Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Sheffield United v Charlton Athletic (closed Sunday teatime)

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,626
in General Charlton
marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

KAMINSKI: 
BURKE: 
JONES: 
BELL: 
BREE: 
CAREY: 
COVENTRY: 
DOCHERTY: 
EDWARDS: 
KELMAN: 
CAMPBELL: 
Referee: 
          Subs: LEABURN: 
                   OLAOFE:n/a
                   KNIBBS: n/a
«13

Comments

  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,738
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7.5
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 6
    CAREY: 6.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 9 MOM
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 
              Subs: LEABURN: 7

  • Leuth
    Leuth Posts: 23,315
    KAMINSKI: 7 assured 
    BURKE: 8 he's really good 
    JONES: 7.5 could have scored 
    BELL: 8 played right on the edge after booking, played well
    ZINEDINE BREEDANE: 9 sign. him. up. 
    CAREY: 5.5 ran around 
    COVENTRY: 7.5 really good as usual 
    DOCHERTY: 7.5 he's a better player at this level than League One for some reason 
    EDWARDS: 8.5 saved our arse
    KELMAN: 6 it'll come 
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 some dynamic play 
    Referee: 6 improved 
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5 did very well really 
  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 51,344
    edited September 20
    KAMINSKI: 7 Decent 
    BURKE: 6.5 Okay
    JONES: 7 Decent
    BELL: 7 Decent 
    BREE: 7 extra 0.5 for the assist. 
    CAREY: 6 okay
    COVENTRY: 6 okay
    DOCHERTY: 7.5 calm and played well. 
    EDWARDS: 7.5 as above.
    KELMAN: 5.5 Not his fault zero confidence and less service.
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 at times had Godfrey on toast. 
    Referee: 3 Poor for both sides

              Subs:
    LEABURN: 5.5 Big and Lazy. One decent shot. Refused to pass at least three times. 
    OLAOFE:n/a
    KNIBBS: n/a
  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 626
    edited September 20
    KAMINSKI: 8
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 9
    CAREY: 6
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 7
              Subs: LEABURN 7
  • DoctorCharlton
    DoctorCharlton Posts: 2,463
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 6.5
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 7.5
    BREE: 7.5
    CAREY: 6
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 7.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 3
              Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
  • Addictedoldgit
    Addictedoldgit Posts: 1,826


    KAMINSKI:  6 still not sure
    BURKE:         7.5
    JONES:         7.5
    BELL:             8
    BREE:            7
    CAREY:         6.5
    COVENTRY:  6.5
    DOCHERTY:  7
    EDWARDS:    7.5
    KELMAN:       5.5
    CAMPBELL:   7
    Referee:       6
              Subs: LEABURN:    6.5
                       OLAOFE:n/a
                       KNIBBS: n/a

  • Longtimeaddicted
    Longtimeaddicted Posts: 576
    KAMINSKI: 7 
    BURKE: 8
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 8.5
    BREE: 8 great to see a player pass the ball if only TC….
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 9
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 8

  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,318
    Kaminski: 7
    Burke: 8
    Jones: 8
    Bell: 7
    Bree: 7
    Carey: 6
    Coventry: 7
    Docherty: 8
    Edwards: 8
    Kelman: 6
    Campbell: 7

    Referee: 5

    Leaburn: 6
  • RonnieMoore
    RonnieMoore Posts: 4,496

    KAMINSKI: 9
    BURKE: 9
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 10 
    BREE: 9
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 9
    DOCHERTY: 9
    EDWARDS: 9
    KELMAN: 7 worked hard but what is he to do with no service 
    CAMPBELL: 6 no final ball how many times I lost count he had the chance to create something and nothing … got to be left out next week 
    Referee: 4 
              Subs: LEABURN: 6
                       OLAOFE: 7 as to start with Kelman 
                       KNIBBS: 6 
  • charente addick
    charente addick Posts: 3,808
    lancashire lad said:
    marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 7
    BREE: 7.5
    CAREY: 6.5
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5
                       OLAOFE:n/a
                       KNIBBS: n/a

