Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Worst Duchatelet Era 18

Can you thin it down to just eighteen? Who to leave out? Who's simoky not quite bad enough to get in the starting eleven, but deserves a place on the bench?

What's the worst team you can pick from the players that have played under the Duchatalet regime?
«1

Comments

  • edited March 13
    Don't know about the whole 18, but off the top of my head I'd say that Thuram, Williams and Lepoint must be absolute shoe-ins for this squad.
  • Was Danny Seabourne pre Duchatelet? I think he was
  • edited March 13
    LenGlover said:

    Was Danny Seabourne pre Duchatelet? I think he was

    Yes. Played his last match for us on Boxing day 2012.
  • edited March 13
    Thuram

    Nego
    Johnson
    Williams
    Page (Harsh given he hasn't played much but struggling for a left back)


    Bergdych
    Lepoint
    Poyet (Mark 2)
    Ba

    Polish Pete
    Vaz Te
  • May I add '2014' ?
    Worst Duchatelet Era: 2014-18
  • edited March 13
    Thuram
    Nego
    Johnson
    Williams
    Bergdych
    Lepoint
    Petrucci
    Frimpong
    Tucadean
    Tudgay
    Polish Pete



  • Polish Pete doesn't qualify imo - one appearance as sub, where i'm not certain he even did anything particularly remarkable.
  • Was Evina better or worse than Page?
  • edited March 13
    Thuram

    Nego
    Johnson
    Williams
    Chicksen (possibly harsh)

    Harriott
    Ceballos
    Lepoint
    Ba

    Church
    Makienok


    Coach: Wim De Corte (hipsters choice)
  • Amazing how many full internationals are getting picked in the worst team to represent Charlton in the club's worst period.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Frimpong was pre-regime. By coincidence his last game was the same as Danny Seabourne (see above).
  • I had completely forgotten that Bergdych ever existed
  • Oguchi Onyewu is worth a mention. A 16-game winless run, hemorrhaging goals, Andre Bikey's completely forgotten how to tackle, pass or stand up, but you still can't get a game. In those circumstances, you've got to be pretty poor.
  • Polish Pete doesn't qualify imo - one appearance as sub, where i'm not certain he even did anything particularly remarkable.

    4 minutes of football in return for an £800k transfer fee and a 4 and a half year contract that we tore up less than half way through. He should be first name on the teamsheet, and Simon Church shouldn't be anywhere near it.
  • edited March 13
    In many ways there haven't been that many bad players under RD, but rather players who were unsuitable to English football and weren't given time to settle, or were unfit/past it/disinterested when they signed

    Reza for example was hopeless for us, but has done enough elsewhere to suggest some talent. Lepoint has had a decent career in Belgium, ditto Nego in Hungary and Polish Pete in the Netherlands

    If you buy players just on stats, you end up with such players
  • Can we include Anil Koc?
  • edited March 13

    Thuram
    Motta Johnson Williams Bergdich
    Petrucci Poyet2 LePoint Ba
    Tucudean VazTe



    :heart: Reza :heart: was never gonna be in the worst side, he clearly had quality but didn't like the physicality of the Championship. He was used to being one of the rougher players as shown in the World Cup.
  • THuram

    Koc. Johnson. Williams. Petrucci

    BA. Poyet2 Reeves Marshall

    Polish Pete, dodoo, Ajose
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited March 13
    Thuram

    Nego, Johnson, Williams, Bergdich

    Ceballos, Ba, Crofts, Byrne

    McAleny, Lepoint

    Bench:
    Etheridge, Vaz Te, Onyewu, Novak, Moussa, Anıl Koç, Piotr Parzyszek, Dodoo
  • Thuram

    Nego, Johnson, Williams, Bergdich

    Ceballos, Ba, Crofts, Byrne

    McAleny, Lepoint

    Bench:
    Etheridge, Vaz Te, Onyewu, Novak, Moussa, Anıl Koç, Piotr Parzyszek, Dodoo

    Byrne?
  • edited March 13
    .
  • Thuram

    Nego, Johnson, Williams, Bergdich

    Ceballos, Ba, Crofts, Byrne

    McAleny, Lepoint

    Bench:
    Etheridge, Vaz Te, Onyewu, Novak, Moussa, Anıl Koç, Piotr Parzyszek, Dodoo

    Byrne?
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_Byrne
  • Thuram, he was so bad I can’t think of anything else.
  • Surely Koc and Fanni must be included. Just about sums it all up.
  • Being serious, all the years I have watched Charlton by miles the worst performance by anyone is given to Lepoint..
  • Thuram

    Nego, Johnson, Williams, Bergdich

    Ceballos, Ba, Crofts, Byrne

    McAleny, Lepoint

    Bench:
    Etheridge, Vaz Te, Onyewu, Novak, Moussa, Anıl Koç, Piotr Parzyszek, Dodoo

    Byrne?
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_Byrne
    I think he was questioning the inclusion. At least that's what I thought when I saw Byrne's name.
  • Oh well in that case, he was just a poor part of our worst ever team under Roland.
  • Being serious, all the years I have watched Charlton by miles the worst performance by anyone is given to Lepoint..

    Tom Hovi? El Khalaj (? spelling) Ben Reeves every week :wink:
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out!