Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Alfie May - signed for Birmingham (p68 - Now Huddersfield )
Comments
-
I’m of the opinion that Alfie has somewhat engineered this move. Just my opinion.superdulvertonred said:Scott was the most influential player I have seen at Charlton and was gutted that he left but it was a move he engineered so couldn’t blame the club7 -
My son has only really got into football in the last year and the worst thing for me in this is trying to explain tohim why his first Charlton hero no longer plays for us.
Knew I made the right decision by getting his own name on his shirt rather than May's like he'd wanted!7 -
I think you’re right, it’s a final contract on more money and don’t blame himLargeAddick said:
I’m of the opinion that Alfie has somewhat engineered this move. Just my opinion.superdulvertonred said:Scott was the most influential player I have seen at Charlton and was gutted that he left but it was a move he engineered so couldn’t blame the club1 -
It’s character building and don’t forget to tell him to expect it to happen on a regular basis.AllHailTheHen said:My son has only really got into football in the last year and the worst thing for me in this is trying to explain tohim why his first Charlton hero no longer plays for us.
Knew I made the right decision by getting his own name on his shirt rather than May's like he'd wanted!5 -
Supporting Charlton, feels like one day you wake up, and feel like you’ve been misold a pension!LargeAddick said:
It’s character building and don’t forget to tell him to expect it to happen on a regular basis.AllHailTheHen said:My son has only really got into football in the last year and the worst thing for me in this is trying to explain tohim why his first Charlton hero no longer plays for us.
Knew I made the right decision by getting his own name on his shirt rather than May's like he'd wanted!0 -
LargeAddick said:
I’m of the opinion that Alfie has somewhat engineered this move. Just my opinion.superdulvertonred said:Scott was the most influential player I have seen at Charlton and was gutted that he left but it was a move he engineered so couldn’t blame the club
I think so too, he didn't (and rightly IMO) feel he should be on the bench as a bit part player and the club would be more than happy to get an extra 1M back on our outgoings to use on players who Jones wants0 -
Oh god yeah. He only needs to look at his dad to see what a lifetime of supporting Charlton does to a man. He's gonna have to get used to crushing disappointment quickly.LargeAddick said:
It’s character building and don’t forget to tell him to expect it to happen on a regular basis.AllHailTheHen said:My son has only really got into football in the last year and the worst thing for me in this is trying to explain tohim why his first Charlton hero no longer plays for us.
Knew I made the right decision by getting his own name on his shirt rather than May's like he'd wanted!1 -
Must have missed us setting up entirely to feed him, spent most of the season playing out of position. To get the best out of May you play a 3-5-2 and pair him with a big target man. How many times did we see that?Leuth said:
He scored tons for two sides who set themselves up entirely to feed him and basically him alone, with the result that other forward players were cast as support act. He may have scored 20 but he probably should have scored 30 given some of the chances he wasted. But here's the thing - are Birmingham going to do that? Will his pace hold up? Will Birmingham have a better penalty taker (probably)? Or is this more of the worst football takes you've all ever seen, blah blahCarter said:
He scored tons for a truly shit Charlton team and even more for a less shit, but still limited Cheltenham Town. He will dip his bread there and their fans will love himNabySarr said:
I’m not sure he will actually do that amazingly there. If it was Huddersfield he’d probably score loads but it remains to be seen how Birmingham will play/set up and whether that will suit MayCarter said:Birmingham have just made the signing of the season, a guy who scores for fun at this level, works his nuts off and antagonises the opposition. They have signed a ready made cult hero.
