Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Players Marks: Charlton v Ipswich

For those who saw the game today, at the Valley or TV or stream, your marks and please keep to the order below:

Henderson -
Solly -
Bauer -
Sarr -
Fox -
Diarra -
Cousins -
Holmes-Dennis -
Berg Gudmundsson -
Makienok -
Lookman -
Vaz Te -

Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
«134

Comments

  • Options
    Lookman 10. Very bright future but probably not with us.
    The rest can have a 4/5s for turning up.
  • Options
    Henderson 6 - Goals weren't his fault.
    Solly 4 - Defence as a whole shocking but he did get forward a bit.
    Bauer 2 - His worst game I've seen,
    Sarr 1 - Sears tore him apart all afternoon. Absolutely shocking player.
    Fox 1 - Wish he'd gone to Cardiff with his idol.
    Diarra 5 - Didn't notice him too much but also didn't notice many mistakes.
    Cousins 6 - Didn't think he had a bad game. One of the best of a bad bunch first half.
    Holmes-Dennis 6 - Got to give him credit for the amount of positions he was forced to play this afternoon.
    Berg Gudmundsson 5 - Craving the JBG we've seen before.
    Makienok 1 - Not sure how he lasted so long. It's like he feels sorry for himself. DO SOMETHING.
    Lookman 7 - Can tell he's a talent, our only hope for a lot of the game.
    Vaz Te 7 - Hope he comes good. Was a real threat towards the end of the game although maybe Ipswich had stopped trying by then.

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a
  • Options
    Henderson 6.5
    Solly 5
    Bauer 5
    Sarr 4
    Fox 5
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 5
    Holmes-Dennis 6
    Berg Gudmundsson 5
    Makienok 3
    Lookman 7
    Vaz Te 6.5
  • Options
    Henderson-7 Not at fault for the goals, one or two good saves
    Solly-7 Good shift
    Bauer-6.5 A few shaky moments
    Sarr-5 Not his best to say the least
    Fox-5.5 Meh
    Diarra- 6.5 Decent
    Cousins-6 Didn't do much
    Holmes-Dennis-7 Solid despite playing 3 different positions
    Berg Gudmundsson-5 Off of it today, one or two good glimpses
    Makienok-5 Did he win any headers?
    Lookman-6.5 Decent shift, will only get better
    Vaz Te-7.5 Provided a spark

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a
  • Options



    Henderson 5
    Solly 4
    Bauer 6
    Sarr 4
    Fox 3
    Diarra 5
    Cousins 6
    Holmes-Dennis 7
    Berg Gudmundsson 6
    Makienok can you give less than 3 ?
    Lookman 4
    Vaz Te 7

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a 6

  • Options
    Henderson - 5
    Solly - 4
    Bauer - 3
    Sarr - 3
    Fox - 5
    Diara - 4
    Cousins - 4
    Holmes-Dennis - 7
    Berg Gudmundsson - 3
    Makienok - 2 (which is generous)
    Lookman - 8
    Vaz Te - 7

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a
  • Options
    Henderson 7 could have been far worse, he was exposed too often.

    Solly 5 really average performance sadly.

    Bauer 5.5 a couple of good bits, was bullied.

    Sarr 4 really poor, but there's something there.

    Fox 5 average.

    Diarra 6 worked hard. Did what he could.

    Cousins 5 ran around a lot lowered our average tackles won % massively.

    Holmes-Dennis 6 worked hard better than Fox.

    Berg Gudmundsson 5 not good enough from him. Needs to be stronger.

    Makienok 3 really poor game. Was bullied from the off.

    Lookman 7 really good game, didn't let himself be bullied.

    Vaz Te 6.5 did really well. If he'd played longer last week I feel the result would have been different.

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a 6.5 some decent work from Reza in his short stint, decent power on his header
    and tee's up Bauer and Vaz Te with chances.

    Think it's no coincidence that when Reza and Vaz were up top we looked so much stronger. We were forced to play more on the ground and work it out to the wings to create chances.


  • Options
    Henderson - 6.5 - Has to look at his positioning for their second and was unfortunate to lose his bearings ahead of the first goal after making a decent save. Killed a lot of long shots

    Solly - 5 - Offered very little going forward and was all over the shop for their third. Should never have been brought on.