  • Sponsored links:



  • CafcWest
    CafcWest Posts: 6,167
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8.5
    BREE: 8
    CAREY: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    Referee: 7
              Subs: LEABURN 7.5
  • Laddick01
    Laddick01 Posts: 6,365
    edited September 20
    KAMINSKI: 7 - solid. 
    BURKE: 8 - more than capable of filling in.
    JONES: 8 - I’d let him do bad things to me (I’m a straight man)
    BELL: 8- Signing of the summer so far
    BREE: 7 - some really rusty stuff combined with genuine quality. Touch for the goal was PL quality
    CAREY: 5.5 - very little from him today.
    COVENTRY: 7 - same as usual
    DOCHERTY: 7 - effort alone gets him there. Do I want to see him play all 46 games? probably not, but you can’t moan at the effort he puts in.
    EDWARDS: 8 - What a player 
    KELMAN: 6 - lovely ball back across that jones should’ve been alert for. Has a very tough job.
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 - was doing really well then faded
    Referee: 6.5 - not horrid , not great.
    Sub: LEABURN
  • Talal
    Talal Posts: 11,487
    edited September 20
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 6.5
    CAREY: 5.5
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 5.5
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 5
              Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
  • Karim_myBagheri
    Karim_myBagheri Posts: 12,716
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 7.5
    CAREY: 6
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 5
              Subs: LEABURN: 6
                       OLAOFE:n/a
                       KNIBBS: n/a
  • MattTeesHeader
    MattTeesHeader Posts: 622
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 7.5
    CAREY: 6
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 7
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5
  • DONVANVLIET
    DONVANVLIET Posts: 235
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 7
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 
              Subs: LEABURN: 7
                       OLAOFE:n/a
                       KNIBBS: n/a

  • Zulu
    Zulu Posts: 93
    KAMINSKI: 7 assured 
    BURKE: 8 he's really good 
    JONES: 7.5 quiet game - but thats good.
    BELL: 9 MOTM - was brilliant - so composed
    BREE: 7 played well. 
    CAREY: 6 fairly anonymous 
    COVENTRY: 8.0 good game 
    DOCHERTY: 8.5 great game
    EDWARDS: 8 so solid, you just might as well give him 8 for every game this season
    KELMAN: 6 hmmmm  - no service as usual.
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 poor with final ball as usual 
    Referee: 6  
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5  
  • Southbank
    Southbank Posts: 5,252
    KAMINSKI: 7 Did everything well
    BURKE: 8 Quality
    JONES: 8 
    BELL: 8.5 Super player
    BREE: 7.5 Looks like he will be good in that position
    CAREY: 6 Started well and faded
    COVENTRY: 7 Strady
    DOCHERTY: 8 someone said he looks better in the Champ, they are right
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6 Presses well
    CAMPBELL: 7 Tricky but no end product
    Referee: 7 Standard of refs is higher(not high)
              Subs: LEABURN 7 Looking fitter
  • Bangkokaddick
    Bangkokaddick Posts: 4,295
    edited September 20
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7.5
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 8
    CAREY: 6.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 7.5
              Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
                       OLAOFE:n/a
                       KNIBBS: n/a
  • Essex_Al
    Essex_Al Posts: 3,582
    KAMINSKI:  6.5
    BURKE:  6.5
    JONES: 6.5
    BELL:  7
    BREE:  6.5
    CAREY:  6
    COVENTRY:  6.5
    DOCHERTY:  7.5
    EDWARDS:  7
    KELMAN:  4
    CAMPBELL:  6.5
    Referee:  6.5
              Subs: LEABURN:  6.5
  • Sponsored links:



