Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Rumours Rumours - Summer 2021 edition (Deadline Day from p814)
Comments
-
Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey
Washington
Maddison
Bogle
Watson
Gunter
Inniss
Jaiyesimi
Shinnie
Loans:
Smith
Smyth
Maatsen
Stockley
Levitt
Famewo
Millar
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.3 -
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
38 -
Think I'm going to be whooshed here :-):smile: but.... he's been in with Ged & Ruben, recruitment is a separate topicLargeAddick said:
been asked already, nobody has responded as yet.WSS said:“I’ve been in with Ged [Roddy, technical director] and Ruben, from a recruitment point of view, it’s just trying to make sure I’ve got my finger on the pulse of everything that is going on.
“I want to be here and drive us on, as much as I can.”
No mention of Gallen here. And who is Ruben?
0 -
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.8 -
11 goals and a fair few games playing out wide is only alright?SELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.4 -
He's done well for the circumstances but yeah I'd say he's only alright.colthe3rd said:
11 goals and a fair few games playing out wide is only alright?SELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.3 -
Horses for courses, I thought he was classSELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.5 -
What circumstances?Vfrf said:
He's done well for the circumstances but yeah I'd say he's only alright.colthe3rd said:
11 goals and a fair few games playing out wide is only alright?SELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.2 -
Sure but did he cement a place in a top league one side? No.CAFCsayer said:
Horses for courses, I thought he was classSELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.
Did he look like he could play a level above? No.0 -
"I’ve been in with Ged [Roddy, technical director] and Ruben, from a recruitment point of view, it’s just trying to make sure I’ve got my finger on the pulse of everything that is going on"charltonbob said:
Think I'm going to be whooshed here :-):smile: but.... he's been in with Ged & Ruben, recruitment is a separate topicLargeAddick said:
been asked already, nobody has responded as yet.WSS said:“I’ve been in with Ged [Roddy, technical director] and Ruben, from a recruitment point of view, it’s just trying to make sure I’ve got my finger on the pulse of everything that is going on.
“I want to be here and drive us on, as much as I can.”
No mention of Gallen here. And who is Ruben?
LargeAddick said:
been asked already, nobody has responded as yet.WSS said:“I’ve been in with Ged [Roddy, technical director] and Ruben, from a recruitment point of view, it’s just trying to make sure I’ve got my finger on the pulse of everything that is going on.
“I want to be here and drive us on, as much as I can.”
No mention of Gallen here. And who is Ruben?
It didn't read that way to me.
To avoid multiple posts, I don't think Gallen is a Scout, in the sense that he unearths players no one else spots. He is a "contract and contacts" man.
By that I mean I don't think we have signed anyone since he has been here that anyone in the game would have said "bloody hell where did he find him" it's more "bloody hell how did he cut a deal for him".
Forster-Caskey, Page, Inniss, Williams even Josh Parker are good examples of that.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
I rate Washington. I really like his work rate, and I agree with you. With better players around him, I think he can definitely contribute more goalsDazzler21 said:
Without his injury Washington was on target for 15.TheAddicks4Ever said:8 -
The fact he hasn't been playing as an out and out striker for most of the season?cafcfan1990 said:
What circumstances?Vfrf said:
He's done well for the circumstances but yeah I'd say he's only alright.colthe3rd said:
11 goals and a fair few games playing out wide is only alright?SELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.0 -
That surely supports the view that his goals tally is more than ok?Vfrf said:
The fact he hasn't been playing as an out and out striker for most of the season?cafcfan1990 said:
What circumstances?Vfrf said:
He's done well for the circumstances but yeah I'd say he's only alright.colthe3rd said:
11 goals and a fair few games playing out wide is only alright?SELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.1 -
Isn't Ruben the HR guy?0
-
What did my original reply say?cafcfan1990 said:
That surely supports the view that his goals tally is more than ok?Vfrf said:
The fact he hasn't been playing as an out and out striker for most of the season?cafcfan1990 said:
What circumstances?Vfrf said:
He's done well for the circumstances but yeah I'd say he's only alright.colthe3rd said:
11 goals and a fair few games playing out wide is only alright?SELR_addicks said:
Wouldn't say Shinnie was good. Spent money getting him on loan, then signing him to get in Matt Smith on loan...end up releasing him after.Dazzler21 said:
With ridiculous restrictions in place.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey - okay signing (injury)
Washington - good signing
Maddison - Poor signing
Bogle - poor signing or poor management?