    Bauer - 5.5 - Looked a bit lost and it's one of his worst games for us. Should have been able to cope with Ipswich's aerial threat much better

    Sarr - 5 - Probably still spinning now off some innocuous Ipswich runs. Utterly clueless the whole game

    Fox - 6 - Created a useful platform going forward and brought Johann into the game more than anyone else. Had some problems with the pace of the Ipswich players though

    Diarra - 6.5 - Started well but found it difficult to run the midfield on his own. Sliced clearance put pressure on us for the second right before half-time

    Cousins - 6.5 - Looked decent on the ball but was rarely on it. Seems to struggle to understand how to impose himself in the diamond

    Holmes-Dennis - 7 MOTM - Looked so comfortable at RB and should never have been moved. No idea why he was put on the left of the diamond but did well there before stopping the Ipswich threat down the left and putting some decent crosses in

    Berg Gudmundsson - 5.5 - When he was in the game he looked classy as ever but he was rarely in it

    Makienok - 4 - Won nothing in the air, was ok with the ball on the deck but was a stroppy cow to go with his lack of nous. Shocking.

    Lookman - 7 - Very positive runner but he's got nothing in the way of a shot and he never looked like being a goal threat unfortunately. Put in a lovely cross for Vaz Te

    Vaz Te - 6.5 - Obviously not fully fit but looked a decent goal threat. Unlucky not to score twice

    Jackson n/a - 10 for his reaction to having to come off
    Reza n/a - Looked so sharp and added a touch of class. Great knock down for Vaz Te's shot
  • Options

    Henderson - 5
    Solly - 4
    Bauer - 3
    Sarr - 3
    Fox - 5
    Diara - 4
    Cousins - 4
    Holmes-Dennis - 7
    Berg Gudmundsson - 3
    Makienok - 2 (which is generous)
    Lookman - 8
    Vaz Te - 7

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a

    That'll do for me too

  • Options
    Henderson 6
    Solly 6
    Bauer 6
    Sarr 5
    Fox 4
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 6
    Holmes-Dennis 7
    Berg Gudmundsson 6
    Makienok 4
    Lookman 7
    Vaz Te 7

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    edited November 2015
    Henderson - 6
    Solly - 5
    Bauer - 5
    Sarr - 4
    Fox - 4
    Diarra - 6
    Cousins - 5
    Holmes-Dennis - 6
    Berg Gudmundsson - 4
    Makienok - 3
    Lookman - 7
    Vaz Te - 7
  • Options
    Henderson - 6
    Solly - 5
    Bauer - 5
    Sarr - 5
    Fox - 5
    Diarra - 6
    Cousins - 5
    Holmes-Dennis - 6
    Berg Gudmundsson - 5
    Makienok - 4
    Lookman - 7 mom
    Vaz Te - 7
  • Options
    Henderson 6
    Solly 5
    Bauer 4
    Sarr 4
    Fox 4
    Diarra 4.5
    Cousins 5
    Holmes-Dennis 7
    Berg Gudmundsson 5
    Makienok 3
    Lookman 8
    Vaz Te 6.5
  • Options
    Henderson 7.5
    Solly 5.5
    Bauer 6
    Sarr 5
    Fox 5.5
    Diarra 5.5
    Cousins 5.5
    Holmes-Dennis 8.5
    Berg Gudmundsson 5
    Makienok 5
    Lookman 8
    Vaz Te 7
  • Options
    Henderson 5 could have done better
    Solly 4 boring, negative and poor
    Bauer 5 should have scored the diving header, poor decisions in clearing the ball etc
    Sarr 4 positional play is all wrong
    Fox 2 hauled at half time, will only pay again when THD is injured
    Diarra 7 does simple things well
    Cousins 6 lots of energy, touch lets him down
    Holmes-Dennis 7 good footballer, positive and exciting, opposite of Solly
    Berg Gudmundsson 5 needs to actually shoot instead of setting up and then shifting sideways
    Makienok 4 easily wound up, nearly got sent off and didn't offer an attacking threat
    Lookman 7 enjoy him while you can, his runs with the ball have purpose other than to make himself look good (unlike TWatt)
    Vaz Te 7 dangerous, could have had a couple of goals, will end up top scorer

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a
  • Options
    Henderson 6
    Solly 4
    Bauer 5
    Sarr 4
    Fox 4.5
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 5.5
    Holmes-Dennis 6.5
    Berg Gudmundson 5.5
    Makienok 4.5
    Lookman 6.5
    Vaz Te 6

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a


  • Options
    edited November 2015
    Henderson - 6
    Solly - 4
    Bauer - 4
    Sarr - 3
    Fox - 5
    Diarra - 5
    Cousins - 4
    Holmes-Dennis - 5
    Berg Gudmundsson - 4
    Makienok - 3
    Lookman - 7
    Vaz Te - 6.5
  • Options
    edited November 2015

    For those who saw the game today, at the Valley or TV or stream, your marks and please keep to the order below:

