KAMINSKI: 7 nothing wrong RAMSAY: 9.5 motm BELL: 7 calm JONES: 9 immense EDWARDS: 7.5 defensively great but a little wasteful going forward for once COVENTRY: 7 got about KELMAN: 5 scraps CAMPBELL: 7.5 scared them DOCHERTY: 6.5 better today CAREY: 7.5 great touches and plays APTER: 8 scared them even more Referee: 4 useless Subs: LEABURN: 7 chomping at the bit OLAOFE: n/a KNIBBS: n/a GILLESPHEY: n/a ANDERSON: n/a
*sigh* after you mostly did so well last week, a bit of a collective pig's ear this weekend.
I'm not going to name and shame those of you whose posts I had to delete for quoting other people's marks, at least not this week, but stop it, cos it makes Lancs' job more difficult. If you want to discuss the variance in marks for certain players, or if you think someone's been overly harsh or generous, do it on the post match thread. Similarly @Crispywood you need to use the template that Lancs provides in the first post, as having them in the wrong order may introduce errors into the process. I corrected it last week and again this week, next week you may not be so lucky.
KAMINSKI: - 7 Solid. A calming influence behind an outstanding defence.
RAMSAY: - 9 MotM Possibly the best 1 v 1 defender I've ever seen in a Charlton Shirt. Blocked a dangerous cross in the first half...while laying down. So many great tackles.
BELL: - 8 A word for Mr. Bell. He may not be getting the same paudits as others...but he's turning into a Hell of a purchase.
JONES: - 9 The red wall. As well as his imperious domination in the air, throws himself into every block, as if conceding is a personal insult...
EDWARDS: - 6.5 Struggled early on, and made a few unusual errors. Got better as the game went on. Did well.
COVENTRY: - 8 Another outstanding performance from our Duracell Bunny. His fitness levels are such, that he seems to get stronger and stronger.
KELMAN: - 6 Works hard, but other players need to get closer to him to help out. Still needs a strike partner to work off of.
CAMPBELL: - 7 Better than last week, but my biggest criticism is that he always reacts, rather than anticipate.
DOCHERTY: - 7 My mate was criticising him, and I said "You watch, he'll getter better as the game goes on." So many underestimate his leadership on the pitch.
CAREY: - 7 Very good again. Works so hard off the ball. And his team work with the raptor is sublime
APTER: - 8 Wow! What a find! I can only say..."Thierry who?"
Referee: Subs: LEABURN: - 7 Looking good. Id really like to see him and Kelman get a run out together...
KAMINSKI: 6.5 - a quiet afternoon but competent in what he did. Our defence don’t give our goalies many chances to shine, do they - he pouched a couple of routine shots and didn’t have any crosses to deal with, as Jones tends to head everything away. Long may it continue RAMSAY: 9 - another quite outstanding performance BELL: 8 - excellent - good physicality, anticipation and calmness. Showed all his experience JONES: 8 - imperious EDWARDS: 6.5 - a quieter game from Josh but played his part in a fine defensive performance COVENTRY: 7 - some good interceptions and kept things ticking over KELMAN: 6 - isolated and well marshalled by City’s central defenders CAMPBELL: 7.5 - he worried City with his pace, while his crisp passing and movement helped to get us on the front foot in the second half DOCHERTY: 6.5 - I admire his fitness and commitment but his use of the ball needs to improve CAREY: 7 - another impressive performance. His movement and link up play with Apter is very good and they are both going to score goals for us APTER: 8 - City doubled up on him in the first half but he found more space in the second half and seriously threatened their goal. Tenacious when out of possession Referee: 5 - gave a lot of soft free kicks but was even-handed in his moments of ineptitude Subs: LEABURN: 7 - posed problems as soon as he came on OLAOFE: n/a - powerful, fast and direct KNIBBS: n/a - only on for a short while but managed to find space in the box to get on the end of Apter’s injury time cross and would have nicked it but for their keeper’s alertness. Will score plenty of goals from midfield GILLESPHEY: n/a ANDERSON: n/a
Comments
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8
Referee: 5
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 9
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8
Referee: 5
Subs: LEABURN: 7
OLAOFE: n/a
KNIBBS: n/a
GILLESPHEY: n/a
ANDERSON: n/a
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 7
