Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlie Kirk (p68 - released by Barrow)
Comments
-
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.3 -
When we had players like Lavelle they were clearly not good enough but at least they tried.
Kirk shows no passion or effort, a complete waste of space.3 -
I don’t believe that Kirk doesn’t give a shit and is just going through the motions. That’s too simplistic an answer and one that I believe would be easily seen and called out by both the manager and his team mates. There’s something else happening here and I think it’s got everything to do with what’s going on between Charlie’s ears. Whatever it is has resulted in a player with some pedigree looking looking like player with absolutely no future in the game. I don’t think he can resolve whatever is wrong at Charlton now. It’s gone too far and he’s lost the entire fan base. Please let him move on in January and try and see if he can find himself at another club. Personally I hope he can.11
-
Met loads of people through working life who are happy to sit around all day and not contribute, while others want to get on if only to make the working day go faster. Don't see why it would be any different in professional footballShootersHillGuru said:I don’t believe that Kirk doesn’t give a shit and is just going through the motions. That’s too simplistic an answer and one that I believe would be easily seen and called out by both the manager and his team mates. There’s something else happening here and I think it’s got everything to do with what’s going on between Charlie’s ears. Whatever it is has resulted in a player with some pedigree looking looking like player with absolutely no future in the game. I don’t think he can resolve whatever is wrong at Charlton now. It’s gone too far and he’s lost the entire fan base. Please let him move on in January and try and see if he can find himself at another club. Personally I hope he can.1 -
Tbh, it would explain why he was once a decent player and now appears to be struggling. Never know what others are going through and it don't necessarily have to have anything to do with him losing a parent.....colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
Not sure what position that puts the Club and supporters in, but obviously the blokes mental health should be considered amongst all this5 -
He needs to go home or very close to it Shooters, and he needs to do it very soon if he has any chance of ressurecting his career. His performance yesterday showed a lack of belief and guile. He won't be the first to move down to London and fail, Francis Jeffers comes to mind and not in a good way. Money is not everything and come the summer he will enter the last year of his contract and if he is still at Charlton by that point then sadly I believe he will drop away from League football for good.ShootersHillGuru said:I don’t believe that Kirk doesn’t give a shit and is just going through the motions. That’s too simplistic an answer and one that I believe would be easily seen and called out by both the manager and his team mates. There’s something else happening here and I think it’s got everything to do with what’s going on between Charlie’s ears. Whatever it is has resulted in a player with some pedigree looking looking like player with absolutely no future in the game. I don’t think he can resolve whatever is wrong at Charlton now. It’s gone too far and he’s lost the entire fan base. Please let him move on in January and try and see if he can find himself at another club. Personally I hope he can.2 -
If there is a MH issue (which I'm not disputing and I dont think its right to speculate on necassarily either) but then why on earth have multiple managers continued to select him/sent him out on loan etc etc?
If you have someone with those kinds of issues then the club has a duty of care - not to just palm him off to another club - not to just expect the player to just carry on knowing the shit he will get (rightly or wrongly) when he clearly isn't at his best on the pitch and hasn't been for a few years.
It just doesn't 100% sit right with me at all and to be honest it doesn't entirely ring true to me that this is the issue. I also would hope that MA wouldn't allude to him in the way he did in the post match interview last night if there was a known MH issue (which it would HAVE to be known about surely within the management team?)0 -
It would but equally we don't know so can't speculate. However, if he is going through stuff to do with the loss of his dad I think it's very poor taste from the other poster to suggest that he needs to get over it as it was 2 years ago.Gribbo said:
Tbh, it would explain why he was once a decent player and now appears to be struggling. Never know what others are going through and it don't necessarily have to have anything to do with him losing a parent.....colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
Not sure what position that puts the Club and supporters in, but obviously the blokes mental health should be considered amongst all this1 -
I think the original post was spot on. I lost my mum before I was 25. I was due to sit professional exams but deferred which was understandable given the circumstances.colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
I did them a year later when my head was clear using the fact that it would have made my mum
proud as motivation.If I kept putting my exams off, my boss would have pulled me to one side and rightfully so.
