Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: Charlton v Walsall (thread will close Thursday afternoon)

at the Valley or from a stream, your marks please:

Referee:
Phillips:
Dijksteel:
Bauer:
Sarr:
Stevenson:
Bielik:
Morgan:
Reeves:
Fosu-Henry:
Taylor:
Grant:

Pratley: n/a
Marshall: n/a

«1

Comments

  • Referee: 6 - Did well to pull Walsall up on their early fouling, poor though for the Taylor "goal"

    Phillips: 8 - Very good display for someone who hasnt played at this level since September, could easily have been rusty but didnt make a single error
    Dijksteel: 6 - He's not a Right-Back and Solly has no concerns about eventually reclaiming his spot when he's needed there
    Bauer: 6.5 - Solid display as expected from the Big Friendly German
    Sarr: 7.5 - Gets a .5 for his excellent clearance off the line, still did better than Patrick for me
    Stevenson: 7 - Didnt really put a foot wrong, got forward nicely
    Bielik: 8 - Protected the defence well after a poor opening few minutes
    Morgan: 7 - Some very nice early passes, played a big part in the penalty, slow faded though - Still has a big future
    Reeves: 6 - Pretty standard display from him, no real errors but no mistakes either
    Fosu: 6 - Better than his standard performances this season but really needs to look up more
    Taylor: 7 - Caused their Defence endless problems, should be in that dressing room with two goals tonight!!
    Grant: 7.5 - Took his goal really well, proper team player who never stopped running or back tracking today
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 5
    Bauer: 6
    Sarr: 8
    Stevenson: 6
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Reeves: 7
    Fosu-Henry: 6
    Taylor: 7
    Grant: 7
  • Referee: 7
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 6
    Bauer: 6.5
    Sarr: 8.5
    Stevenson: 6.5
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 6.5
    Reeves: 7
    Fosu-Henry: 7
    Taylor: 8
    Grant: 7.5

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • edited January 1
    Referee: 6.5

    Phillips: 7.5 did well, handling and distribution all good
    Dijksteel: 6 stuck at it, some clumsy moments was flagging towards the end
    Stevenson: 7 decent not afraid to get forward or cross, done for pace as he tired
    Bauer: 7 steadyish but got brushed off the ball when they nearly equalised
    Sarr: 8 good comeback performance calm defending cool and cultured on the ball, great headed clearance on the line with Philips beaten
    Bielik: 6.5 very slow start looked leggy but kept going
    Morgan: 7 still raw but made nice forward passes not afraid to get on the ball
    Reeves: 6.5 better but too many in swinging set pieces made it easy for the keeper
    Fosu-Henry: 6 great ball with assist for 1st goal but so frustratingly over plays it
    Taylor: 7.5 worked his socks off attacking and defending, great penalty
    Grant: 7.5 also worked very hard and up for it, took his goal well
  • Referee: 6 good first half, lost his head second half
    Phillips: 7 good distribution from hands and took command of area
    Dijksteel: 6 looked shaky at times and didn't know where his touchline was
    Bauer: 6.5 solid if unspectacular
    Sarr: 8.5 MOM Commanding, Composed, Confident and Calm, match winning header off the line
    Stevenson: 7 assured full back play from the young lad
    Bielik: 7 combative and played the ball forwards well
    Morgan: 6.5 decent forward balls, faded
    Reeves: 6.5 thought he battled well, also faded
    Fosu-Henry: 6 hey look, pass early and we scored! Didn't do it again all game, greedy git
    Taylor: 7.5 perfectly good goal chalked off, would really hate to play against him
    Grant: 7.5 took his goal well, lots of good hard running
  • Referee: 6 good first half, less so second
    Phillips: 7 1st game back and did OK.
    Dijksteel: 5.5 not one of his best games
    Bauer: 7 needed to command the back four better
    Sarr: 8.5 MOM from zero to hero, love Nabby, what a left peg he has at times as well.
    Stevenson: 7 i'd keep him at left back, worth a run in the side.
    Bielik: 7 combative and played the ball forwards well
    Morgan: 8 real potential that lad, good with both feet and intelligent player, needs a loan spell or a regular run out
    Reeves: 7 delivery could be better
    Fosu-Henry: 6 less and less impressed by him each game, can hit a worldy but otherwise poor decisions. should have been off at 60 mins.
    Taylor: 7.5 played the awkward bugger as usual, love him
    Grant: 7.5 took his goal well and worked hard all game
  • Referee: 7 (not as bad as many others have been)
    Phillips: 6
    Dijksteel: 5.5
    Bauer: 7
    Sarr: 8 (MoM)
    Stevenson: 6
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Reeves: 7
    Fosu-Henry: 6
    Taylor: 7.5
    Grant: 7

