Players Marks: Charlton v Southampton ( closes Sunday lunchtime)
Comments
-
Nathan Jones - Apter and Hernandez as wing back was a disastrous decision.
marks 0.5 to 10.0 if you please:
KAMINSKI:6 - Made a couple of good saves - no chance with goals
RAMSAY:4.5
JONES:5.5 - got a goal
GILLESPHEY:3 - out of position and pace cruelly exposed, with little protection ahead of him
APTER: n/a - not good in wing back position
CAREY: - 5 not so good
COVENTRY:5 - Southampton midfield ran rings around him and Docherty
DOCHERTY:4.5
HERNÁNDEZ:4 - better at right back than wing half weirdly enough
CAMPBELL:5.5 - tried
LEABURN:6 - kept on battling
Referee: 4 Gave Charlton nothing 2nd half apart from a big pile of yellow cards
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO:4 - got worse as half progressed, not seeing what Blackburn fans saw in him.
ANDERSON: n/a - did his best to inject some energy
OLAOFE: n/a - on late
BERRY: n/a - on late
KNIBBS: n/a - on late
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6.5
RAMSAY: 5.5 damage done in first half
JONES: 5.5. Ditto
GILLESPHEY: 5. Ditto
APTER: ineffective
CAREY: 5. Ditto
COVENTRY: 5.5. Ditto
DOCHERTY: 4.5. Ditto
HERNÁNDEZ: 5. Ditto
CAMPBELL: 7. Worked so hard
LEABURN: 6.5. Held the ball up well
Referee: 4
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 3
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 3
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 3
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 4
CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5
Referee: 2
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 3
JONES: 4.5
GILLESPHEY: 4
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 4
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 2
HERNÁNDEZ: 3
CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 4
Referee:
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 2
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6 not all his fault
RANSEY : 6 as above
JONES: 7 as above
GILLESPHEY: 5 horribly exposed by Hernandez having no idea how to plsy LWB
APTER: n/a surprise he was subbed not Hermandez
CAREY: 4 AWOL
COVENTRY: 5 worked hard to cover the gaping holes in midfield out numbered 5 to 2
DOCHERTY: 5 as above
HERNÁNDEZ: 2 joke footballer better on the right but should be suplud to requirements come January
CAMPBELL: 5 Ran more than any one else no end product
LEABURN: 4 actually tired to hold the ball up but lousy touch
Referee: 2 stinker but not the reason we got beat
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO 5
0 -
KAMINSKI:6
RAMSAY: 3 - Poor first half
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY:2 - outclassed throughout
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 3
COVENTRY: 3
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 3
CAMPBELL: 2
LEABURN: 4
Referee: 4 - Once it became clear he would punish tackles from behind why did we keep making them?
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
0 -
.0
-
KAMINSKI: 7 Done nothing wrong - some good saves
RAMSAY: 4 Tried hard but outclassed today
JONES: 6 Played too deep today playing their runners onside. +1 for his goal & could have won a pen when taken out by their keeper
GILLESPHEY: 2 Looked a poor league 1 defender today
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 2 Nothing came off for him today
COVENTRY: 4 Worked hard but his lack of pace left him exposed today
DOCHERTY: 0.5 So slow in everything he does
HERNÁNDEZ: 5 Done Ok especially when moved to right back
CAMPBELL: 4 Done well last 20 minutes but doesnt play like he has a football brain
LEABURN: 6.5 Put a shift in and won his hea
Referee: 2 Thought he was ok first half but was effing awful second half where he gave everything to them
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3.5 Man marked ok but done nothing with the ball
0 -
marks 0.5 to 10.0 if you please:
KAMINSKI: 5
RAMSAY: 4
JONES: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 4
APTER: 3.5
CAREY: 4
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 4
HERNÁNDEZ: 4
CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 5
Referee: 4
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4.5
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI:7
RAMSAY:4
JONES:4
GILLESPHEY: 3
APTER: n/a
CAREY:4
COVENTRY:4
DOCHERTY:4
HERNÁNDEZ:4
CAMPBELL:3
LEABURN:6
Referee:2
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO:3.5
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 4
JONES: 4.5
GILLESPHEY: 3
APTER: N/A
CAREY: 3
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 3.5
CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 5.5
Referee: 3
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6.5
RAMSAY: 4
JONES: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 4
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 4
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 2
HERNÁNDEZ: 4
CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 5.5
Referee: 2
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3.50 -
KAMINSKI: 5
RAMSAY: 3
JONES: 4
GILLESPHEY: 2
APTER: n/a
CAREY:3
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 2
CAMPBELL: 3
LEABURN: 5
Referee: 3
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
0 -
KAMINSKI: 5
RAMSAY: 3
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 3
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 3
COVENTRY: 3
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 3
CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 4
Referee:
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6RAMSAY: 4JONES: 5GILLESPHEY: 3APTER: 3CAREY: 5COVENTRY: 3DOCHERTY: 3HERNÁNDEZ: 3CAMPBELL: 4LEABURN: 4Referee: 3Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO:
😎
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 3
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 2
APTER: n/a
CAREY:3
COVENTRY: 3
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 2
CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5
Referee: 3
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 2
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 2
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 5
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 2
CAMPBELL: 3
LEABURN: 5
Referee: 2.5
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
0 -