As my opening line, the original
post was spot on. We can't keep saying he is shit because of his dad. He needs to sort himself out and save his career so that he can give the best life to his own family.8 -
Have you thought about volunteering to work for the Samaritans? I'm sure they'd love you to use, well I was fine so you should be to.Todds_right_hook said:
I think the original post was spot on. I lost my mum before I was 25. I was due to sit professional exams but deferred which was understandable given the circumstances.colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
I did them a year later when my head was clear using the fact that it would have made my mum
proud as motivation.If I kept putting my exams off, my boss would have pulled me to one side and rightfully so.
As my opening line, the original
post was spot on. We can't keep saying he is shit because of his dad. He needs to sort himself out and save his career so that he can give the best life to his own family.6 - Sponsored links:
-
I'd blame him for Aneke as well.DA9 said:
I’ll stick up for TS here, he is not a “football” man, who was he supposed to go to for advice? Gallen was the incumbent at the time, blame him, not TSNorth Lower Neil said:
I mean presumably he did listen to Gallen given he'd wanted Kirk for a while.Dazzler21 said:
If Sandgaard had just listened to scouts with the money he spent we could have easily been in the Championship right now.Rothko said:I finally gave up on Charlie last night, and he's the prime example of the Sandgaard era, loads spent badly
But the general point is spot on - Sandgaard at the start at least was genuinely trying to do well and putting some money in, which we rarely have, and just did it so badly because of a failure to get some decent advice.0 -
Who said i'm fine? Losing my mum at a relatively young age was by far the saddest event of my life that I think about every day and will always struggle to come to terms with. I had two choices, to use it as an excuse to plod along in life or to use it as motivation to succeed and not only provide for my family but also ensure we have fun times and enjoy life.colthe3rd said:
Have you thought about volunteering to work for the Samaritans? I'm sure they'd love you to use, well I was fine so you should be to.Todds_right_hook said:
I think the original post was spot on. I lost my mum before I was 25. I was due to sit professional exams but deferred which was understandable given the circumstances.colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
I did them a year later when my head was clear using the fact that it would have made my mum
proud as motivation.If I kept putting my exams off, my boss would have pulled me to one side and rightfully so.
As my opening line, the original
post was spot on. We can't keep saying he is shit because of his dad. He needs to sort himself out and save his career so that he can give the best life to his own family.
9 -
Perhaps he should have stayed with Crewe and not signed a bumper increase on his salary.colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
Staying with Crewe would have meant being with his loved ones.1 -
When I have had close members of family passing away, I have found occupying myself with work has helped take my mind off of things.colthe3rd said:
It would but equally we don't know so can't speculate. However, if he is going through stuff to do with the loss of his dad I think it's very poor taste from the other poster to suggest that he needs to get over it as it was 2 years ago.Gribbo said:
Tbh, it would explain why he was once a decent player and now appears to be struggling. Never know what others are going through and it don't necessarily have to have anything to do with him losing a parent.....colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
Not sure what position that puts the Club and supporters in, but obviously the blokes mental health should be considered amongst all this
As an aside, I do not think @blackpool72 has been rude.2 -
Think the Black Box was in beta mode at the time...ShootersHillGuru said:I think last night burned any bridges Kirk had with Appleton too. He hinted as much and included a few others. I feel for Kirk. Somethings gone horribly wrong for him and I’m sure his life is pretty miserable as far as his football goes. Even if we have to pay all his wages I think it makes sense to loan him out in January. I really don’t see the club paying up his contract. He’s floundering at Charlton and for his sake needs to get away. I know I keep saying it but who scouted him and thought paying serious money for league one.0 -
He just needs to move on from Charlton, it just hasn't worked out for him here. Speculating about possible mental health issues etc doesn't help anyone1
-
I think you need to balance that against the good signings he did pick out. It's also worth looking back at Kirk stats before joining us, highly rated as a playmaker with quite a few clubs chasing his signature at the time. What went wrong ?ElfsborgAddick said:
I'd blame him for Aneke as well.DA9 said:
I’ll stick up for TS here, he is not a “football” man, who was he supposed to go to for advice? Gallen was the incumbent at the time, blame him, not TSNorth Lower Neil said:
I mean presumably he did listen to Gallen given he'd wanted Kirk for a while.Dazzler21 said:
If Sandgaard had just listened to scouts with the money he spent we could have easily been in the Championship right now.Rothko said:I finally gave up on Charlie last night, and he's the prime example of the Sandgaard era, loads spent badly
But the general point is spot on - Sandgaard at the start at least was genuinely trying to do well and putting some money in, which we rarely have, and just did it so badly because of a failure to get some decent advice.0 -
Some players must regret joining Charlton when their careers regress as his has. I'm not apportioning blame for that, but Kirk doesn't perform at the required level, so for that reason alone, without conducting some half arsed psycho analysis on him, he needs to move on.
