While thinking about the whole best and worst charlton loan I found this list of transfers http://www.neilbrown.newcastlefans.com/charlton/charlton.htm
[cite]Posted By: RedArmySE7[/cite]Neil Heaney deserves a mention.
Can't agree there, Red Army.
Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.
Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.
[cite]Posted By: RedArmySE7[/cite]Neil Heaney deserves a mention.
Can't agree there, Red Army.
Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.
Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.
[cite]Posted By: RedArmySE7[/cite]Neil Heaney deserves a mention.
Can't agree there, Red Army.
Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.
Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.
Agree with that totally
I meant a positive mention, he was in the team that gave me my best ever day as a Charlton fan, that's good enough for me.
A bit unfair Clem Rangers nbr three Goalkeeper Lindsey Hamilton only ever played in Steve Gritt's Testimonial and never let in a goal V Spurs . I think he even saved a penalty.
Best: The club's overdraft from the Bank Manager. It kept us alive as a club.
Worst: The club's overdraft from the Bank Manager. They gave, they taketh away.
We could have gone into administration.
Comments
Worst: Harder... Scott Sinclair?
Worst- Neil Etheridge*
*actually most of Pardew's but Cook and Sinclair stand out.
Thats a bit harsh - his manager was being a twat and recalled him!
Yeah I wasn't being serious, hence the real answer just below.
Can't agree there, Red Army.
Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.
Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.
Worst is hard. Carlton Cole was a lazy arrogant player.
Actually, he got better as the games wore on and wasn't that bad
Best had to be Costa, but Smertin was decent, and Song too
I would have to put Sinclair as my worst, but I didn't think Butterfield was a good call, that man stunk of Palace!
Lee Cook must give Cole & Sinclair (2 Chelsea boys........makes you think, Doesn't it) a run for their money too !
Agree with that totally
Worst: Mike Small
Worst: Cook
BTW - WTF does 'brap' mean?
I meant a positive mention, he was in the team that gave me my best ever day as a Charlton fan, that's good enough for me.
Worst: Lindsey Hamilton, Chris Wilder and Iain Ferguson
Worst def Cook
Worse: Butterfield
Worst: Butters
After a shakey start wasn't that bad and wasn't really on loan
Worst: Jon Spector
worst:tom hovi
Worst: The club's overdraft from the Bank Manager. They gave, they taketh away.
We could have gone into administration.