We are now back to less forwards than we had for the last couple of seasons and only one of them stays fit. Triffic16 -
I agree. I was told by a friend of his that Jones and May didn’t get along. But if he’s been offered £11k a week - probably double what he’s on at Charlton - then surely, his head has been turnedLargeAddick said:
I’m of the opinion that Alfie has somewhat engineered this move. Just my opinion.superdulvertonred said:Scott was the most influential player I have seen at Charlton and was gutted that he left but it was a move he engineered so couldn’t blame the club0 -
Shame.1
- Sponsored links:
-
Wrong thread?JaShea99 said:This is getting embarrassing. You’d never see Messi show such desperation.0 -
Can confirm I've also heard this but there's allegedly a 'passion' bonus worth approx 5k per gesture as well.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:
I heard £40k pw and £90k per goal bonusoohaahmortimer said:Fair play to Alfie £25k per week is not to be sniffed at , especially at his age
4 -
superdulvertonred said:Apparently this has not appeared to have wound me up as much as selling Killer or Sven not taking Darren Bent to the World Cup must be mellowing with age.In the end it's a third division player moving on. How upset can we honestly get compared to some of what we've lost? The last time I was truly apoplectic was when we sold Yann. The season before with next to no investment we'd finished 3 points off the Championship Play-Offs. A bloke came in with a bit of money the following January and you felt like we could seriously challenge if Powell just got given some proper backing. Instead we chucked our truly Premier League level player and brought in someone's nephew or whatever to replace him.Now we're trading off players who shuffle us around between midtable third division and slightly lower midtable third divison, I can't be bothered to get wound up about it. Wake me up when the squad's been put together, I've only got so many more existential crises in me before my head bursts and I'd like to save them for some higher level stuff.17
-
This is so much better than the George Dobson hissy fit fall out.0
-
Let’s see how you feel about that at the end of the season.cafcdave123 said:Don’t give a shit about losing may, he scored goals in a meaningless wanky season.
I’d put money on it now that the team scores more goals next season than we did last.
absolutely nothing against him but let’s not pretend he’s something that he wasn’t2 -
Or just used to it by now.superdulvertonred said:Apparently this has not appeared to have wound me up as much as selling Killer or Sven not taking Darren Bent to the World Cup must be mellowing with age.1 -
Some really odd takes, almost as if 20 plus goalscorers are ten a penny and Alfie was shit because he was in tier 3
I hope I'm wrong I really do but selling your goalscorer to a rival is at best misplaced self-belief by Jones and at worst a decision that will rank up there with selling Yann which was stupidly in the first degree
We were never set up to enable him to to his strengths, he got played out of position, got blamed at the start of the season, got shit service. He still scored more than anyone else last season including centre forwards for all conquering Portsmouth, Derby County and Oxford.
31 -
You wait ages and ages for a consistent Goalscorer to come along, and then……
one arrives and we sell him for a £1m profit when we supposedly have plenty of transfer funds.Without NJ we would be in L2 and May would have gone anyway, but Nathan, you have used up your extra life and the clock starts ticking in a few weeks time, that sale was a needless own goal by you.11 -
You might bet on that but not a single Championship side bet on it and I know who would be the better judge.The Red Robin said:
He doesn’t need to be Championship level. He’s a proven League One goalscorer. I’d also bet anyone that can score 23 league goals in the third tier could probably do a half decent job in The Championship.Scoham said:In January I couldn’t see how May would leave, I thought he was worth more than anyone would pay.
Shows how much money there is in football when there are one or two L1 clubs who will pay £1m or close to it for a striker in his 30s with no Championship experience.I have doubts about him at Championship level but he is as close as we can get to guaranteed goals in a player at this level, Birmingham will do what I hoped we’d do and worry about that when they get there.
We need to replace him with two good strikers that leave us stronger overall. Big ask but we’ll see.4 -
I'll sound like a broken record but will say again anyway -
Jones doesn't fancy Alfie for the system he wants to play and as a manager he has to live and die by these decisions, if we go up no one will even be speaking about Alfie May.
If however we have midtable mediocrity again he will be getting questioned and quite rightly so. Its a huge gamble but if im the manager id rather fail trying to do things my way as oppose to fail playing a way i dont to shoehorn a player i dont like to appease fans.