    Henderson 5.5
    Solly 5
    Bauer 4
    Sarr 3
    Fox 3 Have been a fan, but bloody awful today
    Diarra 5
    Cousins 4
    Holmes-Dennis 6.5 mom
    Berg Gudmundsson 4.5
    Makienok 2 this is not a footballer
    Lookman 5 will get overmarked on here, but massive potential
    Vaz Te 6

  • Options
    Henderson - 6.5 - Solid enough, defence let him down. Much more reliable and confidence-inspiring than Pope.
    Solly - 4 - What has happened to him? Surely not fully fit.
    Bauer - 5 - Worst game I've seen him have, looks better with Diarra alongside him but Diarra in defence weakens midfield.
    Sarr - 3 - Shit. Seemed to forget he was actually playing several times.
    Fox - 3 - Not good enough, THD at left-back from now on please.
    Diarra - 6 - Didn't stand out much but decent enough.
    Cousins - 5 - Not one of his better games, think he might need a rest.
    Holmes-Dennis - 7.5 - Very impressive in 3 different positions.
    Berg Gudmundsson - 5 - Never really got into the game.
    Makienok - 3 - I like him and he was brilliant against Hull (albeit months ago) so he is clearly capable. Shocking today though, bullied all game and let it get to him. Should have been subbed at half time.
    Lookman - 7.5 - Confident and impressive, caused Ipswich problems. Doubt he'll be here next season.
    Vaz Te - 7 - Needs to start from now on when fit.

    Jackson n/a Felt so sorry for him when he went off. Legend.
    Reza n/a Looked good, should be starting.
  • Options
    Henderson 7 Not at fault for the goals. Made a couple of world class saves.
    Solly 5 Is it a coincidence we started winning when he wasn't playing?
    Bauer 6 Positioning not always great,me specially for 2nd goal.
    Sarr 4 Naïve at best, mostly out of position.
    Fox 4 Mmmmmmmmm.
    Diarra 6 Was expecting more from him. Was sometimes being drawn too far back though by our defensive frailties.
    Cousins 5 What has happened to his control and sublime passing?
    Holmes-Dennis 7 Exciting prospect, so we won't have him for too long.
    Berg Gudmundsson 6 Was surprised he was getting bullied off the ball so often. Inconsistent.
    Makienok 2 Pants, pony, piss poor, passionless. Any p word you like really. Petulant?
    Lookman 8 When he gets physically stronger he is going to be the business. Has pace, scares defenders - that cross to V-T was amazing.
    Vaz Te 7 I was very meh about his signing, but I'm much happier now. The sooner he starts, the sooner I don't have to watch that Danish dunce. Get him in with Reza and Lookman, three prong attack, and we will look less laughable.

    Jackson n/a
    Reza n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Henderson - 6 - Not much to say really. Would have liked him to claim the ball that Sarr headed away before their second goal

    Solly - 5 Meh, not all that anymore is he....

    Bauer - 4 - normally assured and strong, poor today.

    Sarr - 2 - I have had enough of this guy, he is an absolute joke. Rubbish all game, the opposition were playing hoof ball and they could beat us with just one man up front against us with 3 or 4.

    Fox - 6 - One of my favourite players, not his best game but he put in some good balls, better crosser today than Holmes-Dennis thats for sure, he took a good yellow too.

    Diarra - 6 - Our best player on a good day, didn't have the best day today but tried.

    Cousins - 7 - Never stopped, clearly wanted it.

    Holmes-Dennis - 5 - +1 for playing in 3 positions but he was definitely best at right pack, poor at crossing and forced Fox to take a yellow with an appalling ball.

    Berg Gudmundsson - 4 - A pity because he is a much better player than how he played today..

    Makienok - 3 - He is a tall man that decided he would be a footballer. Crap with the ball at his feet and if he isn't getting on the end of crosses, which is more or less all he can do, what's the point of playing him. Would have preferred to see Vaz Te come on for him...

    Lookman - 7 - Very impressed, he really went for it and he looked dangerous, the fact he can run faster with the ball at his feet than a player chasing him is very positive.

    Vaz Te - 6 - Played well, put in a shot that would have been a goal on a different day. Hope he pushes on.

  • Options
    vffvff
    edited November 2015
    Henderson - 6
    Solly 5 - didn't really look fit
    Bauer 5 - central defence easily out muscled by Ipswich attack
    Sarr 5
    Fox 4.5 - out of position for second goal. Poor today.
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 4.5 - never got into the game
    Holmes-Dennis 6.5 - young player asked to play 3 different positions. Handled it well.
    Berg Gudmundsson 5 - disappeared
    Makienok 4 - stinker of a performance and lost the plot in the second half.
    Lookman 7.5 - lively, one of the few bright performances
    Vaz Te 7 - looked promising.

