Players Marks: Charlton v Southampton ( closes Sunday lunchtime)

KAMINSKI:4

RAMSAY:4

JONES:5

GILLESPHEY:4

APTER: 3

CAREY:4

COVENTRY:4

DOCHERTY:4

HERNÁNDEZ:4 - doesn't offer much

CAMPBELL:3

LEABURN:4

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO:3- wasn't bad as people said he was but still poor

ANDERSON: Stabled a sinking ship

OLAOFE: No effect going forward

BERRY:  Stabled a sinking ship

KNIBBS: Diving about the place

N.JONES: Very Poor

lancashire lad said:

marks 0.5 to 10.0 if you please:

KAMINSKI: 7

RAMSAY: 5

JONES: 5

GILLESPHEY: 3

APTER: n/a

CAREY: 4

COVENTRY: 4

DOCHERTY: 3

HERNÁNDEZ: 4

CAMPBELL: 9 ( put up to this by some eejits giving him 2)

LEABURN: 6

Referee: 1

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4

ANDERSON: n/a

OLAOFE: n/a

BERRY: n/a

KNIBBS: n/a

• 

  sam3110 Posts: 21,460

  November 22

  KAMINSKI: 6 not much he could do, amazingly, for all the goals

  
  

  RAMSAY: 3 out of his depth today

  
  

  JONES: 4.5 best of a bad defending unit, very faint praise though as Armstrong properly done him

  
  

  GILLESPHEY: 2.5 not half a yard off pace, but about 10 yards off pace

  
  

  APTER: n/a scapegoated

  
  

  CAREY: 2 absolutely useless today, didn't put a foot right

  
  

  COVENTRY: 3.5 dreadful positioning midfield, again a lack of pace really shown up

  
  

  DOCHERTY: 3 ponderous on and off the ball, wasn't a leader today

  
  

  HERNÁNDEZ: 3.5 looks unfit and didn't track his man multiple times

  
  

  CAMPBELL: 5 didn't have much to feed on, tried hard I guess

  
  

  LEABURN: 5 held it up pretty well but no support from anyone other than TC on rare occasions 

  
  

  Referee: 1 can't believe the amount of cards we got and the amount of wrong decisions on goal kicks etc. Summed up by then getting in the way of Careys shot at a free kick and just shrugging

  
  

  Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3 pointless sub, very one paced and didn't make us better in defence anyway

  
  

  ANDERSON: n/a

  
  

  OLAOFE: n/a

  
  

  BERRY: n/a

  
  

  KNIBBS: n/a

  Quote4LikeLOL
• 

  RedChaser Posts: 19,892

  November 22 edited November 22

  KAMINSKI: 5

  RAMSAY: 3.5

  JONES: 5.5 extra point for the goal

  GILLESPHEY: 4

  APTER: n/a

  CAREY: 4

  COVENTRY: 4

  DOCHERTY: 3

  HERNÁNDEZ: 3.5

  CAMPBELL: 4.5

  LEABURN: 6

  Referee: 4

  Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4

  
  

KAMINSKI: 7.5 Couldn't have done anything more about the goals. Still made some good stops and distribution was decent. 

RAMSAY: 5.5 Below par for him.

JONES: 7 Still managed a battling performance and got his deserved goal.

GILLESPHEY: 5 Lack of pace showed and passing was also off. Had very little support though.

APTER: n/a There were plenty of  others as ineffective as him.

CAREY: 5.5 Ineffective. Struggled to get on the ball.

COVENTRY: 5.5 Never got to grips with the midfield but never stops trying. Poor game by his standards.

DOCHERTY: 5 Same as Coventry but worse.

HERNÁNDEZ: 4.5 Really don't get what he adds. Ineffective.

CAMPBELL: 6 Needs to up his work rate but still a threat.

LEABURN: 6 Felt sorry for him. Battled hard on the crumbs he had.

Referee: 5 Didn't have much to do but still didn't do it well. Gave way too many yellow cards against us.

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4.5 Was he really an improvement on Apter? Constant gave the ball away and was ineffective.

ANDERSON: n/a

OLAOFE: n/a

BERRY: n/a

KNIBBS: n/a

KAMINSKI: 5.5

RAMSAY: 3.5

JONES: 4.5

GILLESPHEY: 3.5

APTER: n/a

CAREY: 5

COVENTRY: 4.5

DOCHERTY: 4

HERNÁNDEZ: 3.5

CAMPBELL: 5

LEABURN: 6 tried specially 2nd half

Referee: 2 he didn't need to be biased as the game was already won but he was. 

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3.5

ANDERSON: n/a

OLAOFE: n/a

BERRY: n/a

KNIBBS: n/a

KAMINSKI: 5

RAMSAY: 5

JONES: 6

GILLESPHEY: 4

APTER: n/a

CAREY: 5

COVENTRY: 5

DOCHERTY 4

HERNÁNDEZ: 4

CAMPBELL: 6

LEABURN: 5

Referee: 4

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

KAMINSKI: 6

RAMSAY: 4

JONES: 5.5

GILLESPHEY: 4

APTER: n/a

CAREY: 5

COVENTRY:5

DOCHERTY:5

HERNÁNDEZ: 5

CAMPBELL: 5

LEABURN: 6

Referee: 4

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6

Leuth said:

KAMINSKI: 6.5 made one incredible early save then could do nothing

RAMSAY: 4 not his best

JONES: 5.5 or his

GILLESPHEY: 3.5 or his 

APTER: n/a lucky boy 

CAREY: 4 or his 

COVENTRY: 6.5 or his but he steamed about like it mattered 

DOCHERTY: 4.5 thoroughly outclassed

HERNÁNDEZ: 5 kept going even though him not being a defender cost us 

CAMPBELL: 7 really kept going 

LEABURN: 6.5 decent shift yes 

Referee: 5 inconsistent 

Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5 hmm, he's not really it is he 

ANDERSON: n/a

OLAOFE: n/a

BERRY: n/a

KNIBBS: n/a