Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Wendies (closes Monday lunchtime)

at the Valley, on Sky or a live steam your marks please:

Phillips: 
Matthews: 
Lockyer: 
Oshilaja: 
Sarr: 
Doughty: 
Morgan: 
Pratley: 
Oztumer: 
Leko: 
Bonne: 
Vennings: 
Referee: 

Davison: n/a

can anyone tell me why this appears as double spacing when I compose it in single spacing - never used to do this!
«13

Comments

  • Phillips: 7.5 some great saves
    Matthews: 7 thought it might be his best game so far
    Lockyer: 8 huge performance really 
    Oshilaja: 6 some good stuff but no composure 
    Sarr: 6.5 yeah he got done a bit for the opening goal but was largely untroubled aside and played some lovely balls to Doughty
    Doughty: 8 excellent assist and generally gave us so much down the flank 
    Morgan: 5.5 not his day at all
    Pratley: 6.5 he kept going but couldn't make anything happen, not his job I guess 
    Oztumer: 6 thought he was doing pretty well but that was an awful penalty to give away, he was definitely not moving well though after getting a kicking 
    Leko: 7 put himself about well 
    Bonne: 7 nice goal, not much else today, feeding off scraps 
    Vennings: 6.5 thought he did okay 
    Referee: 5 missed a few things 
    Davison: n/a can't really judge 

  • Phillips: 7

    Matthews: 7.5

    Lockyer: 6

    Oshilaja: 8 MOM 

    Sarr: 5.5

    Doughty: 6

    Morgan: 5

    Pratley: 6

    Oztumer: 5

    Leko: 6

    Bonne: 6

    Vennings: 6

    Referee: 3




  • Phillips: 7.5

    Matthews: 7

    Lockyer: 6

    Oshilaja: 7.5

    Sarr: 6

    Doughty: 8

    Morgan: 5.5

    Pratley: 5

    Oztumer: 5.5

    Leko: 6

    Bonne: 6

    Vennings: 6

    Referee: 5

  • Phillips: 7

    Matthews: 7.5

    Lockyer: 7

    Oshilaja: 8

    Sarr: 6

    Doughty: 7.5

    Morgan: 6

    Pratley: 7

    Oztumer: 7

    Leko: 6.5

    Bonne: 6

    Vennings: 7

    Referee: 



    Davison: n/a
  • Phillips: 8 stopped it being a rout. 

    Matthews: 8.5 mom. Up and down and defended superbly

    Lockyer: 7 shame about the yellow card. No defensive help from his partner.

    Oshilaja: 7.5 solid and always involved. Gave the ball away a few times with easy passes.

    Sarr: 4 don't know what has happened to him. Terrible positioning for all set pieces and lost count of the miss kicks.

    Doughty: 7.5 great first half, faded second, but a big positive.

    Morgan: 6 not really involved

    Pratley: 7 chased and passed well. A bit tired last quarter.

    Oztumer: 6 minus 1 for a stupid tackle. Played well apart from that though.

    Leko: 6 lost the ball far too many times, PASS IT!! Had some good points.

    Bonne: 7 another goal, but so so isolated second half.

    Vennings: 7 came on and wanted the ball, didn't hide. Got a future.

    Referee: 6 not the worst, but let a lot go. Nuhui (sp) elbow, Hutchings second yellow, but overall not too bad.

    Davison: n/a not an option for the future I hope, need a regular scorer. He needs time to adapt to this level.
  • Phillips: 7.5 MOM kept us in it

    Matthews: 6 got roasted early 2nd half but did well after

    Lockyer: 6 steady defending

    Oshilaja: 6.5 one sloppy pass nearly costly otherwise good

    Sarr: 5.5 poor challenge for 1st goal minus a point

    Doughty: 7 breath of fresh air going forward from LB

    Morgan: 5 did not impose himself on the game

    Pratley: 6 workload taking its toll at 34yrs

    Oztumer: 5.5 minus 1 for conceding pen with tired lunge 

    Leko: 6.5 mixed bag today

    Bonne: 7 plus 1 for the goal

    Vennings: 6 tidy cameo

    Referee: 5
  • Phillips: 7.5 made some good saves



    Matthews: 7



    Lockyer: 6 stupid yellow card for dissent, now suspended



    Oshilaja: 7



    Sarr: 5



    Doughty: 7.5 did well in his first start, lovely assist for the goal



    Morgan: 6



    Pratley: 7



    Oztumer: 6 should have been taken off once he was showing signs of injury, poor foul for pen



