Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: Charlton vs Sunderland 1998 play-off final

RedRyan
RedRyan Posts: 911
in General Charlton
At the match or on the stream:

Illic
Mills
Bowen
K. Jones
Rufus
Youds
Newton
Kinsella
Bright
Mendonca
Heaney

subs:
S. Jones
Robinson
Brown

Comments

  • seth plum
    seth plum Posts: 53,448
    Stream, and live!

    Illic 6
    Mills 6
    Bowen 7
    K. Jones 7.5
    Rufus 7.5
    Youds 7.5
    Newton 7
    Kinsella 8
    Bright 7
    Mendonca 10
    Heaney 6.5

    subs:
    S. Jones 7
    Robinson 7
    Brown 7.5
  • mattwils
    mattwils Posts: 212
    What a match and I’d forgotten what a great team we had. Unbelievable effort from all of them. Kinsella, Rufus and sir Clive were so good in those days! First time I’ve seen the whole game since being at Wembley 
  • mattwils
    mattwils Posts: 212
    Sorry tens all round too
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,222
    Ilic 4 at fault for every goal and pen, Gray was an easy save, poor distribution.
  • masicat
    masicat Posts: 5,008



    Illic 6
    Mills 8
    Bowen 8
    K. Jones 8.5
    Rufus 9
    Youds 8
    Newton 7.5
    Kinsella 9
    Bright 7
    Mendonca 11
    Heaney 7

    subs:
    S. Jones 8
    Robinson8
    Brown 7

  • Talal
    Talal Posts: 11,487
    Brown deserves at least an 8 for that tackle alone. 
  • wmcf123
    wmcf123 Posts: 5,824
    masicat said:



    Illic 6
    Mills 8
    Bowen 8
    K. Jones 8.5
    Rufus 9
    Youds 8
    Newton 7.5
    Kinsella 9
    Bright 7
    Mendonca 11
    Heaney 7

    subs:
    S. Jones 8
    Robinson8
    Brown 7

    Mills had an absolute shocker 
  • Chizz
    Chizz Posts: 28,335
    Illic 7
    Mills 7
    Bowen 8
    K. Jones 8
    Rufus 7
    Youds 7
    Newton 7
    Kinsella 8
    Bright 8
    Mendonca 9.5
    Heaney 8

    subs:
    S. Jones 9
    Robinson 8
    Brown 10 
  • ricky_otto
    ricky_otto Posts: 22,600
    At the game - I think I still have a hangover 22 years on

    Ilic 7 - 9 clean sheets in a row, but the big occasion got to him
    Mills 7 - I like him, will hate him when he has his 2nd spell at the club
    Bowen 8 - Great player, shrew signing
    K. Jones 7.5 - unsung hero 
    Rufus 8 - Praise the Lord
    Youds 8 - Beast 
    Newton 7 - quiet, nervy pen
    Kinsella 7.5 - Standard 
    Bright 7 - did a good job 
    Mendonca 10 - No words are worthy 
    Heaney 7 - not bad

    subs:
    S. Jones 8 - changed the game. 
    Robinson 7.5 - did well
    Brown 8.5 - bone crunching tackle 
  • Sponsored links:



  • southamptonaddick
    southamptonaddick Posts: 4,054
    11 out of 10 for every single one of them.
    12 out of 10 for the support.

    COYA
  • Oggy Red
    Oggy Red Posts: 44,955
    Mendonca 10

    Hat trick and the 1st pen ..... my MOM.

    I know there will be some posters who'll say he's just a goal hanger, doesn't contribute, waste of space.
  • Sarrf_London
    Sarrf_London Posts: 523
    edited March 2020
    Never been a great fan of slow industrial type centre backs, and Youds was never a great favourite but from the replay rather than being there,  he had a superb game, four goals or not.
  • wmcf123
    wmcf123 Posts: 5,824
    Ilic 6 the beginning of end
    Mills 5 average
    Rufus 8
    Youds 7
    Bowen 8
    Newton 7.5 versatile
    K Jones 7.5
    Kinsella 7.5
    Heaney 7 always did a solid job
    Bright 7
    Mendonca 10

    S Jones 8
    Robinson 7.5
    Brown 8

  • ParkinsonOut
    ParkinsonOut Posts: 1,463
    At the game

    Illic 10
    Mills 10
    Bowen 10
    K. Jones 10
    Rufus 10
    Youds 10
    Newton 10
    Kinsella 10
    Bright 10
    Mendonca 10
    Heaney 10

    subs:
    S. Jones 10
    Robinson 10
    Brown 10
  • JamesSeed
    JamesSeed Posts: 17,380
    Illic 6 Rushed out like a nutter for 2nd, beaten at near post for 3rd. Lucky with the pen.
    Mills 5 At fault for third. Poor distribution. Past it.
    Bowen 8
    K. Jones 8
    Rufus 9
    Youds 6 At fault for the 1st
    Newton 8
    Kinsella 9
    Bright 7 Slow
    Mendonca 7 Should have scored four.
    Heaney 7

    subs:
    S. Jones 7
    Robinson 8 
    Brown 8

    Curbishly 6 Got it all wrong. Apart from the 'plenty of shots.' No Seed.

Categories

“Marketplace”