Also if May has engineered this i really dont blame him 31 this will be his last big contract spent a lot of time in non-league so sure he didnt earn good money until later in his career, doing whats best for his family.11 - Sponsored links:
-
thing is IF a player (in this case May) is determined to go, i m o, let him go .. we don't want anyone on good money downing tools and taking the mick, all it does is cause dressing room unrest as will as cheesing off the fans .. take the money and look around for another striker who will fit into Jones's plansValiantphil said:You wait ages and ages for a consistent Goalscorer to come along, and then……
one arrives and we sell him for a £1m profit when we supposedly have plenty of transfer funds.Without NJ we would be in L2 and May would have gone anyway, but Nathan, you have used up your extra life and the clock starts ticking in a few weeks time, that sale was a needless own goal by you.2 -
If we don't sign 1 or 2 good forwards it will be a terrible decision.
If we do sign 1 or 2 good forwards it may be a decent or very good decision.
Not one person knows how this will pan out and the window doesn't close tomorrow.
So is there any chance of us being sensible and waiting to see what transpires?11 -
I have it on good authority, Alfie wanted to stay at Charlton and see out his professional career with us - but, very shortly after Jones was appointed, he realised that Jones didn’t fancy him, and in reality Alfie didn’t ‘fit’ into what Jones wantedLincsaddick said:
thing is IF a player (in this case May) is determined to go, i m o, let him go .. we don't want anyone on good money downing tools and taking the mick, all it does is cause dressing room unrest as will as cheesing off the fans .. take the money and look around for another striker who will fit into Jones's plansValiantphil said:You wait ages and ages for a consistent Goalscorer to come along, and then……
one arrives and we sell him for a £1m profit when we supposedly have plenty of transfer funds.Without NJ we would be in L2 and May would have gone anyway, but Nathan, you have used up your extra life and the clock starts ticking in a few weeks time, that sale was a needless own goal by you.
This is something - IMO - Alfie has had to put up with all his career - his height - even today, English football has a dislike of short players, especially as CF’s
It’s idiotic - what he lacks in height, he makes up for in so many other areas - and yes, I’m short as well, not much taller than Alfie - and whilst I was nowhere near his standard, I still did a shift as a CF in amateur footballer (an annoying wasp of a player I was)
So, if he knows he is not wanted in reality, and he is just over 30 years old, but still fit as a butchers dog, rapid, scores goals by the bucket load - yes Alfie, get that move - earn a shedload of money for your family, because they matter more than anything for Alfie, and rightly so
As for Charlton Athletic, our loss in my opinion
If Jones has called this wrong, and season starts badly, and Alfie’s replacement is dog eggs, it’s gonna be toxic, and we are back to square root of fuck all ……9 -
Doesn’t fit the system that Nathan wants to play.That will be a system of not scoring goals, not winning games and probably playing three mostly shit wingers “up-front”.
But they will work hard and have great stats at passing backwards.3 -
So because Jones didn’t want to build the team/play around may he wanted to leave?Lordflashheart said:
I have it on good authority, Alfie wanted to stay at Charlton and see out his professional career with us - but, very shortly after Jones was appointed, he realised that Jones didn’t fancy him, and in reality Alfie didn’t ‘fit’ into what Jones wantedLincsaddick said:
thing is IF a player (in this case May) is determined to go, i m o, let him go .. we don't want anyone on good money downing tools and taking the mick, all it does is cause dressing room unrest as will as cheesing off the fans .. take the money and look around for another striker who will fit into Jones's plansValiantphil said:You wait ages and ages for a consistent Goalscorer to come along, and then……
one arrives and we sell him for a £1m profit when we supposedly have plenty of transfer funds.Without NJ we would be in L2 and May would have gone anyway, but Nathan, you have used up your extra life and the clock starts ticking in a few weeks time, that sale was a needless own goal by you.
