Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Swansea (closes Sunday lunchtime)

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,651
in General Charlton

marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

KAMINSKI:

BURKE:

JONES:

GILLESPHEY:

BREE:

COVENTRY:

CAREY:

DOCHERTY:

BELL:

KELMAN:

CAMPBELL:

Referee:

Subs: Ramsay:

Leaburn:

Hernandez: n/a

Olaofe: n/a

Knibbs: n/a

«13

Comments

  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 717

    KAMINSKI: 6

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 5

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 6

    Referee: 6

    Subs: Ramsay: 5

    Leaburn: 5

  • Essex_Al
    Essex_Al Posts: 3,586

    KAMINSKI:  6

    BURKE:  5

    JONES:  6

    GILLESPHEY:  6

    BREE:  5

    COVENTRY:  6.5

    CAREY:  6

    DOCHERTY:  5

    BELL:  5

    KELMAN:  6

    CAMPBELL:  6

    Referee:  5

    Subs: Ramsay:  5

    Leaburn:  6

  • Longtimeaddicted
    Longtimeaddicted Posts: 579

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6 looks a bad injury 

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 6 

    KELMAN: 7 at last Charlie well taken

    CAMPBELL: 7 

    Referee: 5 he lost the plot 

    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 6


  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 51,445
    KAMINSKI: 6

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 5

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 6

    Referee: 5 did well til the last 15-20 mins

    Subs: Ramsay: 4

    Leaburn: 5 - Refs really need to stop punishing him for his size. 
  • Leuth
    Leuth Posts: 23,401
    edited November 1
    KAMINSKI: 7.5 very solid 
    BURKE: 5 hmm 
    JONES: 6.5 not his usual self 
    GILLESPHEY: 7.5 early scare aside, good 
    BREE: 6 not quite his usual bite on the cross 
    COVENTRY: 8 resplendent as ever 
    CAREY: 6.5 some decent thrust 
    DOCHERTY: 5 extremely poor tbh 
    BELL: 6 a few weird blips but we looked less solid when he went off 
    KELMAN: 7.5 good on ya 
    CAMPBELL: 7 huge shift 
    Referee: 5.5 weirdly bad (in our favour mostly) 
    Subs: Ramsay: 5.5 PLAY HIM IN HIS POSITION
    Leaburn: 7 good but a bit slack for their goal? A nitpick
    Hernandez: n/a
    Olaofe: n/a
    Knibbs: n/a
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 21,375
    KAMINSKI: 6.5 well placed shot beat him, couple of reaction saves

    BURKE: 5.5 seemed to be struggling before he went down, was being turned around a lot

    JONES: 6 had a physical battle today and didn't come off better all game like he usually does, if we didn't lose Burke and Bell to injury he would have come off at half time

    GILLESPHEY: 5.5 thought he made a few mistakes today overplaying it

    BREE: 6 also guilty of overplaying at times, some shocking free kicks too

    COVENTRY: 7 did pretty well limiting most of their play to long shots

    CAREY: 6 drifted out of the game for large parts, took some nasty looking tackles, could have won it at the end with a thunderous stop

    DOCHERTY: 6.5 tireless running, moved the ball about well

    BELL: 6 thought he was doing ok until the injury 

    KELMAN: 7.5 gets a slight boost for his first goal, you could see how much it meant to him and to the whole team when he scored. 

    CAMPBELL: 6.5 played in 3 different positions, did well in 2 of them but looked lost at LWB for a while

    Referee: 3 thought he let the game run well in the most part, until the second half, then he absolutely lost control 

    Subs: Ramsay: 4.5 looks like he's gone backwards last few games (he hasn't, but he hasn't made the step up as seamlessly as a lot of the squad)

    Leaburn: 7 thought he worked really hard up top and caused them a lot of issues

    Hernandez: n/a

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a
  • JohnnyH2
    JohnnyH2 Posts: 5,348

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6

    Referee: 4

    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 5

    Hernandez: n/a

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,778

    KAMINSKI: 6

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 5

    BELL: 5

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    Referee: 4

    Subs: Ramsay: 5

    Leaburn: 6.5

  • kenhem
    kenhem Posts: 175

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    BURKE: 5.5

    JONES: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 6.5

    DOCHERTY: 5.6

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 6.6

    Referee: 5

    Subs: Ramsay: 5

    Leaburn: 7

  • SE_7EVEN
    SE_7EVEN Posts: 291

    KAMINSKI: 8

    BURKE: 5

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 4

    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 6

    Hernandez: n/a

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a



  • Sponsored links:



