Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Players Marks: Charlton v Q.P.R.
lancashire lad
Posts: 15,702
For those of you at the Valley this afternoon your marks out of 10 please and include Ajdarevic and Tudgat as they completed 30 minutes:
Thuram
Wilson
Morrison
Dervite
Wiggins
Green
Cousins
Poyet
Jackson
Reza
Church
Ajdarevic
Tudgay
Harriott n/a
Thuram
Wilson
Morrison
Dervite
Wiggins
Green
Cousins
Poyet
Jackson
Reza
Church
Ajdarevic
Tudgay
Harriott n/a
0
Comments
-
lancashire lad said:
For those of you at the Valley this afternoon your marks out of 10 please and include Ajdarevic and Tudgat as they completed 30 minutes:
Thuram 5
Wilson 7
Morrison 6
Dervite 6
Wiggins 7
Green 5
Cousins 6
Poyet 6
Jackson 7
Reza 6
Cousins (church) 7
Ajdarevic 6
Tudgay 6
Harriott n/a0 -
thanks Dan
0 -
Thuram - 4
Wilson - 8
Morrison - 7.5
Dervite - 7
Wiggins - 7
Green - 6
Cousins - 8
Poyet - 9 Outstanding
Jackson - 7
Reza - 6
Church - 6.5
Ajdarevic - 7.5
Tudgay - 6
Harriott n/a0 -
Thuram 6
Wilson 8
Morrison 8
Dervite 8
Wiggins 8
Green 5
Cousins 7
Poyet 8
Jackson 9
Reza 6
Church 60 -
Thurman 4 ? Other then that dodgy pass what did he do wrong ? Seriously I question some peoples intelligence on hereBedsaddick said:
Thuram - 4
Wilson - 8
Morrison - 7.5
Dervite - 7
Wiggins - 7
Green - 6
Cousins - 8
Poyet - 9 Outstanding
Jackson - 7
Reza - 6
Church - 6.5
Ajdarevic - 7.5
Tudgay - 6
Harriott n/a11 -
Thuram 5
Wilson 8
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 8
Green 3
Cousins 6
Poyet 8
Jackson 7 (+1 for the goal)
Reza 6
Church 5
Ajdarevic 7
Tudgay 6
Harriott n/a0 -
Based on his performance you have Jackson a 6 ? Really I didnt want him to start but come on he was excellent todayDeeBee said:Thuram 5
Wilson 8
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 8
Green 3
Cousins 6
Poyet 8
Jackson 7 (+1 for the goal)
Reza 6
Church 5
Ajdarevic 7
Tudgay 6
Harriott n/a
1 -
Game of opinions. Thought he was decent but there were better players, goal was special obviouslyCharltonByBlood said:
Based on his performance you have Jackson a 6 ? Really I didnt want him to start but come on he was excellent todayDeeBee said:Thuram 5
Wilson 8
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 8
Green 3
Cousins 6
Poyet 8
Jackson 7 (+1 for the goal)
Reza 6
Church 5
Ajdarevic 7
Tudgay 6
Harriott n/a0 -
First time I've been able to do scores this year as I watched the streaming, loved every minute of it particularly the 92nd
Thuram 6 did not have much to do
Wilson 8
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 8
Green 4
Cousins 6
Poyet 8 looks a serious talent
Jackson 7 a great captain, enough said
Reza 6
Church 6
Ajdarevic 7 looks class
Tudgay 6
Harriott n/a0 -
Thuram 5 - Didn't have a lot to do in truth. Still doesn't stop him being a lucky, lucky boy.
Wilson 8 - Bundles of energy. Effective at the back as well as going forward
Morrison 9 - Granite Rock
Dervite 7 - Solid enough
Wiggins 7.5 - Also effective down the left wing and contributed a lot to the late attacks
Green 5 - Weak imo and displayed why he probably should move on
Cousins 7 - Started very strongly got stuck in the midfield
Poyet 7.5 - Like cousins, strong from the start
Jackson 9 - Vitlaly important in the midfield. YET again, comes up with the goods
Reza 5.5 - Not partcularly strong and should have scored early doors
Church 5 - Ran around a lot but not sure he contributed much to the attacking play
Ajdarevic 8 - Looked excellent when he came on. Great effort at the end that ultimately led to the goal
Tudgay 8 - Looked sharp. Unlucky with the overhead kick
Harriott n/a0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Watched on Tv
Thuram - 5 really had little to do so cant mark him higher or lower
Wilson - 8 very assured and shut down Traore all day long
Morrison - 8 solid and uncompromising
Dervite - 7 did his job, quiet and effective
Wiggins - 8 thought he had an exceptional game
Green - 5 inneffective
Cousins - 8 superb
Poyet - 8 enjoying these first and probably final few appearances
Jackson - 9 all over the shop in the best possible way
Reza - 5 lightweight think this is a huge step up for him
Church - 7 battled hard, a true Charlton performance
Ajdarevic - 7 looks to be an excellent aquisition
Tudgay - 7 intelligent link up play, should start ahead of Reza
Harriott n/a
0 -
Watched on internet stream.