    Leko: 6.5



    Bonne: 6



    Vennings: 6 looked ok when he came on for debut



    Referee: 5 Hutchinson should’ve had a second yellow, ref bottled it
  • Phillips: 7

    Matthews: 6 

    Lockyer: 7.5

    Oshilaja: 7

    Sarr: 6

    Doughty: 7 

    Morgan: 5.5

    Pratley: 6

    Oztumer: 6.5

    Leko: 6.5

    Bonne: 6.5

    Vennings: 6

    Referee: Twat - but it was a pen.
  • Phillips: 7.5

    Matthews: 6.5

    Lockyer: 8

    Oshilaja: 7 maybe inflated but never hid and worked very hard

    Sarr: 5 some nice passes but rubbish defensively 

    Doughty: 7.5 lad has talent 

    Morgan: 6 quiet but unwell 

    Pratley: 6.5 worked hard 

    Oztumer: 6.5 minus 1 for the penalty 

    Leko: 6 worked hard but end product lacking 

    Bonne: 7 quieter than recently but deserved a goal 

    Vennings: 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips: 7 - Did as well as he could

    Matthews: 6 - Played well going forward, defensively suspect towards the end

    Lockyer: 6 - Average, don't think he's as good as people make out

    Oshilaja: 7 - Played well, but isn't that good

    Sarr: 5.5 - Poor, can't make clearances properly

    Doughty: 6.5 - Has pace but not much else, used it well once. 

    Morgan: 6 - Didn't notice he was there

    Pratley: 7 - Battled well

    Oztumer: 6 - Bowyer should've taken him off 10 mins before he gave away the penalty and lost us the game

    Leko: 8 - Best player on the pitch

    Bonne: 6 - Lucky goal and didn't do much else

    Vennings: 6 - Looked alright
    I know player scores are subjective but I think some of these scores and comments are particularly and needlessly harsh.
  • Phillips: 7

    Matthews: 6

    Lockyer: 6

    Oshilaja: 6.5

    Sarr: 5

    Doughty: 7

    Morgan: 6

    Pratley: 6.5

    Oztumer: 6.5

    Leko: 6

    Bonne: 6.5

    Vennings: 6

    Referee: 5

  • Phillips: 5.5 poor positional sense for balls across his box, highlighted by the third goal today but also by their offside goal, first goal and glaring miss from his parry in the first half. 

    Matthews: 5 wasn't very good

    Lockyer: 5.5 bullied and played backwards too often

    Oshilaja: 5.5 not a great footballer

    Sarr: 5.5 hoofing it in the second half when he should be passing, vice versa in first half

    Doughty: 6.5 done well to be honest

    Morgan: 5 didn't influence the game at all

    Pratley: 6 cut a frustrated figure with his team today, tried too hard at points

    Oztumer: 5.5 silly penalty to give away

    Leko: 4 lazy ball hogger

    Bonne: 6 not much came off for him today

    Vennings: 6 energetic but didn't influence things much

    Referee: 3 other than the penalty for them being stonewall, he should have had the balls to send off Hutchinson, give the penalty for the Lockyer foul and not cave in to their ridiculous diving antics
  • Phillips:   8

    Matthews:   6

    Lockyer:   7

    Oshilaja:   6

    Sarr:   4

    Doughty:   6

    Morgan:   5

    Pratley:   7

    Oztumer:   6.5

    Leko:   7

    Bonne:    6.5

    Vennings:   5

    Referee:   3
  • Phillips: 7.5

    Matthews: 7

    Lockyer: 6.5

    Oshilaja: 7

    Sarr: 6.5

    Doughty: 8

    Morgan: 6.5

    Pratley: 7

    Oztumer: 6.5

    Leko: 7.5

    Bonne: 7

    Vennings: 6.5

    Referee: 5
  • Phillips: 7 A couple of good saves but distribution not so good today

    Matthews: 6.5 I like the look of him but was caught defensivel a few times in the second half

    Lockyer: 7 Not up to his early season form but a good defender

    Oshilaja: 7 Saw a lot of the ball today. Did OK

    Sarr: 6 I don't thonk many defenders would have got to the ball for their first.