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • Referee: 5. Poor for both teams
    Phillips: 7.5 commanded area well and a couple of good saves
    Dijksteel: 5 used the ball well when we were in control but Walsall exploited him
    Bauer: 7 steady
    Sarr: 8 beast
    Stevenson: 7 impressed with him
    Bielik: 7.5 breaks up play well
    Morgan: 6.5 made a few mistakes but will be good
    Reeves: 6.5 brilliant at times, poor at times
    Fosu-Henry: 7 inconsistent
    Taylor: 8 he was everywhere
    Grant: 8 decision making was good

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • at the Valley

    Referee: 4 useless
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 4
    Bauer: 6
    Saar 7
    Stevenson: 7
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 6
    Reeves: 6
    Fosu-Henry: 6
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 6

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited January 1
    Referee: 5
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 6
    Bauer: 7
    Sarr 8 MOM
    Stevenson: 6. 5
    Bielik: 7.5
    Morgan: 6.5
    Reeves: 7
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5
    Taylor: 7.5
    Grant: 7.5
  • Referee: 5
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 6
    Bauer: 6
    Starr: 8 MOTM
    Stevenson: 7
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Reeves: 7.5
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5
    Taylor: 8
    Grant: 7
  • Referee: 5
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 5
    Bauer: 6
    Starr: 8.5 MOTM
    Stevenson: 7
    Bielik: 7.5
    Morgan: 7
    Reeves: 7.5
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5
    Taylor: 8
    Grant: 7.5


  • Referee: 5
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 5.5
    Bauer: 7
    Sarr : 7.5
    Stevenson: 6.5
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Reeves: 6
    Fosu-Henry: 6
    Taylor: 7
    Grant: 7.5

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 5
    Bauer: 6.5
    Sarr 7.5 MUCH better than usual
    Stevenson: 6
    Bielik: 5
    Morgan: 6.5
    Reeves: 5
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5 sublime and awful
    Taylor: 8
    Grant: 8
  • edited January 1
    Referee: 5

    Phillips: 6.5 - Some good claims, didn't have any difficult waves to make. His short passing was slow and often underhit, his longer kick outs were erratic and often missed the mark. He might genuinely be better off throwing it after that 70 yarder to Fosu.

    Dijksteel: 5.5 - I...he had a strange day.

    Bauer: 7.5 - had some shaky moments but finished strong and is a good 1-v-1 defender despite his lack of pace.

    Naby BeckenSarr: 9 - So good on the ball, my God how we could have used him in the last couple matches. Got his head on so many things. Extra half point for saving the goal.

    Stevenson: 6 - Looked tidy in possession but just kept getting skinned. Looks promising for the future but hope he won't have to play too much until said future. The pace and physicality of the senior game really caught up with him in the second half.

    Bielik: 8.5 - A brilliant second half where he got in the way of everything.

    Morgan: 6 - Perhaps I'm being a bit harsh on the youngsters but while he looked good on the ball and is clearly a technically gifted footballer, the pave and physicality of the senior game clearly caught up with him. I doubt he's played much central midfield or on the right side of a diamond, more of a 10 or winger, and positionally he looked completely lost in the second half. He should have come off at 50,60, or 75 minutes.

    Reeves: 7 - I thought he'd scored with the free kick. Put in a lot of graft in the second half.

    Fosu-Henry: 7.5 - His decision making wasn't always great but he kept winning the ball back and kept running at them. His ball for the goal was a moment of class. Just news to get him playing the ball quicker.

    Taylor: 7.5 - A real bastard.

    Grant: 7 - Great finish. Not a lot came off for him after but kept going at it.

