Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton v Gillingham- Player Marks

If you were at the game today, please post some marks up. Poor old @lancashire lad has had to churn through some shite this season, so let him have some nice marks to deal with for a change !

Rudd
Byrne
Bauer
Pearce
DaSilva
Crofts
Konsa
Forster-Caskey
Botaka
Magennis
Holmes
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a
«1

Comments

  • Rudd 6.5 one bad spill led to a scramble, otherwise solid
    Byrne 6.5 good going forward, extremely dodgy defending, must have fouled his man 5 or 6 times
    Bauer 7.5 large performance from a large German
    Pearce 8 also large and also a goal
    DaSilva 8.5 MOM wonderful player
    Crofts 6 harried and hustled and showed his usual cloddish touch
    Konsa 6.5 did ok but not the player to knit moves together
    Forster-Caskey 7 better from him today
    Botaka 7.5 a nice and threatening display with plenty of effort
    Magennis 8 back (mostly) to the Magennis we grew to know before his injury
    Holmes 8 goal, assist and involvement in other goal, only gets an 8 because he made loads of bad decisions and duff crosses. Most things went through him though.
  • Rudd - 6.5
    Byrne - 6.5
    Bauer - 7
    Pearce - 7.5
    Da Silva - 7
    Cofts - 6
    Konsa - 6
    Forster-Caskey - 7
    Botaka - 6
    Maggenis - 7.5
    Holmes - 8

  • Rudd. 7 held on to it more. One sloppy throw out aside. Good game
    Byrne. 8. Very tidy. Carried the ball well
    Bauer. 6.5. Ok
    Pearce. 7. Ok. Extra 0.5 for goal
    DaSilva 8.5. Tenacious little beggar and no little amount of skill
    Crofts 6.5. Battled well
    Konsa. 5. Not at it today
    Forster-Caskey. 6
    Botaka 6
    Magennis 8 worked just socks off. So glad he scored
    Holmes 8. If only his delivery was better??
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a
  • Rudd ... 7 : Standard saves throughout was never REALLY troubled
    Byrne ... 7 : Good performance, would like to see us keep him in the Summer, great option to have
    Pearce ... 7.5 : Gets a slightly better mark for the goal yet made a mistake straight after which put McDonald through
    Bauer ... 7 : Didnt notice him too much but it was his tackle that saved Pearce's mistake (See above)
    Dasilva ... 9 (MOTM) : His performances of late raise a lot of Questions in regards to Robinson's Management skills
    Crofts ... 7 : Standard performance, went about his business as normal
    Konsa ... 6 : Where was he playing, he was all over the place... Robinson explain that one please?
    Forster-Caskey ... 6 : Didnt really notice him
    Botaka ... 6 : Shows glimpses of talent but he's far too laid back
    Magennis ... 8 : Did well today... Deserved his goal
    Holmes ... 8 : Took his goal well, got lucky with the Magennis goal as felt he held on to the ball for too long
  • Rudd 7.5 - calm and in control
    Byrne 6.5 - solid performance, has great pace but is sometimes so slow, I don't get it?
    Bauer 8 - some fantastic tackles
    Pearce 7 - decent
    DaSilva 9 - excellent
    Crofts 8 - solid with some great tackles
    Konsa 6 - weak at times
    Forster-Caskey 7.5 - much improved today, decent pressing and tackles
    Botaka 6 - alright
    Magennis 6 - not understanding eveyone else's praise. Very slow to attack after defending corners, Caskey and Holmes attacked much quicker with Magennis often left back with the defensive line, goal handed to him on a plate
    Holmes 9 - Fantastic control and pace, gifted Magennis that goal, although sometimes he loses the ball in silly situations
  • Rudd 7.5 - calm and in control
    Byrne 6.5 - solid performance, has great pace but is sometimes so slow, I don't get it?
    Bauer 8 - some fantastic tackles
    Pearce 7 - decent
    DaSilva 9 - excellent
    Crofts 8 - solid with some great tackles
    Konsa 6 - weak at times
    Forster-Caskey 7.5 - much improved today, decent pressing and tackles
    Botaka 6 - alright
    Magennis 6 - not understanding eveyone else's praise. Very slow to attack after defending corners, Caskey and Holmes attacked much quicker with Magennis often left back with the defensive line, goal handed to him on a plate
    Holmes 9 - Fantastic control and pace, gifted Magennis that goal, although sometimes he loses the ball in silly situations