  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,755

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    BURKE: 5

    JONES: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY: 5.5

    BREE: 5

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 5.5

    KELMAN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    Referee: 

    Subs: Ramsay: 5.5

    Leaburn: 7


  • 801912601
    801912601 Posts: 625

    KAMINSKI: 6.5 - Needs to command his box more & kicking not great today but 2 instinctive saves

    BURKE: 3 Having a mare before his injury

    JONES: 7 Solid apart from being done for their goal

    GILLESPHEY: 7 Great last tackle early doors and so ok

    BREE: 7 Steady

    COVENTRY: 8 Excellent defensively & an assist

    CAREY: 7.5 Worked his socks off with no support from the ref

    DOCHERTY: 6.5 Worked hard but laboured today 

    BELL: 7 Doing ok before his injury

    KELMAN: 7 Mot involved much as usual but too his goal well

    CAMPBELL: 7.5 + 1 for that run back & tackle first half. Was exposed late on playing wing back

    Referee: 7 Good 80 minutes but terrible last 15

    Subs: Ramsay: 7 Ok

    Leaburn: 4 Gain some muscles

    Hernandez: n/a 7.5 Done well

    Olaofe: n/a 

    Knibbs: n/a 

  • BoPeepAddick
    BoPeepAddick Posts: 164

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    BURKE: 5.5

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 6

    DOHERTY: 5.5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 

    CAMPBELL:  6

    Referee: 4

    Subs: Ramsay: 5.5

    Leaburn: 6.5

  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,798
    edited November 1

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 8

    Referee: 

    Subs: Ramsay: 5

    Leaburn: 8 MOM


  • Diebythesword
    Diebythesword Posts: 354
    edited November 1

    KAMINSKI: 7 his distribution is getting a lot better

    BURKE: 5 not sure what he adds over Ramsay 

    JONES: 6 

    GILLESPHEY: 6 

    BREE: 6 worst game for us so far

    COVENTRY: 6.5 

    CAREY: 7 Swansea clearly had him down as the danger man, always had 3 players on him when he got the ball, although he still managed to have some moments of class. A great footballer

    DOCHERTY: 6 largely anonymous and didn’t really hunt them down like he’s done in the past, felt they walked through our midfield a few times where doc should’ve been 

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 6 plus one for the well taken goal, was otherwise his worst performance for us, and I’ve been a real advocate for him 

    CAMPBELL: 6 probably didn’t help being played in 3 positions

    Referee: 6 was decent and then slowly lost it. 

    Subs: Ramsay: 6 same as Campbell, don’t think playing in 2 different positions really helped him 

    Leaburn: 6.5 did his job but got zero protection from the ref

    Hernandez: n/a really like the look of him, bit of experience and very nippy for a more senior player. 

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

  • vff
    vff Posts: 6,903
    edited November 1

    KAMINSKI:7 -Steady, saved what he could. No chance with goal.

    BURKE: 5.5- mistake with header on the first minute, not at his best, and looked off the pace and injured

    JONES:7 - Steady 

    GILLESPHEY:7 - saving challenge in first minute, header on target but some nervy moments

    BREE:7 - some good passing

    COVENTRY:7 - stuck to it against decent Swansea midfield

    CAREY:7 - looked good and had to help out midfield, so less driving forward.

    DOCHERTY:6.5 - stuck to it against decent Swansea midfield

    BELL:6 - hasn't looked up to his nomal level for couple of weeks and injured looks likely to be out for a couple of months 

    KELMAN:7.5 - first Charlton goal well done. A good poachers goal Matty Godden would be happy with.

    CAMPBELL:7 - some great interceptions and tracked back, pace provides vital outlet

    Referee:6.5 - Lost control last 10 mins, but didn't fall for Swansea diving (Eom worst offender) at most crucial moments.

    Subs: Ramsay:6.5 -steady enough but some loose passess

    Leaburn:7 - not perfect but lead the line and played forward, hopefully playing himself into form.

