Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Every McLeod has a Silver Lining...... Very quick match report

edited September 2007 in General Charlton
Charlton moved up to third, but for the bulk it was a very frustrating evening. We totally dominated the first 30 minutes, Narridge hardly touched the ball. Yet throughout that period we seemed to be stuck in third gear. Everything is neat, pretty and efficient, but it lacks that oomph, the desire to really say we're going to try and hurt you. Only one who looked likely to try and break the gameline was Varney, who on two or three times got the ball wide left in the box, and cut in with intent. Last fifteen mins of the first half, Narridge worked their way back in to it, through more a case of starting to look more frail defensively than them upping the anti. Just before half time Weaver pulled off a top draw point blank save.

Second half was largely much the same, we looked the better side by far without doing any real damage, Narridge never really threatened but increased their possession halfway through. Looked like they were very happy to play for a draw. Varney tired and replaced with McLeod. That's what changed the game. Mcleod showed pace and strength, a ball chipped over his right shoulder into the box saw him running out of room towards the byline when the Narridge defender made a needless foul. Convinced it was a pen, and a stupid and unecessary challenge to make. Second one Mcleod's confidence was up, cut in from the left between two defenders and got tripped. Dubious in my book, either outside or very clever on his part, but i'd feel a bit aggrieved if i was on the other side. Reid finished with comfortably with both, both struck well to the keepers left.

Overall, both full backs were solid doing little wrong, but nothing shining either. Weaver was there when it mattered. Fortune and Bougy done OK, kept a clean sheet, but didn't win enough arial ball for me and i'm still to be convinced.

In midfield, Samedo and ZZ were largely neat and tidy, Reid is developing a habit of doing one great ball / one poor ball in a 50/50 ratio. All our creativity comes through him, but i equally think he has an impact on us playing at a more laboured tempo. Sam was lively, without fully punishing them, but was encouraging none the less. Up top Varney looked good. Busy, quick and looking to be direct with the ball. Got fed a few times in the first half down the left channel by Reid and looked dangerous. Ilewumo does the unglamourous job, works hard but possibly could of won a few more flick ons and never seemed to be dangerously positioned in the box.

Ref Monty had a very good game for the bulk of it. Iet it flow but pulled up when need to be. Towards the end of the game seemed to lose his control a bit when Narridge were getting frustrated. not fully convinced on the second pen.

Narridge - big disappointment for me. Very poor team who appeared to have little attacking intent and seemed to be playing for a draw. Excellent travelling support, around 2000. Not the most vocal we'll get, but great numbers for a midweek with clearly a struggling side.
«1

Comments

  • [cite]Posted By: AFKA Bartram[/cite] Excellent travelling support, around 2000. Not the most vocal we'll get, but great numbers for a midweek with clearly a struggling side.
    yep and i still heard 'your support is f***ing shit' sung by the charlton ultras
  • ref was absolutely awful... far too shy with the cards... therefore both sides got away with awful challenges... we should have been awarded about 4 pens before the 2 we got... and the 2nd pen was about 2 feet outside the area.... he was absolutely wank
  • For Naarwich, I thought Dublin had Big Chris in his back pocket and was their best player by far, that was until he kicked out at Millsy.
  • very unproffessional of Dublin and Huckleby, two very experienced pro's.

    I didn't see anything Mills did to provoke such a clear targetting, did anyone ?
  • They probably thought they could wind him up and get him sent off... Just be thankfull Thatcher wasn't out there tonight!
  • just heard norwich manager on sky saying mills aimed his elbow at huckerby..... a bit like dublin's when he took big chris out in the penalty area!!
  • Don't like Dublin, especially after he knocked us of the FA cup with Leicester.

    So pleased the guy got sent off !
  • Bit harsh on Iwelumo - he did hit the bar in the first half after all!

    Agree that we almost seem to be too "neat and tidy" at times and need to be a bit more incisive in and around the box - and bleedin shoot some more!!!
  • I thought the ref was too lienient in the first 60 minutes, when we appealed for a pen and didn't get it and gave grief he seemed to flip and become unduly harsh. I wonder if the penalties were given partly as we got to him?
  • No, I think the penalties were given because they were blatant fouls.

    The second was borderline on the edge of the box, but we'll take that.
  • Sponsored links:


  • they didnt have 2000 there nowhere near more life 1200
  • Well, if the end holds 3k and the top tier was empty then I'd say that 1200-1500 was probably about fair.