    Botaka got the assist for the third didnt he?
  • edited April 17

    Rudd 7.5 - calm and in control
    Byrne 6.5 - solid performance, has great pace but is sometimes so slow, I don't get it?
    Bauer 8 - some fantastic tackles
    Pearce 7 - decent
    DaSilva 9 - excellent
    Crofts 8 - solid with some great tackles
    Konsa 6 - weak at times
    Forster-Caskey 7.5 - much improved today, decent pressing and tackles
    Botaka 6 - alright
    Magennis 6 - not understanding eveyone else's praise. Very slow to attack after defending corners, Caskey and Holmes attacked much quicker with Magennis often left back with the defensive line, goal handed to him on a plate
    Holmes 9 - Fantastic control and pace, gifted Magennis that goal, although sometimes he loses the ball in silly situations

    Botaka got the assist for the third didnt he?
    Holmes did all the work though, a tapped cross and tap-in goal aren't more impressive than Holme's build up surely
  • Rudd 7
    Byrne 6.5
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 7.5
    DaSilva 7.5
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 5.5
    Forster-Caskey 6
    Botaka 5.5
    Magennis 7
    Holmes 8
  • Rudd 7 Nearly gifted them a goal when he fumbled their free-kick
    Byrne 8 Impressive up and down the wing. Hope we can get him permanently
    Bauer 8.5 Made a great challenge to save Pearce's bacon
    Pearce 8 Good header for the goal, we look far more solid with him in the back four
    DaSilva 8.5 Really impressed was a sceptic when I first saw him, with that performance can see why he skippers England U19
    Crofts 7.5 Did well
    Konsa 7 Bit untidy at times
    Forster-Caskey 7 Similar to Konsa
    Botaka 7 Don't really see it with him. Leeds can keep him
    Magennis 8 Good performance
    Holmes 8.5 He's definitely going in the summer
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rudd 6.5
    Byrne 7.5
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 7
    DaSilva 7
    Crofts 6.5
    Konsa 5.5
    Forster-Caskey 5.5
    Botaka 5.5
    Magennis 7
    Holmes 7
  • Rudd 7
    Byrne 8
    Bauer 8
    Pearce 8
    DaSilva 9
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 6
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Botaka 7
    Magennis 8
    Holmes 9
  • Rudd 7.5 Steady, still think he could command his area better
    Byrne 8 His best game, would like to see him signed and given a chance
    Bauer 8 a couple of excellent challenges
    Pearce 8 Well taken goal, our best centre half
    DaSilva 8 like Byrne his best game for us
    Crofts 7 Not bad for crofts, but still looks out of place
    Konsa 7 Not his best game but OK
    Forster-Caskey 7 Struggling to like him
    Botaka 6.5 flatters to deceive
    Magennis 8 getting back to his earlier form
    Holmes 8.5 as ever, runs and runs and runs.
  • edited April 17
    Rudd - 7 One spill from a powerful free kick but hardly worked overall.
    Byrne - 7 Solid and made a couple of decent runs on the attack.
    Bauer - 7 Solid and a couple of quality tackles.
    Pearce - 8 Header for the first goal and clean sheet.
    DaSilva - 8 Very quick, close control and dangerous with the ball on the move.
    Crofts - 6 solid.
    Konsa - 6 Apart from the odd mistake was solid.
    Forster-Caskey 6.5 solid.
    Botaka - 6.5 Solid.
    Magennis - 7 Seems to be getting back to his best.
    Holmes - 8.5 Goal and 2 assists.
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a
  • Rudd - 6.5
    Byrne - 7.5
    Bauer - 7
    Pearce - 7.5
    Da Silva - 9
    Crofts - 6
    Konsa - 6
    Forster-Caskey - 7
    Botaka - 6
    Maggenis - 7.5
    Holmes - 8
  • Rudd 6.5
    Byrne 7.5
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 7
    DaSilva 8.5
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 6
    Forster-Caskey 6.5
    Botaka 5.5
    Magennis 7
    Holmes 8
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a
  • Rudd - 6 Today was the only time I've doubted Rudd. Spilled a save and almost made another mistake when he didn't give a shout to Bauer.
    Byrne - 6 Played well but you can see he's itching to play back in his normal position.
    Bauer - 6 started off by not winning the first ball per usual, but did well in the end.
    Pearce - 8 immense. What a player, so much better than Teixera at this level
    DaSilva - 7 very good little player
    Crofts - 6
    Konsa - 6
    Forster-Caskey - 6
    Botaka - 6
    Magennis - 7 hustled and bustled and so glad he got a goal
    Holmes - 7 great free kick, works hard but sometimes lacks that bit of quality and decision making.
    Ahearne-Grant 4 - he's lucky we were already 3-0 up as he was awful when he came on, wasted so many opportunities.
    Jackson n/a
  • Rudd - 7 clean sheet.
    Byrne - 7.5 good attacking runs.
    Bauer - 7
    Pearce - 7.5 looked comfortable good
    DaSilva - 8 Quality. Confidence totally different to first game against Milwall. Having watched that explains why he didn't play many games afterwards.
    Crofts - 7 good blocking shots
    Konsa - 6.5 slow but assured. Not suited to midfield.
    Forster-Caskey - 7
    Botaka - 6
    Magennis - 7.5 looked disinterested prior to goal. Ran his heart out afterwards. No sign of carrying an injury
    Holmes 8.5 Main player who didn't stop running. Great free kick but final delivery at times poor.
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a
  • Rudd 6
    Byrne 7.5
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 7
    DaSilva 8
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 5.5
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Botaka 7
    Magennis 7
    Holmes7.5
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a
  • Rudd 7
    Byrne 7
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 7.5
    DaSilva 8
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 6
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Botaka 6
    Magennis 7.5
    Holmes7.5
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rudd 7
    Byrne 7.5
    Bauer 7
    Pearce 7.5
    DaSilva 8.5
    Crofts 7.5
    Konsa 5
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Botaka 5
    Magennis 6.5
    Holmes 7.5
  • Rudd 6.5
    Byrne 6
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 7.5
    Dasilva 8 mom
    Crofts 6.5
    Konsa 6
    Forrester-caskey 7
    Botaka 6.5
    Magennis 7
    Holmes 8
  • edited April 17
    Rudd 6.5
    Byrne 6
    Bauer 8
    Pearce 8
    DaSilva 8
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 5.5 not a midfielder
    Forster-Caskey 7
    Botaka 7
    Magennis 7.5
    Holmes 7.5

