Players you rated that few others did...

blackpool72

Oggy Red said:

Chris Iwelumo ....... surprisingly good for a big lad with the ball at his feet, remember 2 goals scored in a Sheff Weds game (on his Charlton debut, was it?)

That season he scored a terrific last minute winner away at Southampton.
And a last minute winner again a few days later at Bristol City, picture goal after a great Andy Reid cross on the run down the left wing.

I liked him too.
His miss for Scotland was as bad as it gets though

Addickted

Peter Shaw

Oggy Red

ElfsborgAddick said:

Oggy Red said:

Chris Iwelumo ....... surprisingly good for a big lad with the ball at his feet, remember 2 goals scored in a Sheff Weds game (on his Charlton debut, was it?)

That season he scored a terrific last minute winner away at Southampton.
And a last minute winner again a few days later at Bristol City, picture goal after a great Andy Reid cross on the run down the left wing.

Carbon copy goals I seem to recall.

Yep, both quality headers on the run.

killerandflash

Nicky Bailey

Our driving force in midfield for 2 seasons, we would never have reached the playoffs without him...but to many that penalty seems to have overshadowed all the good things he did

wmcf123

Those who named Diawara evidently weren't at the Wycombe cup game.

Amazed to see Keith Jones on this list- did anyone not rate him ?

Oggy Red

wmcf123 said:

Those who named Diawara evidently weren't at the Wycombe cup game.

"The best centre-half that nobody has ever heard of", as I believe he was described by the Chairman at the time.

Simonsen

ElfsborgAddick said:

Oggy Red said:

Chris Iwelumo ....... surprisingly good for a big lad with the ball at his feet, remember 2 goals scored in a Sheff Weds game (on his Charlton debut, was it?)

That season he scored a terrific last minute winner away at Southampton.
And a last minute winner again a few days later at Bristol City, picture goal after a great Andy Reid cross on the run down the left wing.

Carbon copy goals I seem to recall.

One at Southampton was a close range diving header at the far post after a powerful run and cross from the right hand by-line by Luke Varney.

One at Bristol City was an angled cross from centre left by Reid....headed over the keeper.

Ted\'s Addicksson

Mark Stuart
Andy Jones

Oggy Red

Ted\'s Addicksson said:

Mark Stuart

"He could play for Barcelona or Bromley. It's up to him", we were told by his manager of the time.

blackpool72

Oggy Red said:

Ted\'s Addicksson said:

Mark Stuart

"He could play for Barcelona or Bromley. It's up to him", we were told by his manager of the time.

Ironically he did eventually play for Bromley

harveys_gardener

Bobby (marmite) Goldthorpe. Aizelwood, Pates, Stuart M, Dicko, Kish, Moutakil, Pritchard, Waggy, Sam, KAG.

Oggy Red

Gary Churchouse.

No, forget that.

crookester

Liked Paul Hayes though others around me thought he was shite

harveys_gardener

Kids. Nathan Ashton, Harry Pell, Charlie Mac, Campbell-Ryce, Tutt, Gough, Arter (cough), Shittu, Prinvoy, Edwards, Lapslie, last two because no sign they will be re-signed.

Oggy Red

harveys_gardener said:

Pates

Ah, yes ..... Colin Pates. Very neat and tidy for a CB.
Good player.

tom_k

Carl Leaburn

thewolfboy

Roy Matthews. people used to say he was invisible but I rated him.

Scoham

harveys_gardener said:

Kids. Nathan Ashton, Harry Pell, Charlie Mac, Campbell-Ryce, Tutt, Gough, Arter (cough), Shittu, Prinvoy, Edwards, Lapslie, last two because no sign they will be re-signed.

Apart from the fact Lapslie has made his first team debut (and scored)?

Dazzler21

killerandflash said:

Nicky Bailey

Our driving force in midfield for 2 seasons, we would never have reached the playoffs without him...but to many that penalty seems to have overshadowed all the good things he did

And all the diving and feigning injury and being a bit of a mug really.

Dazzler21

wmcf123 said:

Those who named Diawara evidently weren't at the Wycombe cup game.

Amazed to see Keith Jones on this list- did anyone not rate him ?

One game doth not maketh the player.

wmcf123

Dazzler21 said:

wmcf123 said:

Those who named Diawara evidently weren't at the Wycombe cup game.

Amazed to see Keith Jones on this list- did anyone not rate him ?

One game doth not maketh the player.

I think most judge him on what he did after he left

Duncan270566

Luke Varney. I thought he worked hard when playing for us but was never really liked by fans or management.

Six-a-bag-of-nuts

Peter Hunt.
Every team needs one

ricky_otto

wmcf123 said:

Those who named Diawara evidently weren't at the Wycombe cup game.

Amazed to see Keith Jones on this list- did anyone not rate him ?

Jones was mustard at the job he did. Him and Kinsella in midfield were one of the best midfield partnerships I’ve seen at Charlton.

Carter

Duncan270566 said:

Luke Varney. I thought he worked hard when playing for us but was never really liked by fans or management.

If half the team at the time Varney was in the side had his work ethic we would have gone up

ricky_otto

Six-a-bag-of-nuts said:

Peter Hunt.
Every team needs one

We’ve got had quite a few ‘unts over the years.

dickplumb

Dick Plumb.

ricky_otto

Ricky Otto