Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Reading v Charlton (closes Monday brekkers)

2

Comments

  • Chunes
    Chunes Posts: 17,406
    Jscore: 6

    Isted: 7
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 5
    Gillesphey: 5 
    T.Watson: 3
    Coventry: 5
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 2
    May: 4
    Ladapo: 3
    REG: 6
    Referee: 5

  • JohnnyH2
    JohnnyH2 Posts: 5,347

    Isted: 7
    Jones: 5
    Thomas: 5
    Gillesphey: 4
    T.Watson: 4
    Coventry: 5
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 6
    Edun: 4
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 4
    REG: 5
    Referee: 6
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
  • Live_by_The_Sword
    Live_by_The_Sword Posts: 205
    Jscore: not fair to mark on his first game I believe 
    Isted: 7
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 5
    Gillesphey: 4
    T.Watson: 2 rubbish
    Coventry: 5.5
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 4.5
    Edun: 2 rubbish 
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 3
    REG: 4
    Referee: 4
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
    we are very much in trouble 
  • Blucher
    Blucher Posts: 4,148
    Jscore: too early to score him
    Isted: 7 - did well, especially given how long he's been out
    Jones: 6 - ok
    Thomas: 5 - a regression from recent performances
    Gillesphey: 4.5 - unconvincing and another January recruit who's not match fit
    T.Watson: 3 - one good cross in the second half but otherwise absolutely hopeless
    Coventry: 5.5 - started well but faded as Reading assumed control 
    Bakinson: 4 - a good athlete but a poor footballer. He has considerable difficulty in controlling the ball
    L.Watson: 5.5 - a few nice touches and moments of creativity but unable to make a major impact. Not helped by a recent lack of game time
    Edun: 3 - useless - as he has been for most of the season
    May: 4.5 - poor service but was well off it today
    Ladapo: 3 - dreadful - as he has been in all 5 games for us
    REG: 5 - didn't really notice him
    Referee: 6 - ok. Generously missed Thomas' first half handball
    Kanu: n/a - looked lively
    Camara: n/a - a very good cameo, although I doubt that he could do a full game on Tuesday
    Campbell: n/a - tentative, lacking confidence and too easily brushed off the ball
  • FULLERpromise
    FULLERpromise Posts: 342
    Jscore 6 - happy with team selection subs ok gonna be a process for sure 
    Isted: 7 - motm kept us in it and kept his spot
    Jones: 5.5 won some headers best of defence 
    Thomas: 4 - a poor performance today 
    Gillesphey: 4 - just another Meh defender 
    T.Watson: 4 - some good and yes some bad but by no means the worst today 
    Coventry:5 ok 
    Bakinson: 4 - he is so unorthodox still trying to work out if he is good or shit 
    L.Watson: 5.- some nice play at times but not in the game enough 
    Edun: 2 - was a fan when signed today everyone slating t.wat sons performance needs to watch Eduns
    May: 4 - when no one is there to create chances for him he can’t do too much 
    Ladapo: 2 - when he actually has a shot or controls a ball I’m in shock 
    REG: 5 - meh 
    Referee: 6 - ok.
    Kanu: n/a - if NJ is better than previous I hope he starts Kanu instead of the donkey ladapo
    Camara: n/a - excellent when came on hopefully can get at least 45 from him tues 
    Campbell: n/a - not what we need right now but same time we have no wingers or real great wing backs to run at players 
  • eastterrace6168
    eastterrace6168 Posts: 22,831
    Jscore: 6
    Isted: 6
    Jones: 5
    Thomas: 4
    Gillesphey: 3.5
    T.Watson: 4
    Coventry: 4.5
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 4.5
    Edun: 3.5
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 2
    REG: 5
    Referee: 2

  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,535
    Jscore: 6
    Isted: 7
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 4
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 2
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 4
    Edun: 3
    May: 4
    Ladapo: 3
    REG: 6
    Referee: 6
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a 
  • clive
    clive Posts: 19,554
    At the game
    Isted: 7
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 6
    T.Watson: 5.5
    Coventry: 5
    Bakinson: 6
    L.Watson: 6.5
    Edun: 6
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 5
    REG: 6
    Referee: 6
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,745
    lancashire lad said:
    Jscore: 
    Isted:   7
    Jones:   7
    Thomas:   5
    Gillesphey:  5
    T.Watson:   5
    Coventry:  6
    Bakinson:  6
    L.Watson:  6
    Edun:  5.5
    May:   6
    Ladapo: 4
    REG:   5
    Referee: 
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a

  • addickson
    addickson Posts: 893
    Isted: 6
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 5
    Gillesphey: 3
    T.Watson: 5
    Coventry: 4
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 4
    Edun: 3
    May: 3
    Ladapo: 4
    REG: 4
    Referee: 4


  • Sponsored links:



  • Coveredendchoir
    Coveredendchoir Posts: 249
    Jscore: 6 - loved his screaming and shouting on the side...but has a big job on his hands - needs to goto 4-1-2-1-2 playing through the middle... and needs our patience as fans... we have a huge game on Tuesday. The only way is up - surely? 

