Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Derby County

for those who managed to dodge the festive shopping can I have your marks out of ten.
Church and Harriott completed 30 minutes and are included
This thread will closed for marks at 10 a.m. on Monday.

Alnwick
Watson
Morrison
Dervite
wiggins
Green
Cousins
Pritchard
Stephens
Stewart
Kermorgant
Church
Harriott

Sordell n/a
«13

Comments

  • edited December 2013
    Nowhere near as bad as we was against Ipswich but we just lack that quality .


    Alnwick - 6
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Dervite - 6
    wiggins - 6.5
    Green - 7
    Cousins - 6.5
    Pritchard - 6
    Stephens 7.5 MOM
    Stewart - 7.5
    Kermorgant -5
    Church - 7
    Harriot - 6.5


  • Alnwick 4-kicking poor
    Wilson. 6-ok
    Morrison 6 -should have headed in
    Dervite 5 - got skinned often poor passing
    wiggins 7 - tried
    Green. 6.5 - also tried
    Cousins 5- passing poor
    Pritchard 5 - not enough vision
    Stephens 7 - looked good
    Stewart 6 - ok
    Kermorgant 5- to much arm waving when flicking on to no one
    Church 6- at least ran at defenders and keeper
    Harriot 5 -no time but didnt look stong enough
    Overall poor performance

  • strange most people i heard from said we done well just lacked any goal threat
  • edited December 2013
    Alnwick-6
    Wilson-7
    Morrison-7
    Dervite-6
    wiggins-7
    Green-6
    Cousins-7(MOM)
    Pritchard-5
    Stephens-7
    Stewart-6
    Kermorgant-6
    Church-6(How can a forward have such a weak shot)
    Harriott-6
  • Alnwick - 6 - Kicking wasnt great, couldnt do a thing for their two goals, made a great save just before half-time

    Wilson - 6.5 - Made some good runs and linked up well with Green

    Morrison - 7 - Tried to bring the ball out of Defence

    Dervite - 5 - Replace him with Wood, as all he does is hoof it away

    Wiggins - 6.5 - Played well apart from the slight mistake which allowed Derby to hit the bar

    Green - 6 - Had a good first 30mins but went missing after their goal

    Cousins - 7 (MOM) - Did some good passes and loved his tackle before running the length of the pitch with the ball, would have loved to have seen a battle with Hughes and him

    Pritchard - 5 - Couldnt stay on his feet, couldnt get into the game

    Stephens - 7 - Passed the ball well (apart from trying to be too clever at times), tracked back and tackled well also.

    Stewart - 6 - Went down a bit too easily today (Ref refused to buy it)

    Kermorgant - 6 - Had a good first half and really made a nuisance of himself, in the second half he was just a nuisance to the ref

    Subs
    Church - 6 - Difficult circumstances to try and make a difference

    Harriott - 5 - Again same as Church but tried to get through about 6/7 players on his own far too often, its a team game lad (but he's young and am sure he'll learn)
  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    Dervite 6
    wiggins 6.5
    Green 5
    Cousins 7
    Pritchard 5
    Stephens 6.5
    Stewart 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 6
    Harriott 6
  • Some must have been at a differrent game to me?
    How many clear chances did wé have?
  • Some must have been at a differrent game to me?
    How many clear chances did wé have?

    More than Derby thats for sure... Green's FK in the first half / inc. a couple of dangerous corners, right at the start of the second Stephens hit narrowly wide / Church forced a good save from Grant and Morrison was unlucky with a header.

    You sure you were watching???
  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 5
    Dervite 6
    wiggins 7
    Green 6
    Cousins 7
    Pritchard 6
    Stephens 8 mom
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 6
    Harriott 6
  • Alnwick 6.5
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 7
    Green 5
    Cousins 8
    Pritchard 6
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 6
    Harriott 6.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Alnwick - 6 shit kicking
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 5.5 needs some time on the bench, also missed a sitter
    Dervite - 6
    wiggins - 6.5 too good for our team, but is made to look poor with the players around him
    Green - 6 odd long throw, and cross not much else
    Cousins - 6.5
    Pritchard - 5 looked out of his depth again
    Stephens 7.5 MOM got stuck in looked up for it , wasn't sure if he wanted a red so he could have Xmas off
    Stewart - 5.5poor
    Kermorgant -6 doesn't look the same yann we once knew
    Church - 6 like his work rate, should of started
    Harriot - 5 frustrating, too many flicks , needs a gym membership ASAP
  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    wiggins 7
    Green 6
    Cousins 8
    Pritchard 4
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 5

    Church 6
    Harriott 5

  • Alnwick - 6.5 one great save, poor distribution for the most part

    Wilson - 7 good game. Surprised he went off

    Morrison - 6 one shot when he found himself in attacking position, poor passing out of defence.

    Dervite - 6 - wouldn't mind seeing with Wood alongside.

    Wiggins - 7 did well, nullified Derby down wing for most part, bar one attempt which hit bar.