Thuram - 6 (nothing to do!)
Wilson - 8
Morrison - 8
Dervite - 7
Wiggins - 7
Green - 6
Cousins - 7
Poyet - 8
Jackson - 7.5
Reza - 6
Church - 6
Ajdarevic - 7.5
Tudgay - 6
Harriott 80 -
They are my marks not yours. remember that . Stick to just giving your own ratings , not questioning people's intelligence and criticising everyone else's marks.CharltonByBlood said:
Thurman 4 ? Other then that dodgy pass what did he do wrong ? Seriously I question some peoples intelligence on hereBedsaddick said:
Thuram - 4
Wilson - 8
Morrison - 7.5
Dervite - 7
Wiggins - 7
Green - 6
Cousins - 8
Poyet - 9 Outstanding
Jackson - 7
Reza - 6
Church - 6.5
Ajdarevic - 7.5
Tudgay - 6
Harriott n/a12 -
Thuram 6
Wilson 8
Morrison 7.5
Dervite 6.5
Wiggins 6.5
Green 5
Cousins 7
Poyet 8
Jackson 8.5
Reza 6.5
Church 6.5
Ajdarevic 6.5
Tudgay 60 -
Thuram - 6
Wilson - 8
Morrison - 7.5
Dervite - 7
Wiggins - 8
Green - 5
Cousins - 7
Poyet - 8
Jackson - 8
Reza - 6.5
Church - 7
Ajdarevic - 7.5
Tudgay - 6.50 -
Thuram - 6
Wilson - 8
Morrison - 7
Dervite - 7
Wiggins - 7
Green - just FUCK off (no point)
Cousins - 7
Poyet - 8
Jackson - 7
Reza - 6
Church - 7
Ajdarevic - 6
Tudgay - 71 -
Thuram 6 - apart from having to deal with Dervites bullit back pass and the save at the end nothing to do no shots on target from their 13 attempts
Wilson 8 MOM
Morrison 6 better but stlll worries me
Dervite 5 not good enough
Wiggins 7 thank god Hes back
Green 4 shocking too many backward passes
Cousins 7.5 loved his reluctance to play wide after callum came on, he gets it if Powell doesn't
Poyet 7.5 won't be here long unfortunately absolute quality footballer
Jackson 5 good goal masked a labored effort
Reza 6 a real handful with his intelligent runs,
Church 5 like dervite not good enough
Ajdarevic 7 only when he came on did we up the tempo and looked like we could create something
Tudgay like his attitude will be ok for us, very intelligent pass selection1 -
Jacko a laboured effort?!0
-
Thuram-7(kept us in in with a great save at the end)
Wilson-8
Morrison-9
Dervite-8
Wiggins-8
Green-6(Very Very Poor)
Cousins-8
Poyet-8
Jackson-10-MOM(Never give 10's but how much effort did he put in everywhere you looked there he was )
Reza-8
Church-8
Ajdarevic-8
Tudgay-7(Looked very strong)1 -
Thuram - 6
Wilson - 6
Morrison - 6
Dervite - 6
Wiggins - 6
Green - 5
Cousins - 7
Poyet - 8 MOM
Jackson - 7
Reza - 5
Church - 5
Ajdarevic - 6
Tudgay - 6
Harriott - 60 -
Sponsored links:
-
Based on my observations of a stuttering live feed...
Thuram 6
Wilson 7
Morrison 7
Dervite 7
Wiggins 6
Green 5
Cousins 6
Poyet 6
Jackson 7
Reza 6
Church 6
Ajdarevic 8
Tudgay 7
Harriott n/a
0 -
Thuram - 5 decent save at the end. Not sure quite how good the save at the end was, would like to see it again. Distribution is unbelievably awful.
Wilson - 9 MoM - absolutely devoted to the cause going forward and in defence. Love him.
Morrison - 6. Solid I suppose
Dervite -6 as above.
Wiggins -7.5 - great going forward as always, very good and talented with the ball at his feet, looks to receive the ball well.
Green - 5. Given up on him now I think and I liked him. Having said this people have to realise the debate now isn't green v wagstaff it is green v Pritchard....
Cousins - 8 - fantastic, absolutely brilliant at winning the ball and a good eye going forward, worked effectively lapping over with Wilson.
Poyet - 8.5 - no idea how this guy is so good, he is one we will do so well to keep. The amount of times he snuffed out an attack was impossible to count.
