Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

There has Been Plenty

edited November 2008 in General Charlton
of talk recently about players who are useless while with us but good once they leave.

So a two part question:

a) who have we released that we should have kept bearing in mind someone like Michael turner was crowded out by better players as we were in the Prem?

b) what players have come to us and improved?

To kick it off I give you Lisbie for a) (is Varney any better?) and Mark kinsella for b)

Comments

  • a) Iwelumo

    not that i didn't rate him for us but Wolves have certainly done better at fulfilling his true potential.
  • a) Richard Gough, Matt Elliot
  • a) Lisbie is a good un,

    b) Darren Bent, luke young the only 2 I can name
  • a) Linvoy Primus

    b) Derek hales
  • a) Danny Shittu

    b)John Robinson
  • a) Although obviosuly he had to leave when he did you'd definitely have to say Andy Todd did better after leaving us. He went on to play in Europe for Blackburn.

    b) Kinsella is probably the best example but you could also argue Andy Hunt and Clive Mendonce also, although they were both good players before coming here they both enjoyed their best seasons here. Infact that could pretty much be said for most of the 1997-2000 ssquads they all improved here.
  • I thought the first part of this thread was about players who were let go because they were no good for us. I can't see any mentioned as really falling into that category.

    Gough and Elliot were weren't there long enough. Shittu and Turner were just down the pecking order with established players ahead of them.

    Iwelumo was certainly not useless for us.

    Primus was let go because Rufus was considered the better bet (and he had some off field problems).

    So as far as a) is concerned Lisbie is the only taker in my opinion

    As for the second category

    Hales, Robinson, Kinsella, Humphrey, Mendonca, Luke Young, Chris Powell, Flanagan, Robinson, Andy Hunt, Kiely
  • [quote][cite]Posted By: dansmudge[/cite]a) Iwelumo

    not that i didn't rate him for us but Wolves have certainly done better at fulfilling his true potential.[/quote]

    I don't think that Big Chris has improved since he left us, it just that now he's at a team that play to his strengths rather than just hoofing hopeful long balls up to him.
  • Has Lisbie actually improved? Or is he benefitting from playing more regularly - and more importantly at a lower level (Championship) than the bulk of his games for us (Premiership) - I always thought he'd succeed at the lower level as he had shown when on loan at Gillingham
  • [cite]Posted By: East Kent Addick[/cite]Has Lisbie actually improved? Or is he benefitting from playing more regularly - and more importantly at a lower level (Championship) than the bulk of his games for us (Premiership) - I always thought he'd succeed at the lower level as he had shown when on loan at Gillingham

    Well he's stopped getting injured so often, but as a player he's probably just gained confidence from scoring goals by playing every week and being under a lot less pressure.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!