    Hernandez: n/a - Some good moments and calmed the right side. Like the look of him.

    Olaofe: n/a - tried to bring the play forward

    Knibbs: n/a



  • CharltonKerry
    CharltonKerry Posts: 2,966

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 5

    BELL: 5

    KELMAN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    Referee: 3,5

    Subs: Ramsay: 5,5

    Leaburn: 6.5

  • OhMyGodden
    OhMyGodden Posts: 262
    Campbell 10/10 - fantastic, what more can you want from a player, a masterclass.
  • kentred2
    kentred2 Posts: 2,343

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 8.5

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 6.5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 

    Subs: Ramsay: 5.5

    Leaburn: 6

  • Orpingtony
    Orpingtony Posts: 282

    KAMINSKI:7

    BURKE:6

    JONES:6.5

    GILLESPHEY:6

    BREE:6.5

    COVENTRY:7

    CAREY:6.5

    DOCHERTY:6

    BELL:6

    KELMAN:7

    CAMPBELL:7

    Referee:5

    Subs: Ramsay:6

    Leaburn:7

    Hernandez: n/a

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a



  • Sponsored links:



  • RonnieMoore
    RonnieMoore Posts: 4,544

    KAMINSKI:  7 

    BURKE: 6 looked like he got his boot stuck in the turf , expect him to be ok Tuesday .. 

    JONES: 7 real tough day 

    GILLESPHEY: 7 

    BREE: 5 not at his best seemed to have gone of the boil last 3 matches 

    COVENTRY: 6 was not allowed to play his own game excellent tactics from Swansea boss to top our mid 

    CAREY: 6 same as Coventry 

    DOCHERTY: 6 Same as Coventry 

    BELL: 5 was not having a great game now looks like he could be missing till the new year 

    KELMAN: 8 excellent finish … 

    CAMPBELL: 4 enough enough good positions no end product or created anything 

    Referee: 

    Subs: Ramsay: 5 bit of a shocker 

    Leaburn  5 

  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,007
    Kaminski 6
    Burke 6
    Jones 6.5 
    Gillesphey 6
    Bree 6.5
    Coventry 7
    Carey 6.5
    Docherty 6
    Bell 6
    Kelman 7
    Campbell 6.5
    Ramsay 6.5
    Leaburn 6.5 

    Ref 5
  • eastterrace6168
    eastterrace6168 Posts: 22,891
    edited November 1

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    BREE: 6.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    Referee: 3

    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 6.5

  • MattTeesHeader
    MattTeesHeader Posts: 625

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 5.5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 6

    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 7

  • kimbo
    kimbo Posts: 2,999

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 6.5  not his best game 

    DOCHERTY: 6.5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7


    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 5 consistently disappointing 

  • MikeBaileysFanClub
    MikeBaileysFanClub Posts: 313

    KAMINSKI:  7

    BURKE:       6

    JONES:        6

    GILLESPHEY:  6

    BREE:  6

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 5

    Referee:  6

    Subs: Ramsay: 5

    Leaburn: 6

    Hernandez: n/a

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

  • Addictedoldgit
    Addictedoldgit Posts: 1,833

    KAMINSKI:    6.5

    BURKE:           6

    JONES:           7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    BREE:                6

    COVENTRY:      6

    CAREY:              6.5

    DOCHERTY:       6.5

    BELL:                   6

    KELMAN:            6.5

    CAMPBELL:        6.5

    Referee:     6

    Subs: Ramsay:    6

    Leaburn:               6.5.  Looks fitter now

    Hernandez: n/a

    Olaofe: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a


  • Taxi_Lad
    Taxi_Lad Posts: 3,784

    KAMINSKI:  6.5

    BURKE:  5

    JONES: 6.5

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 6.5

    BELL:  5

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL:  7.5

    Referee: 

    Subs: Ramsay: 7

    Leaburn:  6

  • mid_life_crisis
    mid_life_crisis Posts: 3,268

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 5.5

    JONES: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 5.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 6.5

    DOCHERTY: 5.5

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 5

    Subs: Ramsay: 5.5

    Leaburn: 6


  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,273
    At the Game

    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 6

    JONES: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 7

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6

    Subs: Ramsay: 6

    Leaburn: 5

Categories

“Marketplace”