it is highly probable neither of them will be with us come August the main reason for keeping Butterfield also disappears.