Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Top 10 Charlton players of all time

jrcafcjrcafc
in General Charlton
Come on then guys,

This one is going strong on twitter so thought I would get some responses here. Give me your top 10 Charlton players of all time. You don't have to put them in order.

Here's mine.

Bent
Rufus
Robinson
Powell
Holland
Jackson
Mendonca
Jensen
Whyte
Young

I always liked Leaburn and Brown but not quite in my 10.


let's have yours...
«13

Comments

  • Options
    McBobbinMcBobbin
    Kiely
    Jensen
    Parker
    Euell
    Jackson
    Darren Bent
    Kinsella
    Super Clive
    SCP
    Rufus

    Maybe Robinson, but who for?
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    Mosley Mills
    Scotty Kingsley
    Norman Smith
    George Tadman
    Don Welsh
    Sam Bartram
    Chris Duffy
    Gordon Hurst
    Eddie Firmani
    Hans Jeppson


  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    JohnnyJoeyDeeDee said:

    Henry Irving said:

    Sorry, but "all time"?

    Well Sky pretends football started in 1992
    It does but we don't have to agree.
  • Options
    ForeverAddicktedForeverAddickted
    Is this our favourite eleven or all time players in our lifetime.

    I know I wasnt around yet for Bartram / Peacock to not be in anyone's all time top 10 is strange really
  • Options
    C_A_F_CC_A_F_C
    Based on players that I've actually seen wear the shirt, just their Charlton careers alone and the impact they had on the club whichever level we were at at the time.

    Kiely
    Rufus
    Powell
    Parker
    Kinsella
    Jensen
    Jackson
    Bent
    Kermorgant
    Mendonca
  • Options
    GretnaGreenAddickGretnaGreenAddick
    edited February 2018
    Hard to judge since I have only been a Charlton fan since the mid 90s.

    If we are talking personal favourites then mine would be:

    Chris Powell
    Steve Brown
    Sasa Ilic
    Clive Mendonca
    John Robinson
    Mark Kinsella
    Dean Kiely
    Johnnie Jackson
    Yann Kermorgant
    Darren Bent

    Honourable mention to Radostin Kishishev.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    RivieraRiviera
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely
    Kiely

  • Options
    cafcfan1990cafcfan1990
    Started going in 1996, my top 10:

    Kiely
    Young
    Powell
    Rufus
    Costa - albeit briefly his class was obvious
    Kinsella
    Parker
    Jensen
    Bent
    Bartlett

    Chuck in a someone like Graham Stuart and that’s a top 8 team. I’m talking top 8 prem not bloody league 1, how far we have fallen
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    ForeverAddickted said:

    Is this our favourite eleven or all time players in our lifetime.

    I know I wasnt around yet for Bartram / Peacock to not be in anyone's all time top 10 is strange really

    In your lifetime is fine but that's not all time.

    Otherwise May is in the "All time" prime ministers because we weren't alive for Churchill or Attlee.

    Just as well the Charlton Hall of Fame has votes for players in three eras: pre 1950, 50 to 80, 81 to 2013 (five year qualifying period)
  • Options
    Briston_AddickBriston_Addick
    edited February 2018
    Not always the best, but definitely my favourites ... and not exactly a top 10, more a first team squad:

    1. D Kiely

    2. J Humphrey (all-time favourite)
    5. R Rufus
    6. S Balmer
    3. C Powell

    7. C Jensen
    4. R Kishishev (second fav)
    8. M Kinsella
    11. P Mortimer

    9. C Leaburn
    10. C Mendonca

    Subs:
    12. S Brown (he won't let you down)
    13. B Bolder
    14. S Minto
    15. J Robinson
    16. J Melrose

    Edit: although my first Charlton match was 14 Feb 1981 I didn't start going regularly until the mid-80s, hence no Killer etc.
  • Options
    wmcf123wmcf123
    jrcafc said:

    Come on then guys,

    This one is going strong on twitter so thought I would get some responses here. Give me your top 10 Charlton players of all time. You don't have to put them in order.

    Here's mine.

    Bent
    Rufus
    Robinson
    Powell
    Holland
    Jackson
    Mendonca
    Jensen
    Whyte
    Young

    I always liked Leaburn and Brown but not quite in my 10.


    let's have yours...

    Holland. Good lord.
  • Options
    StarinnaddickStarinnaddick
    dwb said:

    My top 10 players are..