KAMINSKI: 5
RAMSAY: 2
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 2
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 4
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 2
CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 4
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO:
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
RAMSAY: 5
JONES: 4.5
GILLESPHEY: 3
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 4
HERNÁNDEZ: 3.5
CAMPBELL: 6
LEABURN: 7
Referee: 3
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4
0 -
At the game
KAMINSKI:7
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 6
APTER: n/a
CAREY:5
COVENTRY:5
DOCHERTY:5
HERNÁNDEZ: 5
CAMPBELL: 5.5
LEABURN: 5
Referee: 5
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 5 does not seem the same player since his Millwall sending off and subsequent dropping by NJ which is a shame
JONES: 5 looked injured by the end (probably should have come off) and Southampton forwards had plenty of clever movement to keep him busy
GILLESPHEY: 5 struggled with the pace of the forwards
APTER: n/a scapegoat
CAREY: 5 was unable to track back and help out the midfield duo
COVENTRY: 5 lacked the athleticism of Saints players
DOCHERTY: 5 lacked the athleticism of Saints players
HERNÁNDEZ: 5 not a full back when needed to put in a defensive shift
CAMPBELL: 5 lacks end product and never looked like scoring
LEABURN: 6 thankless task
Referee: 5
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5 can see why not been selected before
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
At the game till the bitter end
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 6
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 5.5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 5
HERNÁNDEZ: 5
CAMPBELL: 5.5
LEABURN: 5.5
Referee:
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
0 -
Quick reminder, comments about other people's marks etc needs to go on the postmatch thread not here.@JamesSeed Apter wasn't on long enough to earn a a mark, and you need to mark JRC@msomerton you need to mark JRC too.1
-
KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 6.5
JONES: 7 (includes 1 for goal)
GILLESPHEY: 4
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 4
COVENTRY: 4
DOCHERTY: 4
HERNÁNDEZ: 3
CAMPBELL: 7.5
LEABURN: 7
Referee: 6
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
1 -
marks 0.5 to 10.0 if you please:
KAMINSKI: 6.5
RAMSAY: 4
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 3
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 3
COVENTRY: 4.5
DOCHERTY: 3
HERNÁNDEZ: 2.5
CAMPBELL: 5.5
LEABURN: 4
Referee: 3
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 3
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 5
JONES: 5 not a typical performance
GILLESPHEY: 4
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 5
HERNÁNDEZ: 4
CAMPBELL: 5 should have been subbed
LEABURN: 4 should have been subbed earlier
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7, What went on it front of you was not your fault
RAMSAY: 5, Hopelessly exposed by the wing back ( Apter) in front of him
JONES:5, The domination of Saints made Lloyd look leaden footed.
GILLESPHEY: 5, Once again, his wing back went missing.
APTER: n/a
CAREY:5, Not at his best
COVENTRY:5, As above
DOCHERTY:5, And again
HERNÁNDEZ: 4, January and you are gone.
CAMPBELL:5, You weren't in it
LEABURN:5, Yes you tried but for what end.
Referee:6,
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
ANDERSON: n/a
OLAOFE: n/a
BERRY: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7 (kept the score down, and good handling of the greasy ball)RAMSAY: 4.5
JONES: 5.5 (+1 for the goal)GILLESPHEY: 4APTER: n/aCAREY: 4.5COVENTRY: 4.5DOCHERTY: 4HERNÁNDEZ: 4.5 (better in the second half on the right)CAMPBELL: 5LEABURN: 6Referee: 5Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 4.50 -
KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 5
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 5
APTER: n/a
CAREY: 5
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 5
HERNÁNDEZ: 5.5
CAMPBELL: 6
LEABURN: 6
Referee: 4
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
0 -
marks 0.5 to 10.0 if you please:
KAMINSKI: 6 - Made some saves to stop it being worse. Poor kicking.
RAMSAY: 4 - didn't attack the header for their first goal and generally out of position.
JONES: 5 - Made some absolutely lunatic decisions to charge upfield that let them play in behind us. Did score which we got to celebrate ironically
GILLESPHEY:4 - Dominant in the air on the rare occasion they crossed but torn apart on the ground, not just slow but easily bamboozled
APTER: n/a 4 - Might feel it was harsh to get subbed but he showed Scienza inside so many times without putting in a challenge that it couldn't go on.
CAREY: 4 - Terrible in the press and poor on the ball. His worst performance for us
COVENTRY: 5 - Did some things well on the ball but mostly shredded
DOCHERTY: 4 - Left trailing in every player's wake. Terrible
HERNÁNDEZ: 3.5 - Show his positioning for the first goal to a court and no jury would convict you. Did put some nasty challenges in second half which was at least funny.
CAMPBELL: 5 - Got physical a few times but couldn't offer much
LEABURN:6 POTM - Won his physical battles and made Collins look quite poor but didn't do much else
Referee: 4 - Pernickety little fool. Could have given us two penalties for fouls on Leaburn and Jones and got some really obvious corner/throw decisions wrong. Then it felt like as punishment for the crowd turning on him he started booking our players for barely anything.
Subs: RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5 - Started well and really helped stem the total domination of their running. Got loose as the game went on and started giving it away but was always trying to force something between the lines. Should have started.
ANDERSON: n/a - There was a point where he beat his man and instead of putting a cross in tried to beat him again while still being Karoy Anderson. Mystifying
OLAOFE: n/a - Had feet for shins and shins for feet today. Miscontrolled everything and fell out with Jones. Embarrassing
BERRY: n/a - Actually ran at people and made them hurry. Wish we'd had 10 of him
KNIBBS: n/a - Wanted too long on the ball but tried a bit
2
