Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Players Marks: L1 Playoffs: Charlton v Wycombe (closes Friday evening)
 
            
                
                    lancashire lad                
                
                    Posts: 15,645                
            
                        
            
                    your marks please:
MANNION:
GILLESPHEY:
JONES:
RAMSAY:
EDWARDS:
COVENTRY:
DOCHERTY:
SMALL:
GILBERT:
CAMPBELL:
GODDEN:
Referee:
Aneke: n/a
Anderson: n/a
Watson: n/a
                    MANNION:
GILLESPHEY:
JONES:
RAMSAY:
EDWARDS:
COVENTRY:
DOCHERTY:
SMALL:
GILBERT:
CAMPBELL:
GODDEN:
Referee:
Aneke: n/a
Anderson: n/a
Watson: n/a
1      
            Comments
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 9
 RAMSAY: 8
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 10 MOM
 DOCHERTY: 8
 SMALL: 7
 GILBERT: 8
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 80
- 
            MANNION: 7GILLESPHEY: 7JONES: 8RAMSAY: 8EDWARDS: 8COVENTRY: 9DOCHERTY: 7SMALL: 7GILBERT: 7CAMPBELL: 7GODDEN: 8Referee: 6.5Aneke: n/aAnderson: n/aWatson: n/a0
- 
            Mannion: 6
 Gillesphey: 7
 Jones: 8
 Ramsay: 9
 Edwards: 8
 Coventry: 8
 Docherty: 7
 Small: 7
 Gilbert: 7
 Campbell: 6
 Godden: 9
 Referee: 70
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 9
 JONES: 10
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 8
 COVENTRY: 9
 DOCHERTY: 6
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 8
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 9
 Referee: 6
 Aneke: 7
 Anderson: 8 - incredible effort
 Watson: n/a1
- 
            MANNION: 6.5 nothing to do
 GILLESPHEY: 8.5 excellent and such a good ball for the goal
 JONES: 8.5 so towering and makes for a decent striker...sometimes
 RAMSAY: 8.5 a few first half errors but unreal second
 EDWARDS: 7.5 largely very good
 COVENTRY: 8.5 covered every blade of grass and passed really well
 DOCHERTY: 6.5 kept it going despite a patchy game, grew towards the end
 SMALL: 7 some mad skillz and almost an amazing goal
 GILBERT: 7 some real class in the first half, faded a bit
 CAMPBELL: 6 they had his number today
 GODDEN: 8.5 you can rely on Godden
 Referee: 8 largely good
 Aneke: n/a
 Anderson: n/a
 Watson: n/a0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8.5
 RAMSAY: 8
 EDWARDS: 6.5
 COVENTRY: 8
 DOCHERTY: 6
 SMALL: 7
 GILBERT: 6.5
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 8
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8
 RAMSAY: 8
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 7
 DOCHERTY: 6
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 7
 CAMPBELL: 6
 GODDEN: 7
 Referee: 70
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8.5
 RAMSAY: 8
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 7
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 7.5
 GILBERT: 8.5
 CAMPBELL: 6
 GODDEN: 8
 Referee: 6
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8.5
 RAMSAY: 8.5
 EDWARDS: 7.5
 COVENTRY: 9
 DOCHERTY: 8
 SMALL: 7.5
 GILBERT: 9
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 8
 Referee: 7
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 10
 JONES: 8
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 7
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 7
 CAMPBELL: 8
 GODDEN: 90
- 
Sponsored links:
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8.5
 RAMSAY: 8.5
 EDWARDS: 8
 COVENTRY: 8.5
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 7
 GILBERT: 8
 CAMPBELL: 6
 GODDEN: 7
 Referee: 60
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 9
 JONES: 9.5
 RAMSAY: 7
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 8
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 7
 GILBERT: 7
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 80
- 
            MANNION, 7, On a night of few chances he wasn't beaten
 GILLESPHEY: 8, Played very well again
 JONES: 9, As above and an assist
 RAMSAY: 9, Saved us with the blocks
 EDWARDS: 6, I didn't think that was his best game
 COVENTRY: 9, He and Gilbert kept us ticking
 DOCHERTY: 6, Better second half
 SMALL: 7, Tactical substitution, played well
 GILBERT: 8, Tired, but was an influence first half.
 CAMPBELL: 6, Was well shackled and only got freedom when he moved across
 GODDEN: 10, MOM, got very little service but you have to take your chances in these games Wycombe failed Godden didn't.
 Referee: 7, Best ref of the playoffs but he hasn't had a lot of competition.
 Aneke: n/a.
 Anderson: n/a0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8.5
 JONES: 8.5
 RAMSAY: 8
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 8
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 7.5
 GILBERT: 7
 CAMPBELL: 7.5
 GODDEN: 80
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8.5
 JONES: 9.5
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 7
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 7.5
 GILBERT: 7
 CAMPBELL: 6
 GODDEN: 8
 Referee: 6
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7.5
 GILLESPHEY: 8.5
 JONES: 9
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 8.5
 COVENTRY: 7.5
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 8.5
 GILBERT: 9 MOM
 CAMPBELL: 6.5
 GODDEN: 8.5
 Referee: 7
 1
- 
            MANNION: 6 very little to do
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 7 missed a sitter
 RAMSAY: 7 two great blocks
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 10 MOM
