Grading Charlton's transfer activity to date
If Delort signs it goes up to an 8.
Comments
-
If church goes?0
-
Not being funny, but how can you properly rate it until you've seen the players play a few games and settle down ?
As it is, the same people who were excited when we signed Reza, PP and Nego will be excited, and the same people who were cautious will be, err cautious !11 -
Agree with you afka. Am excited but also haven't got too high expectations. Will wait and see!0
-
I agree @AFKABartram. Somewhere between 2 and 8 (if I had to put my head on the block)1
-
Are u avin a f*******g larf?0
-
A Football Manager '6'.0
-
Ask in 6 weeks.0
-
Hard to tell because I have never heard of one of our signings. We will see.1
-
I'm a little bit excited as probably for the first time since we signed Wright-Phillips we have signed someone I've heard of in Tal Ben Haim. Will have to reserve judgement on all the rest in case they turn out to be as disappointing as January's signings.0
-
I know where you are coming from figuratively speaking but as well as TBH what about Bikey, apart from last season in Greece he's been around in English football since 2006 :-0Huskaris said:Hard to tell because I have never heard of one of our signings. We will see.
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
They must be good if their reported fees of €2-3m are true but if we signed them for free or €200-300k then they're pony
*cough* Polish Pete #emperorsnewclothes1 -
Somewhere between P50 and P60. Medium to coarse.0
-
7-8 (If Delort signs) and it all goes to plan0
-
I have no idea who any of them are before we bought them and I've only seen them play in friendlies. Ridiculous question!0
-
Well we can't give a score for the players, but if we are looking purely at the amount of new faces, costs involved then I would say 80
-
People surprise me when they say they've never seen them play , everyone that was at the valley last season against Ipswich would of seen Henderson , everyone must of seen bikey and Ben Haim play a few times atleast as they have both played premier league football within the last 5 years , and moussa has played in England at various levels.1
-
Yes! Thank you All_Thaid_Up. That is what I actually meant (should have explained myself better).All_Thaid_Up said:Well we can't give a score for the players, but if we are looking purely at the amount of new faces, costs involved then I would say 8
How happy are we with the amount of transfer activity this season to date? How about the strategy? (looking abroad, a mix of young players and old pros like TBH)? Do we feel we have enough cover in all positions or are we still short? Should we have perhaps pursued other UK based targets more thoroughly such as O'Grady?
An overall score please.0 -
It is why the title of this thread is grading Charlton's transfer "activity" and not grading Charlton's "new signings". :-)0
-
I'd give it an 8 so far but we don't know how they're going to play yet but I really believe vetokele is going to be a special player for us , one more winger and Delort and I could give it a 9.0
-
SEVERN!1
-
Sponsored links:
-
Indeed.AFKABartram said:Not being funny, but how can you properly rate it until you've seen the players play a few games and settle down ?
As it is, the same people who were excited when we signed Reza, PP and Nego will be excited, and the same people who were cautious will be, err cautious !
I was mostly excited for the signings of Cedric Evina and Mikel Alonso 3 years ago...0 -
Read my comment at 11:06 Dave2IDave2l said:
Indeed.AFKABartram said:Not being funny, but how can you properly rate it until you've seen the players play a few games and settle down ?
As it is, the same people who were excited when we signed Reza, PP and Nego will be excited, and the same people who were cautious will be, err cautious !
I was mostly excited for the signings of Cedric Evina and Mikel Alonso 3 years ago...0 -
Wait till Christmas, then judge.0
-
Have to admit i am exicted about the potential of our signings. Vetokele, Gudmunden, Moussa and Tucudean sound like good attacking options. Bueyen sounds useful and Bikey and Ben Haim have reputations as good defenders.0
-
Fair enough for "transfer activity", but other than pre season squad playing together, its still too early to judge, but following by what you mean, I go for an instictive 7.5/10flyingkiwiDK said:
Read my comment at 11:06 Dave2IDave2l said:
Indeed.AFKABartram said:Not being funny, but how can you properly rate it until you've seen the players play a few games and settle down ?
As it is, the same people who were excited when we signed Reza, PP and Nego will be excited, and the same people who were cautious will be, err cautious !
I was mostly excited for the signings of Cedric Evina and Mikel Alonso 3 years ago...1