    Green - 7 good game, impressed for the most part

    Cousins - 7.5 back to a very good performance after a few dips recently.

    Pritchard - 4 am quite often a fan, but I can't defend that performance. Wandered around, clueless and none of the industry that usually makes his game. Should have been taken off well before he was.

    Stephens - 7 played well, some good tackles and kept game going

    Stewart - 7 some good runs, beat his man consistently, some decent crosses

    Kermorgant - 5 poor. A few good touches, but just toothless as a striking force.

    Subs
    Church - 6 thought he slotted in well and showed more desire in first couple of minutes on pitch than Pritch all game.

    Harriott - 5 a few fancy touches, one attempted shot that Kermorgant blocked, not much else.

    I honestly don't think we were too far away from matching Derby. A lot poorer than I thought they'd be and despaired of their time wasting and some poor refereeing decisions.
  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    Dervite 5
    wiggins 6
    Green 5
    Cousins 6
    Pritchard 5
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 5
    Harriott 5
  • Alnwick - 5
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 6.5
    Dervite - 6
    Wiggins - 6
    Green - 6
    Cousins - 7.5
    Pritchard - 4
    Stephens - 7
    Stewart - 6
    Kermorgant - 5
    Church - 6
    Harriott - 6
  • Alnwick 6 don't think he was at fault for the first as it took a deflection. Kicking poor, throwing good, great save in first half
    Wilson 6 did OK
    Morrison 5.5 wish he'd scored
    Dervite 5.5 OK
    wiggins 6.5 was a threat
    Green 6 not a massive fan of Green but did OK today
    Cousins 6.5 Without him I think we would have been overrun in midfield.
    Pritchard 4.5 not as much energy as usual
    Stephens 7 MOM no faulting his effort today
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 5.5 looks fitter but why are we playing flick ons to no one?
    Church 5.5 his running made them nervous.
    Harriott 5.5 naive at times
  • Alnwick - 5
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 5
    Dervite - 5.5
    wiggins - 6
    Green - 5
    Cousins - 6.5
    Pritchard - 4
    Stephens - 6
    Stewart - 5.5
    Kermorgant - 4.5
    Church - 5
    Harriott - 6
  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 7
    Green 6
    Cousins 8
    Pritchard 5
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 6

    Church 6
    Harriott 6
  • Alnwick 6.5
    Wilson 6.5
    Wiggins 6
    Morrison 7
    Devite 6
    Green 6.5
    Cousins 6
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 6.5
    Pritchard 6
    Kermorgant 6.5

    Harriot 6.5
    Church 6
  • Alnwick 6.5
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6.5
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 7
    Green 5
    Cousins 7.5
    Pritchard 5
    Stephens 7.5
    Stewart 5.5
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 6.5
    Harriott 5.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    Dervite 6
    wiggins 6
    Green 6
    Cousins 7
    Pritchard 4
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 7
    Church 5
    Harriott 5

    The Upbeats 1000000000

  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 5
    Dervite 6
    wiggins 6
    Green 4
    Cousins 7
    Pritchard 4
    Stephens 7.5
    Stewart 4
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 6
    Harriott 4
  • Alnwick 6.5 Not a lot to do really.Competent and without Hamer's dramatic approach.
    Wilson 6.5 Got forward well with decent crosses.When Solly is back he should be given the right-wing supporting Green or Stewart.
    Morrison 7.0 Dealt with Martin but still prone to the odd wobble.How did he miss that chance?
    Dervite 6.5 Did most things well and had no great problems.
    Wiggins 7.5 No one to mark second half so had free rein to get forward and they didn't contain him.
    Green 6.5 Energetic display,unlucky to be subbed.
    Cousins 6.5 Wasted as a holding midfielder,a creative talent put on the back-burner.
    Pritchard 5.0 Not his fault that he was given a very odd role to play.A much better player but has lost confidence.
    Stephens 7.0 Excellent defensively,just pass the ball forward first time,please!
    Stewart 6.5 Good in patches,Derby aware of his shooting and kept him at arm's distance.
    Kermorgant 5.0 What are you doing? Just not the Kermy we know.What has happened?
    Church 6.5 Will chase everything.Please try setting him up for a shot on goal.
    Harriott 6.0 Energetic and skillful but needs to learn when to play in to others and when to just pass.
  • Alnwick - 6.5 - no chance with either goal. Handling was sound but kicking was wayward
    Wilson - 6.5 - occasional scuffed pass but generally defended well and made some good attacking runs. When he came off there was no protection at all on the right - hence their second goal.
    Morrison - 5.5 - failed to dominate an immobile Martin which should have been easy. Bad miss from Kermo's cross (but at least he was up there!)
    Dervite - 5.5 - did nothing of any note
    Wiggins - 6 - defended well and ventured forward at times but not able to get any crosses in
    Green - 6.5 - one of his better games. I was surprised when he was withdrawn
    Cousins - 7.5 - all action and gave everything
    Pritchard - 3- the play bypassed him. As said elsewhere, he was given the wrong role but I have marked him for the role in which he played
    Stephens - 7- didn't give up and made a number of strong tackles. (He and Cousins were the only positive things to come out of today)
    Stewart - 4 - is he trying to outdo Waggy in falling over? He didn't beat his defender on the outside (he crossed once only from the byline in the first half), was too easily disposessed and failed to protect his full back.
    Kermorgant - 4.5 - Won very little in the air and seemed to spend more time being petulant. Played one perfect cross for Morro but seemed unable to sort his feet out more often than not
    Church - 5.5 - ran around a lot but with the one great chance he took a poor option.
    Harriott - 5 - he tried to inject some pace and something different but didn't have much success.