    So much better overall. We looked like a team again.
  • If you were at the game today, please post some marks up. Poor old @lancashire lad has had to churn through some shite this season, so let him have some nice marks to deal with for a change !

    Rudd................7
    Byrne................7
    Bauer................8
    Pearce...............8
    DaSilva..............9
    Crofts................6
    Konsa.................6
    Forster-Caskey....6
    Botaka..................5
    Magennis ............7
    Holmes.................8.5
    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Jackson n/a

  • Rudd 7
    Byrne 7 Increasingly like the look of him
    Bauer 6
    Pearce 7.5 Leader!
    DaSilva 8 Great on the ball and a decent defender
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 6 Out of position
    Forster-Caskey 6.5 Better
    Botaka 7 (one for the assist)
    Magennis 6.5
    Holmes 7 Some poor crosses by his standards
    Ahearne-Grant n/a (looked lively)
    Jackson n/a
  • edited April 17
    Rudd 6 Phillips should play last 2 games now
    Byrne 7 decent going forwards, quick enough to cover ground, had no support second half
    Bauer 7 solid, couple of crunching tackles and commanding headers
    Pearce 7.5 extra mark for goal, also solid
    DaSilva 7.5 great little player
    Crofts 6.5 still jittery in possession
    Konsa 6.5 gets forward more, plays simple balls well but can be too ambitious and hesitant on ball
    Forster-Caskey 7 actually tried to make things happen, confidence player
    Botaka 6 needs to shoot more, tired in second half
    Magennis 7 won a lot of headers and took his goal well
    Holmes 7.5 great free kick, lingers on the ball, but still gets something out of it
    Ahearne-Grant n/a got about a lot, has pace to burn
    Jackson n/a calm head late on
  • Rudd - 6.5
    Byrne - 6.5
    Bauer - 7
    Pearce - 7.5
    DaSilva - 8
    Crofts - 6.5
    Konsa - 6
    Forster-Caskey - 7
    Botaka - 6.5
    Magennis - 7
    Holmes - 7.5
  • Rudd 6.5
    Byrne 7
    Bauer 6.5
    Pearce 7.5
    Da Silva 8
    Crofts 7
    Konsa 6 anonymous.
    Forster Caskey 6.5
    Botaka 6.5
    Magennis 7
    Holmes 8
  • Rudd - 6: spilled one shot and wasn't as commanding as usual on crosses
    Byrne - 7: did well
    Bauer - 7: the best I've seen him play for a while
    Pearce - 7.5: one slip in the first half that could have proved costly but generally very solid. A natural leader
    DaSilva - 8.5: MoM - looks a real player
    Crofts - 6.5: did a decent job in the holding role, winning the ball back and getting in some important blocks
    Konsa - 5: he looked crestfallen today. In mitigation, he's playing out of position and it's been a tough debut season
    Forster-Caskey - 6.5: a tidy performance
    Botaka - 5.5: a nice assist for Magennis' goal and a good cross to JFK in the second half but, otherwise, contributed little
    Magennis - 6.5: better than of late and looked fired up after his goal
    Holmes - 7.5: not everything came off but he is almost inevitably at the centre of anything we create
Sign In or Register to comment.