3 -
This is all a bit ‘No - I’m Spartacus’. I lost my mum at a very young age to lung cancer and had a nervous breakdown afterwards and was a total basket case for years.Todds_right_hook said:
Who said i'm fine? Losing my mum at a relatively young age was by far the saddest event of my life that I think about every day and will always struggle to come to terms with. I had two choices, to use it as an excuse to plod along in life or to use it as motivation to succeed and not only provide for my family but also ensure we have fun times and enjoy life.colthe3rd said:
Have you thought about volunteering to work for the Samaritans? I'm sure they'd love you to use, well I was fine so you should be to.Todds_right_hook said:
I think the original post was spot on. I lost my mum before I was 25. I was due to sit professional exams but deferred which was understandable given the circumstances.colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
I did them a year later when my head was clear using the fact that it would have made my mum
proud as motivation.If I kept putting my exams off, my boss would have pulled me to one side and rightfully so.
As my opening line, the original
post was spot on. We can't keep saying he is shit because of his dad. He needs to sort himself out and save his career so that he can give the best life to his own family.Doesn’t mean I need to bow down in front of you as you dealt with it so much better.
As it happens I am now in a better place but I have never recovered in terms of how I deal with criticism etc. I have a massive short fuse and snap at anything. So in that sense it has always been with me.
It’s this element that means I don’t have a clue how sportsmen in the public eye (and their families) deal with criticism.
If my family was receiving the comments Charlie has had here? I think I would be biting back ten times harder (I was bullied at school and always remember my dad telling me there is always something nastier you can say back).
I think I would be a liability - especially looking at the state of some of the people on social having a go.5 -
I do wonder since he obviously did well at Crewe and obviously has an afffinity there why they haven't seemingly come in for him back to be honest? we can't seriously be still clinging on for money back surely? And he can't seriously be expecting to not have to take a pay cut to stay in the game and rebuild. Is it really worth one more year at good money but become a pariah that potentially either goes back to non league or gives up entirely and has to find a new career?1
- Sponsored links:
-
colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
Too true. My wife lost her Mum nearly two years ago now but she is still having bad days. I don’t think anyone should presume how someone else is feeling and how that affects their day to day life.7 -
Long out of credit was Gallen.Bailey said:
I think you need to balance that against the good signings he did pick out. It's also worth looking back at Kirk stats before joining us, highly rated as a playmaker with quite a few clubs chasing his signature at the time. What went wrong ?ElfsborgAddick said:
I'd blame him for Aneke as well.DA9 said:
I’ll stick up for TS here, he is not a “football” man, who was he supposed to go to for advice? Gallen was the incumbent at the time, blame him, not TSNorth Lower Neil said:
I mean presumably he did listen to Gallen given he'd wanted Kirk for a while.Dazzler21 said:
If Sandgaard had just listened to scouts with the money he spent we could have easily been in the Championship right now.Rothko said:I finally gave up on Charlie last night, and he's the prime example of the Sandgaard era, loads spent badly
But the general point is spot on - Sandgaard at the start at least was genuinely trying to do well and putting some money in, which we rarely have, and just did it so badly because of a failure to get some decent advice.
