Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

PLAYERS MARKS: Championship: Charlton v Watford, 9th August 2025 (closes Sunday teatime)

1235»

Comments

  • KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7

    REF: 5
    LEABURN: 7.5
    KNIBBS: 7.5
    GILLESPHEY: 7
    OLAOFE: 7.5

  • KAMINSKI:  6
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7


  • KAMINSKI: 5.5. Nearly cost us.
    RAMSAY: 9 Superb, love him
    JONES: 8.5 Our most potent attacking threat? 
    BELL: 8 Excellent assured debut
    APTER: 8 Grew into the game
    CAREY: 8 Hadn’t realised how big he was, had an excellent second half
    COVENTRY: 7.5 Keeps things ticking
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8.5 Feel like he’s going to have a lot of tough afternoons this year, but stood up to the challenge very well. 
    KELMAN: 5.5 On the edge of it - makes you realise how good godden is at holding up the ball, because he didn’t offer that. Did almost score tho, showed killer instinct there. 
    CAMPBELL: 7.5 Won’t run teams ragged like last year, but still offered a good amount. 
  • KAMINSKI: 5 - had only one thing to do and his balls up could (and should) have cost us. Looked reluctant to come for crosses.
    RAMSAY: 8 - a Rolls Royce of a player
    JONES: 8.5 - dominant defensively and a menace in the opposition box. Could have scored twice and an assist for the winner
    BELL: 7 - made me nervous in the first half dawdling on the ball but, like the players, maybe I need to settle into the season. Some good distribution down the left in the second half
    APTER: 7.5 - learning a new position and a very good debut. He doesn’t have Small’s strength and raw pace but he’s a more skilful and technical player and one who is going to have far more end product. Two good shots just wide and some fine crosses (I particularly like his left-foot, Colin Walsh style in-swinger).
    CAREY: 7 - a quiet first half but came into the game more in the second. Some good combination play with Apter
    COVENTRY: 6 - a little off his exalted standards but improved as the game went on
    DOCHERTY: 5.5 - a poor first half in which he gave the ball away carelessly on a number of occasions. As is often the case, the Doc had his best period in the last 20 minutes, given his tremendous level of fitness
    EDWARDS: 8 - had a horse of a game against a dangerous opponent. His protracted first half duel with Baah in front of the East Stand was almost worth the admission money alone. 
    KELMAN: 5 - had very little service and, in fairness to the lad, he’s had very little game time in pre-season. 
    CAMPBELL: 6 - blew hot and cold but still troubled Watford on occasions
    Referee: 5 - missed a couple of penalties but wasn’t too bad otherwise
    Subs:LEABURN: 7 - made an immediate impact. Good to see Miles back, as he is well capable of making an impact at this level

    Knibbs - rangy and athletic and anticipated Lloyd’s knockdown for the winner, finishing with aplomb. 
    Gillesphey - slotted in nicely
    Olaofe - strong, fast and athletic. Part of our strongest ever bench
             
  • KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 8
    BELL:  8
    APTER:  7.5
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOCHERTY:6
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 8
    Subs:LEABURN:  7
  • KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 5.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 5
    Referee: 2
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 6

    Knibbs  7
    Gillesphey  6
    Olaofe  7
  • KAMINSKI: 6.5 - Could've cost us a penalty before we scored
    RAMSAY: 8 - What we've come to expect from him. Classy.
    JONES: 7.5 - Solid as always
    BELL: 7.5 - Disappointed he started over Macca, however he impressed.
    APTER: 8 - Think we may have a gem here.
    CAREY: 8.5 - I thought he had an excellent debut.
    COVENTRY: 7 - Went about his business efficiently.
    DOCHERTY: 6 - Will be losing his 1st team spot soon, needs to be better and do more.
    EDWARDS: 7.5 - Solid and was up for the battle.
    KELMAN: 6 - Quiet, but I'm sure he'll start firing soon.
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Frustrating as per end of last season. Some slack passing at times.
    Referee: 
    Subs:LEABURN: 7 - Made their defence look tiny!

    Knibbs - Gonna be a star for us, can just sense it. Reminds me of Jude Bellingham.
    Gillesphey - No sulking, fitted back in superbly.
    Olaofe - So strong in pulling away from challenges.
  • KAMINSKI:  6 
    RAMSAY:  7
    JONES:  7 
    BELL:  6 
    APTER:  6
    CAREY:  6
    COVENTRY:  6 
    DOCHERTY:  5.5 
    EDWARDS:  6
    KELMAN:  5.5 
    CAMPBELL:  6 
    Referee:  6 
    Subs:LEABURN:  7
  • Sponsored links:


  • KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • KAMINSKI:  5.5  Excellent defence meant he wasn't worked hard..plus the momentnof madness
    RAMSAY:  8.5  Looks like a top-half Championship player at the very least 
    JONES:  9  Brilliant all-round performance 
    BELL:  8  Looks very assured and classy.  Just needs to know when not to dwell too much
    APTER:  8.5  As others have said, he grew into the game.  Stuck to his defensive tasks well and clearly has more consistent end product than Small
    CAREY:  8  A promising debut
    COVENTRY:  7.5 Solid as ever
    DOCHERTY:   6 Just doesn't offer enough gping forward and is consistently 10 metres away from the player he is tracking.
    EDWARDS:  8.5 Watford Observer comments tell you enough - generally too good for Baah
    KELMAN: 6.5  Had little service, thought he tried reasonably hard
    CAMPBELL:  5.5  Sadly I'm not sure he's good enough for this level
    Referee:  3.5
    Subs:LEABURN:  7  The new Chuks?

    Knibbs  8.5
    Gillesphey 8

  • KAMINSKI:  5.5
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 7.5
    COVENTRY:  7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 
    Referee:  5 not great but better than most L1 refs
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs 8
    Gillesphey  7.5
    Olaofe 7.5
  • KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 5.5
    DOCHERTY: 4
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 5
    Referee: 
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs
    Gillesphey
    Olaofe
  • KAMINSKI: 5.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 5.5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 6.5
  • KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7 
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8.5
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • edited August 10
    KAMINSKI: 6.5 Deanoesque.
    RAMSAY: 8.5 imperious
    JONES: 8.5 extra half for assist
    BELL: 8 one dodgy moment but looks secure
    APTER: 8 fine debut in attack defence remains a worry
    CAREY: 8.5 amazed we got him on a free
    COVENTRY: 7 too many back/sideways
    DOCHERTY: 6 weak link
    EDWARDS: 8.5 hope he's OK. We have no cover (MotM) 
    KELMAN: 6 lacks movement. Always knew he was just a poacher
    CAMPBELL: 6.5 final ball poor but then KELMAN went missing
    Referee: 5 fussy apart from pens
    Subs: Leaburn 6.5 looked sharp
    Knibbs 6.5 cameo extra half for goal
    Gillesphey 6 not overawed
    Olaofe 6.5 cameo, looked dangerous potential crowd favourite
            


  • KAMINSKI: 5 almost cost us the points at the end
    RAMSAY: 7 played well, maybe a bit lucky to get away with that misskick in his own 6yd box though!
    JONES: 8 dominant and confident as usual
    BELL: 7 started a bit casual. But grew into the game. Looks decent
    APTER: 8 caused them problems. Great delivery and industrious. 
    CAREY: 8.5 MOTM great debut looks a clever signing and more to come hopefully 
    COVENTRY: 7 solid performance 
    DOCHERTY: 7 covered so much ground and worked his nuts off for the team
    EDWARDS: 7 looked comfortable and got forward well a few times. Was brilliant when he mugged off their winger and left him crying by the advertising hordings!
    KELMAN: 6 a bit quiet, maybe lacking a bit of match sharpness. Some nice touches here and there
    CAMPBELL: 7 caused them problems all game and they resorted to doubling up and kicking him
    Referee: 5 erratic and missed two blatant pens for us
    Subs:LEABURN: 7 looked really up for it. Good to see him back

    Knibbs: great composed finish, a joyous moment!
    Gillesphey: solid
    Olaofe: an exciting Chuks like cameo. Really looking forward to see this lad more


  • KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 8
    CAREY:8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee:  Very poor for both sides, kept control of the game though
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs: Well taken great goal
    Gillesphey: was abit nervous when he came on
    Olaofe: Replacement for Chuks, had his fan club sitting behind me (they are up for this season)
  • KAMINSKI 6 nearly cost us the game 
    RAMSAY 8 outstanding 
    JONES 8.5 .really ought to be skip 
    BELL 8 promising debut can't be faulted 
    EDWARDS 8 solid contained their best player 
    COVENTRY 7.5 solid but despite the match winning corner his delivery has to improve 
    APTER 8 great debut 
    DOC 7.5 solid but a few mistakes..had a better 2nd half 
    CAREY 8.5 great debut ..everywhere 
    CAMPBELL 7.5 so much talent..lacks confidence but got better as the game went on 
    KELMAN 7 not sure if he ll work upfront on his own 
    REF 6 could have been 3 penalties 
    SUBS 9 
    NJ 10 ..his decisions won us the match 
  • Sponsored links:


  • KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • KAMINSKI: 6 -1 for the dither. Nothing else to do. 
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 7.5 Some lovely touches& a couple of good efforts. 
    CAREY: 7 Shld have pulled it back when through?
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 5.5 
    EDWARDS: 7.5 Warrior
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 7 Looked to be back on it!
  • KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7
    APTER:7 
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTR7Y: 
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6 
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs  7
    Gillesphey  6
    Olaofe  6
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!