    Doughty: 7.5 Great full debut out of position

    Morgan: 5 Anonymous, but he was sick

    Pratley: 6 Looks happier playing further back

    Oztumer: 6 Some good, some bad, some awful (penalty!)

    Leko: 7.5 Seems to be improving his decision-making

    Bonne: 6.5 Half a point for the goal, otherwise average

    Vennings: 5.5 Not on long emough to make a real impression

    Referee: 5 Not the best.
  • Phillips:  7
    Matthews:  6.5
    Lockyer:   6.5
    Oshilaja:  7
    Sarr:  5
    Doughty:  6.5
    Morgan:  5
    Pratley:  6.5
    Oztumer:  5.5
    Leko:  4
    Bonne:  6
    Vennings:  5.5

    Referee:  5
  • Phillips: 7 - Did as well as he could

    Matthews: 6 - Played well going forward, defensively suspect towards the end

    Lockyer: 6 - Average, don't think he's as good as people make out

    Oshilaja: 7 - Played well, but isn't that good

    Sarr: 5.5 - Poor, can't make clearances properly

    Doughty: 6.5 - Has pace but not much else, used it well once. 

    Morgan: 6 - Didn't notice he was there

    Pratley: 7 - Battled well

    Oztumer: 6 - Bowyer should've taken him off 10 mins before he gave away the penalty and lost us the game

    Leko: 8 - Best player on the pitch

    Bonne: 6 - Lucky goal and didn't do much else

    Vennings: 6 - Looked alright
    I know player scores are subjective but I think some of these scores and comments are particularly and needlessly harsh.
    Judging them for the game they just played, as a first XI. 

    No point marking for potential. A player might look promising but still not play very well. 
  • at the Valley, on Sky your marks please:

    Phillips: 7 Did all he could
    Matthews: 6.5 The winger did better against him than he did in the first half against Doughty
    Lockyer: 6.5 Not at his best
    Oshilaja: 7 Worked hard and I agree with Sky commentator, he was everywhere
    Sarr: 6.5 Some good long range passing but defensive qualities not very good, should have done better with 1st goal
    Doughty: 7.5 I thought he was very good, especially as it was his first start
    Morgan: 6 Unfortunately he was one of the sick players and was sick at half time
    Pratley: 7 His usual bustling game and defending
    Oztumer: 7 Worked hard, some good movements should not have been on the pitch to give away the penalty after injury
    Leko: 6.5 He has everything and nothing, usual Leko
    Bonne: 7 Tried hard with no service, good goal
    Vennings: 6 Did not see enough to really judge
    Referee: 5 Why did he not book Fletcher for the almost headbutt on Phillips after the penalty

    Davison: n/a


  • edited November 30
    Phillips: 7 - These results are nothing do with him, he's been solid for weeks - Looked like was holding his hand up by way of apologising to the fans at the end though!!
    Matthews: 5 - Had another good game @ Right-Back, went missing for the final goal though
    Lockyer: 6 - Gone back to how he was at the start of the season, isnt doing anything spectactulor, doesnt mean he's not doing anything though
    Oshilaja: 7 - Another good game out of position
    Sarr: 5 - Improved second half, terrible start
    Doughty: 6.5 - Excellent assist, got forward well had a really good first start; unsurprisingly faded
    Morgan: 4 - Worst game in a Charlton shirt, understandable considering Bowyer's comments about the sickness bug
    Pratley: 6 - Continues to show his experience
    Oztumer: 5 - Had a good game, and then gave away the penalty
    Leko: 6 - Slowly showing the sort of work rate I want from him compared to the likes of Bonne and Taylor
    Bonne: 6 - Nice goal, continued to work his socks off
    Vennings: 6 - Another one for the future, showed good composure on and off the ball
    Referee: 4 - Booked players for dissent and not for constantly fouling players, might think it was a game all about him but really wasnt!!
  • Sponsored links:


  • Anyone else think Leko is a shocking player. Does t know what to do with the ball. Never passes the ball and all round game quite poor 
  • edited November 30
    Phillips: 7 - generally fine, not at fault for any of the goals

    Matthews: 6 - okay defensively and offensively. A shame the sides of our pitches are so narrow so he can't get a run-up for a long throw.