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a

  • Referee: 5 - poor
    Phillips: 6.5 - confident and solid
    Dijksteel: 4- control was poor today
    Bauer: 7 - good, although perhaps could have done a little more for the goal
    Sarr: 7.5 - did very well, as good a game as he has played, other than couple of weak headers in 2nd half
    Stevenson: 7- very impressed. Good prospect
    Bielik: 8 - excellent although tired 2nd half
    Morgan: 6.5 - good game, couple of excellent passes, but bit in and out
    Reeves: 6.5 - in and out
    Fosu-Henry: 7 - so tricky with the ball. Can be frustrating but can be match winner.
    Taylor: 7 - constant irritant to the Walsall defence (and referee)
    Grant: 7 - must also be nightmare to play against.
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 6
    Bauer: 7
    Sarr: 8
    Stevenson: 7
    Bielik: 8
    Morgan: 7.5
    Reeves: 7
    Fosu-Henry: 6
    Taylor: 7.5
    Grant: 7.5
  • Phillips: 7
    Dijksteel: 5
    Bauer: 7
    Sarr 8
    Stevenson: 6.5
    Bielik: 6
    Morgan: 6.5
    Reeves: 7
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5
    Taylor: 7.5
    Grant: 7.5
  • Referee: 5. Poorest ref for a while
    Phillips: 7.5 Some good saves and kicking was good
    Dijksteel: 5 Isn’t a right back. Solly in for Sunderland hopefully
    Bauer: 7 steady game was hecat fault for their goal?
    Sarr: 9 MoM Outatandind display and amazing goal line stop. Always gives his all. You can’t help liking him for the way he has kept going
    Stevenson: 6.5 impressive crossing, steady game but lacks a bit of pace when winger goes outside him
    Bielik: 7.5 breaks up play well, creative and puts his foot in. He is not the type of loan player who goes through the motions
    Morgan: 6.5 Very good first half with a lovely range of passing. A bit lightweight when we need to win the ball back but will be good player next season if we nurture him
    Reeves: 6.5 brilliant first half but poor second half due to injury
    Fosu-Henry: 7 Same aa ever inconsistent but we need him to win us the big game against Sunderland
    Taylor: 8 he was everywhere and puts in so much effort he inspires the team
    Grant: 8 good goal and ran his heart out

    Pratley: Could have come on earlier for Reeves or Morgan to break up play
    Marshall: really puts himself out even if it’s just a 5 min cameo. I like him
  • Sponsored links:


  • Referee: bottled it - should have sent two off and what was up with Taylor’s second half header from corner
    Phillips: 7 played well

    Dijksteel: 4 awful seen liners turn quicker - good athlete but woeful defender

    Bauer: 7 solid
    Sarr 8 played well
    Stevenson: 6.5 done good
    Bielik: 7 works hard
    Morgan: 7 some superb long balls and worked hard

    Reeves: 6 - went missing second half

    Fosu-Henry: 6.5 has it all needs to get head up and pass more

    Taylor: 8 superb and gives all


    Grant: 7.5 different player this year

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • Referee: 6 extra point for giving the pen.

    Phillips:7 good composed display
    Dijksteel: 5.5 wobbly and erratic.
    Bauer: 7.5 new players around him. Good.
    Sarr: 8 naby was immense today.
    Stevenson: 7 solid performance.
    Bielik: 7 got stuck in
    Morgan: 7.5 shows promise, good assist.
    Reeves: 7 did ok
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5 the X factor player who doesn't always deliver.
    Taylor: 8 proper striker.
    Grant: 8 proper striker.
  • Referee: 5
    Phillips: 7.5
    Dijksteel: 5.5
    Bauer: 6.5
    Sarr : 8
    Stevenson: 6.5
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Reeves: 6.5
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5
    Taylor: 7
    Grant: 8

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • edited January 1
    Referee: 5 inconsistent and scared to give us anything after the pen. Didn't give yellows where warranted to avoid a red and gave a free kick every time either keeper flapped at a ball. Nothing wrong with Taylor's disallowed goal where he just got in front of the keeper.

    Phillips: 7 - couple of good saves, didn't look too challenged. Distribution needs work.
    Dijksteel: 7 looked solid, struggled towards the end when Morgan was flat out on his legs and couldn't keep up. Lost his runner a couple of times.
    Bauer: 8 - commanding.
    Sarr: 7.5 - solid, but less commanding at times. Did well with ball at his feet.
    Stevenson: 7.5 - impressive, bigger than I realised. Worked well with Sarr and Reeves.
    Bielik: 8 - very solid and didn't shirk once. Tired towards the end. Great first touch and a clever player.
    Morgan: 7 - looked good but was shattered after 65 minutes and it showed (he was literally punching his calves in the second half as they were seizing up). Panicked at times towards the end when he didn't have the legs to keep up.
    Reeves: 8 - coordinated everything. A little bit fickle at times flicking the ball across the pitch but had Walsall chasing shadows in the first half. Second half dug deep and was intercepting the ball defensively really well.
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5 - disappointing overall. Always a threat but farted around so much and didn't get his head up and look for a pass after the brilliant assist at the start. Should have played Taylor in for a 1v1 but chose to try to beat his man again unnecessarily. Tried too hard to score himself.
    Taylor: 8.5 - excellent. A handful all the time, worked so hard and led brilliantly from the front. Perfectly good goal disallowed.
    Grant: 8 - really good performance, good goal and worked hard. Really looked like a senior pro out there and worked well with Stevenson on the left.

    Pratley: n/a good presence when came on.
    Marshall: n/a ran for the time he was on and helped us move out from being camped in our own box towards the end.