This is something - IMO - Alfie has had to put up with all his career - his height - even today, English football has a dislike of short players, especially as CF’s
It’s idiotic - what he lacks in height, he makes up for in so many other areas - and yes, I’m short as well, not much taller than Alfie - and whilst I was nowhere near his standard, I still did a shift as a CF in amateur footballer (an annoying wasp of a player I was)
So, if he knows he is not wanted in reality, and he is just over 30 years old, but still fit as a butchers dog, rapid, scores goals by the bucket load - yes Alfie, get that move - earn a shedload of money for your family, because they matter more than anything for Alfie, and rightly so
As for Charlton Athletic, our loss in my opinion
If Jones has called this wrong, and season starts badly, and Alfie’s replacement is dog eggs, it’s gonna be toxic, and we are back to square root of fuck all ……0 -
No - because Jones don’t want himcafcdave123 said:
So because Jones didn’t want to build the team/play around may he wanted to leave?Lordflashheart said:
I have it on good authority, Alfie wanted to stay at Charlton and see out his professional career with us - but, very shortly after Jones was appointed, he realised that Jones didn’t fancy him, and in reality Alfie didn’t ‘fit’ into what Jones wantedLincsaddick said:
thing is IF a player (in this case May) is determined to go, i m o, let him go .. we don't want anyone on good money downing tools and taking the mick, all it does is cause dressing room unrest as will as cheesing off the fans .. take the money and look around for another striker who will fit into Jones's plansValiantphil said:You wait ages and ages for a consistent Goalscorer to come along, and then……
one arrives and we sell him for a £1m profit when we supposedly have plenty of transfer funds.Without NJ we would be in L2 and May would have gone anyway, but Nathan, you have used up your extra life and the clock starts ticking in a few weeks time, that sale was a needless own goal by you.
This is something - IMO - Alfie has had to put up with all his career - his height - even today, English football has a dislike of short players, especially as CF’s
It’s idiotic - what he lacks in height, he makes up for in so many other areas - and yes, I’m short as well, not much taller than Alfie - and whilst I was nowhere near his standard, I still did a shift as a CF in amateur footballer (an annoying wasp of a player I was)
So, if he knows he is not wanted in reality, and he is just over 30 years old, but still fit as a butchers dog, rapid, scores goals by the bucket load - yes Alfie, get that move - earn a shedload of money for your family, because they matter more than anything for Alfie, and rightly so
As for Charlton Athletic, our loss in my opinion
If Jones has called this wrong, and season starts badly, and Alfie’s replacement is dog eggs, it’s gonna be toxic, and we are back to square root of fuck all ……
Why - well you will have to ask Jones
Me - if I was Alfie, I would get out and move on - and I would do the same, even though I am CAFC through and through - because, at the end of the day, my family come before CAFC - pro footballer career is short…
He has landed on a very good deal aged over 30 - good for him
Nathan - over to you…..0 -
Based on what?LargeAddick said:
I’m of the opinion that Alfie has somewhat engineered this move. Just my opinion.superdulvertonred said:Scott was the most influential player I have seen at Charlton and was gutted that he left but it was a move he engineered so couldn’t blame the club
Obviously you're entitled to an opinion, but I'd love to know what that's based on, because I've not heard or read anything of the sort.
If it's no more than a "hunch" then that's pretty poor form.8 -
As people have already said, unless we get in a suitable replacement and we aren't in the shake up at the end of the season this will be on Jones. All I would say is that the players bought into Jones ways (twice) at Luton where he was very successful and they blatantly didn't at Stoke (38 games) and Southampton (14). For that reason, the one thing Jones can't have is players who aren't totally committed to playing the way he wants to play hence Alfie's departure. We won't have to wait too long to find out who was right.2
-
Alfie had booked himself in for private leg extensions operation, to make him 6 foot tall.Off_it said:
Based on what?LargeAddick said:
I’m of the opinion that Alfie has somewhat engineered this move. Just my opinion.superdulvertonred said:Scott was the most influential player I have seen at Charlton and was gutted that he left but it was a move he engineered so couldn’t blame the club
Obviously you're entitled to an opinion, but I'd love to know what that's based on, because I've not heard or read anything of the sort.
If it's no more than a "hunch" then that's pretty poor form.
Once his agent got Brum willing to double his wages, he cancelled the op and signed on the dotted line.0 -
'Sir, permission to officially wet the bed, Sir'Fumbluff said:Doesn’t fit the system that Nathan wants to play.That will be a system of not scoring goals, not winning games and probably playing three mostly shit wingers “up-front”.
But they will work hard and have great stats at passing backwards.
'Not granted Fumbluff.'
'Sir, reporting an unofficial bed wetting incident.'4