Watson - below average
Gunter - below average
Inniss - okay signing (injuries)
Jaiyesimi - good signing
Shinnie - good signing
Loans:
Smith - bad signing
Smyth - Okay signing
Maatsen - Good signing
Stockley - Good signing
Levitt - Bad signing
Famewo - okay signing (injuries)
Millar - Good signing
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
Gunter and Watson on 2 year deals is an awful decision.
Jaiyesimi it's still early to say but at the moment he's only okay to me. Washington again is alright but wouldn't say I'd have him in a top League One side.0 -
Stupid suggestion but could Ruben be a shorten version of Rubenshaw?0
-
No. That would shorten to Rubes or The Rubester.CharltonKerry said:Stupid suggestion but could Ruben be a shorten version of Rubenshaw?21 -
Gallen was off that day ..WSS said:“I’ve been in with Ged [Roddy, technical director] and Ruben, from a recruitment point of view, it’s just trying to make sure I’ve got my finger on the pulse of everything that is going on.
“I want to be here and drive us on, as much as I can.”
No mention of Gallen here. And who is Ruben?
0 -
Nigel was in at the training ground that day. I don't think Steve was. I don't believe there is any drama.12
-
I thought the rumour out there is that Chuks hasn't rejected the deal we have put to him but neither has he signed it yet. He seems to have some Championship clubs interested and is probably weighing up his options.0
-
Sponsored links:
-
Yup, have you heard other wise?MuttleyCAFC said:I thought the rumour out there is that Chuks hasn't rejected the deal we have put to him but neither has he signed it yet. He seems to have some Championship clubs interested and is probably weighing up his options.0 -
-
I would prefer Dion Charles over Colby Bishop!0
-
In that case I'd tell him to sign the contract or fuck offMuttleyCAFC said:I thought the rumour out there is that Chuks hasn't rejected the deal we have put to him but neither has he signed it yet. He seems to have some Championship clubs interested and is probably weighing up his options.1 -
We were still under an embargo when Washington and Gilbey signed.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey
Washington
Maddison
Bogle
Watson
Gunter
Inniss
Jaiyesimi
Shinnie
Loans:
Smith
Smyth
Maatsen
Stockley
Levitt
Famewo
Millar
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
not Sandgaard signings were they?2 -
Why? he isn't a Charlton fan. He needs persuading. If we wanted a team full of Charlton fans it would probably be a shit team.blackpool72 said:
In that case I'd tell him to sign the contract or fuck offMuttleyCAFC said:I thought the rumour out there is that Chuks hasn't rejected the deal we have put to him but neither has he signed it yet. He seems to have some Championship clubs interested and is probably weighing up his options.8 -
In Ruben Gallen we trust.2
-
I love the fact there was a rumour 8 hours ago and it got 1 like and 2 comments 😂😂2
-
This is Reubens.
6 -
If anything that makes it worse.CafcSCP said:
We were still under an embargo when Washington and Gilbey signed.SELR_addicks said:Since Sangaard arrived these are the 'Gallen' signings:
Gilbey
Washington
Maddison
Bogle
Watson
Gunter
Inniss
Jaiyesimi
Shinnie
Loans:
Smith
Smyth
Maatsen
Stockley
Levitt
Famewo
Millar
Wouldn't say judging from that Gallen would give off the greatest first impression to Thomas.
not Sandgaard signings were they?
Takes away 2 of the best signings Gallen has made from that list.1
This discussion has been closed.