    Bowyer - was slow to make changes and Walsall stole a march with the subs that we failed to match, which almost cost us 2 points. He's clearly worried about injuries and rightly so, but Morgan couldn't run and Dijksteel was being overrun on the right as a result.
  • Referee: 5 he was annoying a lot!

    Phillips: 7.5 Hard to criticise him
    Dijksteel: 7 caught out on occasion but good recovery
    Bauer: 7 Solid German
    Sarr: 8.5 MoM goal line clearance was vital to the result, played real well
    Stevenson: 6.5 Caught out a couple of times but supported well
    Bielik: 7.5 impressive first half, class player, liked a foul though!
    Morgan: 7 Struggled second half good performance
    Reeves: 6.5 great first half, bullied second half
    Fosu-Henry: 7 great couple of through balls, please take the easier options Henry!
    Taylor: 8 Great leader of the line and the team
    Grant: 8 good pace and worked hard

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
  • Referee: 5 only decent thing was giving the penalty

    Phillips: 7 done very well today
    Dijksteel: 5.5 probably worst I’ve seen him, lad needs a rest
    Bauer: 7 considering he was captain, he dealt with it well
    Sarr: 7.5 loved him today, classy Naby
    Stevenson: 7 didn’t look out of place, some great passes too
    Bielik: 8 really developing into a very good young player
    Morgan: 7 in possession was very good, invisible without in the second half
    Reeves: 7 better side with him in it, hopefully he’s okay as he will be missed
    Fosu-Henry: 7 if he could play one, two, three touch max, he’d be wanted by Premier League sides, otherwise class
    Taylor: 7.5 worked hard, scored and the disallowed goal should’ve stood
    Grant: 7.5 first half was excellent, it’s great to have him scoring and able to help out wide too

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a thought he was going to score at least twice at the end, should’ve come on sooner
  • Referee: 7 Thought he did quite well apart from chalking off Taylor goal.

    Phillips: 7 Some regulation saves and one decent stop in the 1st half.

    Dijksteel: 6 put us in unnecessary danger on more then one occasion with his ball control but did OK against their best player.

    Bauer: 7 No fuss on the Paddy B bus.

    Steer: 10 Considering he was keeping goal for Villa aswell should be a 10. Sarr though, gets 8.5 for the header off the line, some decent Tekkers and being generally on another level for 99% of that game.

    Stevenson: 6 Looked a bit shaky but grew into the game and was better in the second half.

    Bielik: 7 Ran his body into the ground and when Bowyer said he was hanging by a thread towards the end you could forgive him for the lack of quality at the fag end of the second half.

    Morgan: 6 Got a bit lost during periods when Walsall pressed us in the second but pulled off some lovely passes and got better positionally as the game went on.

    Reeves: 7 Lovely dead ball stuff. Faded in second half probably due to the injury he picked up.

    Fosu-Henry: 7.5 A handful for their defenders, was alive to the bad ball for the first goal setting up Grant with a pin point pass to put him in. Just suffers from Ricky Holmes syndrome sometimes with giving the ball at the right time when doing all the hard work to get in a great position.

    Taylor: 8 Well taken Pen. Some silky skill to get us going, got a bit cocky at one point slowing the game down and going back when going forward seemed the better option. Should have had 2 goals to his name and got in some great positions in the box.

    Grant: 8 Lovely finish for the first goal and looked dangerous every time he ran at their defence. Did not stop running. Stop taking the free kicks though please.
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 6.5
    Dijksteel: 6
    Bauer: 7
    Sarr 8
    Stevenson: 7
    Bielik: 7
    Morgan: 6.5
    Reeves: 6.5
    Fosu-Henry: 6.5
    Taylor: 7
    Grant: 7


  • Referee: 5
    Phillips: 6.5
    Dijksteel: 5.5
    Bauer: 7
    Steer: 0 Sarr 8
    Stevenson: 7.5
    Bielik: 5.5
    Morgan: 7.5
    Reeves: 5.5
    Fosu-Henry: 6
    Taylor: 7
    Grant: 7.5

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a




  • Referee: 6.5 bit whistle happy
    Phillips: 6.5 claimed some crosses well
    Dijksteel: 5.5 lacked confidence still
    Bauer: 7 solid
    Sarr: 7.5 what a save on the line. Saved the game for us
    Stevenson: 6 OK
    Bielik: 7.5 mom
    Morgan: 6.5 couple of great passes
    Reeves: 6.5 great first half, disappeared second
    Fosu-Henry: 7 good assist
    Taylor: 7 handful
    Grant: 7 same

    Pratley: n/a
    Marshall: n/a
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out!