Aneke has to be the most ridiculous signing in our history.
I'd like to know how many people made money out of this signing.
As for Kirk, he was meant to be a good signing, some may say he's lethargic and disinterested, some can say he's lazy. Either way, it's not worked and he will probably sit tight on his contract, which I do not have too much of a problem with tbf.0 -
I’m just glad that now everyone can see what I’ve been saying about him for a long time. He’s an actual fraud. Each and every player for Cray Valley PM are better than him, I am genuinely in belief of that. If he ever plays for us again, that’ll tell you everything you need to know about where we are and where we are heading as a club. Literally play anyone else.
4 -
The comments RE his dad I don’t think are fair. He might still be really struggling, and that might be the spark in his life that he no longer has.
However, he’s had so many opportunities and no matter what is going on, you put in effort. He’s not got you the attitude, he has a serious and pathetic lack of effort, lack of work-rate, and lack basic knowledge of the game. And those, as well as being a generally poor footballer, is why he’s never going to make it and why he’s stealing a living.4 -
The worst thing about Kirk last night wasn't missing the chances.
It was on 30/31 minutes, when he went arm to arm with their player and collapsed to the turf, as if he had been elbowed in the face.
He stayed there whilst they broke away and nearly scored.
I'm not exaggerating, when I say he doesn't appear to have the guts to play football.12 -
That’s a shitty response to someone opening up on a personal experience about a loss of a parent at a young age.colthe3rd said:
Have you thought about volunteering to work for the Samaritans? I'm sure they'd love you to use, well I was fine so you should be to.Todds_right_hook said:
I think the original post was spot on. I lost my mum before I was 25. I was due to sit professional exams but deferred which was understandable given the circumstances.colthe3rd said:
Out of order comment imo. You've got no idea what's going on in his personal life, none of us do. People process grief in different ways and it affects everyone differently.blackpool72 said:Losing his dad was sad, but no worse than anybody else Losing their dad.
It was about 2 years ago so we can't keep using it as a reason for him playing shit.
This isn't to absolve him of any blame, he's not currently meeting the standard required and a number of different managers and coaches have tried. Seems there must be something in training that managers see that means he does keep getting picked, perhaps it is mental but we can't say. To just assume that some people aren't affected more than others by the loss of their dad is a bit crass.
I did them a year later when my head was clear using the fact that it would have made my mum
proud as motivation.If I kept putting my exams off, my boss would have pulled me to one side and rightfully so.
As my opening line, the original
post was spot on. We can't keep saying he is shit because of his dad. He needs to sort himself out and save his career so that he can give the best life to his own family.11 -
How shit is this one then…😬Gribbo said:I've been quite critical of Kirk, but I'm currently working with an Charlton player who reckons that he's always been a quality player when he's played against him, and he's pretty emphatic about it. 🤷♂️
0 -
Did he even make one tackle all game?
He just looks completely uninterested.
I don't ever want to see him in a Charlton shirt again.0 -
I'm not sure he's made one tackle since he's been here.KBslittlesis said:Did he even make one tackle all game?
He just looks completely uninterested.
I don't ever want to see him in a Charlton shirt again.3 -
What are your thoughts on how he achieved a goal and assist record with Crewe that convinced us to pay half a million for him and give him a 4 year contract?Sage said:I’m just glad that now everyone can see what I’ve been saying about him for a long time. He’s an actual fraud. Each and every player for Cray Valley PM are better than him, I am genuinely in belief of that. If he ever plays for us again, that’ll tell you everything you need to know about where we are and where we are heading as a club. Literally play anyone else.
I don't rate his ability or attitude but this isn't a non-league player who had a purple patch for a couple of months and got lucky when Pardew gave him a contract. He made over 200 appearances for Crewe in L1 and L2 across 6 seasons. Even not being good enough for us he did enough to break through with them and make an impact at a professional level.12
This discussion has been closed.
