Players Marks: Burton Albion v Charlton Athletic (Closes Wednesday evening)

Red7Oak

Amos; 5
Matthews: 5 
Gunter: 4 One big F up! Is he playing CB to accom Mathews? Barker would be better surely if Oshilaja and Pearce are not fit!
Pratley: 3 Got the energy but a headless chicken!
Maatsen: 3 Very poor!
Watson: 3 Whats he bring to the team?
Gilbey: 5
Shinnie: 5
Maddison: 2.5 Why the **** did we sign him!
Bogle: 4
Smyth: 5
Aneke: 7.5
Washington: 6
Morgan: 8
Referee: 5

HongCharltonKong

Might be influenced by getting up at 0300 to watch that nonsense

Amos; 4
Matthews: 5
Gunter: 3
Pratley: 3
Maatsen: 1 I would love to see his stats but pass completion and dribble completion must be less than 10%. Before Saturday he was impressive but I guess that is why he is with us he still has alot to learn
Watson: 5
Gilbey: 4
Shinnie: 4
Maddison: 3 Will he ever find that yard of pace to get away from anyone
Bogle: 3
Smyth: 3
Aneke: 8
Washington: 4
Morgan: 7

willieduff

Amos;          6.0
Matthews:    6.0
Gunter:        5.0
Pratley:        5.0
Maatsen:     4.5
Watson:       5.0       
Gilbey:         4.5
Shinnie:       5.0
Maddison:    4.0
Bogle:          4.0
Smyth:         5.0
Aneke:         7.0
Washington: 6.5
Morgan:       7.5
Referee:       5.0

Williams: n/a

Bowyer         4.0  Got it so wrong

Redhenry

Amos; 4
Matthews: 5.5
Gunter: 5
Pratley: 5.5
Maatsen: 5
Watson: 5.5
Gilbey: 5.5
Shinnie: 5.5
Maddison: 5
Bogle: 5
Smyth: 6
Aneke: 7.5
Washington: 6
Morgan: 7
Referee: 2

Longtimeaddicted

Amos; 4 
Matthews: 7
Gunter: 4
Pratley: 6
Maatsen: 6
Watson: 5
Gilbey: 6
Shinnie: 5
Maddison: 2
Bogle: 2
Smyth: 5
Aneke: 8
Washington: 7
Morgan: 8

FULLERpromise

Amos; 4 worst game for us 
Matthews: 6 best of defence 
Gunter: 3 no more cb unless in a 5 
Pratley: 3 no more cb unless in a 5 
Maatsen: 6 some marking him harshly so extra mark as one of few who seemed to care and try even if wasn’t his day 
Watson: 5 ok 
Gilbey: 5 very rusty 
Shinnie: 5 game passed him by 
Maddison: 4 1 extra mark for some good balls but overall work rate was really poor n wasn’t good again 
Bogle: 5 felt for him a little 
Smyth: 6 ok 
Aneke: 8 excellent has to start 
Washington: 7 dangerous 
Morgan: 8.5 motm done more in his time on the pitch than all starters put together 
Referee: 4 not as bad as the one Saturday but really not good either 

Killarahales

Amos; 5
Matthews: 6
Gunter: 4
Pratley: 5
Maatsen: 4
Watson: 5.5
Gilbey: 4.5
Shinnie: 5
Maddison: 4
Bogle: 4
Smyth: 5
Aneke: 7
Washington: 6
Morgan: 6.5
Referee 6

Doesn’t include the last few minutes as I couldn’t bear to watch any more!!

aliwibble

ricky_otto said:

aliwibble said:

ricky_otto said:

Amos; 5.5 - 
Matthews: 5 - 
Gunter: 3.5 - dreadful. 
Pratley: 4.5 - 
Maatsen: 4 - worst performance for us 
Watson: 6 - tried to get things going, but slow at times 
Gilbey: 5 - Rusty and not a wife left player 
Shinnie: 5 - forgot he was playing 
Maddison: 4 - not fit at all 
Bogle: 4 - needs to come out of the team 
Smyth: 6.5 - pleased he got a goal. 
Aneke: 6 - what a goal. Needs to be starting games 
Washington: 6.5 - got in to decent positions, should have had at least 1 goal 
Morgan: 7 - excellent in the time he was in the pitch 
Referee: 5

@ricky_otto is that a typo? Or have you deducted him half a mark for getting in the way of that  shot of Washington's?

No no, that’s my mark for him. Maybe a bit harsh. 

I think a little harsh, certainly in comparison to Smyth, who despite scoring made little impression otherwise, and that's said as someone who generally appreciates his play. You could argue that was down to him not getting the service from those around him, but while he wasn't actively bad, I'd say his positive impact was less than Chuks.