Who's our best player?

cafc_se7

The best period to judge who our best player is this season has got to be the first 5-8 games, where everyone were on tip top form....going from that, i think Semedo or Sam are our best players!

Valley_floyd_red

Nicky Bailey.

kevtherev

MOO2

Oggy Red

Certainly missed Youga.

One player I somehow expected a little more of, is Richardson.

Not that he really lets us down, he doesn't.

Having played a bit of football in the Prem, 2 years in the Championship (including play off finals), and 2 years as a cornerstone player and captain for an always promotion challenging Leeds in Division 3, I just thought he'd bring a little something extra to the table.

Exiled_Addick

I'm not convinced Richo has been fully fit for a coouple of months now. I thought he started the season very brightly, particularly when getting forward and overlapping Sam but he seems to have gone into his shell a bit, in the last few weeks particularly. Tbh, if he needs a rest I'd be quite happy to see Solly given a few games so Richo can get himself sorted for the tough run-in, Solly aquited himself well at left back so I'd feel comfortable about him starting in his strongest position.

101

My fav is Lloydie but our best atm is prob Jonjo or Bailey probably Bailey i would suggest.

Stone

[cite]Posted By: Ru1986[/cite]My fav is Lloydie but our best atm is prob Jonjo or Bailey probably Bailey i would suggest.

Someone who can tell the difference between favorite and best. Nice one Ru.

As an all round player Bailey hands down (when played in his right position)

101

[cite]Posted By: Stone[/cite]

[cite]Posted By: Ru1986[/cite]My fav is Lloydie but our best atm is prob Jonjo or Bailey probably Bailey i would suggest.

Someone who can tell the difference between favorite and best. Nice one Ru.

As an all round player Bailey hands down (when played in his right position)

Im observant arn't i.

cafc4life

lloyd sam is shit... bailey and elliot for me

Morts-Genius-Jnr

Shelvey, he has potential. Bailey still rules supreme lol.

The Red Robin

Semedo and Elliot.

S_E_7

Bailey
shelvey
semedo
youga
racon

Moo2 is a QUALITY player but is obviusly a wa#### judging by his comments.

Maglor

Reid for me.

I think Elliot has been great but should not now be automatic when fit given the performances Randolph has put in

Scoham

[cite]Posted By: S_E_7[/cite]Moo2 is a QUALITY player but is obviusly a wa#### judging by his comments.

Quality based on what? He was poor for Motherwell both attacking and defensively.

Oggy Red

[cite]Posted By: Maglor[/cite]

I think Elliot has been great but should not now be automatic when fit given the performances Randolph has put in

Randolph performed very assuredly yesterday at Southampton.

He's obviously growing in confidence, good positioning, safe hands - and now coming out and catching crosses, instead of punching the ball.

And tearing up and down the park for our stoppage time corners - Saints defenders didn't know to deal with that!
Rather spoiled because our corners weren't timed properly to be met by the unmarked Randolph's 100 yard runs.

On present form, there's no reason why Randolph shouldn't keep his place, even once Rob Elliot is fit again.

ShootersHillGuru

Nicky Bailey.

cafcdan18

I know it is only two/three games but they way we played without Bailey against Huddersfield, MK and Carlisle suggests Semedo would be more of a loss. Semedo is our best player!

nolly

nicky bailey everytime