    Lockyer: 5.5 - completely lost his head in the last half hour, shouting at the ref constantly, even for completely reasonable calls. Lucky to only get booked once imo.

    Oshilaja: 5 - he looks really uncomfortable in this 'Pratley' role. Not a CM at all.

    Sarr: 5.5 - the usual mix of brilliant passes and useless ones

    Doughty: 6 - great play for our goal, not too bad defensively

    Morgan: 4 - really poor

    Pratley: 8 - our best player by a mile, loads of interceptions and looked to drive us forwards.

    Oztumer: 5.5 - he tried, some stuff came off, some stuff didn't. Minus half a point for giving away the pen.

    Leko: 6.5 - took us up the pitch quite well. Decision making much better than usual, I thought.

    Bonne: 5.5 - half a point for the goal. Didn't do much apart from that.

    Vennings: 5.5 - showed good promise, took their RB on well a few times

    Referee: 7 - he got a lot of abuse off us towards the end, but thought he got the decisions mostly right. Pen looked stonewall to me.



    Davison: n/a - did he touch the ball?

    West Stand ballboy: 9 - good keepie-uppies, quick turnaround with the ball. Worth a place on the bench for me.
  • at the Valley, on Sky or a live steam your marks please:

    Phillips: 7.5 - couple of decent saves
    Matthews: 7.5 - decent
    Lockyer: 6.5 - ok
    Oshilaja: 7 - decent in parts, he is a RB for me
    Sarr: 5.5 - Poor for first goal
    Doughty: 6.5 - ok and extra .5 for assist
    Morgan: 5 - did he start? 
    Pratley: 6.5 - battled well
    Oztumer: 5.5 - couple of nice passes but offered very little for the majority 
    Leko: 6 - frustrating
    Bonne: 6 - didn’t do enough but score (very fortunately) 
    Vennings: 5.5 - didn’t get much of a chance
    Referee: 6.5 - was a pen and didn’t do thing majorly wrong


  • Phillips: 7.5 - some great saves in there 

    Matthews: 7 - has that extra bit of recovery pace that Solly doesn’t. Good going forward but gets caught on the ball a bit too often. Needs to release it a little bit quicker. 

    Lockyer: 6.5 - solid but incredibly irresponsible booking given our absentee list

    Oshilaja: 6.5 - strong and shielded the defence well. Needed that extra bit of composure when on the front foot but it’s not his position so fair enough 

    Sarr: 6 - passed well, generally decent but you can’t be that big and keep getting done for headed goals this much

    Doughty: 6.5 - great first half but fell away second half. Understandable given he was out of position and called upon at the last minute 

    Morgan: 4 - totally anonymous. Wasted the ball when on it, failed to clear his lines a couple of times and offered nothing going forward. I’ve heard he was ill but the performance is what it is 

    Pratley: 7 - such a clever midfielder. Leko nearly put him through in the last ten which says it all about the amount of effort he puts in for the team. Lucky not to give away a pen though 

    Oztumer: 5 - we needed him to be the creative spark today and he offered nothing to unlock their defence. Brave to stay on injured but it cost us in the end. 

    Leko: 7.5 - worked so hard throughout and tracked repeatedly. Headed one cross against us out for a corner because he was the one who was tracking the play. You can’t possibly call him lazy today

    Bonne: 6.5 - scored but was really isolated as the game wore on

    Vennings: 6 - tried 

    Referee: 5 - alright first half but was a dick by the end 
  • What's with the spacing?
    Each player gets an extra mark for spirit today.
    Phillips: 7
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 6 Wish he wasn't so nervous
    Doughty: 7.5 Love the look of this fella. Pacy, good touch
    Morgan: 6 (He was sick)
    Pratley: 7 
    Oztumer: 7 We worsened the more they kicked him
    Leko: 7.5 Improving, a bit crazy at times, but threatens at least.
    Bonne: 7 
    Vennings: 7

    Referee: 2 One of the worst
  • at the Happy Valley!