    Stuart Leary
    Derek Hales
    Clive Mendonca
    Scotty Parker
    Sam Bartram
    Johnny Summers
    Eddie Firmani
    Mark Kinsella
    Claus Jenson
    Yann Kermogant

    My favorite player of all time was Stuart Leary but, after that, the names above are in no particular order.
    ,


    Would'nt disagree much with this list apart from maybe including John Hewie.
  • Options
    C_A_F_CC_A_F_C
    seth plum said:

    George Costa would get in any all time Charlton Athletic team.

    Good old George.
  • Options
    AddicksAddictAddicksAddict
    Bartram
    Welsh
    Firmani
    Summers
    Parker
    Hales
    Hewie
    Jensen
    Simonsen
    Mendonca or Hunt, toss a coin
  • Options
    Themightyath2Themightyath2
    This is based on players that I’ve seen & the ones that I always wanted on the teamsheet...

    Bowyer
    Humphrey
    Brown
    Rufus
    Kinsella
    Mendonca
    Jensen
    Di Canio
    Parker
    Yann

    On the flip side, those I’d rather didn’t appear on the teamsheet...

    Thuram
    LePoint
    Abbott
    McLeod
    Kandol
    Spring
    Traore
    Doherty
    Anyinsah
    Țucudean


  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    EveshamAddickEveshamAddick
    edited February 2018
    Bolder
    Humphrey
    Peter Hunt
    Colin Powell
    Killer
    Stevie Gritt
    Morts
    Steve mckenzie
    Darren bent
    Kermorgant
    Colin Walsh

    Subs

    Jeff wood
    Steve Brown
    Minto
    Graham Stuart
    Flanagan
    Mendonca


  • Options
    colthe3rdcolthe3rd
    Favourite or best as there is quite a distinction between the two?
  • Options
    golfaddickgolfaddick
    From when I started going (c 1977):

    Keily
    Rufus
    Hales
    Simonsen
    Powell
    Mendonca
    Bowyer
    Todd
    Jensen
    Kinsella
  • Options
    AddictforlifeAddictforlife
    Johnnie Jackson
    Paul Williams
    Yann Kermorgant
    Mark Kinsella
    Richard Rufus
    Scott Parker
    John Humphrey
    Paul Mortimer
    Clive Mendonca
    Darren Bent
  • Options
    Rock SpectacleRock Spectacle
    Favourite
    Kinsella
    Hales
    Mendonca
    Shirtliff
    C. Walsh
    Brown
    John's
    Leaburn
    Powell
    Bartram (never saw but the legend alone and how people have waxed lyrical will do for me).

    Ability
    Di Canio
    Parker
    Rufus
    D Bent
    P Walsh
    Kinsella
    Simonsen
    Humphrey
    Mendonca
    Jeppson (again record speaks volumes).
    Kiely - does make 11 but couldn't leave him out.

    And already thought of 3 I've missed, either brilliant memories or getting old!
  • Options
    killerandflashkillerandflash
    Really hard to do a "best" list as opposed to a "favourite" list

    What about players you didn't see?
    What league were we playing in - Killer never played in the 1st division for us, whereas Firmani and (for some of the time) Leary did?
    Is a top player with us for a short time (Costa) better than a lesser player who was with us for over 10 years (e.g. Brown)

    Bearing this in mind, and restricting myself to players I've seen

    Bolder
    Rufus
    Johnnie Robinson
    Parker
    Robert Lee
    Hales
    Jensen
    Kinsella
    Mendonca
    Minto
  • Options
    RedlionlaneRedlionlane
    Only players I’ve seen. All could succeed at the highest level.

    Charlie Wright
    Mike Bailey
    Eddie Firmani
    Billy Bonds
    Richard Rufus
    Lee Bowyer
    Chris Powell
    Killer
    Scottie Parker
    Mark Kinsella
    Clive Mendonca
  • Options
    ricky_ottoricky_otto
    edited February 2018
    Players I’ve seen play top 10 - I’ve also gone on the basis of 50 + games

    Shirtliff (all time favourite)
    Rufus
    Thompson
    Parker
    Kinsella
    Mortimer
    Mendonca
    D Bent
    Kermorgant
    Bowyer

  • Options
    thai malaysia addickthai malaysia addick
    Of the ones I’ve seen:

    Alan Simonsen
    Paolo Di Canio
    Jorge Costa
    Darren Bent
    Eddie Firmani
    John Hewie
    Johnny Haynes (1 appearance in a friendly)
    Scott Parker
    Claus Jensen
    Mike Bailey

    I was too young to appreciate how good Stuart Leary and Johnny Summers were so I’ve left them out.
  • Options
    iamdaniamdan
    Robbie Mustoe
    Jesper Blomqvist
    Graeme Murty
    Dan Seabourne

Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!