Diego Poyet To Snub England?

Tell me how since leaving us his career has progressed, if you can't then he has stagnated, stood still,

He may well have passed games played as a 19 yr old than cousins but since then what's he done

Absolutely squat, It don't make him a bad person, don't make him a bad player, and in the future he may turn out to be the best midfielder in the world, but right now since leaving us his career is no further forward, and imo he has not gained valuable mins on the pitch to learn his craft, not his undoubted quality as a natural footballer,

nth london addick said:

Tell me how since leaving us his career has progressed, if you can't then he has stagnated, stood still,

He may well have passed games played as a 19 yr old than cousins but since then what's he done

Absolutely squat, It don't make him a bad person, don't make him a bad player, and in the future he may turn out to be the best midfielder in the world, but right now since leaving us his career is no further forward, and imo he has not gained valuable mins on the pitch to learn his craft, not his undoubted quality as a natural footballer,

yup training day in and day out with International experience, and premier league experience like

Nolan
Downing
Carroll
Noble
Tompkins
Song
and staff like
Allardyce
Sheringham
Mcdonald

that will do nothing for his career will it

nth london addick said:

You can't then, what you can say is that he is in and around good pro's getting good training but that hasn't improved him enough to prove to sam allardyce that even though his team was on a terrible run until Saturday that Diego poyet could assist as he has shown that being involved and surrounded by the people you have mentioned he is not good enough to break through and progress into the first team

So he is no further along his development and as such has stood still


Thought so, hence why I said it

Would Cousins get in the West Ham 1st team NO
why becuase senior pro's are ahead of him
Alex Song- International and Champions League experience
Kevin Nolan-Fantastic goalscorer from Midfield
Mark Noble-West Ham Icon and a decent midfielder

have you seen him play recently, probably not

So how can you say he has not improved just because he is not starting ahead of them 3, it means nothing he might have got a lot better but them 3 still have more experience than him.

now if you have watched him play for their under 21's or watched him in training and think he has gone backwards then fair play and I am sorry for question you, but If you have not then there is no chance you can say he has not improved

paulie8290 said:

nth london addick said:

You can't then, what you can say is that he is in and around good pro's getting good training but that hasn't improved him enough to prove to sam allardyce that even though his team was on a terrible run until Saturday that Diego poyet could assist as he has shown that being involved and surrounded by the people you have mentioned he is not good enough to break through and progress into the first team

So he is no further along his development and as such has stood still


Thought so, hence why I said it

Would Cousins get in the West Ham 1st team NO
why becuase senior pro's are ahead of him
Alex Song- International and Champions League experience
Kevin Nolan-Fantastic goalscorer from Midfield
Mark Noble-West Ham Icon and a decent midfielder

have you seen him play recently, probably not

So how can you say he has not improved just because he is not starting ahead of them 3, it means nothing he might have got a lot better but them 3 still have more experience than him.

now if you have watched him play for their under 21's or watched him in training and think he has gone backwards then fair play and I am sorry for question you, but If you have not then there is no chance you can say he has not improved

I think you're wasting your time NLA...

How do you know if gomez Jordan or fox would have broken through, you don't so you can't say that

What you can say is that since leaving us poyet has not broken in to the west ham first team, this after leaving a club he was head and shoulders the best midfielder in, and was progressing really well

Therefore since leaving cafc he has so far not progressed at the pace he was at ours

Therefore he has stagnated in his progression despite, being around better training, players and coaching

Scoham said:

smudge7946 said:

I thought he was born in Spain

He was

Soo he hasn't snubbed England. He was born in Spain to a Uruguayian family.

As Homer Simpson once said.
"Hee hee u r a gay!."

I would have thought Poyet went to West ham because he thought he would be in the team most weeks, he didn't realize they were going to sign Song and he would struggle to get on the bench. Even with his dad's advise, this season have been a waste of time for Diego, i hope this is all being noted by Joe Gomez, now that he's playing most weeks.
Also John Bostock should be the lesson for all young players, not to move too early.

Last season was the season he broke through. I always thought given his age and the advice at his disposal, that he'd make the right football decision. He should have stayed with us and focused on getting better, but didn't. Next season is going to be very important for him, but he is a great example to other young players. But not for the right reason.

cafcfan said:

paulie8290 said:

Callumcafc said:

But what you can say is, whether he has improved at WHU or not, he'd have definitely progressed much more quickly than he has done by playing competitive games.

That's clear to see with the likes of Fox, now Cousins and even Gomez.

again if oyet was here yes he would be playing first team more than likely
if Fox, Gomez or Cousins went to West Ham would they start NO,
don't think you can say they have developed better than Poyet in that case

unless as I said u have seen him in training or under 21 games

According to Wet Spam's web site, he has made a grand total of three league appearances for their development squad. (in addition to three for their first team and two for Huddersfield.) While at Huddersfield, they played four games. He was an unused sub in one and not selected at all in the last game he was available for. Doesn't sound like he's setting the world alight to me!

You won't get a reply because you've completely finished the job NLA started and he won't have a reply. I know that the Poyet of last season wouldn't have a problem getting into Huddlesfields team.....

In pure terms the question comes down to whether it is better for a player's development to train with Premiership players but only play development football, or go out on loan where you lose the benefit of training with Premiership players, or be a regular first teamer in the Championship?

However we cannot talk solely about pure terms as filthy lucre always rears its ugly head.

nth london addick said:

Tell me how since leaving us his career has progressed, if you can't then he has stagnated, stood still,

He may well have passed games played as a 19 yr old than cousins but since then what's he done

Moved from what was then a bottom half Championship team without a manager to a top half Premier League club. And yes he has played in a handful of games.

Pretty decent progression if you ask me.

C_Jensens_Love_Child said:

paulie8290 said:

C_Jensens_Love_Child said:

cafcfan said:

paulie8290 said:

Callumcafc said:

But what you can say is, whether he has improved at WHU or not, he'd have definitely progressed much more quickly than he has done by playing competitive games.

That's clear to see with the likes of Fox, now Cousins and even Gomez.

again if oyet was here yes he would be playing first team more than likely
if Fox, Gomez or Cousins went to West Ham would they start NO,
don't think you can say they have developed better than Poyet in that case

unless as I said u have seen him in training or under 21 games

According to Wet Spam's web site, he has made a grand total of three league appearances for their development squad. (in addition to three for their first team and two for Huddersfield.) While at Huddersfield, they played four games. He was an unused sub in one and not selected at all in the last game he was available for. Doesn't sound like he's setting the world alight to me!

You won't get a reply because you've completely finished the job NLA started and he won't have a reply. I know that the Poyet of last season wouldn't have a problem getting into Huddlesfields team.....

Not replying because I know when to stop, otherwise I will lose my account.

Its clear I am the only person in the universe who think he made the right choice moving to a premier league club and don't think that at 19 years his career has stagnated

but then you reply to me? So answer this, if he has progressed as you state why did he not feature in all of Huddlesfields 4 games?

Apparently the Huddersfield manager isn't very good.