Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Plymouth v Charlton - Player marks

If you were at Home Park, please give your scores out of ten below

Amos
Solly
Bauer
Pearce
Dasilva
Forster-Caskey
Kashi
Holmes
Clarke
Fosu
Magennis
Ahearne-Grant
Reeco n/a

Comments

  • Amos 5
    Solly 6
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 6.5
    Dasilva 5
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Kashi 5.5
    Holmes 6
    Clarke 7
    Fosu 4
    Magennis 3
    Ahearne-Grant 4
  • Amos 6
    Solly 5
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 7
    Dasilva 5
    Forster-Caskey 5
    Kashi 6
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 6
    Fosu 5.5
    Magennis 4.5
    Ahearne-Grant 6.5
    Reeco n/a 6.5

    I agree with most of what Beardface said above. No movement and little ability to beat a man which was a contrast to the Exeter game. They were huge and they made us play them at their game, which we unsurprisingly lost.

  • Amos 5. Not convinced. At mo I'm of the opinion Phillips is better.
    Solly 5. To many times he seems to give the winger to much time and space to get a cross in. Seems slow too. Been like this for a while now I'm afraid.
    Bauer 7. Strong and thought he did ok.
    Pearce 6.5. Average.
    Dasilva 6.5. Better first half. Worry his height could become an issue at set pieces.
    Forster-Caskey 6. Neat touches but didnt offer anything in attack or creative.
    Kashi 6. Probably expecting to much from him.
    Holmes 6. Busy first half, seemed to go missing a bit in second half which is not like him.
    Clarke 7.5. Best player. Linked well with midfield, always showed for ball. Cant understand his substitution.
    Fosu 6. Average, but wouldn't have replaced him with an untried youngster when we needed a goal.
    Magennis 5. Missed chances and looked lethargic. Needs to be fit to play as he's very average if he's not.
    Ahearne-Grant
    Reeco n/a
  • 6 to all of them. No one stood out and no one was that bad, just not good enough.

  • Amos 5.5
    Solly 5.5
    Bauer 5.5
    Pearce 5.5
    Dasilva 6
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Kashi 5.5
    Holmes 6.5
    Clarke 6.5
    Fosu 6
    Magennis 5
    Ahearne-Grant 5.5
    Reeco n/a


  • Amos 5 couple of decent saves in the 1st half but kicking poor, almost knocked Bauer out and I think he could've done better for their second. So far, I think Phillips is the better keeper.
    Solly 5 seemed off the pace. Slow and gave their wingers too much space.
    Bauer 6 solid for most of the game.
    Pearce 6 same as Bauer. Difficult game as the majority of the Plymouth squad were bigger than him and Bauer.
    Dasilva 6.5 targeted for lack of height but done well. Could work on his delivery into the box. Struggled with long diagonals.
    Forster-Caskey 6.5 looked to get things moving forward.
    Kashi 5.5 very sidewards and backwards today - I think that was down to the Plymouth defence getting tight to the 4 up front.
    Holmes 6.5 decent game but they dealt with him well
    Clarke 6 Tidy player. Will do a lot of unoticed work this season.
    Fosu 5 compared to last week he was very quiet. The Plymouth players stood off him just enough to ensure he couldn't turn them easily. They also doubled up on him.
    Magennis 4.5 the low mark isn't a dig at big Josh, but he's clearly not ready and looked overweight. For a big man he doesn't get in the box enough. Should've scored first half. Twice.
    Ahearne-Grant 7 he came on, he injected pace and he scared them. He's had a long raged effort well saved and it was a breath of fresh air really as we looked scared to shoot from range!
    Reeco n/a was brought on for Fosu which I couldn't really understand other than to get on the end of long diagonals (but we didn't play any of them). The lack of movement from our front 4 was poor. KAG and RHF both struggled to change the game as nobody would move around them

    Great Western Railway - 0
  • If you were at Home Park, please give your scores out of ten below

    Amos 6
    Solly 6
    Bauer 6
    Pearce 6
    DaSilva 7
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Kashi 5
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 7
    Fosu 6
    Magennis 4
    Ahearne-Grant 6
    Reeco n/a

  • Amos 5 - I'm really not sure about him, looks shaky with crosses.
    Solly 6 - defended well enough, he doesn't have the movement of Dasilva though.
    Bauer 6 - didn't really notice him apart from winning a few headers.
    Pearce 6 - same as Bauer.
    Dasilva 7 - he's class, so calm on the ball even when under heavy pressure, glides past opposition forwards and wingers.
    Kashi 5 - the game seemed to pass him by, he didn't win many tackles or stamp his authority.
    Holmes 7 - typical Holmes performance, he drives us forward and really loses the ball.
    Clarke 6.5 - passed it around fairly nicely, an underrated player.
    Fosu 6 - not as a good as last week but pulled some the attention away from Holmes and worried the opposition defence at times.
    Magennis 4.5 - if he'd finished his chances the result would've been very different.
    Ahearne-Grant 6 - He looked pretty lively.

