CAFC Dream Team

LoOkOuT

What would your all time Charlton Dream Team XI be (choose the best players at the peak of their powers)?

LoOkOuT

Mine would include Bartram, Rufus, Parker, Darren Bent, Killer, Super Clive for starters.

Ledge

i won on talksport a couple of years back a comp and the prize was putting my dream team in pictures in 4-4-2 format.

I did this purely as players who have done it for charlton and who i have seen play

mine was

kiely
johnny h shirtliff rufus reid ( edges powelly for his goalscoring)

lee jensen kins walsh ( i love morts but walshy is a legend as well and that goal)

hales mendonca

Ormiston_Addick

Based on the same principles as Ledge....

Bolder
Humphrey - Shirtliff - Rufus - Powell
Lee - Parker - Jensen - Mortimer
Mendonca - Bent

roseandcrown

Kiely
Mills Rufus Fish Powell
Bowyer Kinsella Parker Jensen
Mendonca Bent

daveroan

Got to include some earlier players who I did actually see play but it is hard to visualise how some of the 'oldies' would fit into the modern premiership game. I remain persuaded that they would do as well as some of the over-rated prima donnas that sometimes refuse to perform...So here's my ALL STAR XI plus subs.

Carson
Humphrey Rufus Costa Reid
Jensen Parker Hammond (Cyril)
Leary
Bent Firmani

subs ;
Bartram, Mortimer, Hales, Kinsella, Townsend (Don)

Sco

                        Kiely

Humphrey   Rufus   Shirtcliff   C Powell

Lee        Parker       Kinsella     Mortimer

              D Bent      Mendonca

RedArmySE7

Kiely
Mills Rufus Costa Powell
Bowyer Parker Kinsella Mortimer
Bent Mendonca

MCS

Johns

Johnnie Umf (Capt)
Rufus
Shirtliff
Reid

Parker
Kins
Bowyer

Hales
Mendonca
Flash

LoOkOuT

Sorry, never had time to finish mine up until now. I've never had a chance to see them all, obviously, but they are CAFC through and through, so I had to include some of the legends in with the ones closer my generation:

Bartram

Humphrey Costa Rufus Sir Chris Powell

Bowyer Parker Jensen Paddy Powell

Darren Bent Mendonca


Subs: Kinsella, Hales, Kiely, Shirtliff, Peacock
Manager: Jimmy Seed (Why not?)
Ass. Manager: Lennie Lawrence

ISawLeaburnScore

Based on my time supporting Charlton (1992-)

Kiely

Mills Rufus Brown Powell

Stuart Parker Kinsella Robinson

Mendonca Bent

Subs: Bowyer, Hunt, Lee, Mortimer, Costa and smuggle Super Carl on there as well!
Manager: Curbs of course!

PeakieRocket

Bolder

Johnny H
Rufus
Shirtliff
Powell

Lee
Kinsella
Parker
Walsh

Hales
Hunt (similar scoring record to Mendonca but didn't take pens, and was great at holding the ball up)

paulbaconsarnie

with the emphasis on 'best players at the peak of their powers', (as in the original post), and based on who i've seen 1st hand. mine is.

kiely
humphrey-costa-elliott-powell
lee-parker-barnes-walsh
simonsen
bent

though it would probably be different tomorrow

LoOkOuT

Lord, how could I forget Simonsen!

Henry Irving

Bartram

N Smith Rufus Costa Bonds

Bailey C Walsh Mortimer

Firmani Tess Jepson

Subs C Wright, Simmonsen, Jock Campell, Kinsella, Parker

Maanger J Seed

May all be different tomorrow.