    Phillips:  7

    Matthews:  6

    Lockyer:   6

    Oshilaja:  7

    Sarr:  5

    Doughty:  6.5

    Morgan:  6

    Pratley:  6.5

    Oztumer: 6 (-1 for penalty)

    Leko:  5

    Bonne:  7.5

    Vennings:  5

    Referee:  5
  • Phillips: 7 - a couple of great saves and better distribution

    Matthews: 7 - good going forward and pace an asset at the back

    Lockyer: 7 - solid

    Oshilaja: 6 - solid and some good passing out from the back

    Sarr: 5 - love the bloke but looks timid this season

    Doughty: 8 - MOM. Immense run to set up the goal and great defensive work too. Understandably looked knackered last 30.

    Morgan: 5 - anonymous. Not ready for Championship football

    Pratley: 7 - ran the midfield well

    Oztumer: 7 - some nice touches. Knackered second half leading to sloppy challenge for the pen.

    Leko: 6 - work rate really improving but needs to anticipate Bonne's flick ons

    Bonne: 7 - good work rate and took goal well.

    Vennings: 5 - didn't see much from him but seemed to want the ball

    Referee: 4 
  • edited November 30

    Phillips: 7.5
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 7.5
    Oshilaja: 7
    5arr: 4
    Doughty: 7
    Morgan: 6
    Pratley: 7.5
    Oztumer: 6.5
    Leko: 6.5
    Bonne: 7
    Vennings: 6

    Referee: 5


  • Phillips: 8.5 not a fault for goals

    Matthews: 7.5 done well

    Lockyer: 7.5 as above

    Oshilaja: 8.5 MoM for me

    Sarr: 3 confidence gone sorry Nadster you are a liability, what is the issue with Pearce? 

    Doughty: 8 Good showing great run for the goal, looked knackered for the last 20. 

    Morgan: 6 out of his depth sadly, tries hard but we are asking too much of him

    Pratley: 8 Never stopped trying loved him bollocking Leko

    Oztumer: 7 Tried hard to run the midfield instant a very physical Wednesday, desperately tired lunge gave the pen away 

    Leko: 5 very frustrating to watch

    Bonne: 7 tires real hard need support, never seen Leko run off his headers yet 

    Vennings: 7 Did his Mum know he was out?

    Referee: 4 Not the best, felt he missed a penalty to us and gave a lot of decisions to Wednesday



    Davison: n/a
  • Phillips: 6.5 Couple of fantastic saves! Kicking is still not the greatest! Couldn't do much about any of the goals! 

    Matthews: 6 Looked good at times and terrible at others still haven't made my mind up about him.

    Lockyer: 6.5 Amazing blocks and challenges. But seems a bit lost looking forwards pass backwards and sideways always invites pressure on us.

    Oshilaja: 6 Not good enough passing to be a holding midfielder but good strong challenges in the middle of the park.

    Sarr: 6 Was well below par would have given him a 4 but he actually put up a bit of a fight second half against that big  lump Nuhu.

    Doughty: 7 Only positive to come out of the last few games. Versatile and puts in the effort playing for that shirt. 

    Morgan: 5 Not good enough for this level. Fair play to him for playing through illness and trying but just not enough.

    Pratley: 6 Had a brilliant first half commanding and helping the younger lads but disappeared for most of the 2nd half

    Oztumer: 5 Lovely little player when he has people around him to feed. This game against the big Wednesday boys just didn't suit him... hard to be a playmaker when you don't have anyone to play with

    Leko: 5 Most frustrating player we've had in a while... looks at times to be the premier league player his potential says he is! But the rest of the time looks like a Sunday league donkey plodding along. Needs to put in more effort.

    Bonne: 5 Always puts in a shift. Another lucky goal for him can't fault the goal scoring record but still looks like a League Two player.



    Subs

    Vennings: 5 young lad didn't have much of the ball, one silly challenge towards the end showed his naivety! 



    Referee: 4  It was a penalty unfortunately but don't think he liked the stick he was getting had a decent first half but bottled it second half!


Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out!