    Isted: 8 could have been far worse without him.
    Jones: 6 shame about the goal, was back to his normal self after a couple of iffy games.
    Thomas: 6 worked well considering hes on Left footed and on RHS of back 3.
    Gillesphey: 4 lacking something... maybe trying too hard to pinch the ball... when its not pinch-able?
    T.Watson: 3 See Edun... one less for shocking pass to their attacker in first half.
    Coventry: 6 Not Dobbo, but hes our future.
    Bakinson: 6 Needs to get the ball under control quicker
    L.Watson: 6 nice touches and needs a run of games.
    Edun: 4 poor crossing when in good positions, just isnt a wingback.. thus formation change...
    May: 5 Needs to work closer to Ladapo... no point being so wide or deep... need him nearer the oppo goal.
    Ladapo: 3 things not running for him, comes short ball goes long, goes long the ball comes short... was reasonable in the air and no other option until Aneke's fit?, so we need to stick with him as DK not ready.

    REG: 5 Seen nothing yet to suggest hes better than what we had before he arrived... so yet more shit business by A.Scott (get rid of him)

    Referee: 8 thought he was fine, Lino nearest us was a bit of a knob though.. 
    Kanu: n/a 
    Camara: n/a (Great to see him back....just hope he can stay fit...)
    Campbell: n/a


  • seth plum
    seth plum Posts: 53,448
    Jscore: 5

    Isted: 7
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 6.5
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 6.5
    Coventry: 5.5
    Bakinson: 5.5
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 5
    May: 6
    Ladapo: 4.5
    REG: 5.5

    Referee: 5

  • Bolderhumphreyreid
    Bolderhumphreyreid Posts: 2,556
    Jscore: 6
    Isted: 7
    Jones: 7
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 6
    T.Watson: 6
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 5
    L.Watson: 6
    Edun: 3
    May: 6
    Ladapo: 3
    REG: 6
    Referee: 6
  • ParkinsonOut
    ParkinsonOut Posts: 1,472
    Isted:  7
    Jones:  6
    Thomas:  4
    Gillesphey:  4
    T.Watson:  2
    Coventry: 4
    Bakinson:  4.5
    L.Watson:  4
    Edun:  3
    May:  4
    Ladapo:  2
    REG:  4
    Referee:  6
  • superdulvertonred
    superdulvertonred Posts: 1,147
    At the game

    Isted: 7
    Jones: 7
    Thomas: 5
    Gillesphey: 4
    T.Watson: 4
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 5
    L.Watson: 6
    Edun: 4
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 4
    REG: 5
    Referee: 6
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a

  • Athletico Charlton
    Athletico Charlton Posts: 14,303
    At the game


    Jscore: 6. 
    Isted:   7. No chance withe either goal
    Jones:  7. I thought he was decent today
    Thomas: 6. Ok
    Gillesphey:  5. Weak, slow. Aimless kicks upfield.
    T.Watson:  4. Poor and weak header led to their 2nd.
    Coventry: 5. Nothing player. Poor quality set plays.
    Bakinson: 5. Limited quality.
    L.Watson: 5 another nothing player.
    Edun: 2. Shocker at defending and attacking then started hiding.
    May: 6.5. kept trying/running
    Ladapo:  3. Waste of space 
    REG: 5. I actually didn't know he came on. 
    Referee: 7. Did fine
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a

  • JamesSeed
    JamesSeed Posts: 17,391
    Jscore:  6
    Isted:  6.5 Pretty good. 
    Jones:  6.5 Better. Won headers. 
    Thomas:  6 Sill ok
    Gillesphey:  5 Not sure about him. 
    T.Watson:  4 Lackadaisical 
    Coventry: 5.5 Pretty disappointing
    Bakinson:  6 One great through ball in the second half set up a 1 on 1.
    L.Watson:  5.5 Quite disappointing
    Edun:  5 Poor
    May:  6 Shoot quicker Alfie. 
    Ladapo:  4 Very disappointing
    REG:  5 I really don’t know. 
    Referee:  6.5 MoM
  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,782
    edited February 2024

    Isted: 7
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 7
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 6
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 6
    May: 6
    Ladapo: 3
    REG: 6
  • EastTerrace
    EastTerrace Posts: 3,961
    Jscore:  5
    Isted: 6
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 5,5
    Gillesphey: 5.5 thought he defended well first half 
    T.Watson: 3
    Coventry: 5
    Bakinson: 4 awful, slow, no first touch
    L.Watson: 6 needs to do more but 3 good balls forward 
    Edun: 3
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 2
    REG: 4
    Referee: 
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
  • HongCharltonKong
    HongCharltonKong Posts: 54
    Isted: 8
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 5
    Gillesphey: 6 
    T.Watson: 4
    Coventry: 7 
    Bakinson: 5
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 4
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 5

