Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Worst Pardew XI

edited November 2008 in General Charlton
Given that Pards has played so many players in his time here, who would make the honorary Pards Flops team??

Comments

  • edited November 2008
    GK Randolph D
    RB Halford G
    CB Cranie M
    CB Traore D
    LB Thatcher B
    LM Cook L
    CM Sinclair D
    CM Faye A
    RM Sinclair S
    ST McLeod I
    ST Lita L

    worst 11 in my opinion.
  • Christ - where do you start?

    Randolph (Harsh, I know)

    Halford - McCarthy - Youga - Thatcher

    Scott Sinclair - Dean Sinclair - Racon - Cook

    McLeod - Varney (for price tag alone)
  • RACON??? Racon is one of our best cmids
  • Lita?? Worse than Varney?
  • Yes, but what is that saying? I know he got injured at Watford this year but he hardly played at all last year and with our well known weaknesses in central midfield, epitomised by the continuing presence of the admirable but limited Holland, Pardew should have been spending money on bringing in a decent midfielder with CCC experience rather than bringing in an untried Racon.

    I guess my beef with Racon is more with Pardew than the player himself, maybe his inclusion is a bit harsh.
  • Lita because he was another loan to demoralise what we already had!
  • Doesn't necessarily have to be players he signed, could be players who have gone backwards or woefully underperformed during his reign.

    Youga & Ambrose are names I keep hearing.
  • Ambrose maybe but was he ever as good as some thought?
  • Amdy Faye!
  • Actually Oakster, I think that your call on Ambrose is bang on. Pardew was a goalscoring midfielder, just like Sharon, and yet he singulalrly failed to coax any kind of consistency out of him at all.

    Ambrose should have been our "Koumas" type quality ball-playing, goal-scoring attacking midfielder yet Pardew shuffled him round the side continually and never gave him an extended run behind the strikers, the players preferred role.

    To be fair though, Ambrose must also share the blame for his poor form.

    As for Youga, I think people over-estimate his success at Scunthorpe - they lost a lot of games and conceeded a lot of goals while he was there and still went down!!!
  • Sponsored links:


  • What about Martin Christinsen?

    Not saying that he's no good, and I know that he's had injuries, but he was 'one for the future' nearly two years ago so we must have been looking a long way ahead when we signed him...
  • Jody Morris? Does he count?
  • I cannot seriously see how some think Lita was bad, he always put in 100% unlike some of our other loanee's and scored 3 in about 5 games, we havn't had many strikers with a 0.6 goal per game ratio, great maths, i loved him, if only we had signed him, look wat he's doin for the inbreds

    I think Varney is a harsh choice also, still don't think he is a natural striker, i would prefer him on the right wing, for wat i hav seen he can deliver a good cross and can utilise his pace, sam for me is becoming like JT, great when running at a player but no finish product
  • GK: Randolph
    RB:Halford
    CB:Cranie
    CB:El Karkouri
    LB:Youga
    RM:Sinclair
    LM:Cook
    CM:D Sinclair
    CM:Faye
    FW:McLeod
    FW:Fleetwood
  • Bit harsh putting Faye in there, I think Pards only played him a handful of times after he came to the club - even the old silver fox could see how crap Faye was.
  • Bit unfair on Dean Sinclair who has only started one game for the addicks in the league cup last year where he played well and scored. Also Fleetwood has yet to make an appearance for us.

    Did Traore ever play for Pardew? I thought he got rid of him straight away
  • traore and faye were dowie signings..
  • edited November 2008
    Randolph
    Halford Maccarthy Youga Thatcher
    Sinclair Ambrose ......... Cook
    Varney Mcloed



    to be fair though the entire squad have under performed for the past 20 months, it'll cause unrest but i'd put holland in the gap aswel, I think along with ambrose and big big reason y we simply haven't competed in midfield.

    In pards eyes our worst 11 would be - by fact of never playin them (more so last yr)

    Elliot
    Mouts Fortune....... Basey
    Christiansen Semedo Racon ......
    Dicko Mccloed

    Now out of that we have th two best defensive midfielders we have at the club - the position we have needed to improve for 3/4 years,
    the best left back at the club - discounting semedo as he's betta in CM
    the best right back in the squad - discounting semedo as he's betta in CM
    the only natural finisher in the squad - Dicko
    the quickest player in the squad - Mccloed
  • edited November 2008
    Do Dorian Smith and Paulo Monteiro count, since they didn't even make their debuts?

    Smith isn't even a regular for Welling, no idea where Monteiro went.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!