  • Bostonaddick
    Bostonaddick Posts: 814
    KAMINSKI:  7 did his job 
    BURKE:  7.5 solid. Smart defender
    JONES: 7.5 good as usual
    BELL:  9 MOM.  Excellent today
    BREE:  7 not great but one touch at end showed his playing pedigree
    CAREY: 6 worked hard but seemed clumsy today
    COVENTRY:  7 Mr consistency. Probably won’t often be man of the match at this level but rarely makes a mistake
    DOCHERTY: 8 he looks fitter and more mobile. Perhaps that has led to the improvement
    EDWARDS: 7 solid as per usual.
    KELMAN: 6.5 not a center forward, more of a second striker
    CAMPBELL: 6.5  At times a ten and other times a 4. I always struggle rating him.
    Referee: 
              Subs: LEABURN: 6 you dont need to dribble through the entire defense.  Pass the ball.  That being said,we play better with him in the lineup so should probably start
                       OLAOFE:n/a
                       KNIBBS: n/a
  • RedRyan
    RedRyan Posts: 911
    lancashire lad said:
    marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

    KAMINSKI: 7 collected well, not his biggest fan but was up to the task today 
    BURKE: 7 looked assured, but a few times caught out as he's not entirely up to speed with our play
    JONES: 8.5 man mountain, but for a worldie save he'd have put us 1 up first half 
    BELL: 8.5 class, always frightens me with his play that looks risky but I'm starting to see he's just that confident
    BREE: 8 some great play (inc the assist) some sloppy, was the right choice over Apter today probably 
    CAREY: 6 doesn't look as good without Apter and their psychic connection 
    COVENTRY: 7 tidied up a few times, let fly poor shots a few times
    DOCHERTY: 8 thought his first half was one of his best for us, faded a bit
    EDWARDS: 8.5 quality as always, he's had a few lessons the last few weeks but stood up well today 
    KELMAN: 6 not his day (again), but showed more promise than previous matches 
    CAMPBELL: 7.5 terrified them and had some great chances but no real end product. No protection from the ref didn't help.
    Referee: 2 worst I've seen in a long time, bought every piss poor dive from them and gave us sod all. The win was sweeter for beating 12 men.
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5 we looked better with him on, but he was a bit greedy/wasteful a few times 
                       OLAOFE:n/a he's gotta get a start at some point?
                       KNIBBS: n/a harried and hassled, think he'll be key for us if he can get fully match fit. Him and Tanto were a handful!

  • SE_7EVEN
    SE_7EVEN Posts: 287

    Kaminski: 7
    Burke: 8
    Jones: 8
    Bell: 8
    Bree: 8
    Carey: 6
    Coventry: 7
    Docherty: 8
    Edwards: 8
    Kelman: 6
    Campbell: 7

    Referee: 5

    Leaburn: 6

  • BoPeepAddick
    BoPeepAddick Posts: 158
    KAMINSKI: 6.5 had nothing to do really 
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 7.5
    BREE: 8 looked very comfortable 
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6.5 worked hard but no real service 
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 3.5 blew for everything, forgot about the appalling conditions 
              Subs: LEABURN: 5.5
  • No.1 in South London
    No.1 in South London Posts: 3,960
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 8.5
    JONES: 8.5
    BELL: 8.5
    BREE: 8.5
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 9
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    LEABURN: 7
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,728
    edited September 20
    Kaminski: 7
    Burke: 8
    Jones: 8
    Bell: 8
    Bree: 7.5
    Carey: 6.5
    Coventry: 6.5
    Docherty: 8.5
    Edwards: 7.5
    Kelman: 6
    Campbell: 7

    Referee: 4 What was that with not letting Jones on the pitch and not giving us a pen?

    Leaburn: 7
  • cafc4ever
    cafc4ever Posts: 565
    KAMINSKI: 8
    BURKE: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    BREE: 8
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    Referee: 5
              Subs: LEABURN: 7
  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,261
    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    BURKE:  6.5
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL:  7.5
    BREE: 7.5
    CAREY: 6
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 6
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5
  • thai malaysia addick
    thai malaysia addick Posts: 18,334
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8.5
    BREE: 8
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 9
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 6
              Subs: LEABURN: 7.5
  • Coveredendchoir
    Coveredendchoir Posts: 242
    KAMINSKI: 7
    BURKE: 7
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 9
    BREE: 7
    CAREY: 6
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 10
    EDWARDS: 9
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee:  7
              Subs: LEABURN: 8

Categories

“Marketplace”