Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Should we send some loans back.....

edited December 2008 in General Charlton
and bring in some of the youths?

Shelvey has not been playing mutch recently for fitness reasons apparently but now he's back he's scoring again.....
Godfrey with another assist....

and Long scoring again....

defo worth consideration surely?

Comments

  • Realistically until we are out of relegation trouble, apart from sub appearances (and start places if really impress comin off the bench) I dont see this happening. Unless of course we dont move out the bottom three and start gettin desperate.
  • I only really mean like Cranie and Waghorn, as our youth strikers from my experience are as good as him anyway!
  • I dont think they are at all. Plus I think Cranie's getting better and better. If I was going to send anyone back it'd be Primus but even with him its worth keeping as backup in case either hudson or fortune arent fit. I'd keep them all.
  • Doubt if we can send them back early as we've agreed a fixed time.

    Primus' loan ends in December and Burton looks likely to convert to a purchase so won't count.

    Still not sure on Cranie but he has had some good games.

    Waghorn looked sharper than Godfrey or Dickson. I would hang onto him
  • As Henry says Primus returns after the Derby home game which leaves us with 6. Crainie is worth keeping as cover for centre back or full back. I've not been a fan but he did ok against Southampton although I'd love to see Moo2 as first choice.
  • Cranie's loan ends in January. So whether Parky will extend it remains to be seen. I'd like to see us get Primus here on a permanent in January too, or at least on loan till the end of the season with a view to a permanent.
  • For me I'd send Primus & Cranie back as think Yassin would get a fair crack of the whip under Parkinson at Full back & Hudson looks much more secure playing with Fortune.
  • Yes i think we should, need to bring on our own talent rather than looking at short term solutions. Find is scary that we have 7 on short term loans, where is the stability in that?
  • It depends entirely on who we would send back and whether we are paying their wages or not. If we are paying them, and they are not getting involved, then yes, send back. If their other clubs are paying the wages in full, then they might as well stay to be honest.
  • Primus has been a bit of a failure so can't see his loan being extended. I don't rate Cranie but expect his to continue to end of year. hopefully Burton, McEverly and Gillespie can be permanently signed in January money permitting
  • Sponsored links:


  • I think we'll sign Burton and maybe Gillespie on frees which would solve the problem if we want to extend any of the loans or let them go back and bring in new ones.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!