    Fuggin hate that lary yellow colour too.
  • Your report was pretty accurate AFKA. The Carrot Crunchers offered very little attack wise although the longer the game went on there was the nagging worry that they might somehow nick a goal. Weaver had little to do but made one great save in the first half. I was wondering at half time whether fans have finally accepted him and recognise that he is a decent keeper or would people be back on here again moaning that he should have caught the shot. :-)

    My MOM was Sam. I thought he was a threat throughout the game and really went for it. It was nice to see a big-hearted performance by a winger rather than then short-change crap we have had from the likes of Thomas.

    As for Mcleod, well his pace up against some tired legs absolutely frightened Narrige to death and turned the game decisively in our favour.

    As for Danny Mills, his was a rugged performance, typical of him. He is one serious wind up merchant and probably did catch Huckerby with his elbow, although Iwelumo got flattened with an elbow before the pens, so Narridge were dishing it out as well. He appeared to be remonstrating with the ref not to book Huckerby when he got fouled by him. I like him for his way. Imagine Thatcher and him as our full backs. The only worry is which one is going to get sent of first.

    One final thought crossed my mind as the Narridge fans drifted away after the second pen. Its was a long way back to Norwich after a watching a crap performance by their team. I can testify that it definitely is a long way back to Norwich (I got back at 1.00am). You notice it much less though when you've won!!!!

    Up the Addicks.
  • [cite]Posted By: bingaddick[/cite]My MOM was Sam. I thought he was a threat throughout the game and really went for it. It was nice to see a big-hearted performance by a winger rather than then short-change crap we have had from the likes of Thomas.

    Hopefully Bing, the deserved applause he got when being subbed will give his confidence a boost.
  • i agree, hector played well, someone needs to tell Semedo that he doesnt have 5 minutes to pick out a pass everytime he gets the ball though!

    Varney and Iweleleleeumo looked good.
  • i must admit i previouslty thought sam was too light and wouldn't make the grade but he seems to be improving in leaps and bounds , good luck to him and well done to the much maligned academy for maybe producing a little gem for us!!
  • Where was Racon ?????
  • What last night proved to me was the strenght in depth we have. We lost our top scorer Toddy but still had good strikers on the pitch and at the end of the game could throw on a pacey striker to run at a tired defence. And we had Sodje, Ambrose and Moo2aKill to use as well while there is Thatcher and Racon (where was he?) as well to come back. Don't shoot me down but we didn't miss McCarthy IMHO.

    I like Sam, he tries to make things happen and works hard but I wish his crossing was better.

    I though ZZ had a quiet game and I wasn't sure where he was playing. 2nd half he seemed to drop a bit deeper but first half he was getting in the box and wasn't building the play. The ball seemed to be passed around him.

    Danny Mills is nasty but he's our nasty. Gave as good as he got. You don't get the attacking ability of Yassin but you get a lot of bite. Magic and Fortune both looked better individually and as a pair than anything we've seen so far this season and Chris Powell was Chris Powell.

    I thought Norwich were a decent side who when they wanted to played some good football but they settled for a draw very early and as we have seen all season we can score late in games.

    "And now you're gonna believe us....."
  • bouggy looks so uncomfortable on the ball compared to that youtube clip that pardew must've watched to part with £2m for him
  • [quote][cite]Posted By: oohaahmortimer[/cite]bouggy looks so uncomfortable on the ball compared to that youtube clip that pardew must've watched to part with £2m for him[/quote]

    Disagree there, thought he played some very clever balls and was always in control at the back last night his pace meant he had them in the pocket for most of the match. Although he did have a couple rash clearances i think he is head and shoulders above our other C.backs
  • Sponsored links:


  • [cite]Posted By: StanmoreAddick[/cite]Where was Racon ?????

    Where was Gibbs?

    Sorry, it's going stale now.....

    ;o)
  • Anyone think they could have let MCLeod take the second pen, would have done his confidence a lot of good.....too risky with 2 minutes left on the clock?
  • No- too risky!

    Imagine if he had and missed.
  • Absolutely Nug.

    Different if we'd already been 3-0 up with 2 mins on the clock.

    If Izzy had taken it and missed, it would have given Norwich great belief they could still get something from the match - and might have then snatched a last gasp goal themselves.

    1-1 wouldn't have looked very clever.
  • edited September 2007
    All about opinions eh!