    We really need another forward and keeper. Generally the team is better than last year, finish the squad and I can see us getting the playoffs. Holmes, Clarke & Fosu, (with Reeves & Marshall to come back) will scare opposition defences at this level.
  • Amos 5
    Solly 6
    Bauer 6
    Pearce 6
    Dasilva 6
    Kashi 5
    Holmes 6
    Clarke 6
    Fosu 5
    Magennis 5
    Ahearne-Grant 5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Amos 6
    Solly 5
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 6.5
    Dasilva 7.0
    Forster-Caskey
    Kashi 6.5
    Holmes 7.5
    Clarke 7
    Fosu 6.5
    Magennis 6
    Ahearne-Grant 6.5


  • Amos 6
    Solly 5
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 6.5
    Dasilva 6
    Forster-Caskey 6.5
    Kashi 5.5
    Holmes 6
    Clarke 7
    Fosu 6.5
    Magennis 5.5
    Ahearne-Grant 6.5


  • Amos 4
    Solly 5
    Bauer 6
    Pearce 6
    Dasilva 7
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Kashi 5.5
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 6
    Fosu 5
    Magennis 4.5
    Ahearne-Grant 7
    Reeco n/a


  • Amos - 6.5 Looks like he's still finding his feet
    Solly - 5.5 Given a torrid time on occasions
    Bauer - 7 Steady
    Pearce - 7 Steady
    DaSilva - 7 Thought he was very tidy.
    Forster-Caskey - 7 controlled performance
    Kashi - 7 Did nothing wrong but was often too deep
    Holmes - 8.5 He's our metronome
    Clarke - 7.5 Like this lad. Workhorse and has skill
    Fosu - 6.5 Often too deep
    Magennis - 6.5 Not sure why but didn't look on top form
    Ahearne-Grant - 6.5 Hardly likely to change the game
    Reeco n/a
  • Amos 7
    Solly 6
    Bauer 6
    Pearce 6
    Dasilva 6
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Kashi 6
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 7.5
    Fosu 6
    Magennis 6
    Ahearne-Grant 6
    Reeco n/a
  • edited August 13
    Amos - 7 Made a couple of good saves in the first half . I will judge him properly after a few more games . Wouldn't blame him for either goal .
    Solly - 5 Not sure that he is the player he once was . Teams like Plymouth will target him and DaSilva when playing together.
    Bauer - 7 Reasonable .
    Pearce - 7 Steady
    DaSilva - 6 Exciting going forward . The height is an issue as per Solly .
    Forster-Caskey - 7 Played well
    Kashi - 7 Defended well and kept possession . Maybe faded towards the end . Jackson could have come on ?
    Holmes - 7 Got into a couple of promising positions
    Clarke -7.5 Fast becoming my favourite player . I felt subbing him was the wrong decision although he is the one player to have played a part in all three fixtures this week .
    Fosu - 6 . Not as good as last week . A shame Marshall is not fit . I hope we do not put too much pressure on him .
    Magennis - 6.5 Looking unfit . Maybe should have been subbed .
    Ahearne-Grant - 6 . This is a big season for him
    Reeco N/A Good to see him feature . Hope over the course of the season he can make a contribution .
  • Amos 5
    Solly 6
    Bauer 6
    Pearce 6
    Dasilva 7
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Kashi 7
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 7.5
    Fosu 5
    Magennis 5
    Ahearne-Grant 6
    Reeco n/a
  • Amos 6
    Solly 6
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 6
    Dasilva 7
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Kashi 6
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 8 MOM
    Fosu 6
    Magennis 6
    Ahearne-Grant 6

    Reeco n/a
    Not sure giving a late League debut to a raw kid is the right thing to do when chasing the game.
    Not the lad's fault though.



  • edited August 14
    Amos - 5 Philips is more assured!
    Solly - 5 Both full backs did not offer much.
    Bauer - 7
    Pearce - 7
    Dasilva - 5
    Forster-Caskey - 5
    Kashi - 7.5 solid holding role
    Holmes - 7
    Clarke - 6
    Fosu - 5.5
    Magennis - 5 If fit and sharp could have had at least a couple!
    Ahearne-Grant - 7 The only player prepared to run at them!

    Overall doesnt matter whom we put out there if the manager aint got a clue! or plan B!. We were slow, pedestrian and to predictable at times! Gave them to much space second period! Should have stuck with the team that beat Exeter! :smiley:
  • Sponsored links:


  • Amos 5 why is he playing instead of philips and distribution is awful
    Solly 5.5
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 6.5
    Dasilva 6
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Kashi 6.5 not his usual self seemed a little off the pace
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 7 Mom don't know why he got subbed
    Fosu 6.5
    Magennis 6 wasn't fully fit dont know why he was playing
    Ahearne-Grant 6.5 bright and lively
    Reeco n/a
  • Amos 6
    Solly 6.5
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 6.5
    Dasilva 6.5
    Forster-Caskey - 7
    Kashi 7
    Holmes 6.5
    Clarke 7
    Fosu 6.5
    Magennis 6.5
    Ahearne-Grant 6
  • Amos - 5
    Solly - 5.5
    Bauer - 6
    Pearce - 6
    Dasilva - 7
    Forster-Caskey -6
    Kashi - 6
    Holmes - 6
    Clarke - 7
    Fosu - 6
    Magennis - 5
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Reeco n/a
  • Amos 5 why is he playing instead of philips and distribution is awful
    Solly 5.5
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 6.5
    Dasilva 6
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Kashi 6.5 not his usual self seemed a little off the pace
    Holmes 7
    Clarke 7 Mom don't know why he got subbed
    Fosu 6.5
    Magennis 6 wasn't fully fit dont know why he was playing
    Ahearne-Grant 6.5 bright and lively
    Reeco n/a

    Try not to comment on the scores thread, but I'm pretty sure Billy was hobbling as he went off...
  • Amos 5 - Just not convincing
    Solly 6 - Form has dipped this season
    Bauer 7 - Does what it says on the tin
    Pearce 7 - Ditto
    Dasilva 7.5 - Class
    Kashi 6.5 - Didn't get into top gear
    Holmes 7 - Not dominating but effective
    Clarke 7.5 - Like his temperament and directness
    Fosu 6.5 - Didn't get going
    Magennis 5 - Couldn't score, couldn't jump, so didn't challenge the no 5 who knocked down for the goal
    Ahearne-Grant 7 - Defenders can't live with him
Sign In or Register to comment.