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 7 if only he had a final ball
 GILBERT: 8’excellent but tired
 CAMPBELL: 5 Gone downhill in the last month but concern seems to have no energy.. or confidence
 GODDEN: 7 quite game but strikers win games
 Referee 5
 4
- 
            MANNION: 7GILLESPHEY: 8JONES: 9RAMSAY: 9EDWARDS: 7.5COVENTRY: 9DOCHERTY: 7.5SMALL: 7.5GILBERT: 7.5CAMPBELL: 7GODDEN: 8Referee7.50
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 9
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 8
 DOCHERTY: 8
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 8
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 8
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 6
 JONES: 7.5
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 8
 COVENTRY: 6.5
 DOCHERTY: 6.5
 SMALL: 7.5
 GILBERT: 8.5
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 9
 Referee: 7
 4
- 
Sponsored links:
- 
            MANNION: 7 - not a shot to save but marshalled goal area well enough
 GILLESPHEY: 8 - Solid
 JONES: 8 - Jones excellent defensively, missed a chance but he is defender not striker
 RAMSAY: 8 - Excellent double block and quality defending
 EDWARDS: 7 - Pushed forward and kept going
 COVENTRY: 8 - Kept ball moving and some good through balls
 DOCHERTY: 6.5 - improved as the game went along and kept at it
 SMALL: 7.5 - Some dangerous runs and terrified Wycombe defenders, run out of steam fitness wise
 GILBERT: 7.5 - Did well, though crosses bit hit and miss
 CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Contributed but mostly kept quiet by Wycombe defence
 GODDEN: 8 - Phenomenal work rate and excellent goal
 Referee: 6 - Controlled the game, stopped overtly dirty play but not Wycombe wrestling, uneven in bookings. Linos clueless
 Nathan Jones - did well, right choice Gilbert to replace Berry, subs at right time
 Aneke: n/a - did his bit as sub
 Anderson: n/a - good energy helped when he came on
 Watson: n/a - helped when he came on1
- 
            OK, from the TV, but I was paying close attention!
 MANNION: 7.5GILLESPHEY: 8.5JONES: 8RAMSAY: 8EDWARDS: 8COVENTRY: 8.5DOCHERTY: 8.5SMALL: 8.5GILBERT: 8CAMPBELL: 7.5GODDEN: 8.5Referee: 60
- 
            MANNION: 7.5
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 9
 RAMSAY: 8
 EDWARDS: 8
 COVENTRY: 9.5
 DOCHERTY: 6
 SMALL: 6.5
 GILBERT: 7.5
 CAMPBELL: 6.5
 GODDEN: 9
 Referee: 60
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8
 RAMSAY: 9 mom
 EDWARDS: 8
 COVENTRY: 8
 DOCHERTY: 6
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 6
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 8
 Referee: 6
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 7
 JONES: 10
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 7
 COVENTRY: 8
 DOCHERTY: 7
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 7.5
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 9
 Referee: 7
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7GILLESPHEY: 8JONES: 8 (-1 for missing a sitter!)RAMSAY: 8 (+1 for ridiculous double block)EDWARDS: 6COVENTRY: 8DOCHERTY: 6SMALL: 7 (didn't all come off but lively)GILBERT: 7 (8 first half, 6 second)CAMPBELL: 6 (physical game didn't suit him but a few good moments)GODDEN: 9 (worked his nuts off all game and +1 for the winning goal)Referee: 6 (ok but overly fussy)1
- 
            MANNION: 7 - No shots on target. One good punch
 GILLESPHEY: 8 - Could not be flapped. Great ball in for the goal and unbalanced Kone superbly when he had his chance
 JONES: 9 - Nothing anywhere near troubling him. Sky vastly overstated how easy his header was but what a touch for the goal
 RAMSAY: 9 MOTM - Octopus legs for the blocks. The second one on the ground was worthy of a Wembley visit alone
 EDWARDS: 8 - Really, really good
 COVENTRY: 7.5 - Radar was a little off but shielded the middle well
 DOCHERTY: 7.5 - Was our most involved player first half and was up for it long before others grew into it
 SMALL: 8 - Unplayable, let down by us not using him enough in the second half before he tired
 GILBERT: 7.5 - Really earned his place, especially in the first half. Dead balls uncharacteristically poor though
 CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Fell over too much first half and will be happy not to see Grimmer again
 GODDEN: 8 - Worked his socks off and TC could learn a lot about body language from him. When his moment came he was there.
 Referee: 5 - Weird bookings, especially for Godden's lob. 4 minutes injury time in the second half also felt manufactured
 Aneke: n/a - Perfect when he came on. Absolute wardrobe
 Anderson: n/a - Also perfect. Couldn't have been a better player to bring on, pressed everything and won his headers
 Watson: n/a - Had one thing to do winning a loose ball and didn't just clear it but won the throw.
 0
- 
            Mannion: 7.5
 Gillesphey: 8
 Jones: 9
 Ramsay: 9
 Edwards: 8
 Coventry: 8
 Docherty: 7.5
 Small: 7
 Gilbert: 8
 Campbell: 7
 Godden: 9
 Referee: 7
 0
- 
            If I am over-marking it’s a reflection of the occasion and significance of the match.MANNION: 7.5
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 8.5
 RAMSAY: 8.5
 EDWARDS: 8
 COVENTRY: 7.5
 DOCHERTY: 7.5
 SMALL: 7.5
 GILBERT: 8
 CAMPBELL: 7
 GODDEN: 7.5
 Referee: 6
 Aneke: n/a
 Anderson: n/a
 Watson: n/a
 0
- 
            MANNION: 7
 GILLESPHEY: 8
 JONES: 10
 RAMSAY: 9
 EDWARDS: 9
 COVENTRY: 7.5
 DOCHERTY: 7.5
 SMALL: 8
 GILBERT: 9
 CAMPBELL: 6
 GODDEN: 8
 Referee: 6
 0