  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 6
    Dervite 6
    wiggins 6.5
    Green 6.5
    Cousins 7
    Pritchard 5
    Stephens 6.5
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 6.5
    Church 6
    Harriott 5.5

  • Alnwick - 7. First time I've seen him. Thought he was Hamer. They look alike. Did nothing wrong and inspired confidence.

    Wilson - 6. Poor first half. Strong second. Amazed he was taken off. Not at all amazed that they scored soon afterwards.

    Dervite - 6. Ok. No frills. Didn't do a lot wrong.

    Morrison -6. Better than I've seen him for a while but lost a mark for missing a sitter. Wood is very unlucky not to be in this side.

    Wiggins - 7. Played well. Better than the players around him and frustrated as a result.

    Cousins - 6. Some great moments and some poor ones. The latter are down to inexperience and this boy is going to be some player.

    Stephens - 6. Same as Wiggins. He's too good a player for this team and is now openly frustrated at the ineptitude around him. I honestly thought he was trying to get himself sent off today as he was fizzing into tackles and picking fights with everyone. Good to see in one sense but reckless and could have cost us. We can also do without a suspension.

    Green - 5. Some good moments but not match fit and we didn't play to his strengths.

    Stewart - 4. Poor. Not his fault. He's a right winger and CP cannot get this into his head. On the left he is a one trick pony. Shirked a load of tackles.

    Pritchard - 2. One point for finding the pitch at the end of the tunnel and another for not putting his shirt on back to front. Did nothing and looked disinterested. Poor decision to play him at all and shocking decision to play him in the position he was in.

    Kermorgant - 4. He's not fit and he's pissed off. Spent most of the game moaning at the ref. in this shape/mood he's more of a hindrance than a help. Sad to see him apparently in decline as he has been marvellous. But at the moment he is part of the problem, not part of the solution.

    Harriott - 3. Should be on strictly rather than on a footy pitch. God only knows what position he was supposed to be playing.

    Church - 4. Good old Spongefoot Whitepants. Powderpuff. Tries hard but oh so limited.

    Sod Alll - err. Sod all. Not on long enough to earn his usual 1 point.

    upbeats - 10. Great to see them and fair play to the derby fans for doing their bit.

    CP - 3. All wrong today. Losing the plot and you can't blame him. Wouldn't surprise me if he walked.
  • Alnwick - 6
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Dervite - 6
    wiggins - 6.5
    Green - 6
    Cousins - 6.5
    Pritchard - 5
    Stephens - 6.5
    Stewart - 6
    Kermorgant - 6
    Church - 5.5
    Harriott - 5.5
  • Alnwick 6
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 6 (I think Wood must fancy a chance at getting back in the 11)
    wiggins 7
    Green 6 (Did much more running than I thought he would, delivery from corners/set pieces was variable at best)
    Cousins 7
    Pritchard 5 (Didn't actually do much. But did make an effort at least!)
    Stephens 7
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 6
    Church 6
    Harriott 6
  • Alnwick - 6.5 Thought he did ok. Not sure he'll keep Hamer out but best 2nd choice for a bit.
    Wilson - 6 Solid but not special
    Morrison - 5 Poor miss. Not sure he's the best choice for vice capt.
    Dervite - 6 Solid but not special
    wiggins - 6.5 Tried hard, some good runs but not particularly effective.
    Green - 5.5 A league 1 player who tries hard but lacks Championship quality.
    Cousins - 7 V good start. Quieter after they scored.
    Pritchard - 5 Ran around like a headless chicken, working hard but achieving little.
    Stephens - 7 Tackled hard. Did better than most. Looked frustrated.
    Stewart - 6 Pretty ineffective but looked dangerous at times.
    Kermorgant - 6.5 No help upfront. Zero service and looked v frustrated.
    Church - 5.5 Quick but not a goalscorer.
    Harriot - 5 Needs to go out on loan. These sort of games and late substitutions doesn't help his development.

    Better performance...but we don't shoot never mind score! Very worrying....
  • Alnwick 7
    Wilson 7.5
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    wiggins 6
    Green 8
    Cousins 7.5
    Pritchard 5.5
    Stephens 6.5
    Stewart 6
    Kermorgant 5.5
    Church 5.5
    Harriott 6.5
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!