Jackson -7.5 - very good, he will be our top goal scorer.
Reza - 5. Lightweight.
Church - 5.5 - lightweight and quick.
Ajdarevic - 8. Makes a huge difference, glad Stephens went if it means him cousins and Poyet are the heart of the mid.
Tudgay -7 - much better than church or Reza but still not too amazing. Held the ball up better than the other two though and seemed to know the way to the goal.
Harriott n/a
0 -
watched online.
Thuram 6 - what he did do today he tried his best to fluff up, not convinced at all.
Wilson 9 - Ravel Morrison who? Displayed all the things that were great about today's performance
Morrison - 7 solid
Dervite 7 - solid
Wiggins 7 - started brightly but faded a bit as the game went on
Green 4 - not good enough for the championship, given so many chances to prove himself but cant do it
Cousins 7.5 - Quality player
Poyet 8 - going to be a serious talent
Jackson 7.5 great goal and solid throughout
Reza 6 - desperately unlucky not to score but is really lightweight, grazed his chin and he didnt want to know
Church 6.5 - ran his socks off... not much else
Ajdarevic - 7.5 made a massive difference to our midfield
Tudgay 7 - not quite match sharp but looks like he could be that ric fuller player we've missed.
Harriott n/a - looked dangerous when he came on and a point to prove0 -
Thuram 6.5
Wilson 7.5
Morrison 7
Dervite 7
Wiggins 6.5
Green 6.5
Cousins 8.5
Poyet 7.5
Jackson 7.5
Reza 6
Church 8
Ajdarevic 8
Tudgay 7
0 -
Thuram 5 - Should be Hamer. Looks very unpredictable.
Wilson 7 - Looked solid.
Dervite 6 - Won some decent headers.
Morrison 8 - Looked a real centre half today. Leader at the back.
Wiggins 8.5 - Looked composed. Gave us genuine width
Green 4.5 - Nothing to offer going forward apart from set pieces. Not his level.
Cousins 7.5 - Never stopped working today. Put himself about.
Poyet 9 (MOM) - His tackle which won us the corner for the goal summed him up. Looked composed on the ball & fearless. One for the future.
Jackson 8.5 - Real passion about his game. Goal at the end sums up his importance.
Reza 6 - Nothing special. Could argue should of scored for the chance he had.
Church 6.5 - Ran his balls off today. Never looked a real threat however.
Subs
Ajdarevic 7- Added some fight to our performance. Gave us more threat going forward. Unlucky with his effort.
Tudgay 6.5 - Composed on the ball. Gave us more than Reza offered.0 -
Thuram 6 (had basically nothing to do, sharp when that late chance came to a QPR foot, needs to work on his football skills)
Wilson 9 (absolutely brilliant; his gutbusting run & tackle in the second half was epic)
Morrison 8 (unflustered, distributed ok today)
Dervite 8.5 (similarly unflustered, showed a touch of class now and then)
Wiggins 8 (good performance, overlapped well. crossing wasn't quite there today but everything else excellent)
Green 6.5 (much better than most people are claiming, put in a really energetic shift, including some neat tackles, looked to play through the middle rather than beat his man and cross, was largely efficient)
Cousins 7.5 (the new Vieira! Coped very well with their midfield, helped to outshine them at times)
Poyet 9 MOM (just sensational. CONTRACT PLEASE)
Jackson 8 (crisp-passing shift, usually made the right decision, goal)
Reza 6 (looked technically good, missed open goal)
Church 7 (is in the team for his shift, and duly obliged today)
Ajdarevic 8.5 (one of the best players I've seen play for us in 15 years of coming, sheer unbridled class)
Tudgay 7 (put in a very encouraging & skilful effort, harried their defence, looks like he belongs)0 -
Thuram 6
Wilson 7.5
Morrison 8
Dervite 8
Wiggins 7.5
Green 6
Cousins 7.5
Poyet 8.5
Jackson 8
Reza 6.5
Church 6.5
Ajdarevic 7
Tudgay 70 -
Thuram 7
Wilson 8
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 5
Green 6
Cousins 7
Poyet 8
Jackson 8
Reza 6
Church 6
Ajdarevic 8
Tudgay 8
Harriott n/a
0 -
Thuram 6
Wilson 8.5
Morrison 8
Dervite 8
Wiggins 8
Green 5
Cousins 8
Poyet 8
Jackson 8,5
Reza 6
Church 6
Ajdarevic 7.5
Tudgay 7
CP 8.5
Covered End 80 -
Thuram - 5
Wilson - 7
Morrison - 9
Dervite - 7
Wiggins -7
Green - 6
Cousins - 8
Poyet - 9
Jackson - 9
Reza - 6
Church - 6
Ajdarevic - 8
Tudgay - 7
Harriott n/a0