    I thought we played some superb football especially in the first twenty minutes or so. It's very difficult to raise your attacking tempo in the final third, when the opposition put so may men behind the ball. The midfield three whilst not perfect for the 90, as there were a few wastefull and slow balls, reminded me of the trio that served us so well in the Premiership before it went tits up, (Kish, Smertin and murphy)

    The only main thing driving me mental last night was the constant panic shown by the crowd. Naarwich only managed to get near our box a couple of times in the first half and all around me were screaming and shitting themselves. I accept that we haven't exactly been rock solid so far, but this stuff filters down to the players. I don't think it's any coincidence that Magic, Fortune and others, seem to be much more relaxed in the second half away from the Covered End.

    Thought Sam was outstanding, his final ball in the first half was sometimes wastefull, but he wasn't alone there and as stated before when there are so many yellow shirts in front of you it's hard to be incisive. In the second half he seemed to be all over the park and they couldn't get near him. My MOM and a well deserved standing ovation.

    Varney looked sharp and I was pleased that he isn't afraid to have a crack at goal, but obviously him and Iwelumo need to get an understanding of each others positioning if they are to form a potent strike force.

    Huckerby, Dublin and Docherty deserved all they got. Huckerby was trying to wind up Mills in the first half and got short changed. It carried on in the second and from where I was it looked like Mills caught one in the face. Niggles continued until that Huckerby lunge, so it was only a matter of time before Mills sought retrobution, which I am sure was the intention of a poor Naarwich side from minute one.

    Dublin's flying fore arm smash on Big Chris should have brought a penalty and at the very least a yellow card, but it was ignored, so again after a bit of a niggle with Mills, Dublin cuffed him across the head, what did he expect was going to happen??? And it's not exactly the first time old Dion's done that.

    Docherty was lucky he's nothing but a lumbering no talent cart horse, because if Sam hadn't escaped that lunge, we would now be discussing the possible end of a promising career. Reckless and brutal and deserved a red for intent. The penalty against him was justice in my book.

    Good to see Mcloed ripping them apart when he came on and it bodes well for the future, maybe it could have been sooner as we had started to lump balls up to Iwelumo as ideas understandably began to run out near the end.

    Now the Ref, I thought he was awful, especially at the end. He started well enough, but lost it completely as things got hotter, not helped of course by his inept colleagues on the sidelines. How they mssed that Dublin challenge in the box, I don't know. If he had booked Huckerby early on and possibly Mills when they squared up in the first half, then it might not have escalated to where it did.

    Docherty was allowed to get away with every foul in the book and after that lunge he didn't even get spoken to. Our first pen was soft, but I am convinced it was given as a result of them missing Dublin's challenge. The second was well outside the box and not even debatable in my book. Mills should not have been able to talk the Ref out of giving a red card. If the Ref thought the tackle deserved it, then he should have got it, rightly or wrongly. There were also some spectacularly bad decisions on the direction of throw ins, especially in the second half.

    Sorry Monty, but you're not ready for the Premiership yet.
  • [cite]Posted By: oohaahmortimer[/cite]bouggy looks so uncomfortable on the ball compared to that youtube clip that pardew must've watched to part with £2m for him

    He seems to be really nervous at the start of games. Maybe he's so keen to keep his place. In the second half he was much more assured.
  • [cite]Posted By: Henry Irving[/cite]
    I though ZZ had a quiet game and I wasn't sure where he was playing. 2nd half he seemed to drop a bit deeper but first half he was getting in the box and wasn't building the play. The ball seemed to be passed around him.

    I agree about ZZ, it was his worst performance of the season by his standards. I wonder whether he was affected by missing an open goal in the first half? (Or the second half according to an extremely sloppy report today in the Mirror!!)

    I thought that we were about 70% of what we could achieve once the understanding/confidence really gels. This is good news.
  • Good post KB, and very interesting point about the nervousness of the crowd when we're defending. Think you're right.
  • how the ref didn't book doherty for the intent on that lunge i'll never know(as KB pointed out) and it was during the same passage of play where he played on after samedo's foul but went back and booked him!!
  • It's really interesting reading some of the Match posts as eveyone sees the game so differently. Think our Defence is still sloppy but Bougherra is a huge improvement on McCarthy who i saw in the car park after the game leaving with Holland with a face like thunder. Midfield between ZZ Reid & Semedo pass the ball around well & it is entertaining to watch despite what some of the idiots around me were saying. Pleased with variation we have up front as well. Ref good for 70 mins crap towards the end got two penalty decisions wrong missing the assault on Illulellumo but giving the 2nd trip on McLeod that was well out of the box. Pardew appeared to get the important changes right as well. Apart from our average support in the stands on the night all in all it was a good evening all round.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!