Leaburn 7.5
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 8
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8
Referee: 7
Subs: LEABURN: 7
OLAOFE: n/a
RAMSAY: 10
BELL: 7
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 6.5
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8
Referee: 5.5
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 4
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 8
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8
Referee: 6
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN: 7.5
RAMSAY: 10
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 6.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7
APTER: 9
Referee: 3
Subs: LEABURN: 8
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 5
Subs: LEABURN: 6.5
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 7
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7
APTER: 7
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN 7.5
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 5
CAMPBELL: 6
DOCHERTY: 7.5
CAREY: 6.5
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 7
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 8.5
BELL: 7
JONES: 7.5
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8
Referee: 8
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 8
DOCHERTY: 7.5
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN: 8
RAMSAY: 9*
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 5
CAMPBELL: 6
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 9
RAMSAY: - 9 MotM Possibly the best 1 v 1 defender I've ever seen in a Charlton Shirt. Blocked a dangerous cross in the first half...while laying down. So many great tackles.
BELL: - 8 A word for Mr. Bell. He may not be getting the same paudits as others...but he's turning into a Hell of a purchase.
JONES: - 9 The red wall. As well as his imperious domination in the air, throws himself into every block, as if conceding is a personal insult...
EDWARDS: - 6.5 Struggled early on, and made a few unusual errors. Got better as the game went on. Did well.
COVENTRY: - 8 Another outstanding performance from our Duracell Bunny. His fitness levels are such, that he seems to get stronger and stronger.
KELMAN: - 6 Works hard, but other players need to get closer to him to help out. Still needs a strike partner to work off of.
CAMPBELL: - 7 Better than last week, but my biggest criticism is that he always reacts, rather than anticipate.
DOCHERTY: - 7 My mate was criticising him, and I said "You watch, he'll getter better as the game goes on." So many underestimate his leadership on the pitch.
CAREY: - 7 Very good again. Works so hard off the ball. And his team work with the raptor is sublime
APTER: - 8 Wow! What a find! I can only say..."Thierry who?"
Referee:
Subs: LEABURN: - 7 Looking good. Id really like to see him and Kelman get a run out together...
RAMSAY: 9 - another quite outstanding performance
BELL: 8 - excellent - good physicality, anticipation and calmness. Showed all his experience
JONES: 8 - imperious
EDWARDS: 6.5 - a quieter game from Josh but played his part in a fine defensive performance
COVENTRY: 7 - some good interceptions and kept things ticking over
KELMAN: 6 - isolated and well marshalled by City’s central defenders
CAMPBELL: 7.5 - he worried City with his pace, while his crisp passing and movement helped to get us on the front foot in the second half
DOCHERTY: 6.5 - I admire his fitness and commitment but his use of the ball needs to improve
CAREY: 7 - another impressive performance. His movement and link up play with Apter is very good and they are both going to score goals for us
APTER: 8 - City doubled up on him in the first half but he found more space in the second half and seriously threatened their goal. Tenacious when out of possession
Referee: 5 - gave a lot of soft free kicks but was even-handed in his moments of ineptitude
Subs: LEABURN: 7 - posed problems as soon as he came on
OLAOFE: n/a - powerful, fast and direct
KNIBBS: n/a - only on for a short while but managed to find space in the box to get on the end of Apter’s injury time cross and would have nicked it but for their keeper’s alertness. Will score plenty of goals from midfield
GILLESPHEY: n/a
ANDERSON: n/a
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 7.5
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 7
APTER: 7
Referee:
Subs: LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7.5
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN: 7