Players Marks: FA Cup R1 Charlton v Truro

Amos: 6.5
Solly: 6.5 good goal line clearance from him
Konsa: 6.5
Sarr: 6.5
DaSilva: 7.5 kept going and creating chances
Jackson: 6
Marshall: 4.5 he may end up being an important player for us but his performance first half was terrible
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Reeves: 7
Holmes: 7
Dodoo: 4
Fosu-Henry: 4.5

Ahearne-Grant: n/a
Clarke: n/a

Amos: 6
Solly: 6
Konsa: 5.5
Sarr: 6
DaSilva: 7
Jackson: 6
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Reeves: 7
Holmes: 7
Dodoo: 5.5
Fosu-Henry: 6

I usually respect marks, but for someone to watch that game and then give both Marshall and Sarr 4 but Holmes 8...it's just too damn wrong

Amos: 6, had little to do, pulled off two good saves in the game.
Solly: 6 was ok against a national league 1 south side.
Konsa: 6 same as solly
Sarr: 7 he covered well for the mistakes of Solly and Konsa, going foreward slow and passing not good
DaSilva: 7
Jackson: 5 Just about ok
Marshall: 5, looked tired from midweek game
Forster-Caskey: 6 ok
Reeves: 7 got into the wright positions which is why he scored two goals, two golas makes him motm just.
Holmes: 7, the driving force of the team.
Dodoo: 5, extra point for the goal. he needs more games with the developement squads not ready for the first team.
Fosu-Henry: 6

msomerton said:

Amos: 6, had little to do, pulled off two good saves in the game.
Solly: 6 was ok against a national league 1 south side.
Konsa: 6 same as solly
Sarr: 7 he covered well for the mistakes of Solly and Konsa, going foreward slow and passing not good
DaSilva: 7
Jackson: 5 Just about ok
Marshall: 5, looked tired from midweek game
Forster-Caskey: 6 ok
Reeves: 7 got into the wright positions which is why he scored two goals, two golas makes him motm just.
Holmes: 7, the driving force of the team.
Dodoo: 5, extra point for the goal. he needs more games with the developement squads not ready for the first team.
Fosu-Henry: 6

Dodoo didn't score

Amos: 7 Very sound.
Solly: 7 Steady and played some nice passes.
Konsa: 6 Some good bits but he's very weak in the air and wasn't great for their goal. One excellent twist and turn on the far touch line to get out trouble. Needs to fill out.
Sarr: 6 Bit shaky but grew into it. Wish he'd tried that cross-field diagonal a couple more times.
DaSilva: 7 Buzzed around and played very high.
Jackson: 6 Held his position and did ok. One very nice clipped ball over the top in the 2nd half.
Marshall: 6 Did ok but only started to see him at his best as the game got a bit more stretched 2nd half.
Forster-Caskey: 7 Mainly very efficient. He'll be disappointed not to have got at least one goal and didn't do nearly enough to shut down the cross for their goal.
Reeves: 8 Looks to have a killer pass in his locker and is a very sweet left foot finisher. He could provide the midfield goals a la Jackson.
Holmes: 7.5 Very persistent and a thorn in Truro's right side. On another day, he would've got a couple of goals.
Dodoo: 5 His touch was mainly ok and he was heavily marked (for long periods Truro had 5 at the back). Took up some excellent positions and was ignored once when he would have a tap in 2nd half. No Chance for him to run in behind because Truro were so deep.
Fosu-Henry: 5 He did lose the ball 3 or 4 times.....but every time he chased and got it back himself.

Amos: 7 Dealt with everything no chance with goal
Solly: 7 Got forward well
Konsa: 7 never looked up pressure
Sarr: 6 Gave the ball away too much today
DaSilva: 7 Always an outlet going forward
Jackson: 6.5 kept it ticking
Marshall: 6.5 all these games are good for his fitness.
Forster-Caskey: 7.5 was all over the park today.
Reeves: 7.5 took his goal very well. Can forgive his quiet moments if he keeps scoring
Holmes: 8 definitely makes Charlton tick. Involved in everything.
Dodoo: 5 Not good enough.
Fosu-Henry: 6 Greedy when he came on.