  • Sponsored links:



  • grumpyaddick
    grumpyaddick Posts: 6,597
    Jscore: 5 
    Isted: 7
    Jones: 7
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 6
    T.Watson: 5
    Coventry: 5
    Bakinson: 5
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 3
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 4
    REG: 5
    Referee: 6
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,773
    Isted:  7
    Jones:  5
    Thomas:  5
    Gillesphey:  5
    T.Watson:  5
    Coventry: 5.5
    Bakinson:  6
    L.Watson:  6
    Edun:  4
    May:  5
    Ladapo:  4
    REG:  5
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,369
    Jscore: 4

    Isted:  7
    Jones:  6.5
    Thomas:  5.5
    Gillesphey:  5
    T.Watson:  5.5
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson:  5.5
    L.Watson:  5.5
    Edun:  5
    May:  4
    Ladapo:  4
    REG:  5
    Referee:  6 
  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 51,432
    Jscore: 6 Hard to judge. 
    Isted: 7 Thought he could do nothing for either goal but made some good saves. 
    Jones: 6.5 Okay
    Thomas: 6 Okay
    Gillesphey: 6 Okay 
    T.Watson: 5.5 weak header to Azeez
    Coventry: 6 okay
    Bakinson: 5 very wasteful today
    L.Watson: 5 not the answer
    Edun: 5 hmm
    May: 7 never stops, smeven when shattered l
    Ladapo: 4 Sharpness needed asap or start Kanu
    REG: 6.5 okay
    Referee: 4 usual shenanigans 
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
  • BoPeepAddick
    BoPeepAddick Posts: 162
    Isted: 7.5 
    Jones: 7 
    Thomas: 5.5
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 4
    Coventry: 5.5
    Bakinson: 4.5
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 4
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 3.5
    REG: 5
    Referee: 5
    Kanu: Surely has to start soon
    Camara: Think he has to start, but just how fit is he.
    Campbell: He’s shot to bits - zero confidence 
  • robinofottershaw
    robinofottershaw Posts: 1,932
    Jscore: 7
    Isted: 7
    Jones: 7
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 3
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 5
    L.Watson: 5
    Edun: 4
    May: 6
    Ladapo: 4
    REG: 5
    Referee: 6
    Kanu: n/a
    Camara: n/a
    Campbell: n/a
  • EveshamAddick
    EveshamAddick Posts: 7,030
    edited February 2024
    At the game

    Jscore: 4 - didn’t seem to be an improvement on Apples or Fleming, obviously it’s early days and at least he looked animated
    Isted: 6 - kept us in it first half and seemed to communicate with the defence
    Jones: 6 - steady
    Thomas: 7 - played quite well
    Gillesphey: 4 - slow carthorse
    T.Watson: 3 - not a wingback or defender
    Coventry: 5 - not great
    Bakinson:  2 - slow, poor
    L.Watson: 5 - energetic but didn’t seem to know what he was doing tactically
    Edun: 2 not a wingback or defender
    May: 7 tried hard and was all over the pitch but feeding on scraps
    Ladapo: 1 - terrible
    REG: 5 - looked ok when he came on, didn’t seem to do anything wrong
    Referee: 6 - mostly ok
    Kanu: 8 - worked hard, chasing lost causes, showed what commitment looks like
    Camara: 9 MOM superb cameo, shows what we’ve been missing
    Campbell: 2 pointless sub
  • Stuart_the_Red
    Stuart_the_Red Posts: 1,868
    Unfortunately, I watched on CharltonTV

    Jscore: 6

    Isted: 7
    Jones: 7 
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 5
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 5
    L.Watson: 6
    Edun: 4
    May: 6
    Ladapo: 4
    REG: 5

    Referee: 5
  • PopIcon
    PopIcon Posts: 5,970
    Isted: 7.5
    Jones: 6
    Thomas: 6
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 2
    Coventry: 3
    Bakinson: 3
    L.Watson: 5.5
    Edun: 2
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 3
    REG: 5
  • MrWalker
    MrWalker Posts: 4,137
    At the game, sadly.
    Jscore: 6 
    Isted: 7 
    Jones: 7
    Thomas: 6  
    Gillesphey: 5
    T.Watson: 4
    Coventry: 6
    Bakinson: 4
    L.Watson: 6 
    Edun: 3
    May: 5
    Ladapo: 2
    Reg: 5  
    Referee: 6 

Categories

“Marketplace”