Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

CL Managerial Cup 1st rnd: Steve Clarke v Sammy Lee

edited June 2008 in General Charlton
Battle of the Number Two’s.

Pros – Both have worked with the best, and know what is needed to produce successful football. Both respected as excellent coaches, and both feel they have served their apprenticeship and are ready and eager to make the step up. Under Grant at Chelsea, Clarke was seen by many as virtually the manager.

Cons – Clarke has no No1 experience. Lee has only the short, disastrous spell at Bolton, though you could argue he was on a hiding to nothing post-Alladyce, and that he now has the advantage of learning from that experience and knowing first-hand how being a good No2 is very different to the manager’s job.

REMEMBER: You are voting on who out of the two on offer you would prefer to be Charlton manager.

Comments

  • clarke for me , lives nearer than sammy and seems like he can get nasty if required to
  • wouldnt judge sammy just on that bolton job, looked like he chose the wrong job to jump into when it was obvious they were going to have problems there
  • Scottish hard man gave all for chelsea never saw lee play, steve clarke all the way.
  • Steve Clarke, anyone who can survive under as many managers and regimes as he has done at Chelsea must have something going for them as a coach.

    Sammy Lee is regarded as a good coach but definitely as a player was more highly regarded than his actual ability suggested. Another who got to play for England by dint of his being a Liverpool player. As soon as they flogged him off - to QPR if I recall, he swiftly faded away. As manager at Bolton he was definitely a bit of a Les Reed/Brian Kidd - a good coach who couldn't make the transition from coaching players to managing them.
  • Tough one, but I voted for Sammy Lee - he might be able to get some Liverpool players in on loan :-)
  • Sammy Lee, just.
  • Clarke for me.....
  • was sammy lee interviewed for the charlton job b4 dowie got it???
  • Clarke - Cant vote for anyone who wears an earpiece on the touchline.
  • Sponsored links:


  • How much is it that those against Lee is based on the Bolton experience ?

    A case of one strike and you're out, as opposed to with Clarke into the unknown, but no proven failures against ?
  • you might have to stop this one afka , it's turned into a massacre for sammy lee!!
  • Sammy Lee was interviewed for the Charlton job before Dowie was offered the position
  • ty amos i knew he was talked about wasn't sure if he'd got interviewed
  • Yeah I remember a quote from him at the time that he had spoken to the Charlton Board and was impressed with the set up at Charlton Morts
  • i just like steve clarke he was the sort of player i liked us signing and i think he is respected amongst good players where Sammy seemed to have a mini revolt on his hands within hrs of getting the job
  • clarke for me.
    if sammy lee got the job he would destroy our top scorer iwumelo's confidence by constantly beating him in the air during training.
  • [cite]Posted By: paulbaconsarnie[/cite]clarke for me.
    if sammy lee got the job he would destroy our top scorer iwumelo's confidence by constantly beating him in the air during training.

    disagree, i think big chris would foul him first to try and win the ball;-)
  • Mark Mansfield or Steve Clarke? :)
  • Sammy Lee.

    The successor to Allardyce was always going to be on a hiding to nothing rather like us with whoever followed Curbs.

    You don't realise how good a manager is (was) until he's gone.

    Lee was a good enough player to earn respect on the training ground and has served his apprenticeship as a coach. He just needs a suitable opportunity to make it as a number one.
  • Sponsored links:


  • [cite]Posted By: LenGlover[/cite]
    Curbs.

    You don't realise how good a manager is (was) until he's gone.

    too true len , too true

    **shakes head in disbelief at the fall from grace charlton have suffered since sir alan left the club**
  • I have had to vote against the 2 gingers.
  • Steve Clarke. Just I think working with Jose and Avram Grant will have given him a better insight in the way things are done at the top level.
  • Clarke for me the other one's a bleedin Scouser !
  • Clarke, not sure why. Both pretty uninteresting
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!