    Jackson n/a - gutted for him. Missed JJ'sleadership when off injured.
    Reza n/a - should have started.

    Fraeye - easy to say after the event, but got the set up wrong today.
  • Options

    Henderson - 6.5 - Has to look at his positioning for their second and was unfortunate to lose his bearings ahead of the first goal after making a decent save. Killed a lot of long shots

    Solly - 5 - Offered very little going forward and was all over the shop for their third. Should never have been brought on.

    Bauer - 5.5 - Looked a bit lost and it's one of his worst games for us. Should have been able to cope with Ipswich's aerial threat much better

    Sarr - 5 - Probably still spinning now off some innocuous Ipswich runs. Utterly clueless the whole game

    Fox - 6 - Created a useful platform going forward and brought Johann into the game more than anyone else. Had some problems with the pace of the Ipswich players though

    Diarra - 6.5 - Started well but found it difficult to run the midfield on his own. Sliced clearance put pressure on us for the second right before half-time

    Cousins - 6.5 - Looked decent on the ball but was rarely on it. Seems to struggle to understand how to impose himself in the diamond

    Holmes-Dennis - 7 MOTM - Looked so comfortable at RB and should never have been moved. No idea why he was put on the left of the diamond but did well there before stopping the Ipswich threat down the left and putting some decent crosses in

    Berg Gudmundsson - 5.5 - When he was in the game he looked classy as ever but he was rarely in it

    Makienok - 4 - Won nothing in the air, was ok with the ball on the deck but was a stroppy cow to go with his lack of nous. Shocking.

    Lookman - 7 - Very positive runner but he's got nothing in the way of a shot and he never looked like being a goal threat unfortunately. Put in a lovely cross for Vaz Te

    Vaz Te - 6.5 - Obviously not fully fit but looked a decent goal threat. Unlucky not to score twice

    Jackson n/a - 10 for his reaction to having to come off
    Reza n/a - Looked so sharp and added a touch of class. Great knock down for Vaz Te's shot


    Lookman has usually got a powerful shot. Very unfair to judge his shooting just on today. I went for the first time today, for a while, thought Holmes -Dennis and Lookman looked the best Charlton players. A forward line of Vaz Te, Lookman and Reza is the way to go for me. Makienok was atrocious.

  • Options
    Henderson 5 unusually hesitant at times
    Solly 5 same as he's been all season. Slow and lethargic.
    Bauer 4 never got to grips with Murphy. His worst game for us.
    Sarr 4 as per Bauer
    Fox 5
    Diarra 6 not as influential as last couple of games.
    Cousins 4 thought he was poor today. Not sure this system suits him.
    Holmes-Dennis 7 needs to start regularly now
    Berg Gudmundsson - 6 never really got going.
    Makienok - 3 really poor today
    Lookman - 7 must start with Vaz Te now
    Vaz Te - 7 once the big useless lump went off he flourished
  • Options
    Henderson 6
    Solly 5
    Bauer 5
    Sarr 3
    Fox 5
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 5
    Holmes-Dennis 7
    Berg Gudmundsson 4
    Makienok 2
    Lookman 7.5
    Vaz Te 7
  • Options
    Henderson 6
    Solly 6
    Bauer 4
    Sarr 3
    Fox 5
    Diarra 5
    Cousins 5
    Holmes-Dennis 7
    Berg Gudmundsson 5
    Makienok 1
    Lookman 8
    Vaz Te 7
  • Options
    Henderson 6
    Solly 4
    Bauer 5
    Sarr 4
    Fox 2
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 4
    Holmes-Dennis 6
    Berg Gudmundsson 3
    Makienok 3
    Lookman 6
    Vaz Te 5
  • Options
    Henderson 5
    Solly 3
    Bauer 4
    Sarr 4
    Fox 3
    Diarra 6
    Cousins 3
    Holmes-Dennis 6
    Berg Gudmundsson 3
    Makienok 1
    Lookman 7
    Vaz Te 5
  • Options
    Henderson - 6
    Solly - 4.5
    Bauer - 4.5
    Sarr - 3 (Marks for managing to put his shirt on the right way round and tying his shoe laces)
    Fox - 3 (As above)
    Diarra - 4.5
    Cousins - 3 (Same as Sarr and Fox)
    Holmes-Dennis - 6
    Berg Gudmundsson - 4
    Makienok - 3 (Same as Sarr, Fox and Cousins)
    Lookman - 6
    Vaz Te - 6
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!